Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Feb. 2, 1884
  • Page 2
  • MASONRY AND CHRISTIANITY.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Feb. 2, 1884: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Feb. 2, 1884
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article NATIONAL GREAT PRIORY OF CANADA. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article NATIONAL GREAT PRIORY OF CANADA. Page 2 of 2
    Article MASONRY AND CHRISTIANITY. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

National Great Priory Of Canada.

with that of St . John of Jerusalem , so that " their secret doctrines were preserved and introduced into various countries of Europe . " It is a well-known legend of the Society that a few Templars became mingled with the Architectural

Fraternities , and it is on record that as early as 1590 a Lodge of Builders at Stirling in Scotland had a Templar Chapter attached to it , tho members of which were designated " Cross-legged Masons , " and whose initiatory ceremonies were performed not in a room , but in the old abbey , the

ruins of which are still to be seen in the neighbourhood . After the Reformation , " the combined Orders of the Temple and ' Hospitallers of St . John ' in Scotland appear only as belonging to the Masonio Society . " In England , after 1717 , many brethren , dissatisfied with the

radical changes then introduced , held meetings among themselves for the purpose of teaching the old doctrines , and in the middle of last century " these meetings assumed the form of a revival of the Chivalric- Templars , imitating their ancient ceremonies and usages . " In these Templar

Lodges or Encampments the legitimacy of the Templar and ancient Masonic doctrines was fully believed in . From this has sprung our present system which " appears to serve" to keep alive the true Christian and Trinitarian character of Freemasonry , the direct descent theory of

British Templary from the Ancient Knights being unsustainable , beyond showing " that the doctrines of the Old Order are still intact , and form the basis of our Modern system . " After showing how different is the Templar system as pursued in the United States , Sir Knight Moore goes on

to deprecate any radical change in the present organisation . The American Templars may regard the Canadian as inferior in respect to their nationality , and because the latter form only a branch of the Cosmopolitan Order which boasts of the Prince of Wales as its Grand Master ; but this is the

very point on which they , as Canadian Templars , should pride themselves , and any separation on their part from the Order would degrade them into " a mere adjunct to the Craft , " so that they would become a kind of " Police " guard for public display and demonstrations of Craft

Masonry . Convent General " may have proved a mistake , a mere illusion , and Great Priory should no doubt be selfcontained , but it is in reality independent , and it would be

uncourteous to think of severing our connection with the Grand Master to whom we have sworn fealty , and who moreover belongs to Canada as well as to England and Ireland . "

Other matters are also touched upon , of which the following , relating to the sacredness of the ballot , and being universally applicable , is worth quoting : " It is with pain I feel called upon to notice reports and complaints made to me during the past year of practices utterly at variance

with all the principles of honour and teachings of Masonry , which I did not think it possible could exist . I refer to personal disputes and ill-feeling prevailing in some Preceptories , which has led to the underhand and most dishonourable action of taking advantage of the ' Secret

Ballot' to blackball all candidates brought forward , not from any fault as to their character or merits , but from personal dislike and spite towards the rules of the Preceptory , or the individual member who proposed the candidate . Such acts are most base and unmanly , and if

substantiated that individuals have boasted that they did so , or intended to do so , should subject the offenders to be ignominiously expelled and not tolerated in any society . " We agree with every word of this strong condemnation of so base a practice .

The further proceedings are principally of local interest , but the question of absolute and complete independence of Convent General having been referred to a Special Committee , that body , of which Sir Knight J . H . Graham was Chairman , reported in favour of the proposition , and the

Great Prior , though retaining his own personal views on the question , consented , in deference to the wishes of the general body , to take the necessary steps to bring about the Separation from the Templar system as presided over "b y the Prince of Wales as Grand Master . Sir Knight

Graham is entitled to his own opinions , and to exercise in support of them such influence as he may happen to possess , but , in our view , Colonel Moore is a far better and

more prudent counsellor , and it is to be regretted that Sir Knight Graham did not time his arrival on the scene so as to have been too late , as owing to his ahsence , and that of other members of the sub-Committee , during the earlier

National Great Priory Of Canada.

part of the proceedings , no report was delivered , and it had been resolved that the question should be deferred till next annual assembly . But Sir Graham appeared on the scene , and , as might have been foreseen , the separation question was taken up and settled . Bnt no other result could have

been anticipated when it is remembered that this is the same brother who , as Grand Master of Quebec , had it in contemplation to anathematise all English Masons , from His Royal Highness downwards , because certain Lodges in Montreal will not place themselves under the banner of

the Grand Lodge of Quebec ; and who , since then , has distinguished himself by addressing a most objectionable letter to the Grand Master of the Mark Grand Lodge of England , and having it printed , and we presume published

before it could possibly have reached the brother to whom it was addressed . We say again , it is deeply to be regretted that the prudent course of Great Prior Moore was not preferred to that of Frater Graham .

Masonry And Christianity.

MASONRY AND CHRISTIANITY .

A STRIKING ANALOGY . THE secret , quiet , and yet potent influence that emanates from Freemasonry , an influence which manifests itself not with ostentation or parade , but by tranquil methods , while it meets the approbation of all initiates , and

is not excepted to even by impartial thinkers among the profane , has had the fortune to evoke from ultra-religionists , both Roman Catholic and Protestant , unsparing condemnation . These fanatics will not consider whether the

fundamental principles of Freemasonry are correct , or morall y helpful , but the simple fact that the Fraternity is secret , in the sense of excluding from its meetings all but Initiates , causes it to receive their emphatic disapproval . They seem to forget that for several centuries Christianity itself

was a secret society—more purely so than Freemasonry is now , in that all of its principles were secret , and its meetings were all held in secret , and at night , at which none but Christians were permitted to be present . No Masonio Lodge is more jealously tyled now than a Christian

assemblage was then . More than this : The secrets of Christianity were communicated only to initiates , and these initiates were first made Christians , then advanced in Christianity , and finally raised to a knowledge of all the aporrheta of

Christianity . There were three degrees in Christianity . Its religious system was known as Disciplina Arcani , the Discipline of the Secret . There was an exoteric and an esoteric doctrine . The three classes who received

the three degrees of the Primitive Church were the Catechumens , the Competentes , and the Illuminati , or Mystae . In the first degree of Christianity the candidate was baptized—Baptism introduced the believer to the Christian Mystery . The secret doctrines taught in the several

degrees were those of the Trinity in unity , the Incarnation of the Logos , or Son of God , the Crucifixion , the Resurrection and the secret of the Liturgy . Baptism initiated the candidate , while a participation in the Lord ' s Supper , or Eucharist , marked the raising of the candidate to the

highest degree of Christian light and doctrine . Freemasons will observe the remarkable analogy between the secret character of primitive Christianity , and its division into degrees , and Freemasonry . But this analogy extended even further . The meetings of the early Christians were

held exclusively at night . Indeed , the advent of the Founder of Christianity took place at night , the Lord ' s Supper was instituted at night , and the Resurrection occurred at night . In the time of Justin Martyr ( A . D . 170 ) Christianity was positively a secret society ; but a few

years later it became , if possible , still more so . In the time of Pope Innocent I . ( A . D . 402-417 ) Bishop Dicentius consulted the Pope upon the subject of the Sacramental Rites , when he was told , " That instead of asking for explanations in writing about the secret things , he should have

contented himself with observing what took place in the celebration of the Mysteries , at which he had several times assisted . " And , after giving some sage advice , Pope Innocent I . concluded : "As to the other things about which we are not permitted to write , you will ask us when you come

here , and we will be able to answer . A written communication would oetray the secret" ( Migne's Patrology , vol . 20 , p 51 ) . Twenty-eight times in the New Testament do we find the words Mystery and Mysteries . For example : "We

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1884-02-02, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 4 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_02021884/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
NATIONAL GREAT PRIORY OF CANADA. Article 1
Untitled Article 1
MASONRY AND CHRISTIANITY. Article 2
THE AGE OF MASONRY IN MASSACHUSETTS. Article 3
Untitled Ad 3
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 4
REVIEWS. Article 5
INSTALLATION MEETINGS, &c. Article 6
COMPLIMENTARY BANQUET TO BRO. H. W. TOWNSEND. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
ROYAL ARCH. Article 8
POLISH NATIONAL CHAPTER, No. 534. Article 9
MARK MASONRY. Article 9
RANDOM NOTES AND REFLECTIONS. Article 10
GOOD OFFICERS ESSENTIAL TO THE PROSPERITY OF A LODGE. Article 10
BRIXTON LODGE OF INSTRUCTION, No. 1949. Article 11
PRESENTATION TO A NORTHAMPTON BROTHER. Article 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
THE THEATERS,&c. Article 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

13 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

12 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

15 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

National Great Priory Of Canada.

with that of St . John of Jerusalem , so that " their secret doctrines were preserved and introduced into various countries of Europe . " It is a well-known legend of the Society that a few Templars became mingled with the Architectural

Fraternities , and it is on record that as early as 1590 a Lodge of Builders at Stirling in Scotland had a Templar Chapter attached to it , tho members of which were designated " Cross-legged Masons , " and whose initiatory ceremonies were performed not in a room , but in the old abbey , the

ruins of which are still to be seen in the neighbourhood . After the Reformation , " the combined Orders of the Temple and ' Hospitallers of St . John ' in Scotland appear only as belonging to the Masonio Society . " In England , after 1717 , many brethren , dissatisfied with the

radical changes then introduced , held meetings among themselves for the purpose of teaching the old doctrines , and in the middle of last century " these meetings assumed the form of a revival of the Chivalric- Templars , imitating their ancient ceremonies and usages . " In these Templar

Lodges or Encampments the legitimacy of the Templar and ancient Masonic doctrines was fully believed in . From this has sprung our present system which " appears to serve" to keep alive the true Christian and Trinitarian character of Freemasonry , the direct descent theory of

British Templary from the Ancient Knights being unsustainable , beyond showing " that the doctrines of the Old Order are still intact , and form the basis of our Modern system . " After showing how different is the Templar system as pursued in the United States , Sir Knight Moore goes on

to deprecate any radical change in the present organisation . The American Templars may regard the Canadian as inferior in respect to their nationality , and because the latter form only a branch of the Cosmopolitan Order which boasts of the Prince of Wales as its Grand Master ; but this is the

very point on which they , as Canadian Templars , should pride themselves , and any separation on their part from the Order would degrade them into " a mere adjunct to the Craft , " so that they would become a kind of " Police " guard for public display and demonstrations of Craft

Masonry . Convent General " may have proved a mistake , a mere illusion , and Great Priory should no doubt be selfcontained , but it is in reality independent , and it would be

uncourteous to think of severing our connection with the Grand Master to whom we have sworn fealty , and who moreover belongs to Canada as well as to England and Ireland . "

Other matters are also touched upon , of which the following , relating to the sacredness of the ballot , and being universally applicable , is worth quoting : " It is with pain I feel called upon to notice reports and complaints made to me during the past year of practices utterly at variance

with all the principles of honour and teachings of Masonry , which I did not think it possible could exist . I refer to personal disputes and ill-feeling prevailing in some Preceptories , which has led to the underhand and most dishonourable action of taking advantage of the ' Secret

Ballot' to blackball all candidates brought forward , not from any fault as to their character or merits , but from personal dislike and spite towards the rules of the Preceptory , or the individual member who proposed the candidate . Such acts are most base and unmanly , and if

substantiated that individuals have boasted that they did so , or intended to do so , should subject the offenders to be ignominiously expelled and not tolerated in any society . " We agree with every word of this strong condemnation of so base a practice .

The further proceedings are principally of local interest , but the question of absolute and complete independence of Convent General having been referred to a Special Committee , that body , of which Sir Knight J . H . Graham was Chairman , reported in favour of the proposition , and the

Great Prior , though retaining his own personal views on the question , consented , in deference to the wishes of the general body , to take the necessary steps to bring about the Separation from the Templar system as presided over "b y the Prince of Wales as Grand Master . Sir Knight

Graham is entitled to his own opinions , and to exercise in support of them such influence as he may happen to possess , but , in our view , Colonel Moore is a far better and

more prudent counsellor , and it is to be regretted that Sir Knight Graham did not time his arrival on the scene so as to have been too late , as owing to his ahsence , and that of other members of the sub-Committee , during the earlier

National Great Priory Of Canada.

part of the proceedings , no report was delivered , and it had been resolved that the question should be deferred till next annual assembly . But Sir Graham appeared on the scene , and , as might have been foreseen , the separation question was taken up and settled . Bnt no other result could have

been anticipated when it is remembered that this is the same brother who , as Grand Master of Quebec , had it in contemplation to anathematise all English Masons , from His Royal Highness downwards , because certain Lodges in Montreal will not place themselves under the banner of

the Grand Lodge of Quebec ; and who , since then , has distinguished himself by addressing a most objectionable letter to the Grand Master of the Mark Grand Lodge of England , and having it printed , and we presume published

before it could possibly have reached the brother to whom it was addressed . We say again , it is deeply to be regretted that the prudent course of Great Prior Moore was not preferred to that of Frater Graham .

Masonry And Christianity.

MASONRY AND CHRISTIANITY .

A STRIKING ANALOGY . THE secret , quiet , and yet potent influence that emanates from Freemasonry , an influence which manifests itself not with ostentation or parade , but by tranquil methods , while it meets the approbation of all initiates , and

is not excepted to even by impartial thinkers among the profane , has had the fortune to evoke from ultra-religionists , both Roman Catholic and Protestant , unsparing condemnation . These fanatics will not consider whether the

fundamental principles of Freemasonry are correct , or morall y helpful , but the simple fact that the Fraternity is secret , in the sense of excluding from its meetings all but Initiates , causes it to receive their emphatic disapproval . They seem to forget that for several centuries Christianity itself

was a secret society—more purely so than Freemasonry is now , in that all of its principles were secret , and its meetings were all held in secret , and at night , at which none but Christians were permitted to be present . No Masonio Lodge is more jealously tyled now than a Christian

assemblage was then . More than this : The secrets of Christianity were communicated only to initiates , and these initiates were first made Christians , then advanced in Christianity , and finally raised to a knowledge of all the aporrheta of

Christianity . There were three degrees in Christianity . Its religious system was known as Disciplina Arcani , the Discipline of the Secret . There was an exoteric and an esoteric doctrine . The three classes who received

the three degrees of the Primitive Church were the Catechumens , the Competentes , and the Illuminati , or Mystae . In the first degree of Christianity the candidate was baptized—Baptism introduced the believer to the Christian Mystery . The secret doctrines taught in the several

degrees were those of the Trinity in unity , the Incarnation of the Logos , or Son of God , the Crucifixion , the Resurrection and the secret of the Liturgy . Baptism initiated the candidate , while a participation in the Lord ' s Supper , or Eucharist , marked the raising of the candidate to the

highest degree of Christian light and doctrine . Freemasons will observe the remarkable analogy between the secret character of primitive Christianity , and its division into degrees , and Freemasonry . But this analogy extended even further . The meetings of the early Christians were

held exclusively at night . Indeed , the advent of the Founder of Christianity took place at night , the Lord ' s Supper was instituted at night , and the Resurrection occurred at night . In the time of Justin Martyr ( A . D . 170 ) Christianity was positively a secret society ; but a few

years later it became , if possible , still more so . In the time of Pope Innocent I . ( A . D . 402-417 ) Bishop Dicentius consulted the Pope upon the subject of the Sacramental Rites , when he was told , " That instead of asking for explanations in writing about the secret things , he should have

contented himself with observing what took place in the celebration of the Mysteries , at which he had several times assisted . " And , after giving some sage advice , Pope Innocent I . concluded : "As to the other things about which we are not permitted to write , you will ask us when you come

here , and we will be able to answer . A written communication would oetray the secret" ( Migne's Patrology , vol . 20 , p 51 ) . Twenty-eight times in the New Testament do we find the words Mystery and Mysteries . For example : "We

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy