Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • March 7, 1891
  • Page 2
Current:

The Freemason, March 7, 1891: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemason, March 7, 1891
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE LODGES AT ROME, ITALY, IN 1735-37. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND . Page 1 of 3 →
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Lodges At Rome, Italy, In 1735-37.

through loops made of violin string—evidently the work of an amateur . It was to guard against surprise , no doubt , that such an arrangement of its minute book was adopted by the Roman lodge , for in the event of a domiciliary visit of the papal authorities , the records could easily be removed or destroyed , and the parchment cover left in its entirety .

There are 15 separate entries in the book . The first is without date , and contains the signature of the Master , two Wardens , and 13 members , among whom appear the names of some noted Jacobites : John Stewart , brother to the Earl of Traquair , Dr . James Irvin , Col . William Hay , and William Howard , Master . The Jacobite Duchess of ; Gordon was a Howard .

The next entry is in Latin , and embraces the " original statutes brought down for the Freemasons of the Roman lodge , " and an English translation of the same . These statutes give evidence of their Scottish origin in respect of the prominence they give to the custom of supping in open lodge , and the

presentation of gloves or livery to the brotherhood by initiates on their admission . Foreigners were not admissible except they could speak in English . Absentees were sharply looked after . The following note is appended to the minute of September 16 , 1735

" That it being contrary to the laws of Masonry for a member to absent himself after due warning , it has been thought proper by the Grand Master and the lodge to fine Sir Mar . Constable , M . Fitzmorise , and M . Le Wick in their share of the supper . "

In the first of these minutes is recorded the admission of " George Seton Winton " at a meeting held in Joseppie ' s , in the Corso , August 16 , 1735 . This was the attainted Earl of Winton , who , escaping from the Tower of London while under sentence of death for his share in the Rebellion of 1715 , sought refuge in

the Roman capital , where he resided till his death in 1749 . The minute book under notice was taken possession of by Lord Winton when in August , 1737 , the lodge was suppressed by Pope Clement XII ., by whose order the Tyler , a servant of Dr . Irvin , was sent , as a terror to others , prisoner to the Inquisition , but was soon released .

Meetings were held in " Joseppie ' s on September 26 and 21 and December 27 , 1735 , and on January 4 and February 28 , 173 6 , at which , among others , were admitted one or two French , Neapolitan , and Polish nobles , holding high military rank under their respective sovereigns .

The place of meeting was subsequently changed to " The Three Kings , " Strada Paolina , where , in March , 173 6 , Lord Winton was received as a " Master Mason , " prior to his election as " Great Master" in April of the same year . The admission of Dr . Alexander Cunninghame , afterwards

Sir Alexander Dick of Prestonheld , and Allan Ramsay , junior , son of the celebrated author of the "Gentle Shepherd" and other poetical works , took place on February 2 , 1737 , and on the 23 rd of the same month the " Marquis de Vasse , Brigadier of the French Army and Collonell of Dragoons , " was initiated .

Another communication was held in May , 1737 , and at the last meeting of the lodge , which was held on August 20 th of that year , was admitted "John Murray , " Esqr ., whose signature to the minute identifies him as the Laird of Broughton ,, the devoted friend and Secretary of " Prince Charlie , " but whose subsequent disgrace is known to all students of Scottish history .

We have selected the minute of Murray ' s admission as the subject of our illustration . Its appearance here dispels the illusion under which successive historians of Canongate Kilwinning have claimed for that distinguished lodge the honour ot initiating Murray into Freemasonry . In December , 1738 . he

was " admitted a member " thereof by affiliation . This autograph , along with that of the Jacobite Earl of Kilmarnock , then Grand Master , is appended to the minute of the Grand Visitation to the Canongate Lodge in December , 1742 , and in November of the following year , being present in Grand Lodge , Murray was appointed Junior Grand Warden .

In the oldest existing minute book of Canongate Kilwinning mention is made of visiting brethren from Rome , and on the card of his application Sir Alexander Dick is designated as of the Roman lodge . After passing through the hands of several Jacobite members

of theCraft , the minute book of the Roman lodge was , in 1799 , put into the hands of Sir James Stirling , Baronet , Lord Provost of Edinburgh and Grand Master Mason of Scotland , to be by his lordship deposited in the archives of Grand Lodge , where it has since remained .

The genuineness of this Masonic relic was formally attested by " Mr . Andrew Lumisden , " a gentleman who took an active part in the Rebellion of 1 745 , and afterwards joining the royal exile at Rome , became his private secretary . After 40 years'

residence on the Continent , Bro . Lumisden returned to his native country , and died at Edinburgh December 26 th , 1801 . He was a member of "the Lodge of Edinburgh from Dumfermling , " recorded as such in 1 742 . —Keystone .

United Grand Lodge Of England .

UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND .

The Quarterly Communication of United Grand Lodge was held on Wednes day evening at Freemasons' Hall , when more than 500 brethren were present Bro . W . W . B . Beach , M . P ., Prov . Grand Master Hants and the Isle of Wi ght presided . Bro . Col . Sir Francis Burdett , Bart ., Prov . Grand Master of Middlesex acted as Deputy Grand Master , and Bro . Thomas Halsey , M . P ., Prov . Grand Ma . ster of Herts , as Past Grand Master . Bro . Sir Gabriel Goldney occupied the Senior Grand Warden ' s chair , and Bro . Major-General Somerset J . Calthorpetook the chair of Junior Grand Warden .

After Grand Lodge had been opened , the GRAND SECRETARY read the minutes of the Quarterly Communication of 3 rd December , 1890 , which were put and confirmed . The GRAND SECRETARY then said he had now to report to Grand Lod ge that he duly notified to H . R . H . the Duke of Connaught the fact of his appointment as Past Grand Master of Grand Lodge , and that the Grand Lodge had voted to his Royal Highness the presentation of the insignia of his office ( which he had read in

the minutes ) . The Duke of Connaught was invested by the M . W . G . M . on the occa . sion of the installation of the Duke of Clarence and Avondale at Reading as Provincial Grand Master of Berks . The Duke of Connaught had the pleasure of expressing through him ( the Grand Secretary ) his warm appreciation of the compliment paid to him by Grand Lodge , and he desired to convey to the Grand Master and the Grand Lodge the assurance that he would wear the insignia of his office with much gratification and pride . ( Applause . )

The GRAND SECRETARY next said he had to report for the information of Grand Lodge that the Grand Steward who was nominated last year for the Royal Somer . set House and Inverness Lodge , No . 4 , Bro . Herbert de Stern having resigned his lodge and become ineligible to act , the lodge had nominated in his place Bro . the Rev . A . W . Oxford , W . M ., and that that nomination had been ratified and approved by the M . W . G . M .

Bro . F . A . PHILBRICK , Q . C , Grand Registrar , said that as a communication had been made to Grand Lodge by the Grand Secretary with regard to the Duke of Connaught , he begged to move that the reply of his Royal Highness be entered upon the minutes of Grand Lodge . He thought it was due to Grand Lodge that his Royal Highness ' s gracious reply in acceptance should appear on Grand Lodge records . The motion was seconded , and carried .

Bro . BEACH then read the following communication from the Most Worshi pful Grand Master :

The Most Worshipful Grand Master regrets to have to inform Grand Lodge that in the month of August last he received a report from the District Grand Lodge of Wellington , New Zealand , that Brother Sir Robert Stout , K . C . M . G ., Past Asst . Grand Director of Ceremonies , and Deputy District Grand Master of Otago and Southland , had obtained a warrant from the Grand Orient of France to establish a lodge under it in New Zealand , and had , under that authority , recently opened a lodge in the town of Wellington in that Colony , of which lodge he is the Master .

On receipt of this information , the Grand Master directed the Grand Secretary to address Brother Sir Robert Stout on the subject , and to call on him for an explanation of the grounds on which he felt himself justified in thus taking part in an invasion of British territory by a foreign Masonic body , and especially by one , many of whose members had been declared by a solemn resolution of the Grand Lodge of England on the 6 th March , 1878 , not to be true and genuine brethren .

A reply has now been received from Brother Sir Robert Stout on the subject , in which he admits the facts alleged , and seeks to justify his action . Under these circumstances , the Grand Master , with much regret , feels that he has no alternative but to make a complaint of the conductof Brother Sir Robert Stout , and to submit the matter , with the correspondence relating thereto , to Grand

Lodge for its consideration and decision . The GRAND SECRETARY thereon read the correspondence which had taken place on the subject . Bro . PHILBRICK , in laying the matter before Grand Lodge , said the Grand Master regretted to have to make a communication to Grand Lodge , and had asked the Grand Lodge to take into consideration the complaint which he made

to it of the conduct of one of the officers of Grand Lodge , and that they should consider and decide upon the circumstances of the case . After the correspondence which had just been read , he thought the facts stood pretty clearly before them . The colony of New Zealand was a colony of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland . Its governor was appointed by the Sovereign of this country , a "" writs went in the name of her Most Gracious Majesty the Queen , and the ultimate

appeal was here to her Majesty in Council . He could not conceive , therefore , apart from Masonic question , a case of a land which was more a colony of this Kingdom . With regard to the Masonic jurisdictions that were there , fiv ' English District Grand Lodges , the District Grand Masters of which was appoint

by the M . W . G . M ., the Deputy of one of them being Sir Robert Stout himself . There were also a District Grand Lodge holding under the Grand Lodge ° Scotland , and one under the Grand Lodge of Ireland , respectively , besides whicfi , as Sir R . Stout mentioned , there was a fourth body which , at a w

recent Quarterly Communication , Grand Lodge declined to recognise being the Grand Lodge of New Zealand . Under those circumstances < three jurisdictions , England , Scotland , and Ireland , being lawful within colony , each having Masons all of whom held allegiance to a Grand Lo g situate within the jurisdiction of the United Kingdom , and there having been

invasion of that colony by any other actual or pretended foreign Masonic jurisd tion whatever , he thought he was not going beyond what the good sense every Mason present would confirm when he said that they had here a clear cas as clear a case as cou'd be—of a territorial Masonic jurisdiction of the ^ . Kingdom . He ventured to say that that which had been alleged by

Bro-Robert Stout , in his long and elaborate defence in answer to the Grand Secre ;> c frail " who challenged him on the matter , would hardly carry the opinion or u Lodge with it . With regard to Bro . Sir Robert Stout himself , his was an extremely clear one , as he himself admitted . In a c 0 such as he ( Bro . Philbrick ) had described , with Masonic W

“The Freemason: 1891-03-07, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 28 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_07031891/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
UNITED GRAND LODGE. Article 1
A NEW MASONIC WORK. Article 1
THE LODGES AT ROME, ITALY, IN 1735-37. Article 1
UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND . Article 2
GRAND MARK LODGE. Article 4
SUPREME GRAND CHAPTER OF SCOTLAND. Article 4
THE COLUMBIA LODGE, No. 2397. Article 5
PHILANTHROPIC LODGE, No. 304.— MEMORIAL SERVICE. Article 5
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
To Correspondents. Article 6
Untitled Article 7
Masonic Notes. Article 7
Correspondence. Article 7
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 8
PROVINCIAL MEETINGS. Article 8
Royal Arch. Article 10
Mark Masonry. Article 11
Ancient and Accepted Rite. Article 11
Red Cross of Rome and Constantine. Article 11
Royal Ark Mariners. Article 11
Lodges and Chapters of Instruction. Article 12
Cryptic Masonry. Article 12
ANNUAL FESTIVAL OF THE EMULATION LODGE OF IMPROVEMENT. Article 12
MASONIC CALENDARS , 1891. Article 13
ROYAL MASONIC BENEVOLENT INSTITUTION. Article 14
THE GOLD AND SILVER WYRE DRAWERS' COMPANY. Article 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
MASONIC MEETINGS (Metropolitan) March Article 14
MASONIC MEETINGS (Provincial) Article 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
MASONIC AND GENERAL TIDINGS Article 16
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

23 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

4 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

4 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

7 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

7 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

6 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Lodges At Rome, Italy, In 1735-37.

through loops made of violin string—evidently the work of an amateur . It was to guard against surprise , no doubt , that such an arrangement of its minute book was adopted by the Roman lodge , for in the event of a domiciliary visit of the papal authorities , the records could easily be removed or destroyed , and the parchment cover left in its entirety .

There are 15 separate entries in the book . The first is without date , and contains the signature of the Master , two Wardens , and 13 members , among whom appear the names of some noted Jacobites : John Stewart , brother to the Earl of Traquair , Dr . James Irvin , Col . William Hay , and William Howard , Master . The Jacobite Duchess of ; Gordon was a Howard .

The next entry is in Latin , and embraces the " original statutes brought down for the Freemasons of the Roman lodge , " and an English translation of the same . These statutes give evidence of their Scottish origin in respect of the prominence they give to the custom of supping in open lodge , and the

presentation of gloves or livery to the brotherhood by initiates on their admission . Foreigners were not admissible except they could speak in English . Absentees were sharply looked after . The following note is appended to the minute of September 16 , 1735

" That it being contrary to the laws of Masonry for a member to absent himself after due warning , it has been thought proper by the Grand Master and the lodge to fine Sir Mar . Constable , M . Fitzmorise , and M . Le Wick in their share of the supper . "

In the first of these minutes is recorded the admission of " George Seton Winton " at a meeting held in Joseppie ' s , in the Corso , August 16 , 1735 . This was the attainted Earl of Winton , who , escaping from the Tower of London while under sentence of death for his share in the Rebellion of 1715 , sought refuge in

the Roman capital , where he resided till his death in 1749 . The minute book under notice was taken possession of by Lord Winton when in August , 1737 , the lodge was suppressed by Pope Clement XII ., by whose order the Tyler , a servant of Dr . Irvin , was sent , as a terror to others , prisoner to the Inquisition , but was soon released .

Meetings were held in " Joseppie ' s on September 26 and 21 and December 27 , 1735 , and on January 4 and February 28 , 173 6 , at which , among others , were admitted one or two French , Neapolitan , and Polish nobles , holding high military rank under their respective sovereigns .

The place of meeting was subsequently changed to " The Three Kings , " Strada Paolina , where , in March , 173 6 , Lord Winton was received as a " Master Mason , " prior to his election as " Great Master" in April of the same year . The admission of Dr . Alexander Cunninghame , afterwards

Sir Alexander Dick of Prestonheld , and Allan Ramsay , junior , son of the celebrated author of the "Gentle Shepherd" and other poetical works , took place on February 2 , 1737 , and on the 23 rd of the same month the " Marquis de Vasse , Brigadier of the French Army and Collonell of Dragoons , " was initiated .

Another communication was held in May , 1737 , and at the last meeting of the lodge , which was held on August 20 th of that year , was admitted "John Murray , " Esqr ., whose signature to the minute identifies him as the Laird of Broughton ,, the devoted friend and Secretary of " Prince Charlie , " but whose subsequent disgrace is known to all students of Scottish history .

We have selected the minute of Murray ' s admission as the subject of our illustration . Its appearance here dispels the illusion under which successive historians of Canongate Kilwinning have claimed for that distinguished lodge the honour ot initiating Murray into Freemasonry . In December , 1738 . he

was " admitted a member " thereof by affiliation . This autograph , along with that of the Jacobite Earl of Kilmarnock , then Grand Master , is appended to the minute of the Grand Visitation to the Canongate Lodge in December , 1742 , and in November of the following year , being present in Grand Lodge , Murray was appointed Junior Grand Warden .

In the oldest existing minute book of Canongate Kilwinning mention is made of visiting brethren from Rome , and on the card of his application Sir Alexander Dick is designated as of the Roman lodge . After passing through the hands of several Jacobite members

of theCraft , the minute book of the Roman lodge was , in 1799 , put into the hands of Sir James Stirling , Baronet , Lord Provost of Edinburgh and Grand Master Mason of Scotland , to be by his lordship deposited in the archives of Grand Lodge , where it has since remained .

The genuineness of this Masonic relic was formally attested by " Mr . Andrew Lumisden , " a gentleman who took an active part in the Rebellion of 1 745 , and afterwards joining the royal exile at Rome , became his private secretary . After 40 years'

residence on the Continent , Bro . Lumisden returned to his native country , and died at Edinburgh December 26 th , 1801 . He was a member of "the Lodge of Edinburgh from Dumfermling , " recorded as such in 1 742 . —Keystone .

United Grand Lodge Of England .

UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND .

The Quarterly Communication of United Grand Lodge was held on Wednes day evening at Freemasons' Hall , when more than 500 brethren were present Bro . W . W . B . Beach , M . P ., Prov . Grand Master Hants and the Isle of Wi ght presided . Bro . Col . Sir Francis Burdett , Bart ., Prov . Grand Master of Middlesex acted as Deputy Grand Master , and Bro . Thomas Halsey , M . P ., Prov . Grand Ma . ster of Herts , as Past Grand Master . Bro . Sir Gabriel Goldney occupied the Senior Grand Warden ' s chair , and Bro . Major-General Somerset J . Calthorpetook the chair of Junior Grand Warden .

After Grand Lodge had been opened , the GRAND SECRETARY read the minutes of the Quarterly Communication of 3 rd December , 1890 , which were put and confirmed . The GRAND SECRETARY then said he had now to report to Grand Lod ge that he duly notified to H . R . H . the Duke of Connaught the fact of his appointment as Past Grand Master of Grand Lodge , and that the Grand Lodge had voted to his Royal Highness the presentation of the insignia of his office ( which he had read in

the minutes ) . The Duke of Connaught was invested by the M . W . G . M . on the occa . sion of the installation of the Duke of Clarence and Avondale at Reading as Provincial Grand Master of Berks . The Duke of Connaught had the pleasure of expressing through him ( the Grand Secretary ) his warm appreciation of the compliment paid to him by Grand Lodge , and he desired to convey to the Grand Master and the Grand Lodge the assurance that he would wear the insignia of his office with much gratification and pride . ( Applause . )

The GRAND SECRETARY next said he had to report for the information of Grand Lodge that the Grand Steward who was nominated last year for the Royal Somer . set House and Inverness Lodge , No . 4 , Bro . Herbert de Stern having resigned his lodge and become ineligible to act , the lodge had nominated in his place Bro . the Rev . A . W . Oxford , W . M ., and that that nomination had been ratified and approved by the M . W . G . M .

Bro . F . A . PHILBRICK , Q . C , Grand Registrar , said that as a communication had been made to Grand Lodge by the Grand Secretary with regard to the Duke of Connaught , he begged to move that the reply of his Royal Highness be entered upon the minutes of Grand Lodge . He thought it was due to Grand Lodge that his Royal Highness ' s gracious reply in acceptance should appear on Grand Lodge records . The motion was seconded , and carried .

Bro . BEACH then read the following communication from the Most Worshi pful Grand Master :

The Most Worshipful Grand Master regrets to have to inform Grand Lodge that in the month of August last he received a report from the District Grand Lodge of Wellington , New Zealand , that Brother Sir Robert Stout , K . C . M . G ., Past Asst . Grand Director of Ceremonies , and Deputy District Grand Master of Otago and Southland , had obtained a warrant from the Grand Orient of France to establish a lodge under it in New Zealand , and had , under that authority , recently opened a lodge in the town of Wellington in that Colony , of which lodge he is the Master .

On receipt of this information , the Grand Master directed the Grand Secretary to address Brother Sir Robert Stout on the subject , and to call on him for an explanation of the grounds on which he felt himself justified in thus taking part in an invasion of British territory by a foreign Masonic body , and especially by one , many of whose members had been declared by a solemn resolution of the Grand Lodge of England on the 6 th March , 1878 , not to be true and genuine brethren .

A reply has now been received from Brother Sir Robert Stout on the subject , in which he admits the facts alleged , and seeks to justify his action . Under these circumstances , the Grand Master , with much regret , feels that he has no alternative but to make a complaint of the conductof Brother Sir Robert Stout , and to submit the matter , with the correspondence relating thereto , to Grand

Lodge for its consideration and decision . The GRAND SECRETARY thereon read the correspondence which had taken place on the subject . Bro . PHILBRICK , in laying the matter before Grand Lodge , said the Grand Master regretted to have to make a communication to Grand Lodge , and had asked the Grand Lodge to take into consideration the complaint which he made

to it of the conduct of one of the officers of Grand Lodge , and that they should consider and decide upon the circumstances of the case . After the correspondence which had just been read , he thought the facts stood pretty clearly before them . The colony of New Zealand was a colony of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland . Its governor was appointed by the Sovereign of this country , a "" writs went in the name of her Most Gracious Majesty the Queen , and the ultimate

appeal was here to her Majesty in Council . He could not conceive , therefore , apart from Masonic question , a case of a land which was more a colony of this Kingdom . With regard to the Masonic jurisdictions that were there , fiv ' English District Grand Lodges , the District Grand Masters of which was appoint

by the M . W . G . M ., the Deputy of one of them being Sir Robert Stout himself . There were also a District Grand Lodge holding under the Grand Lodge ° Scotland , and one under the Grand Lodge of Ireland , respectively , besides whicfi , as Sir R . Stout mentioned , there was a fourth body which , at a w

recent Quarterly Communication , Grand Lodge declined to recognise being the Grand Lodge of New Zealand . Under those circumstances < three jurisdictions , England , Scotland , and Ireland , being lawful within colony , each having Masons all of whom held allegiance to a Grand Lo g situate within the jurisdiction of the United Kingdom , and there having been

invasion of that colony by any other actual or pretended foreign Masonic jurisd tion whatever , he thought he was not going beyond what the good sense every Mason present would confirm when he said that they had here a clear cas as clear a case as cou'd be—of a territorial Masonic jurisdiction of the ^ . Kingdom . He ventured to say that that which had been alleged by

Bro-Robert Stout , in his long and elaborate defence in answer to the Grand Secre ;> c frail " who challenged him on the matter , would hardly carry the opinion or u Lodge with it . With regard to Bro . Sir Robert Stout himself , his was an extremely clear one , as he himself admitted . In a c 0 such as he ( Bro . Philbrick ) had described , with Masonic W

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy