Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Sept. 5, 1874
  • Page 6
  • Ad00604
Current:

The Freemason, Sept. 5, 1874: Page 6

  • Back to The Freemason, Sept. 5, 1874
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article RESIGNATION OF THE GRAND MASTER. Page 1 of 1
    Article THE SECRECY OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 2
    Article THE SECRECY OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 2
    Article THE SECRECY OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ad00604

Seci . 'i : d Kdition , Now Ready , j / 6 . A MASONIC MUSICAL SERVICE In the key of C . for A ., T ., T ., B . Opening and Closing Odes . Craft Ceremonies . Royal Arch Ceremony . Consecration Ceremony . Grace before and after Meat . COMPOSED BV DR . J . C . BAKER , NO . 241 . LONDON . —Geo . Kenning , 198 , Fleet-street ; and 1 , 2 , and 3 , Little Britain . „ R . Spencer , 26 , Great Queen-street . LIVERPOOL . —Geo . Kenning , 2 , Mor . ument-place . MANCHESTER . —E . Henry & Co ., 59 , Deansgate . DUBLIN . —C . Hedgelong , 26 , Graf ton-street . GLASGOW . —Geo . Kenning , 145 , Argyle-street .

Ad00605

To W . M . 'S AND SECRETARIES . Bro . KNIGHT SMITH ( 1441 ) , PROFESSOR OF MUSIC , Begs to inform the Craft that he is prepared to assist the Ritual with Music for Consecration , Installation , or 1 st , 2 nd , and 3 rd degrees . For terms , address 6 , London-villas , Devonport-road , Shepherd's Bush , W .

Ad00606

MADAME TUSSAUD'S EXHIBITION , BAKER STREET . Now added , PORTRAIT MODELS of the CZAR OF RUSSIA , SIR GARNET WOLSELEY , the Three Judges in the Tichborne Trial , Cockburn , Mellor , and Lush ; the Shah of Persia , Marshal MacMahon , M . Thiers , and the late Mr . Charles Dickens . Admission is . Children under ten , 6 d . Extra Rooms , fid . Open from ten a . m . to ten p . m .

Ar00607

TheFreemason,SATURDAY , SEPTEMBER j , 1874 .

Resignation Of The Grand Master.

RESIGNATION OF THE GRAND MASTER .

Our many readers will share in the regret and astonishment with which Grand Lodge heard , on Wednesday evening , the announcement of the Marquess of Ripon ' s resignation of the Grand

Mastership . As our distinguished brother gives no other reason , in his letter to the Grand Secretary ; but that he " finds himself unable any longer to discharge the duties ot Grand Master , "

we can only record the event , adding to it the expression of our heartfelt sorrow at such a separation from our noble and excellent brother . No Grand Mastership has ever opened with

fairer promise of permanent well-being and successful administration , and we deeply deplore the loss of so able , and so high-minded a Master . We shall recur to the subject in our next . It

will be seen by the proceedings of the Grand Lodge ,, that , in accordance with the Book of Constitution , our royal brother the Prince of

Wales is to be requested , by a deputation of three of our most distinguished brothers , to act as Grand Master until the annual election .

The Secrecy Of Freemasonry.

THE SECRECY OF FREEMASONRY .

We said in a previous article , that , we should recur to the question of the " secrecy" of Freemasonry , as one of the great objections made against Freemasonry is , that it is a secret society .

We therefore think it well to return to the subject to-day , and would call the attention of our readers , to a very able letter in another part of

our impression , bearing on the same subject . That Freemasonry is and professes to be a secret society , isa fact which "nobody can deny . "

The Secrecy Of Freemasonry.

But " non constat , " that because we are a secret society , that therefore we are a bad society , or hurtful institution , or objectionable organ ization . In order to prove so sweeping an

assertionour opponents , who object to secrecy so much , and are fond of saying , " if there was any real good in Freemasonry it would not be kept secret , " must go on * to prove , that , all secrecy , and

all secret societies , " ipso facto , " by the very nature of the case , are utterly wrong—wrong that is alike objectively and subjectively , in the abstract and in the concrete . In the mouth of

our Roman Catholic opponents , such arguments come with a very bad grace indeed . What are we to say , of their own secret society the " Jesuit Order" ? On their own principles

it is radically bad , utterly wrong and indefensible . Those of us who have given any attention to the history of the Jesuits , know well that " secrecy" is the foundation on which their

whole organization depends . I leave out ofthe question the "Secreta Monita" to-day , but plenty of evidence is forthcoming , to prove that they have a secret proposition , a secret probation , a

secret reception , a secret obligation , and secret " counsels . " So much so is this the fact , that , as the Jesuits are also divided into classes or degrees , some writers have foolishly

endeavoured to prove them to be a Masonic Order . And what are we to say of the secrets of the confessional ? What of the secret conclave ? Many other points of secrecy might be brought

forward , in the Romish system , which as it seems to us , render the position of our Roman Catholic assailants untenable , as , on their own arguments , secret societies of all kind are ipso

facto bad ! If our Roman Catholic opponents reply , we fall back on the decision of Roman councils , and of Papal rescripts , by which secret societies are condemned , our answer is * . granted ,

that you have a right to forbid your own laity joining secret societies , you can have no right to dictate to us . But before you even do so with your own " fideles , " before that you excom-

municate many of your most faithful sons , just i remember the good old adage , '' people who live i in glass houses , should not throw stones , " and t be consistent as regards all secret societies , which (

you denounce as wrong , qua secret societies . Assailants like Mr . Kerr , who base their ob- i jections against Freemasonry as a secret society , 1 must , we presume alike take up the position , i

that all secret societies are bad in themselves ! . Mr . Kerr quotes a scripture text to prove his i point , but we need hardly add , that , it is one of those violent and unworthy adaptations , which <

reflect little credit either on the moral honesty of £ the writer , or on the skill and truth of his i " exegesis . " "Come thou not into their s secret , " was never meant to be applied to <

the Masonic body . Thus then , we have to meet two classes of objections to secrecy as a charac- i teristic of an Order like ours , and we will take c them " seriatim . " The Roman Catholic , for- •* .

getful of the beam in his own eye , sees only the ^ mote that is in a Freemason ' s eye , and ignoring c the fact that secrecy is not unknown to his own e

reli gious body , condemns us on that very t ground ! But in order to do so , as between man 1 and man , and on moral grounds , he has in the j first place to demonstrate clearly , that all secrecy a

The Secrecy Of Freemasonry.

is objectionable , and all secret societies irredeemably bad . But unfortunatel y for him , not only can he not safely lay down such a premise , but the whole history of the Christian Reli gion

is against him , even on this very point . What was the Disci plina Arcani ? It is an undoubted fact , that , in the early history of Christianity , its religious teaching , and its most sacred rites

were sedulously guarded from the intrusion and presence of the profane , and practised and taught in secret ! If the mere fact of " secrecy" then be objectionable , the objection must forcibly apply

to the earliest developments of Christianity itself , but the truth is , such a proposition cannot be accepted as an " universal , " and the whole question of " secrecy" turns not upon secrecy

really at all , but upon the object for which secrecy is used and maintained . States have a right , and it is their bounden duty to object to , and " surveiller , " to use a French word , all secret

societies whose real aim and end they deem to be incompatible either with the liberty of the subject , or the safety of the public . States have often to interefere with secret political societies ,

which use the cloak of secrecy , either to hatch treasonable movements , or to promulgate seditious principles , in the body politic . And no sane person , above all no true Freemason , -

ever does or can approve of such societies , or aid them , or abet them , or take part in their proceedings , or be affiliated to them , because they are in themselves opposed to the true teaching of

the moral duty of all patriotic citizens , and because they are condemned by the laws of the country to which we belong , or where we for the moment reside . In their case secrecy

is bad , most bad , " per se , " and all such secret political associations , which seek to promote aims , or inculcate teaching , adverse to the peace and order and safety of society , or which are

i < condemned , either ' nominatim , ' or by the common law of the land , are to be shunned and to be disavowed by all honest men , and loyal citizens wherever they may be . But

Freemasonry , though a secret society , is not obnoxious , in England , to the laws of the State , on the contrary , is expressly excepted by the legislature from enactments bearing on secret societies . Our

! secrecy is therefore recognised by the law , and is admitted , by this very recognition , to be alike harmless and legal . What , then , can any one really say against Freemasonry on this score ?

: It is recognised by the State , is is excepted by name from the operation of an act directed against secret political societies , its non-political character is fully admitted and it is notorious

as before the world , that whatever its secrecy may cover , whatever its secret tenets may be , it is a society whose object and end are not hurtful , but

bene-1 ficial to society and to mankind . And then , as we know , in England , our Order is made up of of the highest and best in our land , in association with all classes of our fellow-countrymen .

When we remember that men of the most exalted position , the noblest birth , the best education , the most true moral worth , are happy

to avow themselves io be Freemasons , how idle , how worse than idle , how utterly childish is the objection , alike of our unreasoning Roman Catholic and Presby terian assailants that we are a secret

“The Freemason: 1874-09-05, Page 6” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 7 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_05091874/page/6/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Province of Hampshire and the Isle of Wight. Article 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 3
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 3
Scotland. Article 4
Knights Templar. Article 4
UNITED GRAND LODGE. Article 4
EARLY GRAND ENCAMPMENT, SCOTLAND. Article 5
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Article 5
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Article 6
RESIGNATION OF THE GRAND MASTER. Article 6
THE SECRECY OF FREEMASONRY. Article 6
THE PLYMOUTH QUESTION. Article 7
Original Correspondence. Article 7
COSMOPOLITAN MASONIC CALENDAR. Article 9
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 9
Untitled Article 9
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

14 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

16 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

5 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

8 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

6 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

18 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

25 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ad00604

Seci . 'i : d Kdition , Now Ready , j / 6 . A MASONIC MUSICAL SERVICE In the key of C . for A ., T ., T ., B . Opening and Closing Odes . Craft Ceremonies . Royal Arch Ceremony . Consecration Ceremony . Grace before and after Meat . COMPOSED BV DR . J . C . BAKER , NO . 241 . LONDON . —Geo . Kenning , 198 , Fleet-street ; and 1 , 2 , and 3 , Little Britain . „ R . Spencer , 26 , Great Queen-street . LIVERPOOL . —Geo . Kenning , 2 , Mor . ument-place . MANCHESTER . —E . Henry & Co ., 59 , Deansgate . DUBLIN . —C . Hedgelong , 26 , Graf ton-street . GLASGOW . —Geo . Kenning , 145 , Argyle-street .

Ad00605

To W . M . 'S AND SECRETARIES . Bro . KNIGHT SMITH ( 1441 ) , PROFESSOR OF MUSIC , Begs to inform the Craft that he is prepared to assist the Ritual with Music for Consecration , Installation , or 1 st , 2 nd , and 3 rd degrees . For terms , address 6 , London-villas , Devonport-road , Shepherd's Bush , W .

Ad00606

MADAME TUSSAUD'S EXHIBITION , BAKER STREET . Now added , PORTRAIT MODELS of the CZAR OF RUSSIA , SIR GARNET WOLSELEY , the Three Judges in the Tichborne Trial , Cockburn , Mellor , and Lush ; the Shah of Persia , Marshal MacMahon , M . Thiers , and the late Mr . Charles Dickens . Admission is . Children under ten , 6 d . Extra Rooms , fid . Open from ten a . m . to ten p . m .

Ar00607

TheFreemason,SATURDAY , SEPTEMBER j , 1874 .

Resignation Of The Grand Master.

RESIGNATION OF THE GRAND MASTER .

Our many readers will share in the regret and astonishment with which Grand Lodge heard , on Wednesday evening , the announcement of the Marquess of Ripon ' s resignation of the Grand

Mastership . As our distinguished brother gives no other reason , in his letter to the Grand Secretary ; but that he " finds himself unable any longer to discharge the duties ot Grand Master , "

we can only record the event , adding to it the expression of our heartfelt sorrow at such a separation from our noble and excellent brother . No Grand Mastership has ever opened with

fairer promise of permanent well-being and successful administration , and we deeply deplore the loss of so able , and so high-minded a Master . We shall recur to the subject in our next . It

will be seen by the proceedings of the Grand Lodge ,, that , in accordance with the Book of Constitution , our royal brother the Prince of

Wales is to be requested , by a deputation of three of our most distinguished brothers , to act as Grand Master until the annual election .

The Secrecy Of Freemasonry.

THE SECRECY OF FREEMASONRY .

We said in a previous article , that , we should recur to the question of the " secrecy" of Freemasonry , as one of the great objections made against Freemasonry is , that it is a secret society .

We therefore think it well to return to the subject to-day , and would call the attention of our readers , to a very able letter in another part of

our impression , bearing on the same subject . That Freemasonry is and professes to be a secret society , isa fact which "nobody can deny . "

The Secrecy Of Freemasonry.

But " non constat , " that because we are a secret society , that therefore we are a bad society , or hurtful institution , or objectionable organ ization . In order to prove so sweeping an

assertionour opponents , who object to secrecy so much , and are fond of saying , " if there was any real good in Freemasonry it would not be kept secret , " must go on * to prove , that , all secrecy , and

all secret societies , " ipso facto , " by the very nature of the case , are utterly wrong—wrong that is alike objectively and subjectively , in the abstract and in the concrete . In the mouth of

our Roman Catholic opponents , such arguments come with a very bad grace indeed . What are we to say , of their own secret society the " Jesuit Order" ? On their own principles

it is radically bad , utterly wrong and indefensible . Those of us who have given any attention to the history of the Jesuits , know well that " secrecy" is the foundation on which their

whole organization depends . I leave out ofthe question the "Secreta Monita" to-day , but plenty of evidence is forthcoming , to prove that they have a secret proposition , a secret probation , a

secret reception , a secret obligation , and secret " counsels . " So much so is this the fact , that , as the Jesuits are also divided into classes or degrees , some writers have foolishly

endeavoured to prove them to be a Masonic Order . And what are we to say of the secrets of the confessional ? What of the secret conclave ? Many other points of secrecy might be brought

forward , in the Romish system , which as it seems to us , render the position of our Roman Catholic assailants untenable , as , on their own arguments , secret societies of all kind are ipso

facto bad ! If our Roman Catholic opponents reply , we fall back on the decision of Roman councils , and of Papal rescripts , by which secret societies are condemned , our answer is * . granted ,

that you have a right to forbid your own laity joining secret societies , you can have no right to dictate to us . But before you even do so with your own " fideles , " before that you excom-

municate many of your most faithful sons , just i remember the good old adage , '' people who live i in glass houses , should not throw stones , " and t be consistent as regards all secret societies , which (

you denounce as wrong , qua secret societies . Assailants like Mr . Kerr , who base their ob- i jections against Freemasonry as a secret society , 1 must , we presume alike take up the position , i

that all secret societies are bad in themselves ! . Mr . Kerr quotes a scripture text to prove his i point , but we need hardly add , that , it is one of those violent and unworthy adaptations , which <

reflect little credit either on the moral honesty of £ the writer , or on the skill and truth of his i " exegesis . " "Come thou not into their s secret , " was never meant to be applied to <

the Masonic body . Thus then , we have to meet two classes of objections to secrecy as a charac- i teristic of an Order like ours , and we will take c them " seriatim . " The Roman Catholic , for- •* .

getful of the beam in his own eye , sees only the ^ mote that is in a Freemason ' s eye , and ignoring c the fact that secrecy is not unknown to his own e

reli gious body , condemns us on that very t ground ! But in order to do so , as between man 1 and man , and on moral grounds , he has in the j first place to demonstrate clearly , that all secrecy a

The Secrecy Of Freemasonry.

is objectionable , and all secret societies irredeemably bad . But unfortunatel y for him , not only can he not safely lay down such a premise , but the whole history of the Christian Reli gion

is against him , even on this very point . What was the Disci plina Arcani ? It is an undoubted fact , that , in the early history of Christianity , its religious teaching , and its most sacred rites

were sedulously guarded from the intrusion and presence of the profane , and practised and taught in secret ! If the mere fact of " secrecy" then be objectionable , the objection must forcibly apply

to the earliest developments of Christianity itself , but the truth is , such a proposition cannot be accepted as an " universal , " and the whole question of " secrecy" turns not upon secrecy

really at all , but upon the object for which secrecy is used and maintained . States have a right , and it is their bounden duty to object to , and " surveiller , " to use a French word , all secret

societies whose real aim and end they deem to be incompatible either with the liberty of the subject , or the safety of the public . States have often to interefere with secret political societies ,

which use the cloak of secrecy , either to hatch treasonable movements , or to promulgate seditious principles , in the body politic . And no sane person , above all no true Freemason , -

ever does or can approve of such societies , or aid them , or abet them , or take part in their proceedings , or be affiliated to them , because they are in themselves opposed to the true teaching of

the moral duty of all patriotic citizens , and because they are condemned by the laws of the country to which we belong , or where we for the moment reside . In their case secrecy

is bad , most bad , " per se , " and all such secret political associations , which seek to promote aims , or inculcate teaching , adverse to the peace and order and safety of society , or which are

i < condemned , either ' nominatim , ' or by the common law of the land , are to be shunned and to be disavowed by all honest men , and loyal citizens wherever they may be . But

Freemasonry , though a secret society , is not obnoxious , in England , to the laws of the State , on the contrary , is expressly excepted by the legislature from enactments bearing on secret societies . Our

! secrecy is therefore recognised by the law , and is admitted , by this very recognition , to be alike harmless and legal . What , then , can any one really say against Freemasonry on this score ?

: It is recognised by the State , is is excepted by name from the operation of an act directed against secret political societies , its non-political character is fully admitted and it is notorious

as before the world , that whatever its secrecy may cover , whatever its secret tenets may be , it is a society whose object and end are not hurtful , but

bene-1 ficial to society and to mankind . And then , as we know , in England , our Order is made up of of the highest and best in our land , in association with all classes of our fellow-countrymen .

When we remember that men of the most exalted position , the noblest birth , the best education , the most true moral worth , are happy

to avow themselves io be Freemasons , how idle , how worse than idle , how utterly childish is the objection , alike of our unreasoning Roman Catholic and Presby terian assailants that we are a secret

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 5
  • You're on page6
  • 7
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy