Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Nov. 8, 1873
  • Page 6
  • Answers to Correspondents.
Current:

The Freemason, Nov. 8, 1873: Page 6

  • Back to The Freemason, Nov. 8, 1873
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Answers to Correspondents. Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article ANOTHER ROMAN CATHOLIC ATTACK ON FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 2
    Article ANOTHER ROMAN CATHOLIC ATTACK ON FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ar00600

NOTICE .

The Subscription lo THE FREEMASON is now io . v . per annum , post-free , payable tn advance . Vol . 1 ., bound in cloth ... ... •4 s . 6 d .

Vol . II ., ditto 7 s . 6 d . Vol . s III ., IV ., and V . ... each 15 s . od . Reading Cases to hold 52 numbers ... 2 S ' . 6 d . Ditto ditto 4 do . ... •is . 6 d .

United States of America * THE FREEMASON is delivered fiee in any part of the United States for 12 S . per annum , payable in advance . The Freemason is published on Saturday Mornings in time for tile early trains . The price of the Freemason is Twopence per weekj annual

subscription , ios . ( payable in advance . ) All communications , letters , & c , to be addressed to the' Editor , 108 , Fleet-street , E . C . The Editorwill pay careful attention to all MSS . entrusted to him , butcannot undertake to return them unlessaccoinpanied hy postage sramDs .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

LA RUCHE . —Declined . A VICTIM . —It will be better to let tbe matter rest as it is REMITTANCE RECEIVED . VV . HAHPEH , Nevada , U . S . A . —P . O . O . US . 3 d . EltiiATUM . —Page 709 of our last issue—Communicatior

regarding Masonic Literature—line 14 , for " exposes shame , " read " exposes shams . " The following stand over : — Reports of Grand Chapter ; thejMark Benevolent Association ; Lodges 1 31 , 1261 , 1 348 , 1421 ( Instruction ) .

Ad00605

THE HISTORY OF FREEMASONRY , FROM ITS ORIGIN TO THE PRESENT DAY . Drawn from the best sources and the most recent investigations . BY J . G . FINDEL , Second Edition , Revised , and Preface written by Bro . D . MURRAY LYON . One vol ., 800 pages 8 vc , with an Index . Cloth gilt . Price , ios . Od . ••This volume is the history of Masonry pur excellence Every inteiested person may regard it , therefore , as the present text-book on the subject . "—Manchester Guardian "The author seems to have fairly exhausted the subject . "—The Athenaeum . " Of its value to Freemasons , as a detailed history of their Brotherhood , it is not possible to speak too hi g hly . "Pul-lic Opinion . Bro . GEORGE KENNING , 19 S , ILEET STREET , LONDON , K . C .

Ad00607

THE MASONIC M A G A Z INE , A moiilh / y digesl if Freemasonry in all its Brunches .. NOW READY No . 5 , NOVEMBER . Price Sixpence , Post free Scvenpence ; Annual subscription , including postage : United Kingdom 7 s ., America 9 s . ( Payable in advance ) . Office , 198 , _ Fleet Street .

Ad00606

KI ' . ADY SHORTLY . Roan , Gilt Edges , Elastic Band , Price 2 s ., Post Free 2 , s . -j . il . THE COSMOPOLITAN MASONIC CALENDAR , DIARY , AND POCKET-BOOK , FOR 1874 , CONTAINING (\ 111 nriU ' inVi ' k " ' ! ' V > L , :, P ,, TS- Conclaves , Grand councils and ls-. l . 1 receptones with ine names ot Officers in England and Wales , Scotland Ireland , and abroad . May le had of all Hunksellers , Tylers , Janitor ,, Sentinels , Eijiierries , & c , Publishing Office , 198 , Fleet-street , E . C .

Ad00608

Second Edition , Now Ready , 1 / 6 . A MASONIC MUSICAL SERVICE . In tlie key of C . for A ., T ., T ., U . Opening and Closing Odes . Craft Ceremonies . Royal . Arch Ceremony . Consecration Ceiemony . Grace before and after Meat . COMPOSED 13 V DR . J . . BAKER , NO . 241 . LONDON . —Geo . Kenning , i , > 8 , Fleet-street ; and 2 , 3 , and 4 , Little Hi itain . *' „ R . Spencer , 20 , Great Queen-street . LIVEHPOOI .. —Geo . Kenning , 2 , Mor . ument-place . MANCHESTO .-I ,. Jlenry . V Co ., Deansgate . DUBLIN .-C . Hedgelong , 26 , Grafton-. treet GLASGOW . —Geo . Kenning , 145 , Argyle-street . liDisiiuitcii . —Geo . Kenning , 67 , Manov-. r-street .

Ar00602

NOTICE . All Communications , Advertisements , & c , intended for insertion in the Number of the following

Saturday , must reach the Office not later than 6 o ' clock on Wednesday evening .

Ar00609

TheFreemason SATURDAY , NOVEMBER 8 , 1873 .

Another Roman Catholic Attack On Freemasonry.

ANOTHER ROMAN CATHOLIC ATTACK ON FREEMASONRY .

We had occasion , some time back , to call attention to a professedly humourous and sarcastic attack , by an accredited Roman Catholic periodical on our Fraternity , and we succeeded ,

as we hoped , in showing how utterly meaningless and inane such an attack really was , and how little we were affected by so childish and so flippant an article .

To-day , however , we have to call attention to a somewhat more serious aggression , namely to the after-luncheon speech of Dr . Brown , a Roman Catholic bishop , in whose ecclesiastical

jurisdiction Chester , we believe , is . Dr . Brown is , we also understand , the titular Bishop of Shrewsbury , and having laid the foundation stone of a new Roman Catholic Church

in the good City of Chester , and having attended a luncheon and a numerous assembly of the faithful , he amused ^ himself , and we presume his hearers , by an onslaught on us poor

Freemasons . Why he should , on such a day , and after such a ceremony , have thought it needful to introduce the subject of Freemasonry at all , we cannot pretend to explain , or even to surmise .

Roman Catholic bishops alter all , are but men , and something had evidently gone wrong with his digestion , or the" menu . " Perhaps the '' Mayonnaise ii l'Homard" was not

properly mixed , or the fine sirloin the " piece dc resistance , " was too tough . The Doctor evidently wanted some of Bob Sawyer ' s " patent digestor , " for he

incontinently proceeded to attack Freemasonry " more Romaiioruni" in a peculiarly offensive way . As he is reported in the Chester Courant of October 22 nd , Dr . Brown ventured to couple

" Freemasons" and " Fenians" together , and to pronounce them equally under the ban of the Pope , and to be avoided by all good Roman Catholics .

Hi' -- isfnil words are these : — "The allerriance they owed to their Sovereign was a reli gious duty . No one could be admitted to the benefits of the holy tribunal of penance who was guilty of

a violation of the laws , which were the commandments of God . The obedience they owed to the civil government of the country was a duty impressed upon them b y the Church of God .

So strongly did the church feel that , and so strongly did she set the seal of her approbation upon it , that no one could , as he had said , be admitted to the Sacraments who conspired , or

was supposed to be conspiring , against the civil government of the country in which he lived . It was forbidden a priest ^ to bestow any of the

benefits of the confessional on such offenders . All , for instance , belonging to secret societies were , interdicted from those benefits , because

Another Roman Catholic Attack On Freemasonry.

they were supposed to hold tenets and princi ples which , in some way or other , were contrary to the laws of God and their country . No matter whether the society was that of Freemasons or

Fenians , its members were , so long as they belonged to it , excluded from the benefits of the tribunal of penance . That every catholic might continue to hold allegiance to his Sovereign was

the earnest wish of the pastors of the Church . " We cannot see why the Freemasons are introduced at all , and we can only suppose that it was for the pleasant alliteration of " Fenians and

Freemasons . " There is really otherwise no meaning in the connection or in the passage itself , Is Dr . Brown so ignorant of history as not to

be aware that Freemasons are specially exempt from the operation of the Secret Societies' Act ? He must know , if he knows anything of Freemasonry , that in England , and in Ireland ,

and in Scotland , its members have always constituted a pre-eminently loyal body , and that they have always been distinguished by devoted adherence to the Throne , and zealous

obedience to the laws of this great country . He must have known that , at its head in Cheshire , is Lord De Tabley and was good old Lord Combermere ; that its Grand

Master is theManmisof Ripon ; its Deputy Grand Master the Earl of Carnarvon , that the Prince of Wales himself is a member of the Fraternity ,

and that to brand Freemasonry as a secret political society , or to put it on a level with the Fenians , muse be either an absurdity or an

impertinence . As it is not the first time that Roman Catholic Dignitaries have thought fit to couple together

two such dissimilar societies , we think it right , once for all , to protest against such an unwarrantable , such an uncharitable , such an

offensive juxtaposition . Freemasonry is a peculiarly loyal , peaceful , philanthropic brotherhood , one of whose first and unchanged axioms is , " Loyalty to the

Sovereign of our native land , " and we indignantly repudiate any alleged similarity in our organization with that of the Fenians , just as we denounce such an unjust allusion to our

benevolent and tolerant order . Why , in the city of Chester , where there are two excellent lodges , the Cestrian , No . 425 , and the Lodge of Independence , No . 721 , or wh y in

Cheshire , where there are no less than thirty-live lodges , all distinguished by Masonic zeal , and we feel sure , by English loyalty , Dr . Brown Should have Uiuught well 10 use such very

oilcnsive words to all Freemasons , we cannot , for the life of us , understand . In Shrewsbury , itself , there are two lodges , all "good men and true , " and why , on such a day , Dr . Brown should have

gone out of his way to say the most disagreeable thing he could possibly say of us loyal Freemasons , is one of those mysteries of Roman Catholic proceedings in this country , which we

cannot profess to be able to understand or to expound . It is not so many decades , or years ago , since we could tell of a Roman Catholic

archbishop , and of a Roman Catholic bishop as being Freemasons , and having a high value for the institution . Dr . Brown may say , I am only speaking

“The Freemason: 1873-11-08, Page 6” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 5 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_08111873/page/6/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 3
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 3
Royal Arch. Article 4
Mark Masonry. Article 5
Scotland. Article 5
THE MAYOR, CORPORATION, AND FREEMASONS OF LIVERPOOL AT CHURCH. Article 5
SURREY MASONIC HALL. Article 5
Untitled Article 6
Answers to Correspondents. Article 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
ANOTHER ROMAN CATHOLIC ATTACK ON FREEMASONRY. Article 6
SURREPTITIOUS CRAFT RITUALS. Article 7
GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND. Article 7
CONSECRATION OF THE ST. ALPHEGE LODGE (No. 1431), AT SOLIHULL. Article 7
Original Correspondence. Article 8
Reviews. Article 8
Obituary. Article 9
Poetry. Article 10
RELATIONS OF STS. JOHN TO FREEMASONRY. Article 10
Public Amusements. Article 10
Masonic Tidings. Article 11
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 11
MASONIC MEETINGS IN LIVERPOOL, &c. Article 11
MASONIC MEETINGS IN GLASGOW. Article 11
MASONIC MEETINGS IN EDINBURGH. Article 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Article 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

19 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

21 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

7 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

10 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

6 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

4 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

5 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

6 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

13 Articles
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ar00600

NOTICE .

The Subscription lo THE FREEMASON is now io . v . per annum , post-free , payable tn advance . Vol . 1 ., bound in cloth ... ... •4 s . 6 d .

Vol . II ., ditto 7 s . 6 d . Vol . s III ., IV ., and V . ... each 15 s . od . Reading Cases to hold 52 numbers ... 2 S ' . 6 d . Ditto ditto 4 do . ... •is . 6 d .

United States of America * THE FREEMASON is delivered fiee in any part of the United States for 12 S . per annum , payable in advance . The Freemason is published on Saturday Mornings in time for tile early trains . The price of the Freemason is Twopence per weekj annual

subscription , ios . ( payable in advance . ) All communications , letters , & c , to be addressed to the' Editor , 108 , Fleet-street , E . C . The Editorwill pay careful attention to all MSS . entrusted to him , butcannot undertake to return them unlessaccoinpanied hy postage sramDs .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

LA RUCHE . —Declined . A VICTIM . —It will be better to let tbe matter rest as it is REMITTANCE RECEIVED . VV . HAHPEH , Nevada , U . S . A . —P . O . O . US . 3 d . EltiiATUM . —Page 709 of our last issue—Communicatior

regarding Masonic Literature—line 14 , for " exposes shame , " read " exposes shams . " The following stand over : — Reports of Grand Chapter ; thejMark Benevolent Association ; Lodges 1 31 , 1261 , 1 348 , 1421 ( Instruction ) .

Ad00605

THE HISTORY OF FREEMASONRY , FROM ITS ORIGIN TO THE PRESENT DAY . Drawn from the best sources and the most recent investigations . BY J . G . FINDEL , Second Edition , Revised , and Preface written by Bro . D . MURRAY LYON . One vol ., 800 pages 8 vc , with an Index . Cloth gilt . Price , ios . Od . ••This volume is the history of Masonry pur excellence Every inteiested person may regard it , therefore , as the present text-book on the subject . "—Manchester Guardian "The author seems to have fairly exhausted the subject . "—The Athenaeum . " Of its value to Freemasons , as a detailed history of their Brotherhood , it is not possible to speak too hi g hly . "Pul-lic Opinion . Bro . GEORGE KENNING , 19 S , ILEET STREET , LONDON , K . C .

Ad00607

THE MASONIC M A G A Z INE , A moiilh / y digesl if Freemasonry in all its Brunches .. NOW READY No . 5 , NOVEMBER . Price Sixpence , Post free Scvenpence ; Annual subscription , including postage : United Kingdom 7 s ., America 9 s . ( Payable in advance ) . Office , 198 , _ Fleet Street .

Ad00606

KI ' . ADY SHORTLY . Roan , Gilt Edges , Elastic Band , Price 2 s ., Post Free 2 , s . -j . il . THE COSMOPOLITAN MASONIC CALENDAR , DIARY , AND POCKET-BOOK , FOR 1874 , CONTAINING (\ 111 nriU ' inVi ' k " ' ! ' V > L , :, P ,, TS- Conclaves , Grand councils and ls-. l . 1 receptones with ine names ot Officers in England and Wales , Scotland Ireland , and abroad . May le had of all Hunksellers , Tylers , Janitor ,, Sentinels , Eijiierries , & c , Publishing Office , 198 , Fleet-street , E . C .

Ad00608

Second Edition , Now Ready , 1 / 6 . A MASONIC MUSICAL SERVICE . In tlie key of C . for A ., T ., T ., U . Opening and Closing Odes . Craft Ceremonies . Royal . Arch Ceremony . Consecration Ceiemony . Grace before and after Meat . COMPOSED 13 V DR . J . . BAKER , NO . 241 . LONDON . —Geo . Kenning , i , > 8 , Fleet-street ; and 2 , 3 , and 4 , Little Hi itain . *' „ R . Spencer , 20 , Great Queen-street . LIVEHPOOI .. —Geo . Kenning , 2 , Mor . ument-place . MANCHESTO .-I ,. Jlenry . V Co ., Deansgate . DUBLIN .-C . Hedgelong , 26 , Grafton-. treet GLASGOW . —Geo . Kenning , 145 , Argyle-street . liDisiiuitcii . —Geo . Kenning , 67 , Manov-. r-street .

Ar00602

NOTICE . All Communications , Advertisements , & c , intended for insertion in the Number of the following

Saturday , must reach the Office not later than 6 o ' clock on Wednesday evening .

Ar00609

TheFreemason SATURDAY , NOVEMBER 8 , 1873 .

Another Roman Catholic Attack On Freemasonry.

ANOTHER ROMAN CATHOLIC ATTACK ON FREEMASONRY .

We had occasion , some time back , to call attention to a professedly humourous and sarcastic attack , by an accredited Roman Catholic periodical on our Fraternity , and we succeeded ,

as we hoped , in showing how utterly meaningless and inane such an attack really was , and how little we were affected by so childish and so flippant an article .

To-day , however , we have to call attention to a somewhat more serious aggression , namely to the after-luncheon speech of Dr . Brown , a Roman Catholic bishop , in whose ecclesiastical

jurisdiction Chester , we believe , is . Dr . Brown is , we also understand , the titular Bishop of Shrewsbury , and having laid the foundation stone of a new Roman Catholic Church

in the good City of Chester , and having attended a luncheon and a numerous assembly of the faithful , he amused ^ himself , and we presume his hearers , by an onslaught on us poor

Freemasons . Why he should , on such a day , and after such a ceremony , have thought it needful to introduce the subject of Freemasonry at all , we cannot pretend to explain , or even to surmise .

Roman Catholic bishops alter all , are but men , and something had evidently gone wrong with his digestion , or the" menu . " Perhaps the '' Mayonnaise ii l'Homard" was not

properly mixed , or the fine sirloin the " piece dc resistance , " was too tough . The Doctor evidently wanted some of Bob Sawyer ' s " patent digestor , " for he

incontinently proceeded to attack Freemasonry " more Romaiioruni" in a peculiarly offensive way . As he is reported in the Chester Courant of October 22 nd , Dr . Brown ventured to couple

" Freemasons" and " Fenians" together , and to pronounce them equally under the ban of the Pope , and to be avoided by all good Roman Catholics .

Hi' -- isfnil words are these : — "The allerriance they owed to their Sovereign was a reli gious duty . No one could be admitted to the benefits of the holy tribunal of penance who was guilty of

a violation of the laws , which were the commandments of God . The obedience they owed to the civil government of the country was a duty impressed upon them b y the Church of God .

So strongly did the church feel that , and so strongly did she set the seal of her approbation upon it , that no one could , as he had said , be admitted to the Sacraments who conspired , or

was supposed to be conspiring , against the civil government of the country in which he lived . It was forbidden a priest ^ to bestow any of the

benefits of the confessional on such offenders . All , for instance , belonging to secret societies were , interdicted from those benefits , because

Another Roman Catholic Attack On Freemasonry.

they were supposed to hold tenets and princi ples which , in some way or other , were contrary to the laws of God and their country . No matter whether the society was that of Freemasons or

Fenians , its members were , so long as they belonged to it , excluded from the benefits of the tribunal of penance . That every catholic might continue to hold allegiance to his Sovereign was

the earnest wish of the pastors of the Church . " We cannot see why the Freemasons are introduced at all , and we can only suppose that it was for the pleasant alliteration of " Fenians and

Freemasons . " There is really otherwise no meaning in the connection or in the passage itself , Is Dr . Brown so ignorant of history as not to

be aware that Freemasons are specially exempt from the operation of the Secret Societies' Act ? He must know , if he knows anything of Freemasonry , that in England , and in Ireland ,

and in Scotland , its members have always constituted a pre-eminently loyal body , and that they have always been distinguished by devoted adherence to the Throne , and zealous

obedience to the laws of this great country . He must have known that , at its head in Cheshire , is Lord De Tabley and was good old Lord Combermere ; that its Grand

Master is theManmisof Ripon ; its Deputy Grand Master the Earl of Carnarvon , that the Prince of Wales himself is a member of the Fraternity ,

and that to brand Freemasonry as a secret political society , or to put it on a level with the Fenians , muse be either an absurdity or an

impertinence . As it is not the first time that Roman Catholic Dignitaries have thought fit to couple together

two such dissimilar societies , we think it right , once for all , to protest against such an unwarrantable , such an uncharitable , such an

offensive juxtaposition . Freemasonry is a peculiarly loyal , peaceful , philanthropic brotherhood , one of whose first and unchanged axioms is , " Loyalty to the

Sovereign of our native land , " and we indignantly repudiate any alleged similarity in our organization with that of the Fenians , just as we denounce such an unjust allusion to our

benevolent and tolerant order . Why , in the city of Chester , where there are two excellent lodges , the Cestrian , No . 425 , and the Lodge of Independence , No . 721 , or wh y in

Cheshire , where there are no less than thirty-live lodges , all distinguished by Masonic zeal , and we feel sure , by English loyalty , Dr . Brown Should have Uiuught well 10 use such very

oilcnsive words to all Freemasons , we cannot , for the life of us , understand . In Shrewsbury , itself , there are two lodges , all "good men and true , " and why , on such a day , Dr . Brown should have

gone out of his way to say the most disagreeable thing he could possibly say of us loyal Freemasons , is one of those mysteries of Roman Catholic proceedings in this country , which we

cannot profess to be able to understand or to expound . It is not so many decades , or years ago , since we could tell of a Roman Catholic

archbishop , and of a Roman Catholic bishop as being Freemasons , and having a high value for the institution . Dr . Brown may say , I am only speaking

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 5
  • You're on page6
  • 7
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy