Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • April 22, 1882
  • Page 2
  • OCCASIONAL PAPERS.—No. IX. THE SO-CALLED "ANCIENT" MASONS.
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, April 22, 1882: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, April 22, 1882
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article OCCASIONAL PAPERS.—No. IX. THE SO-CALLED "ANCIENT" MASONS. Page 1 of 2
    Article OCCASIONAL PAPERS.—No. IX. THE SO-CALLED "ANCIENT" MASONS. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Occasional Papers.—No. Ix. The So-Called "Ancient" Masons.

OCCASIONAL PAPERS . —No . IX . THE SO-CALLED " ANCIENT" MASONS .

( Concluded from page 266 . ) SETTING aside the question , when and under what circircumstances the Great Secession of last century arose , there is no doubt that , after the establishment of the "Ancient" Grand Lodge in 1753 , and especially under the auspices of Bro . Laurence Dermott , author of the Ahimon

Rezon , or Book of Constitutions of tho Masonic Body of which he was so distinguished a member—if , indeed , I may not go the length of calling him its main pillar—the Schismatics went on rapidly increasing in numbers . Bnt especially was this the case Avhen , in 1771 , John , third Dnke

of Athole , accepted the office of Grand Master , ancl , as has already been remarked , it is to his influence and that of his successor in tho Dukedom , who presided over that section of the English Craft for two periods , amounting together to twenty-eight years , that tho members were as

frequently called " Athole" as they were " Ancient " Masons . Not only were numerous Lodges founded ia London and the Provinces , but Provincial Grand Lodges were established in the Colonies , especially in those situated in North America . In fact , though Provincial Grand

Deputations were granted by England , before a Schism was dreamt of—though not before dissatisfaction had broken ont in the ranks of the English Crnft—many of the parent G . Lodges of the United States of North America owe their origin rather to the Deputations granted by the "Ancients "

than to those of its rival , or of the one Grand Lodge of England anterior to 1750 . Thus in Pennsylvania , New Tork , Massachusetts , the Carolinns , & c , there were Lodges which owed their origin to the Regular Grand Lodge of England , and though some of these still exist , the

Constituted Grand Lodges trace their descent rather from the '"' Ancients" than the " Moderns , " this being , however , a matter of no great moment , now that tbe distinction between the two bodies no longer exists . As showing , however , the extent to which the schism prevailed , it is

worthy of note , that of the 333 Lodges constituted prior to the Union of 1813 , which are still on the roll of our United Grand Lodge—the highest number is 339 , but six of them no longer remain—no less than 126 worked under the regime of the "Ancients . " This coupled with what I have said as to its wide ramifications both at home and

abroad is sufficient to show how influential a body it must have been , and consequently how deep is the debt of gratitude we owe to the Dukes of Kent and Sussex , and their distinguished coadjutor , the Earl of Moira , afterwards

Marquis of Hastings , for having healed the wounds which , for three parts of a century , had afflicted Freemasonry in England . Another feature in connection with the " Ancients "

deserves attention . It is often stated that more intimate relations existed between the Grand Lodges of Ireland aud Scotland and the Grand Lodge of the " Ancients " than with the "Regular" Grand Lodge , and that , as regards Scotland , it was not till the Earl of Moira visited Edinburgh ,

in the early years of this century , that our Scottish brethren were fully informed of the circumstances of Freemasonry in England , its division into two bodies , and the mutual recriminations in which those bodies indulged . It is certainly the case that with the exception of Lord Aberdour ,

who was Grand Master of the " Regular " Grand Lodge of London from 17-57 to 1761 , and Grand Master of Scotland in 1755 56 , no Regular Grand Master in England had any part in the Government , as Grand Master , of the Craft in Scotland from 1753 till the year 1806-7 , when the

Earl of Moira , Acting Grand Master of the " Regular " or " Modern" Lodge , was elected Grand Master of Scotland . On the other hand , both the Dukes of Athole were Grand Masters of Scotland as well as of the "Ancients , " the third Dnke , as stated in the earlier

portion of this paper , in 1773 , and the fourth Duke in 1778-79 , while , as regards Ireland , the greater intimacy between its Grand Lodge and the " Ancients " is , no doubt , to be explained by the fact that the Earl of Blessington ,

the Hon . Thomas Mathevv , and the Earl , afterwards Marquis , of Antrim , who were Grand Masters of the " Ancients " or " Seccders" in 1756-60 , 1766-70 , and 1783-91 respectively , were connected with the Craft in Ireland , the Earl

Occasional Papers.—No. Ix. The So-Called "Ancient" Masons.

of Blessington as Grand Master in 1738-9 , the Earl of Antrim as Grand Master iu 1773 and again in 1779 , aud the Hon . T . Mathew as Provincial Grand Master of Mnnster . A few words seem necessary respecting Bro . Laurence

Dermott , who , as I have suggested , must be looked upon as the genius of tho " Ancients . " It is true that but littl e is known of him beyond tbe fact , that ho came originall y from Ireland—another circumstance which will doubtless in great measure help to account for the close intimacy that

existed between Ireland and our " Ancient " friends . He , in the first instance , occupied the position of Grand Secretary , and afterwards became Deputy Grand Master . He is best known , however , by his celebrated work , alread y referred to , the "Ahimon Rezon , " the first edition of

which appeared in 1756 , the second iu 1764 , while others were published subsequently . He is also usually credited with having introduced the " Royal Arch , " at all events as the speciality which characterised the Masonic creed of the "Ancients" and distinguished it from thafc of the

" Regular " Craffc . Though enthusiastic in the interests of his own section of English Freemasonry , he was by no means slow to take a leaf out of the book of his rivals ; and tbe better regulations for the government of the "Regular" Masons , introduced by Brother , afterwards

Lord , Ward , were adopted by him en bloc . Two or three ofcher points may also bo noted . Firstly , the Dukes of Athole , two of whom played so dististinguished a part in connection with the Grand Lodge of the " Ancients , " have since retained their interest in the Craft , the sixth

Dnke having been Grand Master of Scotland from 1846 to 1863 , while the present , or seventh Duke , is also a distinguished member of the Scottish Craft . Another point in connection with the " Ancients " is the plan they adopted by which a Lodge holding an inferior place on the roll of

their Grand Lodge might purchase a superior one by paying a certain sum to the Fund of Charity . Thus , if , we will say , Lodge No . 35 ceased to be in active working , Lodge No . 145—to take any number for the purpose of illustration—might purchase the warrant for a sum of guineas

paid over to the aforesaid Fund of Charity . This , of course , complicates the labours of such zealous investigators of Masonic history as Bros . Hughan and Gould , the latter of whom appears to have taken tho " Athole " Lodges under his especial charge . A third point more

properly concerns the Calendar Committee of our Board of General Purposes , which , without due reflection , appears to have taken upon itself to place the present Lodges Nos . 3 , 5 , 7 , 9 , 11 , 13 , and 15 , which were all " Ancient , " on the same footing as the "Modern "

Nos . 2 and 4 , which remain of the " Four Old Lodges " which , in 1717 , established the Grand Lodge of England . Now , as the readers of Findel may discover for themselves , the real " Ancients " are unquestionably , the so-called " Moderns , " while the real " Moderns " are the self-styled

"Ancients , " as it was the latter who seceded from the original one Grand Lodge of England . _ It was no doubt intended by these rival designations to distinguish between the brethren who upheld what were deemed to be the true principles of " Ancient" Masonry as they were enunciated

in the days anterior to 1717 , from those who upheld the principles laid down by tbe Grand Lodge constituted in that year . Still , it cannot be denied that the Seceders were , in the order of things , junior to the body from which they separated , and the terms as they were applied to

themselves and the Lodges holding under the 1717 Grand Lodge are consequently misleading . Moreover , as the " Four Old Lodges , " to which we owe the establishment of the Speculative system of Freemasonry , alone existed before that event , it follows that even the oldest of the

Athole Lodges must have been established at known dates , ancl this is shown in Bro . Kenning ' s " Cosmopolitan Masonic Calendar , " where , on the authority of Brother Hughan , the dates of the foundation of these Lodges are

given as follow : —No . 3 in 1784 ; No . 5 in 1752 ; Nos . 7 , 9 , ancl 11 in 1751 ; No . 13 in 1785 ; and No . 15 in 1752 . The application of " Time Immemorial " to these Lodges seemsthereforeto be terribly misapplied .

, , I have now completed my—I fear , imperfect—sketch of the so-called "Ancient" Masons . That they did good work may not be denied ; our present Royal Masonic Institution

for Boys is partly of " Ancient " origin , but that till the year 1813 they were anything else than schismatics is equally undeniable . However , there is no longer any such distinction prevailing in our midst . Time healed the wounds of our

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1882-04-22, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 8 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_22041882/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
FREEMASONRY IN INDIA. Article 1
Untitled Article 1
OCCASIONAL PAPERS.—No. IX. THE SO-CALLED "ANCIENT" MASONS. Article 2
THE FIFTEEN SECTIONS Article 3
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF STAFFORDSHIRE. Article 4
ROYAL ARCH. Article 5
NOTICES OF MEETINGS. Article 6
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
THE MASON'S CONSTITUTIONS. Article 8
Obituary. Article 9
MARK MASONRY. Article 10
RED CROSS OF CONSTANTINE. Article 10
Untitled Ad 10
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 11
INSTALLATION MEETINGS, &c. Article 12
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

9 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

13 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

15 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

13 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Occasional Papers.—No. Ix. The So-Called "Ancient" Masons.

OCCASIONAL PAPERS . —No . IX . THE SO-CALLED " ANCIENT" MASONS .

( Concluded from page 266 . ) SETTING aside the question , when and under what circircumstances the Great Secession of last century arose , there is no doubt that , after the establishment of the "Ancient" Grand Lodge in 1753 , and especially under the auspices of Bro . Laurence Dermott , author of the Ahimon

Rezon , or Book of Constitutions of tho Masonic Body of which he was so distinguished a member—if , indeed , I may not go the length of calling him its main pillar—the Schismatics went on rapidly increasing in numbers . Bnt especially was this the case Avhen , in 1771 , John , third Dnke

of Athole , accepted the office of Grand Master , ancl , as has already been remarked , it is to his influence and that of his successor in tho Dukedom , who presided over that section of the English Craft for two periods , amounting together to twenty-eight years , that tho members were as

frequently called " Athole" as they were " Ancient " Masons . Not only were numerous Lodges founded ia London and the Provinces , but Provincial Grand Lodges were established in the Colonies , especially in those situated in North America . In fact , though Provincial Grand

Deputations were granted by England , before a Schism was dreamt of—though not before dissatisfaction had broken ont in the ranks of the English Crnft—many of the parent G . Lodges of the United States of North America owe their origin rather to the Deputations granted by the "Ancients "

than to those of its rival , or of the one Grand Lodge of England anterior to 1750 . Thus in Pennsylvania , New Tork , Massachusetts , the Carolinns , & c , there were Lodges which owed their origin to the Regular Grand Lodge of England , and though some of these still exist , the

Constituted Grand Lodges trace their descent rather from the '"' Ancients" than the " Moderns , " this being , however , a matter of no great moment , now that tbe distinction between the two bodies no longer exists . As showing , however , the extent to which the schism prevailed , it is

worthy of note , that of the 333 Lodges constituted prior to the Union of 1813 , which are still on the roll of our United Grand Lodge—the highest number is 339 , but six of them no longer remain—no less than 126 worked under the regime of the "Ancients . " This coupled with what I have said as to its wide ramifications both at home and

abroad is sufficient to show how influential a body it must have been , and consequently how deep is the debt of gratitude we owe to the Dukes of Kent and Sussex , and their distinguished coadjutor , the Earl of Moira , afterwards

Marquis of Hastings , for having healed the wounds which , for three parts of a century , had afflicted Freemasonry in England . Another feature in connection with the " Ancients "

deserves attention . It is often stated that more intimate relations existed between the Grand Lodges of Ireland aud Scotland and the Grand Lodge of the " Ancients " than with the "Regular" Grand Lodge , and that , as regards Scotland , it was not till the Earl of Moira visited Edinburgh ,

in the early years of this century , that our Scottish brethren were fully informed of the circumstances of Freemasonry in England , its division into two bodies , and the mutual recriminations in which those bodies indulged . It is certainly the case that with the exception of Lord Aberdour ,

who was Grand Master of the " Regular " Grand Lodge of London from 17-57 to 1761 , and Grand Master of Scotland in 1755 56 , no Regular Grand Master in England had any part in the Government , as Grand Master , of the Craft in Scotland from 1753 till the year 1806-7 , when the

Earl of Moira , Acting Grand Master of the " Regular " or " Modern" Lodge , was elected Grand Master of Scotland . On the other hand , both the Dukes of Athole were Grand Masters of Scotland as well as of the "Ancients , " the third Dnke , as stated in the earlier

portion of this paper , in 1773 , and the fourth Duke in 1778-79 , while , as regards Ireland , the greater intimacy between its Grand Lodge and the " Ancients " is , no doubt , to be explained by the fact that the Earl of Blessington ,

the Hon . Thomas Mathevv , and the Earl , afterwards Marquis , of Antrim , who were Grand Masters of the " Ancients " or " Seccders" in 1756-60 , 1766-70 , and 1783-91 respectively , were connected with the Craft in Ireland , the Earl

Occasional Papers.—No. Ix. The So-Called "Ancient" Masons.

of Blessington as Grand Master in 1738-9 , the Earl of Antrim as Grand Master iu 1773 and again in 1779 , aud the Hon . T . Mathew as Provincial Grand Master of Mnnster . A few words seem necessary respecting Bro . Laurence

Dermott , who , as I have suggested , must be looked upon as the genius of tho " Ancients . " It is true that but littl e is known of him beyond tbe fact , that ho came originall y from Ireland—another circumstance which will doubtless in great measure help to account for the close intimacy that

existed between Ireland and our " Ancient " friends . He , in the first instance , occupied the position of Grand Secretary , and afterwards became Deputy Grand Master . He is best known , however , by his celebrated work , alread y referred to , the "Ahimon Rezon , " the first edition of

which appeared in 1756 , the second iu 1764 , while others were published subsequently . He is also usually credited with having introduced the " Royal Arch , " at all events as the speciality which characterised the Masonic creed of the "Ancients" and distinguished it from thafc of the

" Regular " Craffc . Though enthusiastic in the interests of his own section of English Freemasonry , he was by no means slow to take a leaf out of the book of his rivals ; and tbe better regulations for the government of the "Regular" Masons , introduced by Brother , afterwards

Lord , Ward , were adopted by him en bloc . Two or three ofcher points may also bo noted . Firstly , the Dukes of Athole , two of whom played so dististinguished a part in connection with the Grand Lodge of the " Ancients , " have since retained their interest in the Craft , the sixth

Dnke having been Grand Master of Scotland from 1846 to 1863 , while the present , or seventh Duke , is also a distinguished member of the Scottish Craft . Another point in connection with the " Ancients " is the plan they adopted by which a Lodge holding an inferior place on the roll of

their Grand Lodge might purchase a superior one by paying a certain sum to the Fund of Charity . Thus , if , we will say , Lodge No . 35 ceased to be in active working , Lodge No . 145—to take any number for the purpose of illustration—might purchase the warrant for a sum of guineas

paid over to the aforesaid Fund of Charity . This , of course , complicates the labours of such zealous investigators of Masonic history as Bros . Hughan and Gould , the latter of whom appears to have taken tho " Athole " Lodges under his especial charge . A third point more

properly concerns the Calendar Committee of our Board of General Purposes , which , without due reflection , appears to have taken upon itself to place the present Lodges Nos . 3 , 5 , 7 , 9 , 11 , 13 , and 15 , which were all " Ancient , " on the same footing as the "Modern "

Nos . 2 and 4 , which remain of the " Four Old Lodges " which , in 1717 , established the Grand Lodge of England . Now , as the readers of Findel may discover for themselves , the real " Ancients " are unquestionably , the so-called " Moderns , " while the real " Moderns " are the self-styled

"Ancients , " as it was the latter who seceded from the original one Grand Lodge of England . _ It was no doubt intended by these rival designations to distinguish between the brethren who upheld what were deemed to be the true principles of " Ancient" Masonry as they were enunciated

in the days anterior to 1717 , from those who upheld the principles laid down by tbe Grand Lodge constituted in that year . Still , it cannot be denied that the Seceders were , in the order of things , junior to the body from which they separated , and the terms as they were applied to

themselves and the Lodges holding under the 1717 Grand Lodge are consequently misleading . Moreover , as the " Four Old Lodges , " to which we owe the establishment of the Speculative system of Freemasonry , alone existed before that event , it follows that even the oldest of the

Athole Lodges must have been established at known dates , ancl this is shown in Bro . Kenning ' s " Cosmopolitan Masonic Calendar , " where , on the authority of Brother Hughan , the dates of the foundation of these Lodges are

given as follow : —No . 3 in 1784 ; No . 5 in 1752 ; Nos . 7 , 9 , ancl 11 in 1751 ; No . 13 in 1785 ; and No . 15 in 1752 . The application of " Time Immemorial " to these Lodges seemsthereforeto be terribly misapplied .

, , I have now completed my—I fear , imperfect—sketch of the so-called "Ancient" Masons . That they did good work may not be denied ; our present Royal Masonic Institution

for Boys is partly of " Ancient " origin , but that till the year 1813 they were anything else than schismatics is equally undeniable . However , there is no longer any such distinction prevailing in our midst . Time healed the wounds of our

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy