Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • April 21, 1888
  • Page 4
  • FURTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT THE OHIO G. MASTER'S BLUNDER.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, April 21, 1888: Page 4

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, April 21, 1888
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article FURTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT THE OHIO G. MASTER'S BLUNDER. Page 1 of 2
    Article FURTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT THE OHIO G. MASTER'S BLUNDER. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Further Particulars About The Ohio G. Master's Blunder.

FURTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT THE OHIO G . MASTER'S BLUNDER .

Bv BRO . JACOI ; NORTON .

MR JAMES GRANT , in his History of " The News . paper Press , " ( Vol . I . p . 171 ) says : " In the year 17 G 4 , Mr . Wilkes , who had fled to France , to escape the imprisonment which ho knew to bo consequent ou his conviction for libel , carried on a correspondence

with Mr . Almau , his friend and admirer . * * * * Mr . "Wilkes , in one of his letters to Mr . Alman , made a brief but ludicrous allusion to the Rev . Mr . Trail , a Scotchman , as administering to the English subjects in

Paris in Spirituals , though a Peer was our Ambassador , ancl David Hurue his Secretary . I confess I cannot see any point in this , but bo this as it may , on the appearance of

the paragraph in the Loudon Evening Post , the Earl of Marchmont moved that , the House take proceedings against the printer for a breach of its privileges in mentioning the namo of one of its members . The result was that the

printer of the London Evening Post was fined £ 100 . The precedent thus set " the House of Lords was industriousl y followed up by itself . In several succeeding years , printers

of newspapers were lined each session , whenever they mentioned , by accident or otherwise , the name of a Peer of the Realm . Who could believe that little more than a

century ago such a state of things could have existed in this country , which boasted as much then as it does now of being pre-eminently the land of liberty . " Surprising as it may be to learn about the arrogance and

I may say impudence of the Tory lords of a hundred or more years ago , yet is it more surprising that some of our American Masons of to-day should presume to do

what the Tories of the time of George III . did ? In short , our Masonic Tories as a rule are high degree Gourgasites : these Gourgasites preponderate in our Grand Lodges . I have shown iu former communications that the

Gours-asites in Massachusetts passed laws for disqualifying Cerneauites from holding offices in Lodges , ancl that they may even be expelled from Masonry for belonging to Cerneauite concerns . These ridiculous laws were , however ,

never enforced , and they are mere " dead letters . The Grand Lodge of Ohio , in October 1887 was pleased to inform the brethren , that the Cerneauites were " illegal , irregular , and un-Masonic , aud ought not to be

countenanced or recognised in any manner by brethren under obedience to the said Graud Lodge of Ohio . " But it does not seem that any penalties for disobedience were imposed upon the Cerneauites . Now it is very curious , viz . that while tho Massachusetts Grand Lodo * e authorities

never molested the Cerneauites , though the Grand Lodge empowered them to do so , the Grand Master and his satellites in Ohio attempted to finish the Cerneauites of

Ohio , without having any authority whatever to interfere in the matter . I have already sent an outline , in a former paper , about the new trouble in Ohio . The March Number of the Cincinnati Masonic lievieiu furnishes additional

details , which I shall herewith explain : — Coshocton Lodge , No . 96 , elected its officers , 23 rd Dec . last ; the installation was to take place on the 27 th following . The W . M . was confined to his house by

sickness , hence the Senior Warden opened the Lodge , and placed in his chair a distinguished Gourgasite , viz . Brother Winegarer ; after the election , Brother Winegarer claimed to be a proxy ofthe Grand Master , aud by virtue of which

power he declared the election of the "W . M ., the two Wardens , the Secretary ancl the Treasurer , null ancl void ( because the said parties were Cerneauites ) , and ordered

the election for new officers to take place in January 1888 . At this juncture Bro . Judge John D . Nicholas thought proper to have his say .

" I rise [ said Bro . N . ] to ask a question , in order thatl may know how to act intelligently . I ha ve been a member of this Lodge for more than forty years , and am among the oldest , if not the very oldest ; certainly the oldest member

present to-night . During that long period * * * there have been many Grand Masters , not one of whom ever assumed such extraordinary powers as is attempted

to be here exercised to-night . I therefore * * * ask whence is this most extraordinary power derived ? It is not to be found in the Proc' -odiur's of the Grand LocVo . 73 O * * * If , however , ib is to b :- fmnd iu any O . m . j . itution- * , Bye-law 3 , Decisions oi * Oil * . ;; of Masonry , and you will

Further Particulars About The Ohio G. Master's Blunder.

point it ont , I am willing to bow in humble submission . * * * But if this power is not to be found there , and you will not point it out , I will never submit to such usurpation of power . "

Tho following interesting dialogue then took place : Proxy : " Brother Nicholas , your question is entirely out of order , the Grand Master is the law . " [ The italicising is not mine ] .

Judge N .: " Where is the authority for such a claim ? Proxy ; " The Grand Master claims the authority . " Judge N . : " The assumption of unwarranted authority is but , tho evidence of arrogance , ancl not proof of the claim . "

Brother Nicholas then moved to proceed with the installation , but Brother Winegarer declared tho motion out of order , and that the Lodge was closed , and called upon all tho loyalists ( which means the Gourgasites ) to leave the

hall ; when eight or nine visitors and members obeyed the Proxy ' s order , and about forty brethren remained . It seems , however , that one or both of the Wardens were either Gourgasites or chicken-hearted , any how , no

installation took place that night . It was , however , decided to obtain an injunction from the State Court , against the Grand Master ' s arrogance ; which was done accordingly a few clays after , and it was decided to instal the officers

elect on the night Brother Proxy appointed for election of new officers . On the said night , the outgoing W . M . of Coshocton Lodge was still confined to his house , and Brother Proxy induced both Wardens to keep away from

the meeting : n-ay , more , the Grand Master himself arrived there , ancl doubtless threatened with his displeasure all who dared to disobey his dictum . It seems , that without at least the presence of one of the regular officers ,

the installation of the new officers would have been illegal . However , after an hour and a half ' s search , the Senior Warden was caught . In vain did he protest that " the Grand Master would deprive him of all his Masonic rights if

he granted their request . " B y hook or by crook , he was induced cr compelled to open the Lodge , and a Brother Mitchell , P . M . of Newark Lodge , dared to instal the

Master elect , after which the old Senior Warden departed , ancl the remaining officers were invested , and here are specimens of the resolutions passed by the Lodge at a subsequent meeting , viz : —

" That this Lodgo recognises but three degrees in Masonry , ancl has nothing whatever to do with any other so-called hi "her clee-rees .

" That in the aforesaid action of the Grand Master this Lodge recognises a ridiculous assumption of power , unwarranted by the Constitution , Bye-laws , usages or landmarks of pure Masonry , a reckless prostitution of the Blue

Lodge to the base purpose of building up an institution of which he is a member , ancl which purports to confer certain so-called high degrees iu Masonry , even though he wreck the Blue Lodge by his un-Masonic and unholy

course . " That the Blue Lodge is for Master Masons , and not for a laundry to wash the soiled linen of so-called higher Masonic deerees . "

The above extracts will give the reader an idea of the remaining resolutions . I hope , however , that the whole will be published by the worthy editor of this paper . The

reader is now acquainted with the Ohio Grand Master ' s doings in Coshocton Lodge , and now I will toll of something copied by the Cincinnati Masonic , Bevieio from the Ohio Enquirer of 13 th March , viz : —

" Columbus—Ohio , 12 th March . —The war between the Cerneau and Northern Jurisdiction Masons , broke out here to-night with renewed vigour . Goodale Lodge was about to try the Cerneau members for conduct unbecoming

Masons . The members sought to be expelled embrace such gentlemen as Congressman Outhwaite , C . D . Firestone , ancl many leading citizens , about forty in number . The Cerneaus were prepared for the emergency , having

secured a temporary injunction from Judge Even ' s Court this afternoon which , was served in the Blue Lodge this evening by John A . Sarber as Deputy Sheriff . The petition

charges conspiracy , and is signed by Hon . R . A . Harrison , Ex-Supreme Judge , W . J . Gilmore , Judge , J . H . Collins , and F . A . Davis .

The petition avers that the defendant , S . Stocker Williams , Grand Master of Masons in Ohio , R . M . Gilbert , Dr . N . Kinsman , Tyler , and Goodale Lodge , No . 372 , entered into a conspiracy for the purpose of suppressing the Cerneau Bodies of Ohio , and , as a part of the con-

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1888-04-21, Page 4” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_21041888/page/4/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Article 1
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS. Article 1
OBJECTS AND PURPOSES OF OUR ORDER. Article 2
MASONRY IN SWEDEN AND NORWAY. Article 3
Obituary. Article 3
MASONIC FUNERAL OF A DERBY MAN IN INDIA. Article 3
FURTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT THE OHIO G. MASTER'S BLUNDER. Article 4
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 5
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
PROSPECTUS. Article 8
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Ad 9
Untitled Article 9
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF WEST YORKS. Article 9
SOUTH AUSTRALIA. Article 10
MARK MASONRY. Article 10
SCOTLAND. Article 10
Untitled Ad 10
THE THEATRES, &c. Article 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
THE THEATRES, AMUSEMENTS, &c. Article 15
HOTELS,ETC. Article 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

5 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

10 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

6 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

6 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

9 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

10 Articles
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Further Particulars About The Ohio G. Master's Blunder.

FURTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT THE OHIO G . MASTER'S BLUNDER .

Bv BRO . JACOI ; NORTON .

MR JAMES GRANT , in his History of " The News . paper Press , " ( Vol . I . p . 171 ) says : " In the year 17 G 4 , Mr . Wilkes , who had fled to France , to escape the imprisonment which ho knew to bo consequent ou his conviction for libel , carried on a correspondence

with Mr . Almau , his friend and admirer . * * * * Mr . "Wilkes , in one of his letters to Mr . Alman , made a brief but ludicrous allusion to the Rev . Mr . Trail , a Scotchman , as administering to the English subjects in

Paris in Spirituals , though a Peer was our Ambassador , ancl David Hurue his Secretary . I confess I cannot see any point in this , but bo this as it may , on the appearance of

the paragraph in the Loudon Evening Post , the Earl of Marchmont moved that , the House take proceedings against the printer for a breach of its privileges in mentioning the namo of one of its members . The result was that the

printer of the London Evening Post was fined £ 100 . The precedent thus set " the House of Lords was industriousl y followed up by itself . In several succeeding years , printers

of newspapers were lined each session , whenever they mentioned , by accident or otherwise , the name of a Peer of the Realm . Who could believe that little more than a

century ago such a state of things could have existed in this country , which boasted as much then as it does now of being pre-eminently the land of liberty . " Surprising as it may be to learn about the arrogance and

I may say impudence of the Tory lords of a hundred or more years ago , yet is it more surprising that some of our American Masons of to-day should presume to do

what the Tories of the time of George III . did ? In short , our Masonic Tories as a rule are high degree Gourgasites : these Gourgasites preponderate in our Grand Lodges . I have shown iu former communications that the

Gours-asites in Massachusetts passed laws for disqualifying Cerneauites from holding offices in Lodges , ancl that they may even be expelled from Masonry for belonging to Cerneauite concerns . These ridiculous laws were , however ,

never enforced , and they are mere " dead letters . The Grand Lodge of Ohio , in October 1887 was pleased to inform the brethren , that the Cerneauites were " illegal , irregular , and un-Masonic , aud ought not to be

countenanced or recognised in any manner by brethren under obedience to the said Graud Lodge of Ohio . " But it does not seem that any penalties for disobedience were imposed upon the Cerneauites . Now it is very curious , viz . that while tho Massachusetts Grand Lodo * e authorities

never molested the Cerneauites , though the Grand Lodge empowered them to do so , the Grand Master and his satellites in Ohio attempted to finish the Cerneauites of

Ohio , without having any authority whatever to interfere in the matter . I have already sent an outline , in a former paper , about the new trouble in Ohio . The March Number of the Cincinnati Masonic lievieiu furnishes additional

details , which I shall herewith explain : — Coshocton Lodge , No . 96 , elected its officers , 23 rd Dec . last ; the installation was to take place on the 27 th following . The W . M . was confined to his house by

sickness , hence the Senior Warden opened the Lodge , and placed in his chair a distinguished Gourgasite , viz . Brother Winegarer ; after the election , Brother Winegarer claimed to be a proxy ofthe Grand Master , aud by virtue of which

power he declared the election of the "W . M ., the two Wardens , the Secretary ancl the Treasurer , null ancl void ( because the said parties were Cerneauites ) , and ordered

the election for new officers to take place in January 1888 . At this juncture Bro . Judge John D . Nicholas thought proper to have his say .

" I rise [ said Bro . N . ] to ask a question , in order thatl may know how to act intelligently . I ha ve been a member of this Lodge for more than forty years , and am among the oldest , if not the very oldest ; certainly the oldest member

present to-night . During that long period * * * there have been many Grand Masters , not one of whom ever assumed such extraordinary powers as is attempted

to be here exercised to-night . I therefore * * * ask whence is this most extraordinary power derived ? It is not to be found in the Proc' -odiur's of the Grand LocVo . 73 O * * * If , however , ib is to b :- fmnd iu any O . m . j . itution- * , Bye-law 3 , Decisions oi * Oil * . ;; of Masonry , and you will

Further Particulars About The Ohio G. Master's Blunder.

point it ont , I am willing to bow in humble submission . * * * But if this power is not to be found there , and you will not point it out , I will never submit to such usurpation of power . "

Tho following interesting dialogue then took place : Proxy : " Brother Nicholas , your question is entirely out of order , the Grand Master is the law . " [ The italicising is not mine ] .

Judge N .: " Where is the authority for such a claim ? Proxy ; " The Grand Master claims the authority . " Judge N . : " The assumption of unwarranted authority is but , tho evidence of arrogance , ancl not proof of the claim . "

Brother Nicholas then moved to proceed with the installation , but Brother Winegarer declared tho motion out of order , and that the Lodge was closed , and called upon all tho loyalists ( which means the Gourgasites ) to leave the

hall ; when eight or nine visitors and members obeyed the Proxy ' s order , and about forty brethren remained . It seems , however , that one or both of the Wardens were either Gourgasites or chicken-hearted , any how , no

installation took place that night . It was , however , decided to obtain an injunction from the State Court , against the Grand Master ' s arrogance ; which was done accordingly a few clays after , and it was decided to instal the officers

elect on the night Brother Proxy appointed for election of new officers . On the said night , the outgoing W . M . of Coshocton Lodge was still confined to his house , and Brother Proxy induced both Wardens to keep away from

the meeting : n-ay , more , the Grand Master himself arrived there , ancl doubtless threatened with his displeasure all who dared to disobey his dictum . It seems , that without at least the presence of one of the regular officers ,

the installation of the new officers would have been illegal . However , after an hour and a half ' s search , the Senior Warden was caught . In vain did he protest that " the Grand Master would deprive him of all his Masonic rights if

he granted their request . " B y hook or by crook , he was induced cr compelled to open the Lodge , and a Brother Mitchell , P . M . of Newark Lodge , dared to instal the

Master elect , after which the old Senior Warden departed , ancl the remaining officers were invested , and here are specimens of the resolutions passed by the Lodge at a subsequent meeting , viz : —

" That this Lodgo recognises but three degrees in Masonry , ancl has nothing whatever to do with any other so-called hi "her clee-rees .

" That in the aforesaid action of the Grand Master this Lodge recognises a ridiculous assumption of power , unwarranted by the Constitution , Bye-laws , usages or landmarks of pure Masonry , a reckless prostitution of the Blue

Lodge to the base purpose of building up an institution of which he is a member , ancl which purports to confer certain so-called high degrees iu Masonry , even though he wreck the Blue Lodge by his un-Masonic and unholy

course . " That the Blue Lodge is for Master Masons , and not for a laundry to wash the soiled linen of so-called higher Masonic deerees . "

The above extracts will give the reader an idea of the remaining resolutions . I hope , however , that the whole will be published by the worthy editor of this paper . The

reader is now acquainted with the Ohio Grand Master ' s doings in Coshocton Lodge , and now I will toll of something copied by the Cincinnati Masonic , Bevieio from the Ohio Enquirer of 13 th March , viz : —

" Columbus—Ohio , 12 th March . —The war between the Cerneau and Northern Jurisdiction Masons , broke out here to-night with renewed vigour . Goodale Lodge was about to try the Cerneau members for conduct unbecoming

Masons . The members sought to be expelled embrace such gentlemen as Congressman Outhwaite , C . D . Firestone , ancl many leading citizens , about forty in number . The Cerneaus were prepared for the emergency , having

secured a temporary injunction from Judge Even ' s Court this afternoon which , was served in the Blue Lodge this evening by John A . Sarber as Deputy Sheriff . The petition

charges conspiracy , and is signed by Hon . R . A . Harrison , Ex-Supreme Judge , W . J . Gilmore , Judge , J . H . Collins , and F . A . Davis .

The petition avers that the defendant , S . Stocker Williams , Grand Master of Masons in Ohio , R . M . Gilbert , Dr . N . Kinsman , Tyler , and Goodale Lodge , No . 372 , entered into a conspiracy for the purpose of suppressing the Cerneau Bodies of Ohio , and , as a part of the con-

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 3
  • You're on page4
  • 5
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy