Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Sept. 3, 1870
  • Page 6
  • Answers to Correspondents.
Current:

The Freemason, Sept. 3, 1870: Page 6

  • Back to The Freemason, Sept. 3, 1870
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Foreign and Colonial Agents. Page 1 of 1
    Article Births, Marriages, and Deaths. Page 1 of 1
    Article Answers to Correspondents. Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article PENALTIES of GREATNESS Page 1 of 2
    Article PENALTIES of GREATNESS Page 1 of 2 →
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Foreign And Colonial Agents.

Foreign and Colonial Agents .

—•»—AMERICA : Bro . J . FLETCHER B RENNAN , 114 , Mainstreet , Cincinnati , Ohio . Messrs . WOODRUFF & BLOCKER , Little

Rock , Arkansas , U . S . CANADA : Messrs . DEVRIE & SON , Ottawa . CAPE OF GOOD HOPE : Bro . G EORGE BRITTAIN , Cape Town . CEYLON : Messrs . W . L . SKEENE & Co ., Colombo . CONSTANTINOPLE : Br . J . L . HANLY , Levant Times .

EAST INDIES : Allahabad : Messrs . "WVMAN BROS . Bombay : Bro . M . B . COHEN . Byculla : Bro . GEO . BEASE . Central Provinces : Bro . F . J . J ORDAN . Kurraclue : Bro . G . C . BRAYSON . Madras : Mr . CALEB FOSTER .

Mhow : Bro . COWASJEE N USSERWANJEE . Poona : Bro . W . WELLIS . GALATA : IPSICK KHAN , Perche-Bajar . LIBERIA : Bro . HENRY D . BROWN , Monrovia . PARIS : M . DECHEVAUX-DUMESNIL , Rue de Harlaydu-Palais , 20 , near the Pont Neuf ; Editor Le Franc-Mafon .

WEST 1 JND 1 KS : Jamaica : Bro . J A . D . SOUZA , Falmouth . Trinidad : Bros . S . CARTER and J . LEWIS , 3 , Abercrombie-street , Port of Spain ; and Bro . W . A . KERNAHAN , San Fernando . And all Booksellers and Newsagents in England , Ireland , and Scotland .

Births, Marriages, And Deaths.

Births , Marriages , and Deaths .

BIRTH . BOYLE . —On the 29 th ult ., at Eaglesham , the wife of Bro . John Boyle , S . M ., Lodge Clyde , 408 , of a son . DEATH . CROW . —On Thursday , 26 th ultt ., at De Montfort-terrace , Leicester , Florence Edith , infant daughter of Bro . Edwin J . Crow , J . W . 279 , P . G . O . Leicestershire and Rutland .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

BRO . ARMSTRONG , W . M . 531 . —The candles in the East , South and West must be kept alight in all the degrees , and that in the East should never be extinguished , even during the ceremony of raising . Lamps or other contrivances used as substitutes for the light in the East are an utter abomination , and must have been introduced into lodges by some imbecile , who could

not comprehend the beautiful . symbolism of the light that " shineth in the valley of darkness , yea , even the valley of the shadow of death . " A little thought over these matters would weed many incongruities from the Masonic system , and many of those erroneous arrangements may be said to have arisen from the ignorance of some of the antiquated teachers of thc Craft in days gone by .

PHILALETHES . —We are really anxious to give every facility for the fair discussion of the question mooted , but we put it strongly to yourself whether the use of such expressions as "low fellows , " " gang of conspirators , " can possibly assist in elucidating the points

involved . For ourselves , we may safely say that we believe Prince Rhodocanakis to be a gentleman of worth and intelligence , but wc must decline giving any opinion upon his claims to the title of" Imperial Hi gh-Bess . " With the exceptions noted , your letter is fair criticism .

BRO . DUNCAN WILKIE . —If you send us a brief statement ofthe facts , it shall appear . S . P . —As a Dutch Rose Croix , you are eligible to attend an English Rose Croix Chapter upon the production of your 18 ° certificate , and undergoing an examination . BRO . WILLIAM WAYNE , P . M . No . 1161 . —You are quite correct ; thc word " two " is wanting , and we find that

it was not in thc paper from whicli we copied the explanation—hence , the Reader ' s sin was not one of " omission . " Candidates for the R . A . degree are very frequently proposed by letter to the Scribe E , although the proposition in open chapter is to be preferred , when practicable ; but the full particulars , excepting age , should be stated on the summons . A Royal Arch

Chapter in England can be opened by tlie Three Principals , or by Present or Past Principals of corresponding rank , and consequently a chapter can be held by three ; but no brother can be legally exalted unless nine companions—to represent the ancient "Chapter of Jerusalem "—be present . In America and elsewhere chapters are not opened exclusively by Principals ( there

termed High Priest , King , and Scribe ); but nine companions must be in attendance to form a quorum for opening and transacting business . M . M . —We have now given both sides a hearing , and believe it best to close the discussion . We deeply regret ,

however , to learn that " such things can be" amongst men who ought to practise fraternity and good-will . BRO . A . F . V . —We have to apologise for having mislaid your letter , which reached us when out of town . It is , however , so much to the point that delay will fortunately not put it out of date .

Several reviews and jottings from Masonic journals , with reports of Lodge of Harmony , 220 , and Lebanon Lodge , 1326 , and other communications , will appear in our nest .

Ar00603

The Freemason , SATURDAY , SEPTEMBER 3 , 1 S 70 . THE FREEMASON is published on Saturday Mornings in time for the early trains . The price of THE FREEMASON is Twopence per week ; quarterly subscription ( including postage ) 3 s . 3 d . Annual Subscription , 12 s . Subscriptions payable in advance . All communications , letters , & c , to be addressed to the EDITOR , 2 , 3 , and 4 , Little Britain , E . C . The Editor will pay careful attention to all MSS . entrusted to himbut cannot undertake to return them unless accompanied by postage stamps .

Penalties Of Greatness

PENALTIES of GREATNESS

THE spell of war is upon us ; the fearful fascination of blood enthralls our soulsnothing is talked of but marches and counter-marches , sieges and sorties , defeats

or victories . Of a truth the present aspect of Europe is enough to discourage the most hopeful ; each day seems to add to the bitterness of the struggle between the

French and German nations , and every hour that passes appears to diminish the prospect of a speedy cessation of the strife . It was , we believe , Sir James Mackintosh

who said that , unfortunately for the repose of mankind , great states are compelled to consider the military spirit and martial habits of their people , as one of the main

objects of their policy , Lrequent hostilities seem almost thc necessary condition of greatness ; and , without being great , they cannot remain safe . " If this be so—and

history corroborates it to a remarkable extent—our surprise at the sudden outbreak of war between Prussia and France was

somewhat ill-founded , as the most superficial observer of European politics for the last four or five years must have noticed the war-cloud that dimmed the horizon

from time to time , and must have arrived at the conviction that a contest for supremacy between France and her powerful neighbour was sooner , or later , inevitable .

Lamentable " condition of greatness , deplorable penalty for increasing prosperity and power ! Must thc nations of the earth ever gird themselves for the fight , and

wrestle grimly to the death , like the gladiators of a Roman arena , in order to decide which is the strongest in skill and resources ? It is not a question of valour , because valour

is to be found amongst every race of men , and the tests of victory in these days arc sought in other directions . There must be generalship — there must be foresight — there must be an infinite combination of

strategy and tactics , as well as death-defying courage in the field ; and , unfortunately for France in her hour of peril , none of the required tests , save the last , are forthcoming .

In vain her chivalry rush upon the foe—in vain they sacrifice themselves bravely , but madly—because there is no guiding hand , no calculating brain to measure the

chances or to direct their onward course . As we have said before , we have no desire to enter upon the political bearings of the war , and we may add that our chief anxiety

is the restoration of peace without thc paramount triumph of either party ; but wc should be less , or more , than human if we could survey unmoved the fall of so many

Penalties Of Greatness

gallant men , all of whom , whether they be Gauls or Teutons , believe in the justice of their cause , and all of whom are fighting to maintain the fancied prestige of their respective fatherlands .

Now , although Englishmen make good soldiers , we are , happily , as yet very inexperienced in the duties of defending our

" homes and altars , " as the patriotic phrase goes , and long may we continue so ; but as men are said to have learnt to swim without

the trouble of entering the water , it would certainly not be out of place were we to attempt the feat of guarding our little island against even possible foes . Ambition is a

perilous thing , and the wealth of Great Britain is a somewhat tempting bait to a hungry foe . Let us , therefore , be wise in time , and show the vain-glorious boasters

of the Continent that England is still ready to defend her shores against all-comers ; aye , and to protect the interests of her children in every sea . " Without being

great , we cannot remain safe ; " these are words pregnant with meaning for all men who have studied the mighty book of human progress in every age , No nation

was ever yet enslaved , until the spirit of cowardice invaded its councils , and the surest way for a great nation to court danger is to abdicate its natural position in

the front rank . However , we have no distrust of this kind so far as Ensrland is concerned ; and in point of fact , unless we have very much degenerated , it

would be strange , indeed , to find that the thirty-one millions who inhabit the British Islands in 1870 are incapable of the

efforts liy which a world in arms was quelled by less than half that number of their ancestors . Wc would not be mistaken .

War is utterly abhorrent to our ideas ; but , at the same time , we should for ever regret having uttered a word whicli could be construed into an acknowledgment that

peace is preferable at any price . On the contrary , we hold that every man is justified infighting for his own home and for the safety of his family and friends ; and as

nations have wider responsibilities , we hold that England is bound to maintain , pure and unsullied , that flag which has waved triumphantly o ' er many a well-fought field .

Wc , nevertheless , sympathise with all those who arc enduring the privations and the miseries of war , and we commend the exertions of those true-hearted men and

women who seek to alleviate the pangs of the wounded and the anguish of the bereaved . Ali honour to the Grand Orient of France , who , in the holiest interpretation

of their Masonic mission , have come forward with pecuniary aid for the victims of battle , and may every success attend the appeal which they have made on behalf of our

common humanity . We have often had to differ with the foreign policy of the Grand Orient—a policy dictated by imperfect

information more than unsound views—and we , therefore , gladly greet the opportunity of bearing testimony to the fact that the leaders of French Masonry arc ever to be

“The Freemason: 1870-09-03, Page 6” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 8 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_03091870/page/6/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 1
FREEMASONRY IN ENGLAND. Article 1
MASONIC CURIOSITIES.-IV. Article 1
THE MARK DEGREE. Article 2
LETTER from a BROTHER in ENGLAND to a BROTHER in SCOTLAND. Article 2
AID TO THE SICK AND WOUNDED IN WAR. Article 3
ANNUAL COMMUNICATION OR THE GRAND LODGE OF CANADA. Article 3
MASONRY IN AMERICA. Article 4
Reports of Masonic Meetings. Article 5
MARK MASONRY. Article 5
ANTIQUITY OF FREEMASONRY. Article 5
Foreign and Colonial Agents. Article 6
Births, Marriages, and Deaths. Article 6
Answers to Correspondents. Article 6
Untitled Article 6
PENALTIES of GREATNESS Article 6
Multum in Parbo, or Masonic Notes and Queries. Article 7
Original Correspondence. Article 8
RED CROSS OF ROME AND CONSTANTINE. Article 10
ROYAL ARCH. Article 10
Poetry. Article 11
THE "RED-CROSS KNIGHT." Article 11
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS Article 11
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

5 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

5 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

6 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

4 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

5 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

16 Articles
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Foreign And Colonial Agents.

Foreign and Colonial Agents .

—•»—AMERICA : Bro . J . FLETCHER B RENNAN , 114 , Mainstreet , Cincinnati , Ohio . Messrs . WOODRUFF & BLOCKER , Little

Rock , Arkansas , U . S . CANADA : Messrs . DEVRIE & SON , Ottawa . CAPE OF GOOD HOPE : Bro . G EORGE BRITTAIN , Cape Town . CEYLON : Messrs . W . L . SKEENE & Co ., Colombo . CONSTANTINOPLE : Br . J . L . HANLY , Levant Times .

EAST INDIES : Allahabad : Messrs . "WVMAN BROS . Bombay : Bro . M . B . COHEN . Byculla : Bro . GEO . BEASE . Central Provinces : Bro . F . J . J ORDAN . Kurraclue : Bro . G . C . BRAYSON . Madras : Mr . CALEB FOSTER .

Mhow : Bro . COWASJEE N USSERWANJEE . Poona : Bro . W . WELLIS . GALATA : IPSICK KHAN , Perche-Bajar . LIBERIA : Bro . HENRY D . BROWN , Monrovia . PARIS : M . DECHEVAUX-DUMESNIL , Rue de Harlaydu-Palais , 20 , near the Pont Neuf ; Editor Le Franc-Mafon .

WEST 1 JND 1 KS : Jamaica : Bro . J A . D . SOUZA , Falmouth . Trinidad : Bros . S . CARTER and J . LEWIS , 3 , Abercrombie-street , Port of Spain ; and Bro . W . A . KERNAHAN , San Fernando . And all Booksellers and Newsagents in England , Ireland , and Scotland .

Births, Marriages, And Deaths.

Births , Marriages , and Deaths .

BIRTH . BOYLE . —On the 29 th ult ., at Eaglesham , the wife of Bro . John Boyle , S . M ., Lodge Clyde , 408 , of a son . DEATH . CROW . —On Thursday , 26 th ultt ., at De Montfort-terrace , Leicester , Florence Edith , infant daughter of Bro . Edwin J . Crow , J . W . 279 , P . G . O . Leicestershire and Rutland .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

BRO . ARMSTRONG , W . M . 531 . —The candles in the East , South and West must be kept alight in all the degrees , and that in the East should never be extinguished , even during the ceremony of raising . Lamps or other contrivances used as substitutes for the light in the East are an utter abomination , and must have been introduced into lodges by some imbecile , who could

not comprehend the beautiful . symbolism of the light that " shineth in the valley of darkness , yea , even the valley of the shadow of death . " A little thought over these matters would weed many incongruities from the Masonic system , and many of those erroneous arrangements may be said to have arisen from the ignorance of some of the antiquated teachers of thc Craft in days gone by .

PHILALETHES . —We are really anxious to give every facility for the fair discussion of the question mooted , but we put it strongly to yourself whether the use of such expressions as "low fellows , " " gang of conspirators , " can possibly assist in elucidating the points

involved . For ourselves , we may safely say that we believe Prince Rhodocanakis to be a gentleman of worth and intelligence , but wc must decline giving any opinion upon his claims to the title of" Imperial Hi gh-Bess . " With the exceptions noted , your letter is fair criticism .

BRO . DUNCAN WILKIE . —If you send us a brief statement ofthe facts , it shall appear . S . P . —As a Dutch Rose Croix , you are eligible to attend an English Rose Croix Chapter upon the production of your 18 ° certificate , and undergoing an examination . BRO . WILLIAM WAYNE , P . M . No . 1161 . —You are quite correct ; thc word " two " is wanting , and we find that

it was not in thc paper from whicli we copied the explanation—hence , the Reader ' s sin was not one of " omission . " Candidates for the R . A . degree are very frequently proposed by letter to the Scribe E , although the proposition in open chapter is to be preferred , when practicable ; but the full particulars , excepting age , should be stated on the summons . A Royal Arch

Chapter in England can be opened by tlie Three Principals , or by Present or Past Principals of corresponding rank , and consequently a chapter can be held by three ; but no brother can be legally exalted unless nine companions—to represent the ancient "Chapter of Jerusalem "—be present . In America and elsewhere chapters are not opened exclusively by Principals ( there

termed High Priest , King , and Scribe ); but nine companions must be in attendance to form a quorum for opening and transacting business . M . M . —We have now given both sides a hearing , and believe it best to close the discussion . We deeply regret ,

however , to learn that " such things can be" amongst men who ought to practise fraternity and good-will . BRO . A . F . V . —We have to apologise for having mislaid your letter , which reached us when out of town . It is , however , so much to the point that delay will fortunately not put it out of date .

Several reviews and jottings from Masonic journals , with reports of Lodge of Harmony , 220 , and Lebanon Lodge , 1326 , and other communications , will appear in our nest .

Ar00603

The Freemason , SATURDAY , SEPTEMBER 3 , 1 S 70 . THE FREEMASON is published on Saturday Mornings in time for the early trains . The price of THE FREEMASON is Twopence per week ; quarterly subscription ( including postage ) 3 s . 3 d . Annual Subscription , 12 s . Subscriptions payable in advance . All communications , letters , & c , to be addressed to the EDITOR , 2 , 3 , and 4 , Little Britain , E . C . The Editor will pay careful attention to all MSS . entrusted to himbut cannot undertake to return them unless accompanied by postage stamps .

Penalties Of Greatness

PENALTIES of GREATNESS

THE spell of war is upon us ; the fearful fascination of blood enthralls our soulsnothing is talked of but marches and counter-marches , sieges and sorties , defeats

or victories . Of a truth the present aspect of Europe is enough to discourage the most hopeful ; each day seems to add to the bitterness of the struggle between the

French and German nations , and every hour that passes appears to diminish the prospect of a speedy cessation of the strife . It was , we believe , Sir James Mackintosh

who said that , unfortunately for the repose of mankind , great states are compelled to consider the military spirit and martial habits of their people , as one of the main

objects of their policy , Lrequent hostilities seem almost thc necessary condition of greatness ; and , without being great , they cannot remain safe . " If this be so—and

history corroborates it to a remarkable extent—our surprise at the sudden outbreak of war between Prussia and France was

somewhat ill-founded , as the most superficial observer of European politics for the last four or five years must have noticed the war-cloud that dimmed the horizon

from time to time , and must have arrived at the conviction that a contest for supremacy between France and her powerful neighbour was sooner , or later , inevitable .

Lamentable " condition of greatness , deplorable penalty for increasing prosperity and power ! Must thc nations of the earth ever gird themselves for the fight , and

wrestle grimly to the death , like the gladiators of a Roman arena , in order to decide which is the strongest in skill and resources ? It is not a question of valour , because valour

is to be found amongst every race of men , and the tests of victory in these days arc sought in other directions . There must be generalship — there must be foresight — there must be an infinite combination of

strategy and tactics , as well as death-defying courage in the field ; and , unfortunately for France in her hour of peril , none of the required tests , save the last , are forthcoming .

In vain her chivalry rush upon the foe—in vain they sacrifice themselves bravely , but madly—because there is no guiding hand , no calculating brain to measure the

chances or to direct their onward course . As we have said before , we have no desire to enter upon the political bearings of the war , and we may add that our chief anxiety

is the restoration of peace without thc paramount triumph of either party ; but wc should be less , or more , than human if we could survey unmoved the fall of so many

Penalties Of Greatness

gallant men , all of whom , whether they be Gauls or Teutons , believe in the justice of their cause , and all of whom are fighting to maintain the fancied prestige of their respective fatherlands .

Now , although Englishmen make good soldiers , we are , happily , as yet very inexperienced in the duties of defending our

" homes and altars , " as the patriotic phrase goes , and long may we continue so ; but as men are said to have learnt to swim without

the trouble of entering the water , it would certainly not be out of place were we to attempt the feat of guarding our little island against even possible foes . Ambition is a

perilous thing , and the wealth of Great Britain is a somewhat tempting bait to a hungry foe . Let us , therefore , be wise in time , and show the vain-glorious boasters

of the Continent that England is still ready to defend her shores against all-comers ; aye , and to protect the interests of her children in every sea . " Without being

great , we cannot remain safe ; " these are words pregnant with meaning for all men who have studied the mighty book of human progress in every age , No nation

was ever yet enslaved , until the spirit of cowardice invaded its councils , and the surest way for a great nation to court danger is to abdicate its natural position in

the front rank . However , we have no distrust of this kind so far as Ensrland is concerned ; and in point of fact , unless we have very much degenerated , it

would be strange , indeed , to find that the thirty-one millions who inhabit the British Islands in 1870 are incapable of the

efforts liy which a world in arms was quelled by less than half that number of their ancestors . Wc would not be mistaken .

War is utterly abhorrent to our ideas ; but , at the same time , we should for ever regret having uttered a word whicli could be construed into an acknowledgment that

peace is preferable at any price . On the contrary , we hold that every man is justified infighting for his own home and for the safety of his family and friends ; and as

nations have wider responsibilities , we hold that England is bound to maintain , pure and unsullied , that flag which has waved triumphantly o ' er many a well-fought field .

Wc , nevertheless , sympathise with all those who arc enduring the privations and the miseries of war , and we commend the exertions of those true-hearted men and

women who seek to alleviate the pangs of the wounded and the anguish of the bereaved . Ali honour to the Grand Orient of France , who , in the holiest interpretation

of their Masonic mission , have come forward with pecuniary aid for the victims of battle , and may every success attend the appeal which they have made on behalf of our

common humanity . We have often had to differ with the foreign policy of the Grand Orient—a policy dictated by imperfect

information more than unsound views—and we , therefore , gladly greet the opportunity of bearing testimony to the fact that the leaders of French Masonry arc ever to be

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 5
  • You're on page6
  • 7
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy