Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • July 20, 1889
  • Page 9
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, July 20, 1889: Page 9

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, July 20, 1889
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article AMERICAN MASONIC MANIAS. Page 1 of 2
    Article AMERICAN MASONIC MANIAS. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ad00902

4IK4181iP&t&ffiK. GREAT DAILY PROGRAMME . TWO GRAND VARIETY SHOWS . TWO PERFORMANCES DAILY OF Frederick ' s Circus . Baldwin Monkey . The Leopolds , & c , & c . BEST SHOW IN LONDON , 5000 Free Seats . One Shilling Admits to all .

Ad00903

FORTHCOMING ENGAGEMENTS . July 20 tli and every Thursday aud Saturday . —FIREWORKS by JAMES PAIN . July 22 nd .-GRAND POST OFFICE FETE . July 23 rd .-MUSIC HALL BENEVOLENT FUND FIRST GRAND FESTIVAL and SPORTS . July 27 th . —BALLOON SOCIETY of GREAT BRITAIN . Second Balloon Gardon Party of tho Season . Aii £ ? ust 5 th . —GREAT BANK HOLIDAY FETE . A nuat 22 nd . —POLICE FETE . S-iitombor 2 nd .-GREAD GOLD MINING EXHIBITION opens . S . LEE BAPTY , General Manager .

Ar00904

Skwwwgggraf ^ SATURDAY , 20 TH JULY 1889 .

American Masonic Manias.

AMERICAN MASONIC MANIAS .

Br BRO . JACOB NORTON . WHEN I first came to Boston , I heard for the first time the phrase " Masonic Jurisprudence . " When I asked whether Masonic jurisprudence is not embraced in tho Masonic Constitutions ? I was answered that we have

written and unwritten laws , and Masonic jurisprudence means both kinds of laws . But the joke is , there is no agreement among our learned expounders of unwritten laws . I have here a book called " Digest of Masonic Law , being a complete code of Regulations , Decisions , and Opinions , " & c , by Geo . Wingate Chase , which is full of

contradictions . The mania of Masonic jurisprudence was magnified into a science . Symbolism also had its day . In 1846 ( I believe ) Mackey gave an outline of about two dozen Masonic landmarks , which he afterwards amplified

and enlarged , and which were quoted as " Gospel truth . " Since then the mania for expelling Masons for not believing that every word in the Bible was inspired , raged in several Masonic jurisdictions . Still more recently , laws wero

oaacted m some jurisdictions to expel saloon keepers from Masonry , bub the most absurd mania which afflicts some jurisdictions is the anti-Cerneauite mania . To make the subject clear to new subscribers or readers of tho FREEMASON ' S CHRONICLE , I must inform them that

there are in existence some thirty ceremonies or degrees , which are variously called " Scotch Rite , " and " Ancient and Accepted Rite . " In reality , however , the said degrees are neither Scotch nor ancient . These degrees , wherever

they were introduced , always gave rise to splits , divisions , and discord . Now , in the United States , there are two Sovereigns of that Scotch rite , one is in the South and the other is iu

tho North , but the sovereiguty on each side of the dividing line ia disputed ; the descendants of Cerneau claim jurisdiction over all tho " United States and its Territories . "

These antagonistic factions abase each other ia Billingsgate style , each swears to be the Simon Pare , and denounces the opponent , as bogus , illegitimate , & c . Now , the leading members of the respective Grand Lodges North and South

belong either to what i 3 called the "Northern Jurisdiction " of tho A . aud A . rite , or to the " Southern Jurisdiction " of the same rite . As a rule , the leading dignitaries of the Grand Lodges North and South never paid a cent for the

honours of being thirty -thirded or thirty-seconded ; these degrees are conferred upon them merely as a bribe to enlist their influence in behalf of the faction ; getting , as

they do , these degrees for nothing , they are bound to sweatthrough thick aud thin that their organization is of the true blue blood , while tho other organizations arc mere Masonic bastards . For a time their squabbles were confined among

American Masonic Manias.

themselves , and were only made known through their own publications . But a few years ago a mania began to rage in certain jurisdictions , among the leading members of its

Grand Lodges , to pass laws for expelling from Masonry all thoso who belong to the Scotch rite of the opposite or Cerneau faction . The excuse of the said leaders of Grand Lodge is , that it was the duty of the Grand Lodgo to

prevent imposition among Masonic brethren . Tho fact , however , is simply this : both factions aro aliko worthless , but one faction sells its stuff for one hundred dollars , while

the other faction charges for the same stuff only twentyfive dollars . Now our worthy conscientious Grand Lodge members have no objection to our Masonic brethren being

cheated out of one hundred dollars , but they are ready to expel a brother Mason who allowed himself to be cheated out of twenty-five dollars . Bro . Parvin P . G . M .. and now Grand Secretary , and also

Chairman of tho Committee of Foreign Correspondence of Iowa , seemed to have been for some time the champion for Masonic rationalism ; he bravely fought , right and left , with all believers or pretended believers in the old nonsense

written in bygone times , and he does so still . But oveu Bro . Parvin has lost his balanco on the Saloon Keeper question . I do not think that he pretends to be a total

abstinence man ; at least he does not seem to insist that Masons must be teetotallers . It seems that ho does not object to moderate drinking by Masonic brethren , bat ho

is fiercely opposed to the man who sells them the liquor . This notion seems to me inconsistent , for if a man may drink , he surely must buy the stuff , and if he may buy it , then why may not another man sell it ? They say that in ancient times Masons used to meet on

high hills and in low vales . If so they could not havo been either English , Scotch , Irish , or American Masons , for , as far as I know , English speaking Masons , from the

remotest antiquity , always met in public houses . The four old Lodges" we read of , who formed the first Grand Lodge , met in public houses . The Grand Lodge of England was originally constituted in a public house , and for many years it continued to hold its meetings in public houses . The engraved Lodge Lists of the last century

prove conclusively that Lodges were principally known by the names and signboards of the public houses where they held their meetings , and even to-day a majority of the

English Lodges meet in public houses . Henry rrice constituted the first regular chartered Lodge in America in a Boston public house , and Franklin's unchartered Lodge in Philadelphia , from its very start in 1731 , used to meet in

a public house . Now , as a rule , the keepers of public houses where Masons meet are , and always were , Masons , and I never heard that public house keepers behaved worse in Lodges than brethren who follow other trades do . Iu

1739 , that is one hundred and fifty years ago , Bro . Luke Yardy , the keeper of a public house wherein the Boston Lodge used to hold its meetings , walked in a public St . John ' s Day Masonic procession , in Boston , sido by side

with Henry Price , Andrew Belcher , and other founders of American legitimate Masonry ; and if a public house keeper was worthy of being a Mason then , why cannot ouo of them be worthy of Masonry to-day ? Besides , for a

number of years after my arrival iu America , the Grand Lodge of New York used to hold its meetings in a public house , and so did every Lodge iu New . York and Brooklyn . The Grand Lodge of England lets part of its premises for

a tavern , or public house , and the manager of Freemasons ' Tavern is a Mason , aud a worthy one too . In short , public houses may be claimed to have beeu , iu olden times , tho

hot-houses and nurseries of ancient Freemasonry , and I believe that if thero had been no public houses in England for hundreds of years past , we should have been to-day without Masonic Ldrlges both in England and America .

Bat that is not all . I was verbally informed ([ hope it is not true ) that my philosophic friend Bro . Parvin was recently attacked with tho now spreading anti-Cerncauinm mania . Now , I can understand the reason of extremo

teetotallers for opposing tho admissiou or even expelling the Saloon Keepers from Masonry , but I cannot oouoeivo what Bro . Parvin can say against Ccrneauism that cannot with equal jiutiee be said against Gourgasisru , Pikeisui ,

Teaiplarism , and all other kinds of high dugretis / ji . One is not better than another , and no Grand Lodge has a right to patronise or to recommend either kind of hambug .

-rt ^ L -ii . _ n T >_ . T > »„ .. _ , » :.. „„ „ .. » : ») :.. But with all Bro . Parvia ' 3 new notiun ? , we are still indebted to him for the guod Le has done , aad is still doing , in hit , efforts to cure our deluded American Masonic writers of

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1889-07-20, Page 9” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 26 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_20071889/page/9/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
PRIVILEGED COMMUNICATIONS. Article 1
MASONRY AND EVERY-DAY LIFE. Article 2
THE PORCH OF THE TEMPLE. Article 3
ENTHUSIASTIC WELCOME OF THE GOVERNOR OF NEW ZEALAND. Article 4
Untitled Article 4
LONDON AND SOUTH WESTERN RAILWAY. Article 4
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 4
PROV. GRAND LODGE OF SURREY. Article 5
PROV. G. LODGE BERKS AND BUCKS. Article 6
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Article 9
AMERICAN MASONIC MANIAS. Article 9
ROYAL ARCH. Article 10
Untitled Article 10
Untitled Article 10
NOTICES OF MEETINGS, continued. Article 10
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
THE GRAND LODGE OF NEW YORK. Article 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
LIST OF RARE AND VALUABLE WORKS ON FREEMASONRY Article 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

9 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

5 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

6 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

9 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

10 Articles
Page 9

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ad00902

4IK4181iP&t&ffiK. GREAT DAILY PROGRAMME . TWO GRAND VARIETY SHOWS . TWO PERFORMANCES DAILY OF Frederick ' s Circus . Baldwin Monkey . The Leopolds , & c , & c . BEST SHOW IN LONDON , 5000 Free Seats . One Shilling Admits to all .

Ad00903

FORTHCOMING ENGAGEMENTS . July 20 tli and every Thursday aud Saturday . —FIREWORKS by JAMES PAIN . July 22 nd .-GRAND POST OFFICE FETE . July 23 rd .-MUSIC HALL BENEVOLENT FUND FIRST GRAND FESTIVAL and SPORTS . July 27 th . —BALLOON SOCIETY of GREAT BRITAIN . Second Balloon Gardon Party of tho Season . Aii £ ? ust 5 th . —GREAT BANK HOLIDAY FETE . A nuat 22 nd . —POLICE FETE . S-iitombor 2 nd .-GREAD GOLD MINING EXHIBITION opens . S . LEE BAPTY , General Manager .

Ar00904

Skwwwgggraf ^ SATURDAY , 20 TH JULY 1889 .

American Masonic Manias.

AMERICAN MASONIC MANIAS .

Br BRO . JACOB NORTON . WHEN I first came to Boston , I heard for the first time the phrase " Masonic Jurisprudence . " When I asked whether Masonic jurisprudence is not embraced in tho Masonic Constitutions ? I was answered that we have

written and unwritten laws , and Masonic jurisprudence means both kinds of laws . But the joke is , there is no agreement among our learned expounders of unwritten laws . I have here a book called " Digest of Masonic Law , being a complete code of Regulations , Decisions , and Opinions , " & c , by Geo . Wingate Chase , which is full of

contradictions . The mania of Masonic jurisprudence was magnified into a science . Symbolism also had its day . In 1846 ( I believe ) Mackey gave an outline of about two dozen Masonic landmarks , which he afterwards amplified

and enlarged , and which were quoted as " Gospel truth . " Since then the mania for expelling Masons for not believing that every word in the Bible was inspired , raged in several Masonic jurisdictions . Still more recently , laws wero

oaacted m some jurisdictions to expel saloon keepers from Masonry , bub the most absurd mania which afflicts some jurisdictions is the anti-Cerneauite mania . To make the subject clear to new subscribers or readers of tho FREEMASON ' S CHRONICLE , I must inform them that

there are in existence some thirty ceremonies or degrees , which are variously called " Scotch Rite , " and " Ancient and Accepted Rite . " In reality , however , the said degrees are neither Scotch nor ancient . These degrees , wherever

they were introduced , always gave rise to splits , divisions , and discord . Now , in the United States , there are two Sovereigns of that Scotch rite , one is in the South and the other is iu

tho North , but the sovereiguty on each side of the dividing line ia disputed ; the descendants of Cerneau claim jurisdiction over all tho " United States and its Territories . "

These antagonistic factions abase each other ia Billingsgate style , each swears to be the Simon Pare , and denounces the opponent , as bogus , illegitimate , & c . Now , the leading members of the respective Grand Lodges North and South

belong either to what i 3 called the "Northern Jurisdiction " of tho A . aud A . rite , or to the " Southern Jurisdiction " of the same rite . As a rule , the leading dignitaries of the Grand Lodges North and South never paid a cent for the

honours of being thirty -thirded or thirty-seconded ; these degrees are conferred upon them merely as a bribe to enlist their influence in behalf of the faction ; getting , as

they do , these degrees for nothing , they are bound to sweatthrough thick aud thin that their organization is of the true blue blood , while tho other organizations arc mere Masonic bastards . For a time their squabbles were confined among

American Masonic Manias.

themselves , and were only made known through their own publications . But a few years ago a mania began to rage in certain jurisdictions , among the leading members of its

Grand Lodges , to pass laws for expelling from Masonry all thoso who belong to the Scotch rite of the opposite or Cerneau faction . The excuse of the said leaders of Grand Lodge is , that it was the duty of the Grand Lodgo to

prevent imposition among Masonic brethren . Tho fact , however , is simply this : both factions aro aliko worthless , but one faction sells its stuff for one hundred dollars , while

the other faction charges for the same stuff only twentyfive dollars . Now our worthy conscientious Grand Lodge members have no objection to our Masonic brethren being

cheated out of one hundred dollars , but they are ready to expel a brother Mason who allowed himself to be cheated out of twenty-five dollars . Bro . Parvin P . G . M .. and now Grand Secretary , and also

Chairman of tho Committee of Foreign Correspondence of Iowa , seemed to have been for some time the champion for Masonic rationalism ; he bravely fought , right and left , with all believers or pretended believers in the old nonsense

written in bygone times , and he does so still . But oveu Bro . Parvin has lost his balanco on the Saloon Keeper question . I do not think that he pretends to be a total

abstinence man ; at least he does not seem to insist that Masons must be teetotallers . It seems that ho does not object to moderate drinking by Masonic brethren , bat ho

is fiercely opposed to the man who sells them the liquor . This notion seems to me inconsistent , for if a man may drink , he surely must buy the stuff , and if he may buy it , then why may not another man sell it ? They say that in ancient times Masons used to meet on

high hills and in low vales . If so they could not havo been either English , Scotch , Irish , or American Masons , for , as far as I know , English speaking Masons , from the

remotest antiquity , always met in public houses . The four old Lodges" we read of , who formed the first Grand Lodge , met in public houses . The Grand Lodge of England was originally constituted in a public house , and for many years it continued to hold its meetings in public houses . The engraved Lodge Lists of the last century

prove conclusively that Lodges were principally known by the names and signboards of the public houses where they held their meetings , and even to-day a majority of the

English Lodges meet in public houses . Henry rrice constituted the first regular chartered Lodge in America in a Boston public house , and Franklin's unchartered Lodge in Philadelphia , from its very start in 1731 , used to meet in

a public house . Now , as a rule , the keepers of public houses where Masons meet are , and always were , Masons , and I never heard that public house keepers behaved worse in Lodges than brethren who follow other trades do . Iu

1739 , that is one hundred and fifty years ago , Bro . Luke Yardy , the keeper of a public house wherein the Boston Lodge used to hold its meetings , walked in a public St . John ' s Day Masonic procession , in Boston , sido by side

with Henry Price , Andrew Belcher , and other founders of American legitimate Masonry ; and if a public house keeper was worthy of being a Mason then , why cannot ouo of them be worthy of Masonry to-day ? Besides , for a

number of years after my arrival iu America , the Grand Lodge of New York used to hold its meetings in a public house , and so did every Lodge iu New . York and Brooklyn . The Grand Lodge of England lets part of its premises for

a tavern , or public house , and the manager of Freemasons ' Tavern is a Mason , aud a worthy one too . In short , public houses may be claimed to have beeu , iu olden times , tho

hot-houses and nurseries of ancient Freemasonry , and I believe that if thero had been no public houses in England for hundreds of years past , we should have been to-day without Masonic Ldrlges both in England and America .

Bat that is not all . I was verbally informed ([ hope it is not true ) that my philosophic friend Bro . Parvin was recently attacked with tho now spreading anti-Cerncauinm mania . Now , I can understand the reason of extremo

teetotallers for opposing tho admissiou or even expelling the Saloon Keepers from Masonry , but I cannot oouoeivo what Bro . Parvin can say against Ccrneauism that cannot with equal jiutiee be said against Gourgasisru , Pikeisui ,

Teaiplarism , and all other kinds of high dugretis / ji . One is not better than another , and no Grand Lodge has a right to patronise or to recommend either kind of hambug .

-rt ^ L -ii . _ n T >_ . T > »„ .. _ , » :.. „„ „ .. » : ») :.. But with all Bro . Parvia ' 3 new notiun ? , we are still indebted to him for the guod Le has done , aad is still doing , in hit , efforts to cure our deluded American Masonic writers of

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 8
  • You're on page9
  • 10
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy