Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason's Chronicle
  • Aug. 29, 1885
  • Page 1
  • "AS ITHERS SEE US."
Current:

The Freemason's Chronicle, Aug. 29, 1885: Page 1

  • Back to The Freemason's Chronicle, Aug. 29, 1885
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article "AS ITHERS SEE US." Page 1 of 2
    Article "AS ITHERS SEE US." Page 1 of 2 →
Page 1

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

"As Ithers See Us."

"AS ITHERS SEE US . "

A FRIEND has done us the unkindness to send two broadsheets filled with the ravings of a man more fit for Bedlam than to be at large . We advise Mr . R . H . Cotter , the person alluded to , to remain in Ireland ,

for a law was passed on the 6 th inst . which gives power to overseers , relieving overseers and policemen to arrest any person who may appear to them to be under the influence of some mania . It would not be difficult to arrive

at a conclusion with regard to Mr . Cotter . Only let England be named , or Freemasonry be hinted at even , and the vials of his wrath would be poured out in such a torrent as to convince those who heard him that he must

be labouring under extraordinary delusions , ancl that in his ravings he forgets the decencies of life , the slightest regard for facts , It is not pleasant work to gibbet an

enemy , but there is no objection to his doing the thing himself . We are not sure that we are wise in letting our readers see how wild some men become when filled with

hate and all uncharitableness . Freemasons have always had bitter opponents , ancl none more unscrupulous than the Romish Church , but never have we read anything so violent and outrageous as the slanders penned by Mr . R . EL

Cotter . We shall not attempt to reason with a man who is incapable of believing any good of Freemasons ; he shall speak for himself , and our readers can judge how far we are justified in classing him with persons scarcely to

be held responsible for their actions . If he had only Freemasonry on the brain we should not be so much surprised , but he seems to be the incarnation of all that is violent

in his feelings with regard to England . He is no respecter of persons , and we are afraid we must add , has not the least respect for truth .

It would be labour in vain to argue -with such a man . We give some specimens of his language that our readers may know how low it is possible for an enemy to descend . Besides , Mr . Cotter is a curiosity in his way , and let us

hope is even unique in Ireland . The object of the broadsheets before us is " to unmask the plot of God-defying political domination in blaspheming Freemasonry , which it appears is now the State religion of England , " to show

that ^ Masonry was heathenish , as its humbugging libations of ^ wine and oil and corn might suggest . " We owe our origin to a " Jew , who rejected Christianity in toto , for their motto is not only composed of Babylonian Hebrew

cabalistic words , but actually refers to the heathen doctrine of transmigration of souls—a ' doctrine of devils . ' " As their origin is , so are their works , and we need not be surprised that our brethren in Ireland— " traitors to God

, are drawing down Heaven ' s wrath " upon that country . Mr . Cotter has got hold of some books ; he has learned of some renegades , who , like perverts and false friends , become the bitterest of enemies as well as the falsest of

guides . From these he draws pretty largely , and takes all they relate as pure gospel . A Dr . Carwifchen is a great authority in the eyes of Mr . Cotter , and so is a Mr . Trevillan , who thus described a system that had once

tolerated him as a disciple , as " scandalously and detest-+ L ( f nti-Cliristl ' - " He relies very much upon the fact that " one hundred and three " American Masons seceded

from the Order on the ground that it was " a bloody relic ot barbarism . " He mouths this over frequently as if alarmed afc the poverty of his own conversion . Mr . Cotter

"As Ithers See Us."

need not fear ; his vocabulary is stored with epithets that an Irish fishwife would envy , some of which we shall presently reproduce . We are told that Freemasonry is a school for grabbing

as well as for murder , " for it is hardly necessary to say that Mr . Cotter believes in the Morgan story . Bishop Plunket , of Meath , according to this veracious witness , was made an Archbishop by " his clique of cowardly ,

darkness - loving blaspheming Freemasons - God - blaspheming ring . " Daniel O'Connell , who was at one time a member of the Fraternity , but retired from it at the bidding of the Romish priests , once described Mr . Disraeli as " the

heir-atlaw of the blasphemous thief upon the cross . " Mr . Cotter has studied the Repealer as a model of vituperation . He calls Archbishop Plunkeb " an impenitent Freemason ;" calls Lodges " Cowardly murderers' dens ; " says that their

frequenters have " blasphemous lying mouths , " and that they are " liars , assassins and blasphemers . " He rails at times against their secret arts , at another he says , " The more secrecy ' the devil' and these ' his angels' keep , the

better I ' m pleased , till they ' re pinned down into the bottomless pit . " We have said that this coarse traducer was no respecter of persons , and the proof is forthcoming . Writing of a relative he described him as " a most gloriously

charitable , most pious skull-drinking , most blaspheming Freemason of immortal memory . " His own brother , a member of the Craft , rebuked him for his vile language , and he is immediately lashed and accused of being " without natural

affection . " Another brother , also a Freemason , who renounced the Order before he died , is extolled almost as an angel . Mr . R . H . Cotter believes any story that can be

made to tell against the Fraternity . He has got it into his head that the brethren make a practice of drinking out of human skulls . This is a great fact with him , and he calls " one hundred and three" seceders and the Standard

newspaper as witnesses . But then he has another witness , " a butler , who lived in the house of the notorious Freemason named Furnell , and that batler saw a coffin full of skulls and bones lying for months in Furnell ' s parlour , in

George Street , Limerick . " After that who can deny that skulls are converted into drinking cups by the abominable Freemasons , who might with equal truth be dubbed bodysnatchers and cannibals .

There is scarcely a crime under the sun of which it is not possible for a Freemason to be guilty , but it may be a consolation to know that they are condemned in the company of others . England is denounced with the same

unsparing hand , and Orangemen belong to the same tribe of fiends . England is " the great Red Dragon , " and Mr . Cotter calls in a witness who believed the day would come when " she would lose all her commerce , and that

Tyre and Sidon ' s end would be hers . She is also a ' scarlet-coloured beast' —the leopard , spotted with all the lies from Puseyism to Bradlaughism . " After all , Freemasonry is the ground-work of all our wickedness . The

brethren are the evil genii of the world ; they are the serpent that beguiled Eve ; they cannot be saved ; they are the elect of the damned , and Mr . Cotter is the destroying angel who means to execute

vengeance . We can imagine how the brethren will open their eyes with wonder at being so foully stigmatised , how they will tremble when they enter

the Lodge , lest the " red dragon , " the " leopard , spotted with all the lies , " should fall upon them and devour them . Let them not fear , Mr . Cotter is living in a world created

“The Freemason's Chronicle: 1885-08-29, Page 1” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 16 Jan. 2026, django:8000/periodicals/fcn/issues/fcn_29081885/page/1/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
"AS ITHERS SEE US." Article 1
THE BURNING BUSH. Article 2
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF DEVONSHIRE Article 4
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF DURHAM. Article 4
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 6
MARRIAGE. Article 7
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
QUARTERLY COMMUNICATION OF UNITED GRAND LODGE. Article 8
ROYAL ARCH. Article 9
PATRIOTIC CHAPTER, No. 51. Article 9
Old Warrants (H ). Article 9
INSTALLATION MEETINGS, &c. Article 10
KING HAROLD LODGE, No. 1327. Article 11
R.M.I. FOR BOYS—PREPARATORY SCHOOL. Article 11
PROV. GRAND LODGE OF HAMPSHIRE AND THE ISLE OF WIGHT. Article 11
DIARY FOR THE WEEK. Article 12
REVIEWS. Article 13
THE THEATRES. Article 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Article 16
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

8 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

15 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

13 Articles
Page 1

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

"As Ithers See Us."

"AS ITHERS SEE US . "

A FRIEND has done us the unkindness to send two broadsheets filled with the ravings of a man more fit for Bedlam than to be at large . We advise Mr . R . H . Cotter , the person alluded to , to remain in Ireland ,

for a law was passed on the 6 th inst . which gives power to overseers , relieving overseers and policemen to arrest any person who may appear to them to be under the influence of some mania . It would not be difficult to arrive

at a conclusion with regard to Mr . Cotter . Only let England be named , or Freemasonry be hinted at even , and the vials of his wrath would be poured out in such a torrent as to convince those who heard him that he must

be labouring under extraordinary delusions , ancl that in his ravings he forgets the decencies of life , the slightest regard for facts , It is not pleasant work to gibbet an

enemy , but there is no objection to his doing the thing himself . We are not sure that we are wise in letting our readers see how wild some men become when filled with

hate and all uncharitableness . Freemasons have always had bitter opponents , ancl none more unscrupulous than the Romish Church , but never have we read anything so violent and outrageous as the slanders penned by Mr . R . EL

Cotter . We shall not attempt to reason with a man who is incapable of believing any good of Freemasons ; he shall speak for himself , and our readers can judge how far we are justified in classing him with persons scarcely to

be held responsible for their actions . If he had only Freemasonry on the brain we should not be so much surprised , but he seems to be the incarnation of all that is violent

in his feelings with regard to England . He is no respecter of persons , and we are afraid we must add , has not the least respect for truth .

It would be labour in vain to argue -with such a man . We give some specimens of his language that our readers may know how low it is possible for an enemy to descend . Besides , Mr . Cotter is a curiosity in his way , and let us

hope is even unique in Ireland . The object of the broadsheets before us is " to unmask the plot of God-defying political domination in blaspheming Freemasonry , which it appears is now the State religion of England , " to show

that ^ Masonry was heathenish , as its humbugging libations of ^ wine and oil and corn might suggest . " We owe our origin to a " Jew , who rejected Christianity in toto , for their motto is not only composed of Babylonian Hebrew

cabalistic words , but actually refers to the heathen doctrine of transmigration of souls—a ' doctrine of devils . ' " As their origin is , so are their works , and we need not be surprised that our brethren in Ireland— " traitors to God

, are drawing down Heaven ' s wrath " upon that country . Mr . Cotter has got hold of some books ; he has learned of some renegades , who , like perverts and false friends , become the bitterest of enemies as well as the falsest of

guides . From these he draws pretty largely , and takes all they relate as pure gospel . A Dr . Carwifchen is a great authority in the eyes of Mr . Cotter , and so is a Mr . Trevillan , who thus described a system that had once

tolerated him as a disciple , as " scandalously and detest-+ L ( f nti-Cliristl ' - " He relies very much upon the fact that " one hundred and three " American Masons seceded

from the Order on the ground that it was " a bloody relic ot barbarism . " He mouths this over frequently as if alarmed afc the poverty of his own conversion . Mr . Cotter

"As Ithers See Us."

need not fear ; his vocabulary is stored with epithets that an Irish fishwife would envy , some of which we shall presently reproduce . We are told that Freemasonry is a school for grabbing

as well as for murder , " for it is hardly necessary to say that Mr . Cotter believes in the Morgan story . Bishop Plunket , of Meath , according to this veracious witness , was made an Archbishop by " his clique of cowardly ,

darkness - loving blaspheming Freemasons - God - blaspheming ring . " Daniel O'Connell , who was at one time a member of the Fraternity , but retired from it at the bidding of the Romish priests , once described Mr . Disraeli as " the

heir-atlaw of the blasphemous thief upon the cross . " Mr . Cotter has studied the Repealer as a model of vituperation . He calls Archbishop Plunkeb " an impenitent Freemason ;" calls Lodges " Cowardly murderers' dens ; " says that their

frequenters have " blasphemous lying mouths , " and that they are " liars , assassins and blasphemers . " He rails at times against their secret arts , at another he says , " The more secrecy ' the devil' and these ' his angels' keep , the

better I ' m pleased , till they ' re pinned down into the bottomless pit . " We have said that this coarse traducer was no respecter of persons , and the proof is forthcoming . Writing of a relative he described him as " a most gloriously

charitable , most pious skull-drinking , most blaspheming Freemason of immortal memory . " His own brother , a member of the Craft , rebuked him for his vile language , and he is immediately lashed and accused of being " without natural

affection . " Another brother , also a Freemason , who renounced the Order before he died , is extolled almost as an angel . Mr . R . H . Cotter believes any story that can be

made to tell against the Fraternity . He has got it into his head that the brethren make a practice of drinking out of human skulls . This is a great fact with him , and he calls " one hundred and three" seceders and the Standard

newspaper as witnesses . But then he has another witness , " a butler , who lived in the house of the notorious Freemason named Furnell , and that batler saw a coffin full of skulls and bones lying for months in Furnell ' s parlour , in

George Street , Limerick . " After that who can deny that skulls are converted into drinking cups by the abominable Freemasons , who might with equal truth be dubbed bodysnatchers and cannibals .

There is scarcely a crime under the sun of which it is not possible for a Freemason to be guilty , but it may be a consolation to know that they are condemned in the company of others . England is denounced with the same

unsparing hand , and Orangemen belong to the same tribe of fiends . England is " the great Red Dragon , " and Mr . Cotter calls in a witness who believed the day would come when " she would lose all her commerce , and that

Tyre and Sidon ' s end would be hers . She is also a ' scarlet-coloured beast' —the leopard , spotted with all the lies from Puseyism to Bradlaughism . " After all , Freemasonry is the ground-work of all our wickedness . The

brethren are the evil genii of the world ; they are the serpent that beguiled Eve ; they cannot be saved ; they are the elect of the damned , and Mr . Cotter is the destroying angel who means to execute

vengeance . We can imagine how the brethren will open their eyes with wonder at being so foully stigmatised , how they will tremble when they enter

the Lodge , lest the " red dragon , " the " leopard , spotted with all the lies , " should fall upon them and devour them . Let them not fear , Mr . Cotter is living in a world created

  • Prev page
  • You're on page1
  • 2
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2026

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy