Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Aug. 3, 1872
  • Page 4
Current:

The Freemason, Aug. 3, 1872: Page 4

  • Back to The Freemason, Aug. 3, 1872
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Original Correspondence. ← Page 2 of 3
    Article Original Correspondence. Page 2 of 3
    Article Original Correspondence. Page 2 of 3 →
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Original Correspondence.

I have no doubt that in the end , some of them , at any rate , will become experienced and good Masons . I will now give you answers to the question at thehead of this letter , given by some of our Brethren experienced in the Craft , which I have from time

to time , in my readings , noted down , should you think them worthy of a place in your paper . The Rev . Dr . Oliver , in a note to his Historical Landmarks of Freemasonry , says that " Freemasonry is an institution sift generis ; no other society can be compared with it , it exists solely

of itself . It eclipses all the institutions and orders in the world , which have been on shall be ( Christianity alone excepted ) . The numerous attempts which ever have been made at different periods to expose it to public derision , and destroy its existence have all signally failed . Every

attack has produced an effect contrary to the wishes and anticipations of its projectors . The most vindictive assault has tended to enlarge the place of its tents , to stretch forth the curtains of its habitation , to lengthen its cords and strengthen its stakes , " His Royal Highness the Duke of

Sussex ( our former G . M . ) thus described our excellent institution : — " Masonry , " said he , " is one of the most sublime and perfect institutions that ever was formed for the advancement of happiness and the general good of mankind ; creatine in all its varieties universal benevolence

and brotherly love . It holds out alluivmerits so captivating as to inspire the brotherhood with emulation to deeds of glory , such as must command throughout the world veneration and applause , and such as must entitle those who perform them to dignity ancl respect .

It teaches us those useful , wise , and instructive doctrines , upon which alone true happiness is founded ; and at the same time affords those easy paths by which we attain the rewards of virtue . It teaches us the duties which we owe to our neighbour , never to injure him in any one

situation , but to conduct ourselves with justice anil impartiality ; it bids us not to divulge the mystery to the public , and it orders us to be true to our trust , and above all meanness \\ w \ dissimulation , and in all our vocations lo perform religiously that which we ought to do . "

Brother Robinson , D . P . G . M . for Cornwall , in an address to the brethren at Falmouth , thus describes our ancient fraternity : —• " Its profession , " he said , " instructs and enjoins us to worship and adore our Almighty Maker , to honour and obey the sovereign of our country , to be

peaceful and order ! ) ' in all our stations , diligent in our callings , uprig ht and honest in our dealings , obedient and respectful towards our superiors , gentle ancl condescending to our inferiors , merciful towards our enemies , considerate , mild , and indulgent in our censures , and kind , courteous

ancl obliging in all the relative duties of life . " The Rev . Brother John Russell , P . G ., Chaplain for Devon , in his sermon before the P . G . Lodge at Barnstaple , said , " The precepts of the Gospel were universally the obligations of masonry : so far from containing aught that was

inconsistent with the Gospel , the love of the brotherhood , the fear of God , and the honour of the Queen , were three of the brightest Jewels of Masonry—three of its richest ornaments—three of its first and leading principles . "

I am , Dear Sir and Brother , Yours faithfully and fraternally J . . SIIAI ' LANI ) , P . M . 421 . R . A ., 312 , and M . M . ( 9 South Moulton , July 29 th , 1 S 72

THE ANCIENT GRAND LODGE OF YORK . Bro . Jacob Norton ' s letter in the last number of the Freemason , appears to me to require a few remarks .-mil rnrtvrtinnQ

i . There never has really been any question among those who have looked into the . subject for sometime past , about the " York Rite . " They have long known that it is a complete

misnomer , in as far and inasmuch as it claims to originate at York , or to be a product of the York Grand Lodge . The York Rite , as it is called , has really nothing whatever to do with the York Grand Lodge , but is a production of the middle of the last century .

Original Correspondence.

The only degrees practised in York , were the Three Craft Degrees , the Royal Arch , and quite late in last century , about 1780 , the Masonic Kni ghts Templar Degree ! 2 . I fail altogether to follow Bro . Norton ' s argument as regards the comparative price of

wages . In the fourteenth century , the Master Mason was a person of high education and high wages , and ranked generally as a " genirosus , " or gentleman , while the Masons " ensmentarii , " and their assistants , were all very well paid , indeed , and above the average of common workmen elsewhere .

Bro . Norton falls into the mistake he has , by forgetting a very important question , the value of money then and now . If we want to ascertain to-day the comparative value of money and wages , say as regards the fourteenth century , we must add fourteen

times to the amount then , to get the present value , or some writers even say , fifteen times ! If we take this test , and study the York Fabric Rolls of 1370 , and onwards , we shall soon see that the Masons were well paid . If we descend to 1 r . 8 j , we may freely add ten

times , and about seven times to 1600 , so as to get the comparative value of wages and money . There is , therefore , really no force in the argument that the Masons were too poor to go to York to attend the Grand Assembly , as they were always ; i well paid body , and were , in

truth , the skilled artizans of those days . 3 . With regard to the earliest mention of York as the place of the meeting of the Masons , though it is not in Halliwell ' s MS ., or Matthew Cocke ' s , yet we find it in Dowland ' s copy , which represents a very old form , and that" cyte , "

mentioned both in the poem and the additional MS ., may fairly be assumed to be " York . " Dowland ' s form represents a very old original ( not yet found ) , not later than 1300 , and I see no reason whatever for rejecting the old

Masonic Legend of York being the place of meeting of the Grand Assembly . 4 . Alhelstan is mentioned in all the MSS ., and as his date was about 927 , it is hardly correct to say that nothing is found of his date until 1717 .

j . It is quite true that St . Alban is not mentioned in the poem , so far as memory serves me now , without any book to refer to , but lie is mentioned in Matthew Cooke ' s MS . about

1490 . 6 . And though it is quite true that no Charter from Alhelstan has yet turned up , 1 am not prepared to admit that such never existed , or may not even yet exist , as I have already previously shewn , the a priori probability of Alhelstan granting a Charter to the Masonic guilds . A MASONIC STUDENT .

PROFESSOR RAWLINSON AND THE TEN TRIBES . To the Editor if the Freemason .

Dear Sir and Brother , — We may be tolerably certain that when a man of piofound learning , who has many imperative calls upon his time , and who occupies , moreover , the chair of a Professor in the University

of Oxford , turns aside from his usual course , to address himself to a subject that does not properly fall in his way , it must be because he attaches some importance to it , either for its truth ancl the consequences resulting from it , or for its supposed erroneousness and the mischief it is likel y to produce .

In the " Leisure Hour" of July 6 th , which a friend lias been good enough to send to me , I find a paper , bearing the name of Professor Rawlinson , " ' author of the Five Great Monarchies , " and sundry other erudite works , some of which , especiall y his " Five Great Monarchies , " would induce one to believe that he is one of the

men most likely to throw some light on the interesting question he has chosen to dilate upon , " Where are the Ten Tribes r" And the style in which he writes , and the supercilious terms in which he speaks of those who have given to the enquiry the most diligent study , and have written the most largely and intelligently upon it , evinces , very unmistakeably , the high estimate

Original Correspondence.

he has formed of his own capabilities for disposing of the question , and the assurance he feels of being able to dissipate , by a few strokes of his pen , the delusion by which , he believes , many deep-thinking and learned men are led astray ! That the question upon which the Professor

now writes is one of much interest , he shews , in calling attention to the published literature of the subject , which " is so large , " he says , " that even a condensed account of it , would occupy more space than can be afforded to it , within the limits of this article . "

T . his is not overstating the fact , and it might be thought that a writer who thus calls attention to it , would have been restrained from speaking or writing contemptuously , not only of those who happen to differ from him in the view he takes of the subject , but of those who " waste their powers

of ratiocination upon a question that has been examined , sifted , argued out , and put away as 'done with . ' "' In like manner , the Professor speaks of a book which has received the most respectful attention and called forth expressions of profound admiration , for both its

substance and its style , from scholars , if not so deeply read in history as the Camden Professor , yet having a reputation for much learning , critical acumen , and sound judgment , as being made up of " arguments of the most flimsy and unsubstantial kind , " the book being " after a short

time forgotten , no traces of the opinions put forth in it having been adopted by any writer of any ( or even of no ) reputation "; that is , between 18 43 and 1870 . What has the Professor been doing , during the quarter of a century he speaks of ? Have Babylonian bricks and Assyrian cylinders so

absorbed his attention that he has been wholl y oblivious of what has occupied the minds and engaged the pens of hundreds of learned ancl devout men , who have been induced to adopt the opinions he writes so disparagingly of , ancl puts away as " done with " ? To be ignorant that the question has , during the years the Professor

speaks of , been treated as a topic of great interest , in the religious world , at home and ' abroad , may not be a matter for censure ; but it is a disqualification for writing upon it , ancl especiall y for writing upon it in a tone of disparagement and almost of contempt of those who " waste their time and and thought " in reading what may be written on the other side .

To enumerate the names of those who have espoused and written in furtherance of the views put forth in " Our Origin , " during the twentyfive years the Professor speaks of , would far exceed the limits within which I must confine myself , but I may mention Professor Piazzi

Smyth , Astronomer Royal of Scotland , author of several learned works on the Great Pyramid , and Ancient Egyptain Life ; Dr . George Moore , of Hastings , author of " the Use of the Bod y in relation to the Mind , " " The Lost Tribes , or the Saxons of the East ancl West . " "The ancient

Pillar Stones of Scotland , " ike . ; the Rev . Jacob Tomlin , author of " A Comparative Vocabulary of 48 Languages , " "An exposition of the Apocalypse , " ike . ; the late Rev . Alexander Dallas , Dr . Marsh , and Dr . Campbell ; Mr . R . Govett , author of " English derived from Hebrew , with

glances at Greek ancl Latin ; " and Mr . Robert Mimpriss , whose " Gospel Treasury and Expository Harmony of the Four Evangelists , " partly the work of Mr . Wilson , whose views on the Israelites pervade it , and of which there have been editions , in different sizes ,

sold to the number of more than 30 , 000 copies . These are all men of some reputation ; and it may be safely affirmed , because the proof is at hand , that during the period that Professor Rawlinson supposes thequestionof "OurOrigin "

to have been dead ancl put away as " clone with , " it was exciting a very lively interest throughout the United Kingdom , in America , where the work was republished and largely circulated , ancl in such distant regions as Syria and Palestine .

But as if awaking out of sleep , Professor Rawlinson finds that after a lapse of five and twenty years , Mr . Wilson ' s " views have been reasserted , " in a a sort of reproduction of his

work" Our Israclitish Origin—in a modern form ; " but though " the brochure is having a wonderful circulation , " it " is not , " he says , " calculated to produce the slightest effect on the opinion of those competent to form one , " but " only on the

“The Freemason: 1872-08-03, Page 4” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 29 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_03081872/page/4/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS Article 1
FOOTSTEPS OF FREEMASONRY; Article 1
CONSECRATION OF A ROSE CROIX CHAPTER AT SOUTHAMPTON. Article 2
A KIND WORD TO THE BRETHREN. Article 3
Original Correspondence. Article 3
LIBELLING THE PRIME MINISTER. Article 5
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
ROYAL ORDER OF SCOTLAND. Article 6
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 7
Royal Arch. Article 8
Knights Templar. Article 9
THE GRAND MARK LODGE OF ENGLAND. Article 9
TRINIDAD. Article 10
Masonic Tidings. Article 11
FREEMASONRY IN ITALY. Article 11
WEST LANCASHIRE MASONIC RELIEF COMMITTEE. Article 12
ARTEMUS WARD, M.W.G. M.S.M. Article 12
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 12
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

4 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

8 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

9 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

21 Articles
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Original Correspondence.

I have no doubt that in the end , some of them , at any rate , will become experienced and good Masons . I will now give you answers to the question at thehead of this letter , given by some of our Brethren experienced in the Craft , which I have from time

to time , in my readings , noted down , should you think them worthy of a place in your paper . The Rev . Dr . Oliver , in a note to his Historical Landmarks of Freemasonry , says that " Freemasonry is an institution sift generis ; no other society can be compared with it , it exists solely

of itself . It eclipses all the institutions and orders in the world , which have been on shall be ( Christianity alone excepted ) . The numerous attempts which ever have been made at different periods to expose it to public derision , and destroy its existence have all signally failed . Every

attack has produced an effect contrary to the wishes and anticipations of its projectors . The most vindictive assault has tended to enlarge the place of its tents , to stretch forth the curtains of its habitation , to lengthen its cords and strengthen its stakes , " His Royal Highness the Duke of

Sussex ( our former G . M . ) thus described our excellent institution : — " Masonry , " said he , " is one of the most sublime and perfect institutions that ever was formed for the advancement of happiness and the general good of mankind ; creatine in all its varieties universal benevolence

and brotherly love . It holds out alluivmerits so captivating as to inspire the brotherhood with emulation to deeds of glory , such as must command throughout the world veneration and applause , and such as must entitle those who perform them to dignity ancl respect .

It teaches us those useful , wise , and instructive doctrines , upon which alone true happiness is founded ; and at the same time affords those easy paths by which we attain the rewards of virtue . It teaches us the duties which we owe to our neighbour , never to injure him in any one

situation , but to conduct ourselves with justice anil impartiality ; it bids us not to divulge the mystery to the public , and it orders us to be true to our trust , and above all meanness \\ w \ dissimulation , and in all our vocations lo perform religiously that which we ought to do . "

Brother Robinson , D . P . G . M . for Cornwall , in an address to the brethren at Falmouth , thus describes our ancient fraternity : —• " Its profession , " he said , " instructs and enjoins us to worship and adore our Almighty Maker , to honour and obey the sovereign of our country , to be

peaceful and order ! ) ' in all our stations , diligent in our callings , uprig ht and honest in our dealings , obedient and respectful towards our superiors , gentle ancl condescending to our inferiors , merciful towards our enemies , considerate , mild , and indulgent in our censures , and kind , courteous

ancl obliging in all the relative duties of life . " The Rev . Brother John Russell , P . G ., Chaplain for Devon , in his sermon before the P . G . Lodge at Barnstaple , said , " The precepts of the Gospel were universally the obligations of masonry : so far from containing aught that was

inconsistent with the Gospel , the love of the brotherhood , the fear of God , and the honour of the Queen , were three of the brightest Jewels of Masonry—three of its richest ornaments—three of its first and leading principles . "

I am , Dear Sir and Brother , Yours faithfully and fraternally J . . SIIAI ' LANI ) , P . M . 421 . R . A ., 312 , and M . M . ( 9 South Moulton , July 29 th , 1 S 72

THE ANCIENT GRAND LODGE OF YORK . Bro . Jacob Norton ' s letter in the last number of the Freemason , appears to me to require a few remarks .-mil rnrtvrtinnQ

i . There never has really been any question among those who have looked into the . subject for sometime past , about the " York Rite . " They have long known that it is a complete

misnomer , in as far and inasmuch as it claims to originate at York , or to be a product of the York Grand Lodge . The York Rite , as it is called , has really nothing whatever to do with the York Grand Lodge , but is a production of the middle of the last century .

Original Correspondence.

The only degrees practised in York , were the Three Craft Degrees , the Royal Arch , and quite late in last century , about 1780 , the Masonic Kni ghts Templar Degree ! 2 . I fail altogether to follow Bro . Norton ' s argument as regards the comparative price of

wages . In the fourteenth century , the Master Mason was a person of high education and high wages , and ranked generally as a " genirosus , " or gentleman , while the Masons " ensmentarii , " and their assistants , were all very well paid , indeed , and above the average of common workmen elsewhere .

Bro . Norton falls into the mistake he has , by forgetting a very important question , the value of money then and now . If we want to ascertain to-day the comparative value of money and wages , say as regards the fourteenth century , we must add fourteen

times to the amount then , to get the present value , or some writers even say , fifteen times ! If we take this test , and study the York Fabric Rolls of 1370 , and onwards , we shall soon see that the Masons were well paid . If we descend to 1 r . 8 j , we may freely add ten

times , and about seven times to 1600 , so as to get the comparative value of wages and money . There is , therefore , really no force in the argument that the Masons were too poor to go to York to attend the Grand Assembly , as they were always ; i well paid body , and were , in

truth , the skilled artizans of those days . 3 . With regard to the earliest mention of York as the place of the meeting of the Masons , though it is not in Halliwell ' s MS ., or Matthew Cocke ' s , yet we find it in Dowland ' s copy , which represents a very old form , and that" cyte , "

mentioned both in the poem and the additional MS ., may fairly be assumed to be " York . " Dowland ' s form represents a very old original ( not yet found ) , not later than 1300 , and I see no reason whatever for rejecting the old

Masonic Legend of York being the place of meeting of the Grand Assembly . 4 . Alhelstan is mentioned in all the MSS ., and as his date was about 927 , it is hardly correct to say that nothing is found of his date until 1717 .

j . It is quite true that St . Alban is not mentioned in the poem , so far as memory serves me now , without any book to refer to , but lie is mentioned in Matthew Cooke ' s MS . about

1490 . 6 . And though it is quite true that no Charter from Alhelstan has yet turned up , 1 am not prepared to admit that such never existed , or may not even yet exist , as I have already previously shewn , the a priori probability of Alhelstan granting a Charter to the Masonic guilds . A MASONIC STUDENT .

PROFESSOR RAWLINSON AND THE TEN TRIBES . To the Editor if the Freemason .

Dear Sir and Brother , — We may be tolerably certain that when a man of piofound learning , who has many imperative calls upon his time , and who occupies , moreover , the chair of a Professor in the University

of Oxford , turns aside from his usual course , to address himself to a subject that does not properly fall in his way , it must be because he attaches some importance to it , either for its truth ancl the consequences resulting from it , or for its supposed erroneousness and the mischief it is likel y to produce .

In the " Leisure Hour" of July 6 th , which a friend lias been good enough to send to me , I find a paper , bearing the name of Professor Rawlinson , " ' author of the Five Great Monarchies , " and sundry other erudite works , some of which , especiall y his " Five Great Monarchies , " would induce one to believe that he is one of the

men most likely to throw some light on the interesting question he has chosen to dilate upon , " Where are the Ten Tribes r" And the style in which he writes , and the supercilious terms in which he speaks of those who have given to the enquiry the most diligent study , and have written the most largely and intelligently upon it , evinces , very unmistakeably , the high estimate

Original Correspondence.

he has formed of his own capabilities for disposing of the question , and the assurance he feels of being able to dissipate , by a few strokes of his pen , the delusion by which , he believes , many deep-thinking and learned men are led astray ! That the question upon which the Professor

now writes is one of much interest , he shews , in calling attention to the published literature of the subject , which " is so large , " he says , " that even a condensed account of it , would occupy more space than can be afforded to it , within the limits of this article . "

T . his is not overstating the fact , and it might be thought that a writer who thus calls attention to it , would have been restrained from speaking or writing contemptuously , not only of those who happen to differ from him in the view he takes of the subject , but of those who " waste their powers

of ratiocination upon a question that has been examined , sifted , argued out , and put away as 'done with . ' "' In like manner , the Professor speaks of a book which has received the most respectful attention and called forth expressions of profound admiration , for both its

substance and its style , from scholars , if not so deeply read in history as the Camden Professor , yet having a reputation for much learning , critical acumen , and sound judgment , as being made up of " arguments of the most flimsy and unsubstantial kind , " the book being " after a short

time forgotten , no traces of the opinions put forth in it having been adopted by any writer of any ( or even of no ) reputation "; that is , between 18 43 and 1870 . What has the Professor been doing , during the quarter of a century he speaks of ? Have Babylonian bricks and Assyrian cylinders so

absorbed his attention that he has been wholl y oblivious of what has occupied the minds and engaged the pens of hundreds of learned ancl devout men , who have been induced to adopt the opinions he writes so disparagingly of , ancl puts away as " done with " ? To be ignorant that the question has , during the years the Professor

speaks of , been treated as a topic of great interest , in the religious world , at home and ' abroad , may not be a matter for censure ; but it is a disqualification for writing upon it , ancl especiall y for writing upon it in a tone of disparagement and almost of contempt of those who " waste their time and and thought " in reading what may be written on the other side .

To enumerate the names of those who have espoused and written in furtherance of the views put forth in " Our Origin , " during the twentyfive years the Professor speaks of , would far exceed the limits within which I must confine myself , but I may mention Professor Piazzi

Smyth , Astronomer Royal of Scotland , author of several learned works on the Great Pyramid , and Ancient Egyptain Life ; Dr . George Moore , of Hastings , author of " the Use of the Bod y in relation to the Mind , " " The Lost Tribes , or the Saxons of the East ancl West . " "The ancient

Pillar Stones of Scotland , " ike . ; the Rev . Jacob Tomlin , author of " A Comparative Vocabulary of 48 Languages , " "An exposition of the Apocalypse , " ike . ; the late Rev . Alexander Dallas , Dr . Marsh , and Dr . Campbell ; Mr . R . Govett , author of " English derived from Hebrew , with

glances at Greek ancl Latin ; " and Mr . Robert Mimpriss , whose " Gospel Treasury and Expository Harmony of the Four Evangelists , " partly the work of Mr . Wilson , whose views on the Israelites pervade it , and of which there have been editions , in different sizes ,

sold to the number of more than 30 , 000 copies . These are all men of some reputation ; and it may be safely affirmed , because the proof is at hand , that during the period that Professor Rawlinson supposes thequestionof "OurOrigin "

to have been dead ancl put away as " clone with , " it was exciting a very lively interest throughout the United Kingdom , in America , where the work was republished and largely circulated , ancl in such distant regions as Syria and Palestine .

But as if awaking out of sleep , Professor Rawlinson finds that after a lapse of five and twenty years , Mr . Wilson ' s " views have been reasserted , " in a a sort of reproduction of his

work" Our Israclitish Origin—in a modern form ; " but though " the brochure is having a wonderful circulation , " it " is not , " he says , " calculated to produce the slightest effect on the opinion of those competent to form one , " but " only on the

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 3
  • You're on page4
  • 5
  • 14
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy