Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • April 8, 1876
  • Page 5
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, April 8, 1876: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, April 8, 1876
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 1
    Article CENTENARY LODGES. Page 1 of 1
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

We do not hold ourselves responsible for the opinions of our Cor . respondents . We cannot undertake to return rejected communications . All Letters must bear the name and address of the Writer , not necessarily for publication , but as a guarantee of good faith .

GRAND LODGE HONOURS . To the Editor of THE FREEMASON ' S CHRONICLE . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , — " Ecco homo , " or , in plain English , " Behold tho man , " He is in our midst . There is not a particle of a mistake about it . All history proves that " with the hour cometh tho man . " Then why should the trite saying bo falsified in Masonio history . The fires of discontent and disaffection which are supposed

to be smouldering beneath the placid , bufc treacherous surface , will soon bo fanned into lurid flame . Tho first note of the coming tempest was sounded in my former letter . I again feel bound to raise a voice of warning , for the letter of " Enquirer , " which appeared in your pages of 25 th March , contains confirmation , strong as " Holy Writ , " that my apprehensions were only too well founded . In it we find

openly proclaimed what was until then only vaguely and insiduously indicated . It behoves us , therefore , be on tho alert . Protestations of loyalty notwithstanding , our vigilance must not bo relaxed . Great captains permit themselves all manner of stratagems to gain an advantage . Wo havo no reason to assume that the great leader of tho coming revolution will be less expert in their use . Already a step in advance

has been taken . The programme is published . It is tho manifesto of the chief . It has probably been read and commented upon by thousands . Why should we hesitate to analyze it ? The first portion has reference to my personal self . As a rule I hato egotism , and upon principle like to remain in the back-gronnd . But I feel so positively grateful to tho writer for expressing a fear that by his agency

my mental and physicial equilibrium has been rudely shaken , that I hasten to re-assure him . He may banish all anxiety about mo , and undisturbedly enjoy "his night ' s rest . It may also be gratifying to him to learn that it takes a wonderful deal to " disturb my equanimity . " My peculiar temperament enables mo to tako part in a discussion , however intensely interesting , with calm and dispassionate

deliberation , and to bear with exemplary meekness any amount of abuse an opponent might see fit to heap upon me , always provided it is undeserved . In the present controversy , as well as in all others , personal feelings should bo held in abeyance ; I endeavour to follow this rule , and confine my observations to combat such arguments as may seem worthy of consideration . " Enquirer " describes mo as a

" dogmatic critic . " I have never hoard that dogmatism is sinful , or even a breach of propriety . I can , however , conscientiously say , which somo that I could name cannot , that if my opinions aro flavoured with dogmatism , thoy havo at least tho merit of being unbiassed by any hope of gratifying personal vanity or latent ambition . And if such views as I happen to entertain upon this or any other

subject aro not acceptable to " Enquirer , " and those who think with him , I shall be perfectly contented if I secure the approbation of those whoso fairness , impartiality and good sense are universally known and beyond question . Personal matters are of course uninteresting ; wo will , therefore , drop them , and proceed to the next point , which must certainly be regarded as of tho highest importance

to mankind in general . In somewhat bombastic language the world is given to understand that " Enquirer " is stoutly resolved to " hold fast the Englishman ' s privilege of freedom of speech . " Let ns sing Hallelujah , and rejoice in the fact . But as I am unaware of any one over having attempted to deprive him of his undoubted right , tho pompous outburst seems gratuitous . Yet , while loudly claiming

the privilege for himself , he furnishes proof thafc had ho the power , he wonld deny it to others . As , for instance , the views expressed in my last letter , he designates " a string of invectives , " and declares that he " refuses to have my opinions thrust down his throat , " as he elegantly and classically phrases ifc . It is , however , vastly amusing to note tho extreme caution with which he exercises tho much

vaunted privilege securely under cover of the safe and convenient shelter of a noni de plume . Unfortunatel y , I labour under the disadvantake of being a foreigner , yet do I most highly value and appreciate the great boon of freedom of utterance , written or verbal . But , in common with all peace-loving men , I would rejoice in its restriction , or even total suppression , were ifc generally used at tho

expense of honesty and truth . Liberty of speech , degenerating into licence becomes a curse , especially when employed in unjust and unfair criticism , or taken advantage of for tho purpose oi ; garbeling or misconstruing the statements of an opponent . These truisms are in no way intended for personal application . Until the contrary is proved , we are bound to suppose every one actuated bv the

worthiest of motives . I should bo very sorry even to hint that , with '' malice aforethonght , " my opponent has treated my remarks with wilful aud intentional dishonesty , yet how am 1 to account for the fact that not one of my statements is fairly represented , and plain and obvious meanings so misconstrued , twisted ai .-L perverted , as tc obliterate all resemblance IO the original . I will charitably ascriW

it to misconception on Ids part . I am prompted to do so . not onl > from benevolent motives , but from the consideration of his notion ' - of refinement . A gentleman " who is able to dance , and has the yract to lisp sweet nothings to brainless young ladies , " ho conceives to bt endowed with the tastes , habits and usages of refined society ! L

it credible , a man possessing more than average intelligence , unless his mind has suddenly become unhinged , or in moments of mental abstraction , can seriously entertain an idea so preposterous , 01 honestl y maintain that that was the meaning it was intended to convey , Perhaps the writer meant to he jocular when penning that

part of- his letter . Ho next volunteers tho unnecessary information that he did not seek to oppose the re-election of H . R . H . Whoever said ho did ? Consistently with tho principles he advocates ho ought to havo done so . It is to that end they naturally and inevitably tend . If , as ho asserts , as Masons wo aro all equal , in tho sense ho wishes us to understand the term , then I maintain Bro . Growler has

as good a light to the Grand Mastership as tho Prince , for where , is the lino to bo drawn ? Tho last part of this extraordinary document contains the programme . In the view of the coming liberator tho Grand Lodge , as at present constituted , is an oligarchy , which he thinks it his mission to destroy . To do this effectually he must secure the dethronement of tho present Ruler , ho being tho Chief Oligarch .

We are further informed of his determination to form a healthy (?) public opinion amongst tho members of Graud Lodge , and make them shake off their indifference or apathy ( which you prefer , my Masters ) to enable him to achieve his purpose . Ho promises to try to emulate the zeal and earnestness of Peter tho Hermit' ( he , being only half fledged , modestly refuses to bo called by that name as yet ) in

preaching a crusade againgst the , to him , so obnoxious oligarchy , by and bye . Then let the Grand Lodgo shako in its shoes , for its days will be numbered . Tho restorers of our newly regained liberties will sing " Tommy make room for your Uncle , " and the despotic oligarchs who so long and tenaciously have kept their grinding heels upon our slavish necks will havo to evaporate . A few words more and I have

done . In many respects tho principles of Freemasonry aro democratic , but not in tho sense Red Republicans or Communists understand it . Our traditions show tho chiefs to havo always been selected from tho highest in the land . Tho first Grand Lodge was presided over by three of tho greatest men in Israel , tho second , from which , be it observed , wo are taught to believe is derived

our present system of government , by two kings , and one who was " of living men best dowered of Heaven , " tho third by a princo , a prophet , and a high priest . Would ifc bo wise , prudent or politic , to discard an inheritance whose value has stood the test of ages , for an innovation , the merits of which , to put it mildly , aro at least problematical . In the outer world , republicanism has of late cut but a sorry figure . Jobbery , peculation , dishonesty

in every shape , and all manner of odious and disgusting vices have been dominant amongst men who attained high positions in the state upon the principle of perfect equality , which " Enquirer " so strongly advocates , and promises to do his best to establish . Honest men are not likely to bo charmed with , a'system which can produce no bettor results , aud Masons will scarcely be induced to accept ifc in exchange for their ancient landmarks and time-honoured traditions . lours fraternally , E . GOTTHEIL .

Centenary Lodges.

CENTENARY LODGES .

To the Editor oj THE I UEEMASON s CHUOMCLE . DEAR BRO . —I notice that Bro . Spencer intends publishing a history of the Lodges under tho Grand Lodge of England . Such a work is much wanted , and would , iu my opinion , be as acceptable to our foreign brethren as to the Craft at home . I write ( of course , with all due deference to Bro . Spencer's views )

to suggest the publication , in the columns of your readable paper , of a list of all the Lodges entitled to a centenary jewel , according to the designs submitted for the approval of the M . W . G . M . prior to the new regulations requiring all the members of centenary Lodges ( since 186 G ) to wear a jewel of a uniform pattern , issued by the Grand

Lodge-of England , and not to be obtained elsewhere . Such a list would prove most valuable and interesting , as also one affording information as to all special jewels allowed to be worn by the members of certain Lodges . Yours fraternally , S . 0 .

Those who may have cast a glance at our advertisement columns last week must have noticed , in the announcement of the business that will be submitted to the Quarterly General Court of tho Girls' School to-day , a notice of motion by Bro . Kenyon , to the effect that a

Committee of five Governors be appointed to inspect certain freehold lands at divers places near London , with a view to the erection of enlarged school premises thereon . However , onl y four names appear in t . iiu advertisement . , namely : —those of Lieut .-Colonel Burdett , Dudley R > 1 U

Ivsq ., Dr . R .-iiiisay , and ii . ICenyon , ( llsq . Limit .-Colonel Ureaion ' s name was ori g inally included , but wiDhont his sanction , aud , ; is soon as he heard this , he gave peremptory infractions for its withdrawal . Hence the apparent inoinalv of a Commhioe of live , ronsis : of four members

only , fanace then Lieun .-uohmol Bnniei . ; , h ; is written , to . he effect that his name likewise has boon used , -i , hunt : iis sanction , and that he , too , d'Hiue .- ; to act upon the Committee . Of course , Bro . Kenyan m iy ho in a podfcion r . explain his monstrous presumption in usiai ' , without

heir . sanction , the names of r , wo gentlemen , of whom one it least , we know , is committed to a particular pron .. sit : on re the enlargement of the Girls' School . But the fc . egoing information is perfectl y trustworth y , and , knowing this , we consider comment on Bro . Kenyou ' s conduct supsjrfhiotis .

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1876-04-08, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 3 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_08041876/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE BOYS' SCHOOL. Article 1
MASONIC PORTRAITS (No. 23). A RIGHT HAND MAN. Article 2
Obituary. Article 3
WEST YORKSHIRE. ANNUAL MEETING OF PROV. GRAND LODGE. Article 4
POLLUTING THE BALLOT BOX. Article 4
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 5
CENTENARY LODGES. Article 5
REVIEWS. Article 6
READING.—UNITED MEETING OF THE TWO LODGES. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 9
OUR WEEKLY BUDGET. Article 9
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 11
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 12
TENTH ANNUAL FESTIVAL OF ST. ANDREW'S LODGE , No. 465. Article 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

2 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

7 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

3 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

14 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

18 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

We do not hold ourselves responsible for the opinions of our Cor . respondents . We cannot undertake to return rejected communications . All Letters must bear the name and address of the Writer , not necessarily for publication , but as a guarantee of good faith .

GRAND LODGE HONOURS . To the Editor of THE FREEMASON ' S CHRONICLE . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , — " Ecco homo , " or , in plain English , " Behold tho man , " He is in our midst . There is not a particle of a mistake about it . All history proves that " with the hour cometh tho man . " Then why should the trite saying bo falsified in Masonio history . The fires of discontent and disaffection which are supposed

to be smouldering beneath the placid , bufc treacherous surface , will soon bo fanned into lurid flame . Tho first note of the coming tempest was sounded in my former letter . I again feel bound to raise a voice of warning , for the letter of " Enquirer , " which appeared in your pages of 25 th March , contains confirmation , strong as " Holy Writ , " that my apprehensions were only too well founded . In it we find

openly proclaimed what was until then only vaguely and insiduously indicated . It behoves us , therefore , be on tho alert . Protestations of loyalty notwithstanding , our vigilance must not bo relaxed . Great captains permit themselves all manner of stratagems to gain an advantage . Wo havo no reason to assume that the great leader of tho coming revolution will be less expert in their use . Already a step in advance

has been taken . The programme is published . It is tho manifesto of the chief . It has probably been read and commented upon by thousands . Why should we hesitate to analyze it ? The first portion has reference to my personal self . As a rule I hato egotism , and upon principle like to remain in the back-gronnd . But I feel so positively grateful to tho writer for expressing a fear that by his agency

my mental and physicial equilibrium has been rudely shaken , that I hasten to re-assure him . He may banish all anxiety about mo , and undisturbedly enjoy "his night ' s rest . It may also be gratifying to him to learn that it takes a wonderful deal to " disturb my equanimity . " My peculiar temperament enables mo to tako part in a discussion , however intensely interesting , with calm and dispassionate

deliberation , and to bear with exemplary meekness any amount of abuse an opponent might see fit to heap upon me , always provided it is undeserved . In the present controversy , as well as in all others , personal feelings should bo held in abeyance ; I endeavour to follow this rule , and confine my observations to combat such arguments as may seem worthy of consideration . " Enquirer " describes mo as a

" dogmatic critic . " I have never hoard that dogmatism is sinful , or even a breach of propriety . I can , however , conscientiously say , which somo that I could name cannot , that if my opinions aro flavoured with dogmatism , thoy havo at least tho merit of being unbiassed by any hope of gratifying personal vanity or latent ambition . And if such views as I happen to entertain upon this or any other

subject aro not acceptable to " Enquirer , " and those who think with him , I shall be perfectly contented if I secure the approbation of those whoso fairness , impartiality and good sense are universally known and beyond question . Personal matters are of course uninteresting ; wo will , therefore , drop them , and proceed to the next point , which must certainly be regarded as of tho highest importance

to mankind in general . In somewhat bombastic language the world is given to understand that " Enquirer " is stoutly resolved to " hold fast the Englishman ' s privilege of freedom of speech . " Let ns sing Hallelujah , and rejoice in the fact . But as I am unaware of any one over having attempted to deprive him of his undoubted right , tho pompous outburst seems gratuitous . Yet , while loudly claiming

the privilege for himself , he furnishes proof thafc had ho the power , he wonld deny it to others . As , for instance , the views expressed in my last letter , he designates " a string of invectives , " and declares that he " refuses to have my opinions thrust down his throat , " as he elegantly and classically phrases ifc . It is , however , vastly amusing to note tho extreme caution with which he exercises tho much

vaunted privilege securely under cover of the safe and convenient shelter of a noni de plume . Unfortunatel y , I labour under the disadvantake of being a foreigner , yet do I most highly value and appreciate the great boon of freedom of utterance , written or verbal . But , in common with all peace-loving men , I would rejoice in its restriction , or even total suppression , were ifc generally used at tho

expense of honesty and truth . Liberty of speech , degenerating into licence becomes a curse , especially when employed in unjust and unfair criticism , or taken advantage of for tho purpose oi ; garbeling or misconstruing the statements of an opponent . These truisms are in no way intended for personal application . Until the contrary is proved , we are bound to suppose every one actuated bv the

worthiest of motives . I should bo very sorry even to hint that , with '' malice aforethonght , " my opponent has treated my remarks with wilful aud intentional dishonesty , yet how am 1 to account for the fact that not one of my statements is fairly represented , and plain and obvious meanings so misconstrued , twisted ai .-L perverted , as tc obliterate all resemblance IO the original . I will charitably ascriW

it to misconception on Ids part . I am prompted to do so . not onl > from benevolent motives , but from the consideration of his notion ' - of refinement . A gentleman " who is able to dance , and has the yract to lisp sweet nothings to brainless young ladies , " ho conceives to bt endowed with the tastes , habits and usages of refined society ! L

it credible , a man possessing more than average intelligence , unless his mind has suddenly become unhinged , or in moments of mental abstraction , can seriously entertain an idea so preposterous , 01 honestl y maintain that that was the meaning it was intended to convey , Perhaps the writer meant to he jocular when penning that

part of- his letter . Ho next volunteers tho unnecessary information that he did not seek to oppose the re-election of H . R . H . Whoever said ho did ? Consistently with tho principles he advocates ho ought to havo done so . It is to that end they naturally and inevitably tend . If , as ho asserts , as Masons wo aro all equal , in tho sense ho wishes us to understand the term , then I maintain Bro . Growler has

as good a light to the Grand Mastership as tho Prince , for where , is the lino to bo drawn ? Tho last part of this extraordinary document contains the programme . In the view of the coming liberator tho Grand Lodge , as at present constituted , is an oligarchy , which he thinks it his mission to destroy . To do this effectually he must secure the dethronement of tho present Ruler , ho being tho Chief Oligarch .

We are further informed of his determination to form a healthy (?) public opinion amongst tho members of Graud Lodge , and make them shake off their indifference or apathy ( which you prefer , my Masters ) to enable him to achieve his purpose . Ho promises to try to emulate the zeal and earnestness of Peter tho Hermit' ( he , being only half fledged , modestly refuses to bo called by that name as yet ) in

preaching a crusade againgst the , to him , so obnoxious oligarchy , by and bye . Then let the Grand Lodgo shako in its shoes , for its days will be numbered . Tho restorers of our newly regained liberties will sing " Tommy make room for your Uncle , " and the despotic oligarchs who so long and tenaciously have kept their grinding heels upon our slavish necks will havo to evaporate . A few words more and I have

done . In many respects tho principles of Freemasonry aro democratic , but not in tho sense Red Republicans or Communists understand it . Our traditions show tho chiefs to havo always been selected from tho highest in the land . Tho first Grand Lodge was presided over by three of tho greatest men in Israel , tho second , from which , be it observed , wo are taught to believe is derived

our present system of government , by two kings , and one who was " of living men best dowered of Heaven , " tho third by a princo , a prophet , and a high priest . Would ifc bo wise , prudent or politic , to discard an inheritance whose value has stood the test of ages , for an innovation , the merits of which , to put it mildly , aro at least problematical . In the outer world , republicanism has of late cut but a sorry figure . Jobbery , peculation , dishonesty

in every shape , and all manner of odious and disgusting vices have been dominant amongst men who attained high positions in the state upon the principle of perfect equality , which " Enquirer " so strongly advocates , and promises to do his best to establish . Honest men are not likely to bo charmed with , a'system which can produce no bettor results , aud Masons will scarcely be induced to accept ifc in exchange for their ancient landmarks and time-honoured traditions . lours fraternally , E . GOTTHEIL .

Centenary Lodges.

CENTENARY LODGES .

To the Editor oj THE I UEEMASON s CHUOMCLE . DEAR BRO . —I notice that Bro . Spencer intends publishing a history of the Lodges under tho Grand Lodge of England . Such a work is much wanted , and would , iu my opinion , be as acceptable to our foreign brethren as to the Craft at home . I write ( of course , with all due deference to Bro . Spencer's views )

to suggest the publication , in the columns of your readable paper , of a list of all the Lodges entitled to a centenary jewel , according to the designs submitted for the approval of the M . W . G . M . prior to the new regulations requiring all the members of centenary Lodges ( since 186 G ) to wear a jewel of a uniform pattern , issued by the Grand

Lodge-of England , and not to be obtained elsewhere . Such a list would prove most valuable and interesting , as also one affording information as to all special jewels allowed to be worn by the members of certain Lodges . Yours fraternally , S . 0 .

Those who may have cast a glance at our advertisement columns last week must have noticed , in the announcement of the business that will be submitted to the Quarterly General Court of tho Girls' School to-day , a notice of motion by Bro . Kenyon , to the effect that a

Committee of five Governors be appointed to inspect certain freehold lands at divers places near London , with a view to the erection of enlarged school premises thereon . However , onl y four names appear in t . iiu advertisement . , namely : —those of Lieut .-Colonel Burdett , Dudley R > 1 U

Ivsq ., Dr . R .-iiiisay , and ii . ICenyon , ( llsq . Limit .-Colonel Ureaion ' s name was ori g inally included , but wiDhont his sanction , aud , ; is soon as he heard this , he gave peremptory infractions for its withdrawal . Hence the apparent inoinalv of a Commhioe of live , ronsis : of four members

only , fanace then Lieun .-uohmol Bnniei . ; , h ; is written , to . he effect that his name likewise has boon used , -i , hunt : iis sanction , and that he , too , d'Hiue .- ; to act upon the Committee . Of course , Bro . Kenyan m iy ho in a podfcion r . explain his monstrous presumption in usiai ' , without

heir . sanction , the names of r , wo gentlemen , of whom one it least , we know , is committed to a particular pron .. sit : on re the enlargement of the Girls' School . But the fc . egoing information is perfectl y trustworth y , and , knowing this , we consider comment on Bro . Kenyou ' s conduct supsjrfhiotis .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy