Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Jan. 1, 1881
  • Page 2
  • HOW LONG WILL MASONS CONTINUE TO BELIEVE IN IMAGINARY HISTORY?
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Jan. 1, 1881: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Jan. 1, 1881
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE WARWICKSHIRE MASONIC BENEVOLENT AND PUPILS' AID FUND. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article THE MOTHER CITY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY.—IV. Page 1 of 1
    Article THE MOTHER CITY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY.—IV. Page 1 of 1
    Article HOW LONG WILL MASONS CONTINUE TO BELIEVE IN IMAGINARY HISTORY? Page 1 of 2 →
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Warwickshire Masonic Benevolent And Pupils' Aid Fund.

Masonic Pupils' Assistance , when in working trim , will fulfil the objects t ' ov which it was started , without in the slightest degree interfering with the other Charities . Indeed , its " object has been stated to bo , that it should always remain iu a subsidiary position as regards the

Schools . However , though our Warwickshire brethren will have nothing to say to a general Pupils' Assistance Fund , they have started a similar fund of their own in

conjunction with their Benevolent Fund , and all we need say by way of concluding theso remarks is , as we have once already said , that wo hope and believe this scheme will bo a successful one .

The Mother City Of American Freemasonry.—Iv.

THE MOTHER CITY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY . —IV .

By BRO . R . F . GOUM > . BT way of Appendix to the friendly disputation which , under the above heading , has been conducted in the

FREEMASON ' CHRONICLE , the " Title-Pages" of the two " Pocket Companions " ( so frequently referred to ) , may be usefully presented .

It will bo seen that the motto— " Denis Nobis Sol et Scutum "—and the names of printer [ E . Rider ] and compiler [ W . Smith ] are the same in both publications .

From the London list of Lodges being published in 1734 , and the Dublin list in 1735 , it is evident that the latterexcept as to the No . 79—was copied from the former . [ Title Page of London Pocket Companion , 1735 . ]

A POCKET COMPANION JOB . FREE MASONS .

Deus Nobis Sol Sf Scutum . DEDICATED TO THE SOCIETT .

LONDON : Friuted and Sold by E . Rider in Blaokroore-street , near Clare-market . JIDCCXXXV . The dedication of the London " Pocket Companion " follows the Title-page , and concludes as under : —

" Signed by Your loving Brother And most obedient servant , W . SMITH . "

What may be termed the first part of the book , terminates at p 45 , and though the pagination continues , a new Title-page heads what may be described as the second part . [ Title Page of Second Part . ]

COLLECTION OF THE SONGS OF MASONS ,

& c . & c . & c . LONDON : Printed in tho year MDCCXXXIV . At p 95 is given : — " AN EXACT

LIST oy REGULAR LODGES

ACCORDING TO THE IK SENIORITY AND CONSTITUTION . In this list the No . 79 is vacant . [ Title Page of tho DaUin Pocket Companion , 1735 . *] A POCKF . T COMPANION FOR FREE-MASONS , CONTAINING [ The various headings I .-VII . comprise the History of Masonry .

Charges , General Regulations , etc ., etc . ] VIII . A List of tho Warranted Lodges in Ireland , Great Britain , France , Spain , Germany , East and West Indies , etc . Approved of , and Recommended by the Grand Lodge .

Dens nobis Sol efc Scutum . Dnblin : Printed by E . Rider , and sold at the Printing Offico in George ' s Lane ; T . Jones , in Clarendon Streot ; and J . Pennel , at the Hercules in St . Patrick Street . "Huccxxxv . ( Price eight-pence ) . "It is dedicated" ( says Bro . TCnghan ) " to the BRETHREN and

* From an article by Bro . W . J . Hughan , originally published in the "Voice of Masonry , " Chicago , September 1875 , and reprinted in "Early History of the Grand Lodge of Pennsylvania , 1877 , " pp xiv - xxiii .

The Mother City Of American Freemasonry.—Iv.

FF . r . i , ows .... of FREE and ACCEPTED MASONS , by your loving BROTHER and most obedient servant . " W . ( illiam ) S . ( mith ) . In the list of Lodges shown in this work , the 79 th place on the English roll is no longer vacant , but is filled by an American Lodge , which is thus described : " The Hoop in

Water Street , in Philadelphia , 1 st Monday . " I may add , in conclusion , that whilst my hypothesis , as to the Boston Lodge , afterwards No . 126 , being misdescribed as the Lodge at the " Hoop , " & c , is strengthened

by tho fact of the earlier " Pocket Companion " having the No . 79 vacant , it is weakened by the dissimilarity of the clays of meeting assigned to the Lodges at No . 79 and 126 respectively .

No . 126 met on the second and fourth Wednesday , and not on the first Monday .

How Long Will Masons Continue To Believe In Imaginary History?

HOW LONG WILL MASONS CONTINUE TO BELIEVE IN IMAGINARY HISTORY ?

BY BRO . JACOB NORTON . A IIALF ~ cracked dreamer , who was initiated into Masonry , wrote in 1724 a book called " Long Livers , " in which he claimed that Masonry was understood by him better than any one else . Thereupon , the editor of tho Freemason took it for granted that High Grades were in existence in 1724 . A humbug imposed upon the High Graders in Golden-square a so-called Henry IV . of France Rose Croix apron , and the same authority tells us that the History of

Freemasonry will have to be re-written . A splurge was recently made by a set of dreamei' 3 about Egyptian Masonry , and the same writer again insists that tbe History of Masonry will have to be re-written . In a like manner the Philadelphia " Mother of American Masonry " was embalmed by the same writer in Bro . Kenning's Cyclopoedia . I supposed that my demonstration about Lodge No . 79 having been an

English Lodge would have settled the Philadelphia pretension ; but a correspondent of mine insists that I must account for the reason as to why the Dnblin editor of the" Pocket Companion" in 1735 made No . 79 a Philadelphia Lodge . Now , with all deference to that Brother , does he really think that we are bound to account for all the whys and wherefores of Masonio writers who have propagated

some thousands of falsehoods in their writings P Thus , several old English Lodge Lists state that a certain Lodge was constituted in the days of Julius Cassar . In 1875 the late Bro . Tisdal asserted that he saw the Warrant of Albion Lodge at Quebec , and that it was dated 1721 . In C . W . Moore ' s Magazine , Boston , U . S . of 1844 ( pp 163-4 ) I found the following assertion : —

" The first [ authority ] for this country was received about ; the year 1720 . It was a Dispensation authorising the opening of a Lodge in this City . " We have the fact from a clergyman ( the late Rev . Mr . Montague , of Dedham ) , who found it stated in an old account in the archives of King ' s Chapel . The Lodge was regularly organized , but was soon after discontinued . "

But although Moore gave it upon the authority of a Rev . Mr . Montagne , yet there is not a word of truth in the above statement . Anderson ' s History of Freemasonry , " Multa Paucis , " Hutchinson ' s , Preston's , and Oliver ' s Works , as well as our Masonic Magazines in general , abound in similar mis-statements . All that is necessary to

do in such cases , is simply to expose their absurdities , and no one is required to account as to why or wherefore the said falsehoods were manufactured , and I really can see no reason why I should be called upon to account for a blunder of the Dnblin editor of 1735 . Bro . Philadelphos , in the issue of this paper of 30 th Oct ., says :

" Bnt I have always looked upon the Coxe Deputation , and the extracts from the Philadelphia Journal ' • • as having a very direct bearing upon the subject , and till the reality of their existence has been very seriously disturbed , I shall always be of opinion that Freemasonry undoubtedly established itself in Philadelphia beforo it

did in any other city of the present United States ; I will go further and say , that even if the Coxe Deputation was never granted—and I know no Craftsman who is more competent to throw light on this than Bro . Gould—I should still hold to the belief that the evidence of a contemporary journal as to there having been meetings of the Craft in the City of Brotherly Love , cannot be overset . "

Now , I have never doubted that Coxe received a deputation in 1730 ' constituting him P . G . M . of Kew York , New Jersey , and Pennsylvania . I believo , also , that in 1730 Franklin , in his paper , stated that several Lodges existed in Pennsylvania ; and in 1732 he gave an account of the meeting of a Grand Lodge in Philadelphia . But I maintain that no evidence is in existence showing a connection between Daniel

Coxe and Pennsylvania Freemasonry . Coxe joined a Loudon Lodge in 1731 , and no one could find his return to America before 1734 , that is , two years after he ceased to be G . M . Now , had Coxe founded Masonry in Pennsylvania , and , residing as he did within twenty miles of Philadelphia , he would snrely have visited the Philadelphia Grand Lodge , at least once , on a 24 th of June , to participate with his Masonic children in the Festival of St . John ' s Day ; and had he so visited them

his name would have appeai'ed among the distinguished dignitaries in tho Pennsylvania Gazette . Coxe died in 1739 ; had his Grand Mastership been known to Benjamin Franklin , Franklin would have noticed him in the Pennsylvania'Gazette . Yet there is not only no evidence in tho Pennsylvania Gazette that Franklin knew of Coxe ' s Deputation , bt . t there is no evidence in ail Franklin ' s writings of his knowledge of the very existence of Daniel Coxe ; and , furthermore , there is no

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1881-01-01, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 16 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_01011881/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE WARWICKSHIRE MASONIC BENEVOLENT AND PUPILS' AID FUND. Article 1
THE MOTHER CITY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY.—IV. Article 2
HOW LONG WILL MASONS CONTINUE TO BELIEVE IN IMAGINARY HISTORY? Article 2
OUR CHARITIES—A YEAR'S WORK. Article 3
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Article 3
ROYAL MASONIC BENEVOLENT INSTITUTION. Article 3
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS. Article 3
INSTALLATION MEETINGS, &c. Article 4
LODGE OF FRIENDSHIP, No. 202. Article 4
CHARITY LODGE, No. 223. Article 4
LODGE OF GOOD FELLOWSHIP, No. 276. Article 4
ST. JOHN'S LODGE, No. 348, BOLTON. Article 4
POMFRET LODGE, No. 360. Article 5
ST. MARTIN'S LODGE, No. 510, LISKEARD. Article 5
LOYAL VICTORIA LODGE, No. 557, CALLINGTON. Article 5
ELMS LODGE No. 1212. Article 5
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS. Article 6
COMMITTEE MEETING OF THE GIRLS' SCHOOL. Article 6
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 6
To the Editor of the FREEMASON'S CHRONICLE. Article 6
Untitled Ad 7
THE THEATRES, &c. Article 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
LODGE HISTORIES. Article 8
THE LATE FRANK BUCKLAND. Article 10
ANSWERS TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 10
THE MOHAWK MINSTRELS. Article 10
BERNER'S HALL. Article 10
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 11
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 12
JAMAICA. Article 13
SOUTH AFRICA. Article 13
DEVON MASONIC EDUCATIONAL FUND. Article 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

6 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

6 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

5 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

8 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

15 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

5 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

13 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

14 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

15 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Warwickshire Masonic Benevolent And Pupils' Aid Fund.

Masonic Pupils' Assistance , when in working trim , will fulfil the objects t ' ov which it was started , without in the slightest degree interfering with the other Charities . Indeed , its " object has been stated to bo , that it should always remain iu a subsidiary position as regards the

Schools . However , though our Warwickshire brethren will have nothing to say to a general Pupils' Assistance Fund , they have started a similar fund of their own in

conjunction with their Benevolent Fund , and all we need say by way of concluding theso remarks is , as we have once already said , that wo hope and believe this scheme will bo a successful one .

The Mother City Of American Freemasonry.—Iv.

THE MOTHER CITY OF AMERICAN FREEMASONRY . —IV .

By BRO . R . F . GOUM > . BT way of Appendix to the friendly disputation which , under the above heading , has been conducted in the

FREEMASON ' CHRONICLE , the " Title-Pages" of the two " Pocket Companions " ( so frequently referred to ) , may be usefully presented .

It will bo seen that the motto— " Denis Nobis Sol et Scutum "—and the names of printer [ E . Rider ] and compiler [ W . Smith ] are the same in both publications .

From the London list of Lodges being published in 1734 , and the Dublin list in 1735 , it is evident that the latterexcept as to the No . 79—was copied from the former . [ Title Page of London Pocket Companion , 1735 . ]

A POCKET COMPANION JOB . FREE MASONS .

Deus Nobis Sol Sf Scutum . DEDICATED TO THE SOCIETT .

LONDON : Friuted and Sold by E . Rider in Blaokroore-street , near Clare-market . JIDCCXXXV . The dedication of the London " Pocket Companion " follows the Title-page , and concludes as under : —

" Signed by Your loving Brother And most obedient servant , W . SMITH . "

What may be termed the first part of the book , terminates at p 45 , and though the pagination continues , a new Title-page heads what may be described as the second part . [ Title Page of Second Part . ]

COLLECTION OF THE SONGS OF MASONS ,

& c . & c . & c . LONDON : Printed in tho year MDCCXXXIV . At p 95 is given : — " AN EXACT

LIST oy REGULAR LODGES

ACCORDING TO THE IK SENIORITY AND CONSTITUTION . In this list the No . 79 is vacant . [ Title Page of tho DaUin Pocket Companion , 1735 . *] A POCKF . T COMPANION FOR FREE-MASONS , CONTAINING [ The various headings I .-VII . comprise the History of Masonry .

Charges , General Regulations , etc ., etc . ] VIII . A List of tho Warranted Lodges in Ireland , Great Britain , France , Spain , Germany , East and West Indies , etc . Approved of , and Recommended by the Grand Lodge .

Dens nobis Sol efc Scutum . Dnblin : Printed by E . Rider , and sold at the Printing Offico in George ' s Lane ; T . Jones , in Clarendon Streot ; and J . Pennel , at the Hercules in St . Patrick Street . "Huccxxxv . ( Price eight-pence ) . "It is dedicated" ( says Bro . TCnghan ) " to the BRETHREN and

* From an article by Bro . W . J . Hughan , originally published in the "Voice of Masonry , " Chicago , September 1875 , and reprinted in "Early History of the Grand Lodge of Pennsylvania , 1877 , " pp xiv - xxiii .

The Mother City Of American Freemasonry.—Iv.

FF . r . i , ows .... of FREE and ACCEPTED MASONS , by your loving BROTHER and most obedient servant . " W . ( illiam ) S . ( mith ) . In the list of Lodges shown in this work , the 79 th place on the English roll is no longer vacant , but is filled by an American Lodge , which is thus described : " The Hoop in

Water Street , in Philadelphia , 1 st Monday . " I may add , in conclusion , that whilst my hypothesis , as to the Boston Lodge , afterwards No . 126 , being misdescribed as the Lodge at the " Hoop , " & c , is strengthened

by tho fact of the earlier " Pocket Companion " having the No . 79 vacant , it is weakened by the dissimilarity of the clays of meeting assigned to the Lodges at No . 79 and 126 respectively .

No . 126 met on the second and fourth Wednesday , and not on the first Monday .

How Long Will Masons Continue To Believe In Imaginary History?

HOW LONG WILL MASONS CONTINUE TO BELIEVE IN IMAGINARY HISTORY ?

BY BRO . JACOB NORTON . A IIALF ~ cracked dreamer , who was initiated into Masonry , wrote in 1724 a book called " Long Livers , " in which he claimed that Masonry was understood by him better than any one else . Thereupon , the editor of tho Freemason took it for granted that High Grades were in existence in 1724 . A humbug imposed upon the High Graders in Golden-square a so-called Henry IV . of France Rose Croix apron , and the same authority tells us that the History of

Freemasonry will have to be re-written . A splurge was recently made by a set of dreamei' 3 about Egyptian Masonry , and the same writer again insists that tbe History of Masonry will have to be re-written . In a like manner the Philadelphia " Mother of American Masonry " was embalmed by the same writer in Bro . Kenning's Cyclopoedia . I supposed that my demonstration about Lodge No . 79 having been an

English Lodge would have settled the Philadelphia pretension ; but a correspondent of mine insists that I must account for the reason as to why the Dnblin editor of the" Pocket Companion" in 1735 made No . 79 a Philadelphia Lodge . Now , with all deference to that Brother , does he really think that we are bound to account for all the whys and wherefores of Masonio writers who have propagated

some thousands of falsehoods in their writings P Thus , several old English Lodge Lists state that a certain Lodge was constituted in the days of Julius Cassar . In 1875 the late Bro . Tisdal asserted that he saw the Warrant of Albion Lodge at Quebec , and that it was dated 1721 . In C . W . Moore ' s Magazine , Boston , U . S . of 1844 ( pp 163-4 ) I found the following assertion : —

" The first [ authority ] for this country was received about ; the year 1720 . It was a Dispensation authorising the opening of a Lodge in this City . " We have the fact from a clergyman ( the late Rev . Mr . Montague , of Dedham ) , who found it stated in an old account in the archives of King ' s Chapel . The Lodge was regularly organized , but was soon after discontinued . "

But although Moore gave it upon the authority of a Rev . Mr . Montagne , yet there is not a word of truth in the above statement . Anderson ' s History of Freemasonry , " Multa Paucis , " Hutchinson ' s , Preston's , and Oliver ' s Works , as well as our Masonic Magazines in general , abound in similar mis-statements . All that is necessary to

do in such cases , is simply to expose their absurdities , and no one is required to account as to why or wherefore the said falsehoods were manufactured , and I really can see no reason why I should be called upon to account for a blunder of the Dnblin editor of 1735 . Bro . Philadelphos , in the issue of this paper of 30 th Oct ., says :

" Bnt I have always looked upon the Coxe Deputation , and the extracts from the Philadelphia Journal ' • • as having a very direct bearing upon the subject , and till the reality of their existence has been very seriously disturbed , I shall always be of opinion that Freemasonry undoubtedly established itself in Philadelphia beforo it

did in any other city of the present United States ; I will go further and say , that even if the Coxe Deputation was never granted—and I know no Craftsman who is more competent to throw light on this than Bro . Gould—I should still hold to the belief that the evidence of a contemporary journal as to there having been meetings of the Craft in the City of Brotherly Love , cannot be overset . "

Now , I have never doubted that Coxe received a deputation in 1730 ' constituting him P . G . M . of Kew York , New Jersey , and Pennsylvania . I believo , also , that in 1730 Franklin , in his paper , stated that several Lodges existed in Pennsylvania ; and in 1732 he gave an account of the meeting of a Grand Lodge in Philadelphia . But I maintain that no evidence is in existence showing a connection between Daniel

Coxe and Pennsylvania Freemasonry . Coxe joined a Loudon Lodge in 1731 , and no one could find his return to America before 1734 , that is , two years after he ceased to be G . M . Now , had Coxe founded Masonry in Pennsylvania , and , residing as he did within twenty miles of Philadelphia , he would snrely have visited the Philadelphia Grand Lodge , at least once , on a 24 th of June , to participate with his Masonic children in the Festival of St . John ' s Day ; and had he so visited them

his name would have appeai'ed among the distinguished dignitaries in tho Pennsylvania Gazette . Coxe died in 1739 ; had his Grand Mastership been known to Benjamin Franklin , Franklin would have noticed him in the Pennsylvania'Gazette . Yet there is not only no evidence in tho Pennsylvania Gazette that Franklin knew of Coxe ' s Deputation , bt . t there is no evidence in ail Franklin ' s writings of his knowledge of the very existence of Daniel Coxe ; and , furthermore , there is no

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy