Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Sept. 13, 1884
  • Page 5
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 13, 1884: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Sept. 13, 1884
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article FREEMASON'S JOURNAL AND MASONIC PRESS. Page 1 of 1
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemason's Journal And Masonic Press.

FREEMASON'S JOURNAL AND MASONIC PRESS .

FROM THE HEBREW LEADEK . WE have obtained a copy of n new four page paper having the above title , ami issued in the City of Now York , wo bespeak it a large patronage , and trust in its success ; indeed , wo do not . doubt its success if it , will carry ont its professions as contained in its leader of No . 4 . The motto is of the true Masonic ring , " Parity , Harmony , Fraternity . " The Publisher ia Bro . John VV . Keeler :

Editor , Wor . W . II . McDougall ; Contributors , Bros . VV . Dalamatet and A . J . Barton ; Office , 164 Pulton . street . In welcoming this now comer , we ardently hope it will over bear in mind its pronounced purpose and opinion , and jnst so long do wo desire to be its companion . The Freemason's Journal says : " Starting upon the premise that tho publication of derogatory

personalities , by papers claiming Masonic snpport , and supposed tn be animated by tho pnro principles of Masonic teaching , in contrary to the established idea of dnty , as taught to overy initiate and gradnlnto in onr fraternal society , wo havo no difficulty before iia in onr attempts to show what shonld be the aim and end of Masonic Jonrnalism * * * . The Masonio writer , above all members of tho

Craft , shonld be npright , truthful , and honourable , inasmuch as tho opinions of the profane are influenced by his writing . The effect of a dishonest publication , an nntrathfnl statement or a misreprosentation of facts is not usually regarded as serious as it is in fact . The secret of -non-success of Masonio publications in the City of

New York is the hitherto unrecognised fact that there has always been too muoh passion , prejudice , and personal favouritism displayed in them . We havo witnessed , with much sorrow , the rise and fall of promising ventures in Masonic publications , have expressed astonishment at the brevity of their existence , and still have failed to attribute their collapse to the proper cause . Starting fair , they

invariably drifted upon well-known shoals , and were stranded . One is occasionally forced to ask himself the question . Has the subject of Masonry , its morals , its fraternal ties , its charity , its great and important truths , been completely exhausted ? Ave we obliged , as a brotherhood , to resort to the lowest and meanest kind of journalism to secure readers ? Must we fill onr Masonic colnmns

with flattery , buncombe , gush , abase , and scandal to make them interesting to tho great body of intelligent Masons ? We feel like uttering au emphatic negative to each of these questions , but the facts will not warrant suoh answers . A brother meeting another says : ' Have yon seen the Blatant Scandal this week ? "Vou ought to get it and see the way it pitches into Bro . Jones . ' Straightway

the questioned looks for the paper and reads a fierce onslaught on a brother whom he knows to be a good man and Mason . A laugh follows—and this they call Masonio jonrnalism ! And just this sort of thing is what has produce ! fcho lamentable lack of pure Masonio reading . Personalities between brethren shonld meet with general

condemnation , if for no other reason than thafc they encourage the worst elements of onr fraternity as against the bettor . Of late years we have become accnstomed to seeing and hearing certain of our brethren spoken of in highly slanderous and improper terms , and have forgotten onr duty to make strong and earnest protest . The time is now como to make a firm stand against the villainous personal attacks upon tho

reputations of Masons that havo become common ; the time is come to slum and avoid tho ntterers of scandalous lies and vilo insinuations against tho honour and probity of well-known good men and brethren ; tho time is come to discourage and frown npon men (?) who make Masonry a tool to gratify a malicious nature ; tho time ia come to deny all detractors and falsifiers the rights and privileges

due the deserving brother ; the time is come to show these miserable creatures of mistaken charity aud to the world , that honest Masons do indeed love their honest brethren , and that they will no longer be allowed the use of their foul wills , by pen and by tongue , by press and by speech , to abase , slander , and defame the men who have served Masonry honourably and faithfully .

Well may we ask ourselves the question : Why do we permit the vicious of the Fraternity to exercise their foul propensities in the view and hearing of all without vigorous defence ? It may be said silence is better than repressive action ; but silence sometimes becomes acquiescence , and in failure to defend strongly and openly

we are apt to be considered as giving some credence to the defamation . Let this no longer be the rule . Crush slander by putting upon it tbe foot of earnest protest , and if that fails try the remedies Masonic law permits . " If the Freemason's Journal will act in the spirit it commends , it will not be long ere " Blatant Scandal " will be kicked ont of decent

Nooiot y , when Grand Officers will cease to walk hand in hand with "Jendacifcy , and when Lodges and brethren will stjp their contributions now given for fear of tho pen of tbe vilifior , or in other words when tho necessity for present cowardice will be removed , and Masonry and manhood will assert themselves .

The twenty-sixth Annual Conclave of the Grand Commandery Knights Templar of California was hold in April last , in San Francisco . Sir Kuighfc George 0 . Perkins k-C . presided , aud twenty-two Commanderies were

represented . The annual statement of accounts showed total fund 8 , 485 dollars ; disbursements 4 , 434 dollars ; balance 'V- * ' 51 dollars . An elegant silver service was presented to kir

Knight Perkins on his retirement from tho Grand konimandershi p . Sir Knight W . Monroe Petrie , of Sacra-*^ nio , was elected Grand Commander , and Sir Kni ght ¦ * ¦ ¦ Hubbard Caswell re-elected Graud Recorder .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

We do not hold ourselves responsible for the opinions of our Cor rtspnndents . AV Letter * must , hear the name and address of the Writer , no \ t \ eces \ aribi for publication , but as a guarantee of good faith . We cannot undertake to return rejected communications .

REV . BROTHER JOHN ENTICK . To the Editor of the FREEMASON ' CHRONICLE . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —You have given frequent opportunities of airing his Wows to Bro . Jacob Norton ; perhaps you will spare me a small space for a few remarks auent that able and somewhat eccentric brother . I do nofc think I am far wrong in regarding Bro . Norton as a Masonic Iconoclast . He is always tilting afc some cherished

idol or other , and if he is not tho Don Quixote of tho Craft , he ia never tirod of warring against what most ; Freemasons regard as the pieture-qne and romantic surroundings of tho Order . Hia admiration for Rationalism seems to deprive him of all reverence for Tradition . With him the absence of proof that does not amount to mathematical demonstration is regarded as positive evidence against

all speculative philosophy , all tradition , and those charming poetic sentiments which abound in the Craft , and without whioh it would be shorn of much of its beauty and grandeur . Bro . Norton , nevertheless , has done , and is doing , good service by hia sledge-hammer criticisms and his courageous and bold assertions . Like thousands of others I reverence traditions , I venerate old-world thoughts and

actions , where they are not absolutely wicked , and I have a decided objection to have my idols rudely demolished before my very eyes . I believe utilitarianism to be one of the greatest curses of the present age—worse than any superstitions belief that is now prevalent or likely to arise among the Masonic body . I hold strongly , too , thafc to be withont the traditions of the past would be a present living

death . Sentiment is a greater factor in life than Bro . Norton seems willing to admit , and while I respect him for having fche courage of his convictions , I shonld be moro inclined to pay attention to him were he less brutal in assailing what he may term false and worthless prejudices . Bro . Norton's letter in yonr last issue places him in a very

favourable light . He there ceases to destroy , and attempts to educate . He exposes the shortcomings of what should be regarded as a hi gh Masonic authority , and he supplies some facts which merit and demand a larger audience than the Craft affords . Bro . Enfcick was not only an able Freemason , the author of Latin and English dictionaries , but he was a somewhat prolific historian . This fact ought to have found

a place in a work professing to be a Masonio Cyclopedia . Bro . Norton has done well in pointing out omissions in a work that shonld be free from snch blemishes . It is another matter when political aud partisan opinions and acts are in question . Bro . Entick may havo been a patriot , but I hardly think , wero he alive , he would claim the exceptional honour with which Bro . Norton would invest him at the expense

of his brethren of the same Order . All English Freemasons know that politics are excluded from Lodges and Masouic intercourse , and ifc is a matter of opinion how mnch of tho career of a distinguished brother should be given in a work purporting to be a cyclopaedia . My own idea is , thafc all matters of a public character should be regarded in tho simplest form when they in no way relate to the

Craft , leaving it , to the reader s desire for further information to seek it where ifc nny be found . I fear , in the caso in question , tho omis . sions referred to by Bro . Jacob Norton are the result of ignorance and slovenliness , two faults in a compiler that go far to destroy confidence in his accuracy and judgment . Most intelligent Masons would like to know of the doings of a learned brother , more especially if

those doings were of a particularly noteworthy character . Some men miss fame as others do fortune , " and this appears to have been the case with Bro . Entick , who acted a real patriot ' s part , but who , unlike Wilkes , failed to attain the popularity that followed and still clings to the demagogue ' s name . I may mention that I have three authorities where Bro . Entick ' s

name onght to appear , but , strange to say , he only figures in one . and in that no mention is made of his patriotic resistance to the exercise of tyrannical and arbitrary authority . Where his name is mentioned , the date of his death is given as 1780 . If any excuse is needed for Bro . Woodford ' s omission ifc is to be found in the fact that , in a

dictionary devoted to literature , Bro . Entick ' s name is nofc to be found , and that in a popular reference book , where the name is recorded , no mention is made of facts given by Sir Erskine May in his great work . Notwithstanding this defence , I agree with Bro . Norton that Bro . Entick deserved better treatment than ho has received at the bauds of the compiler of the cycloptedia he refers to .

lam , Sir aud Brother , Yours fraternally , WATCHMAN , 9 th Sept . 18 S 4 .

To the Editor of the FREEMASON S CtiRONtCTiE . PEAR Sin A . VB BROTHER , —When I wrote last week about Bro . Entick tho Masonic library room was undergoing repairs , and I could not get any books out of tho cases . I have , however , since then consulted Mackey ' s Cyclopaedia and Oliver ' s Revelations of a Square .

Mackey mentions Entick ' s History in five volumes , and another work in four volumes , and Oliver merely gives the names of several of Entick's sermons . In Gordon ' s Biographical Dictionary Entick is thus referred to : — "A miscellaneous compiler ; was born in 1713 . Wheie he was educated is not known ; nor , although he styled himself 'B . ev . John

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1884-09-13, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 13 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_13091884/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE ENGLISH RITE OF FREEMASONRY.* Article 1
FREEMASONRY IN SPAIN. Article 2
CHRISTIAN SAINTS AND THEIR SUPPOSED FUNCTIONS. Article 3
FREEMASON'S JOURNAL AND MASONIC PRESS. Article 5
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 5
MARK MASONRY. Article 6
SEASONABLE REMARKS. Article 6
DESIGN OF THE DEGREES. Article 6
VACATION PERIODS. Article 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
CATALOGUE OF THE MASONIC SOIREE AND EXHIBITION, WORCESTER, AUGUST, 1844. Article 8
NATIONAL STANDARD THEATRE. Article 10
INSTALLATION MEETINGS, &c. Article 10
Untitled Ad 11
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
DlARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Article 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

4 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

7 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

8 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

6 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

11 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

14 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemason's Journal And Masonic Press.

FREEMASON'S JOURNAL AND MASONIC PRESS .

FROM THE HEBREW LEADEK . WE have obtained a copy of n new four page paper having the above title , ami issued in the City of Now York , wo bespeak it a large patronage , and trust in its success ; indeed , wo do not . doubt its success if it , will carry ont its professions as contained in its leader of No . 4 . The motto is of the true Masonic ring , " Parity , Harmony , Fraternity . " The Publisher ia Bro . John VV . Keeler :

Editor , Wor . W . II . McDougall ; Contributors , Bros . VV . Dalamatet and A . J . Barton ; Office , 164 Pulton . street . In welcoming this now comer , we ardently hope it will over bear in mind its pronounced purpose and opinion , and jnst so long do wo desire to be its companion . The Freemason's Journal says : " Starting upon the premise that tho publication of derogatory

personalities , by papers claiming Masonic snpport , and supposed tn be animated by tho pnro principles of Masonic teaching , in contrary to the established idea of dnty , as taught to overy initiate and gradnlnto in onr fraternal society , wo havo no difficulty before iia in onr attempts to show what shonld be the aim and end of Masonic Jonrnalism * * * . The Masonio writer , above all members of tho

Craft , shonld be npright , truthful , and honourable , inasmuch as tho opinions of the profane are influenced by his writing . The effect of a dishonest publication , an nntrathfnl statement or a misreprosentation of facts is not usually regarded as serious as it is in fact . The secret of -non-success of Masonio publications in the City of

New York is the hitherto unrecognised fact that there has always been too muoh passion , prejudice , and personal favouritism displayed in them . We havo witnessed , with much sorrow , the rise and fall of promising ventures in Masonic publications , have expressed astonishment at the brevity of their existence , and still have failed to attribute their collapse to the proper cause . Starting fair , they

invariably drifted upon well-known shoals , and were stranded . One is occasionally forced to ask himself the question . Has the subject of Masonry , its morals , its fraternal ties , its charity , its great and important truths , been completely exhausted ? Ave we obliged , as a brotherhood , to resort to the lowest and meanest kind of journalism to secure readers ? Must we fill onr Masonic colnmns

with flattery , buncombe , gush , abase , and scandal to make them interesting to tho great body of intelligent Masons ? We feel like uttering au emphatic negative to each of these questions , but the facts will not warrant suoh answers . A brother meeting another says : ' Have yon seen the Blatant Scandal this week ? "Vou ought to get it and see the way it pitches into Bro . Jones . ' Straightway

the questioned looks for the paper and reads a fierce onslaught on a brother whom he knows to be a good man and Mason . A laugh follows—and this they call Masonio jonrnalism ! And just this sort of thing is what has produce ! fcho lamentable lack of pure Masonio reading . Personalities between brethren shonld meet with general

condemnation , if for no other reason than thafc they encourage the worst elements of onr fraternity as against the bettor . Of late years we have become accnstomed to seeing and hearing certain of our brethren spoken of in highly slanderous and improper terms , and have forgotten onr duty to make strong and earnest protest . The time is now como to make a firm stand against the villainous personal attacks upon tho

reputations of Masons that havo become common ; the time is come to slum and avoid tho ntterers of scandalous lies and vilo insinuations against tho honour and probity of well-known good men and brethren ; tho time is come to discourage and frown npon men (?) who make Masonry a tool to gratify a malicious nature ; tho time ia come to deny all detractors and falsifiers the rights and privileges

due the deserving brother ; the time is come to show these miserable creatures of mistaken charity aud to the world , that honest Masons do indeed love their honest brethren , and that they will no longer be allowed the use of their foul wills , by pen and by tongue , by press and by speech , to abase , slander , and defame the men who have served Masonry honourably and faithfully .

Well may we ask ourselves the question : Why do we permit the vicious of the Fraternity to exercise their foul propensities in the view and hearing of all without vigorous defence ? It may be said silence is better than repressive action ; but silence sometimes becomes acquiescence , and in failure to defend strongly and openly

we are apt to be considered as giving some credence to the defamation . Let this no longer be the rule . Crush slander by putting upon it tbe foot of earnest protest , and if that fails try the remedies Masonic law permits . " If the Freemason's Journal will act in the spirit it commends , it will not be long ere " Blatant Scandal " will be kicked ont of decent

Nooiot y , when Grand Officers will cease to walk hand in hand with "Jendacifcy , and when Lodges and brethren will stjp their contributions now given for fear of tho pen of tbe vilifior , or in other words when tho necessity for present cowardice will be removed , and Masonry and manhood will assert themselves .

The twenty-sixth Annual Conclave of the Grand Commandery Knights Templar of California was hold in April last , in San Francisco . Sir Kuighfc George 0 . Perkins k-C . presided , aud twenty-two Commanderies were

represented . The annual statement of accounts showed total fund 8 , 485 dollars ; disbursements 4 , 434 dollars ; balance 'V- * ' 51 dollars . An elegant silver service was presented to kir

Knight Perkins on his retirement from tho Grand konimandershi p . Sir Knight W . Monroe Petrie , of Sacra-*^ nio , was elected Grand Commander , and Sir Kni ght ¦ * ¦ ¦ Hubbard Caswell re-elected Graud Recorder .

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

We do not hold ourselves responsible for the opinions of our Cor rtspnndents . AV Letter * must , hear the name and address of the Writer , no \ t \ eces \ aribi for publication , but as a guarantee of good faith . We cannot undertake to return rejected communications .

REV . BROTHER JOHN ENTICK . To the Editor of the FREEMASON ' CHRONICLE . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —You have given frequent opportunities of airing his Wows to Bro . Jacob Norton ; perhaps you will spare me a small space for a few remarks auent that able and somewhat eccentric brother . I do nofc think I am far wrong in regarding Bro . Norton as a Masonic Iconoclast . He is always tilting afc some cherished

idol or other , and if he is not tho Don Quixote of tho Craft , he ia never tirod of warring against what most ; Freemasons regard as the pieture-qne and romantic surroundings of tho Order . Hia admiration for Rationalism seems to deprive him of all reverence for Tradition . With him the absence of proof that does not amount to mathematical demonstration is regarded as positive evidence against

all speculative philosophy , all tradition , and those charming poetic sentiments which abound in the Craft , and without whioh it would be shorn of much of its beauty and grandeur . Bro . Norton , nevertheless , has done , and is doing , good service by hia sledge-hammer criticisms and his courageous and bold assertions . Like thousands of others I reverence traditions , I venerate old-world thoughts and

actions , where they are not absolutely wicked , and I have a decided objection to have my idols rudely demolished before my very eyes . I believe utilitarianism to be one of the greatest curses of the present age—worse than any superstitions belief that is now prevalent or likely to arise among the Masonic body . I hold strongly , too , thafc to be withont the traditions of the past would be a present living

death . Sentiment is a greater factor in life than Bro . Norton seems willing to admit , and while I respect him for having fche courage of his convictions , I shonld be moro inclined to pay attention to him were he less brutal in assailing what he may term false and worthless prejudices . Bro . Norton's letter in yonr last issue places him in a very

favourable light . He there ceases to destroy , and attempts to educate . He exposes the shortcomings of what should be regarded as a hi gh Masonic authority , and he supplies some facts which merit and demand a larger audience than the Craft affords . Bro . Enfcick was not only an able Freemason , the author of Latin and English dictionaries , but he was a somewhat prolific historian . This fact ought to have found

a place in a work professing to be a Masonio Cyclopedia . Bro . Norton has done well in pointing out omissions in a work that shonld be free from snch blemishes . It is another matter when political aud partisan opinions and acts are in question . Bro . Entick may havo been a patriot , but I hardly think , wero he alive , he would claim the exceptional honour with which Bro . Norton would invest him at the expense

of his brethren of the same Order . All English Freemasons know that politics are excluded from Lodges and Masouic intercourse , and ifc is a matter of opinion how mnch of tho career of a distinguished brother should be given in a work purporting to be a cyclopaedia . My own idea is , thafc all matters of a public character should be regarded in tho simplest form when they in no way relate to the

Craft , leaving it , to the reader s desire for further information to seek it where ifc nny be found . I fear , in the caso in question , tho omis . sions referred to by Bro . Jacob Norton are the result of ignorance and slovenliness , two faults in a compiler that go far to destroy confidence in his accuracy and judgment . Most intelligent Masons would like to know of the doings of a learned brother , more especially if

those doings were of a particularly noteworthy character . Some men miss fame as others do fortune , " and this appears to have been the case with Bro . Entick , who acted a real patriot ' s part , but who , unlike Wilkes , failed to attain the popularity that followed and still clings to the demagogue ' s name . I may mention that I have three authorities where Bro . Entick ' s

name onght to appear , but , strange to say , he only figures in one . and in that no mention is made of his patriotic resistance to the exercise of tyrannical and arbitrary authority . Where his name is mentioned , the date of his death is given as 1780 . If any excuse is needed for Bro . Woodford ' s omission ifc is to be found in the fact that , in a

dictionary devoted to literature , Bro . Entick ' s name is nofc to be found , and that in a popular reference book , where the name is recorded , no mention is made of facts given by Sir Erskine May in his great work . Notwithstanding this defence , I agree with Bro . Norton that Bro . Entick deserved better treatment than ho has received at the bauds of the compiler of the cycloptedia he refers to .

lam , Sir aud Brother , Yours fraternally , WATCHMAN , 9 th Sept . 18 S 4 .

To the Editor of the FREEMASON S CtiRONtCTiE . PEAR Sin A . VB BROTHER , —When I wrote last week about Bro . Entick tho Masonic library room was undergoing repairs , and I could not get any books out of tho cases . I have , however , since then consulted Mackey ' s Cyclopaedia and Oliver ' s Revelations of a Square .

Mackey mentions Entick ' s History in five volumes , and another work in four volumes , and Oliver merely gives the names of several of Entick's sermons . In Gordon ' s Biographical Dictionary Entick is thus referred to : — "A miscellaneous compiler ; was born in 1713 . Wheie he was educated is not known ; nor , although he styled himself 'B . ev . John

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy