Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Feb. 14, 1874
  • Page 7
  • REFUSAL TO BURY A ROMAN CATHOLIC SOLDIER, A FREEMASON.
Current:

The Freemason, Feb. 14, 1874: Page 7

  • Back to The Freemason, Feb. 14, 1874
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article FREEMASONRY IN ITALY AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article FREEMASONRY IN ITALY AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH. Page 2 of 2
    Article REFUSAL TO BURY A ROMAN CATHOLIC SOLDIER, A FREEMASON. Page 1 of 1
    Article REFUSAL TO BURY A ROMAN CATHOLIC SOLDIER, A FREEMASON. Page 1 of 1
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemasonry In Italy And The Roman Catholic Church.

The other Grand Lodge of Berlin , called the '" Royal York , " is represented in Rome by General Duke Filippo Lante di Montefeltro . There is thus an intimate connection between the Prussian and Italian lodges , not to speak of

the common bond -which unites together in obedience the members of aU the lodges in all parts ofthe world . Yet , although the Pope has no allies amongst the rulers of this world , who seemed to have combined together to ignore or

destroy the Pontifical authority , Catholics have no fear for the issue of this unequal combat . The aged Pontiff may be dethroned , his servants may be cast into prison or exiled , or even persecuted unto death . Yet the triumph eventually

is certain and beyond doubt . The material conquests of the kings of the earth are destined , now as ever , to vanish before the moral might of that strength which is made perfect in weakness . The promise of the King of kings and Lord of

lords to be with His Church to the end ofthe world is as valid now as when first uttered . And the victory of Christianity over brute force , of faith over scepticism , of life over death , is to Catholics as certain as the existence of God and the reality of the mission of Christ . —Tablet . "

Now we will only permit ourselves to-day , to remark , that , the writer of this long-winded article

entirely mistakes and misunderstands the position of English Freemasonry . It is not only tolerated , as he would put it , by our lenient laws , but it is , for its well-known spirit of loyalty and peaceful submission to the " ordinances of this

realm , " specially exempted by name from the operation of the Secret Societies' Act . In the next place , as we said before , we have nothing to do with tha proceedings of foreign Grand Lodges . Our own course of action is

• well known to all , our principles of entire neutrality in all matters relating to politics or religion , ( that is as regards denominational differences ) , are admitted even by those who differ from us in England .

Indeed , our very abnegation on such topics , especially religious teaching , is one of the complaints curiously enough , most frequently brought against us .

But we cannot and do not profess to legislate for foreign Grand Lodges , and we are not responsible , therefore , for the differences which are to be traced between their proceedings and

our own . "We can hardly believe that Bro . Guiseppe Garibaldi , or Bro . Ferrari used the words

attributed to them , and we would like to see a verification of them before we condemn the Speakers on the ipse dixit of the writer in the Tablet .

If these are the opinions of these two brethren , Mid the formal utterance of tbe Italian Grand Lodge , we deeply deplore the fact , and have no hesitation whatever , as Freemasons , in saying that by the tolerating and charitable principles of our

Order , they are equally indefensible and improper . We do not think that there ever was any intention in the use of particular words to ridicule or parody the religious ceremonies or organization of the Church of Rome . The words were

chosen , because , they were convenient words to the Masonic Order , and are used , we believe , simply with that intent and end . At the same time , we have often felt , that

some of the foreign high grades , are so very peculiar in their forms and ceremonies , that , they may appear objectionable to religiousminded persons . Hence a strong argument , as it appears to us ,

Freemasonry In Italy And The Roman Catholic Church.

for the simple forms and ritual of Craft Masonry . Neither do we believe , that , there is any foundation for the idea of a common crusade nf the Italian and German Freemasons as

against ths Supreme Pontiff , the Roman Catholic Church , society in general , and legitimate authority in particular . This seems to be the chimera which is agitating Roman Catholics

everywhere , at the moment , and the Masonic Order appears just now to be the bugbear of the whole Roman Catholic Hierarchy . One should have thought that

they had something better to do than fulminate ceaseless anathemas against Freemasons . But in the meantime the writer of this lachrymose jeremiad forgets this undoubted truth , that the Roman Catholic Church has commenced a

most unseemly attack on the Freemasons . In Brazil , in Belgium , in America , and even in England , the Roman Catholb Hierarchy have unceasingly proclaimed that the wicked

Freemasons are the cause of all the present evils , and above all of the serious conflict between the state in Prussia , and the Roman Catholic

Church . We believe , that , never in their history , though they have made many great mistakes , has the Roman Catholic Curia and the Roman

Catholic Dignitaries committed-so great a blunder . There may be in Germany , as elsewhere , some who seem to think they never can be

satisfied , unless they are attacking " Ultramontanism and Ultramontanes . " But such uneasy Masons are in a very great minority . The great majority of our Order , true to their

old teachings , are ever most opposed to the " debasing practice of persecution , " from whatever quarter it comes , and are most anxious to live

in peace and amity with all men , and above all , are seeking in all of sincerity , loyalty , and submission to the laws of their several countries ,

to pursue their honest callings , their one banner being the banner of toleration , sincerity , and charity , their watchword being ever , and under all circumstances , and alone—brotherly love .

Refusal To Bury A Roman Catholic Soldier, A Freemason.

REFUSAL TO BURY A ROMAN CATHOLIC SOLDIER , A FREEMASON .

As a very remarkable corollary on our preceding article , and a very striking commentary on the recent denunciations , and overt acts of

Roman Catholic prelates , against our unoffending Order , we beg to call the attention of our readers particularly to the following extract from the Times ' s military and naval intelligence of

February jth : — " Some excitement has been caused in Chatham Garrison by the refusal of the Rev . M . Cuffe , Roman Catholic Chaplain to the Forces , to perform the burial service over

Armourer-Sergeant , J . V . Johnstone , of the 82 d Regiment , a Roman Catholic Freemason , who died in Fort Pitt Hospital . The deceased had been a member of the Buckley Lodge of Freemasons , which met at the Soldiers' Institute . A resident

Roman Catholic priest also declined , as the Rev . M . Cuffe was his senior . The Rev . Mr . Phillips , a Protestant clergyman , performed the

Church service when the deceased was interred in the military burial ground near Fort Pitt . The deceased was much respected , and hundreds of soldiers attended the funeral . "

Refusal To Bury A Roman Catholic Soldier, A Freemason.

Where then will this persecution of Freemasons end ? Though protected by the laws of the country , peaceable and loyal citizens , a Roman Catholic

Chaplain , paid by the Government , actually refuses to perform the Roman Catholic Burial service , over a gallant Roman Catholic soldier , simply because he is a

Freemason . To say nothing of the evident illegality of the above proceeding , even according to Roman Catholic canon law , we have in this

act ofthe Rev . Mr . Cuffe , a most painful violation of the great Christian law of kindness and brotherly love .

It is not the first time Roman Catholic Clergy and Prelates have refused to bury Roman Catholic Freemasons . A case occurred at Gibraltar some

years back , when Bishop Hughes , though a very kindly man himself , then the Roman Catholic Bishop at Gibraltar , declined to allow extreme unction to be admin'Stered to a Roman Catholic

unless he abjured Freemasonry , and then after the poor man ' s death , refused to bury him . Dr . Burrows , then the Resident Civil Chaplain

at Gibraltar , and P . G . M ., read the service over our brother , in the presence of thousands of spectators .

What good the Roman Catholic clergy can think will accrue to their Church or themselves by such unwise proceedings , we are altogether

at a loss to guess , but of this they may rest assured , that such acts are utterly repugnant to the true spirit of that religion they profess to believe in . Matters however cannot be allowed

to rest here , and the attention of the G . M . and the Grand Lodge ought at once to be called , to a course of action on the part of the Roman Catholic clergy , which is most subversive of the

rig hts of Freemasons as peaceable citizens of the country , most derogatory to religion , and most unjustifiable ' on every ground of peace and toleration , and in the general interests of civiliza ^

tion and humanity . Mr . Cuffe ' s refusal to bury Sergeant Johnstone is quite unprecedented in this country , and

must be looked at in a most serious light , as in itself a most irreligious and unrighteous proceeding .

We feel quite certain that our Grand Master and our Grand lodge , will , on a proper representation from the Buckley Lodge , take such steps

as will tend to uphold the right or our Roman Catholic brethren , as , be they ever so humble , they equally claim our sympathy , and deserve our support .

Messrs . Morton , Rose and Co . announce an issue of a ^ i jOoo . ooo Five per Cent . Sterling Sinking Fund Bonds or the Illinois Central Railway Company , at the price of 84 per cent . The proceeds are to purchase an equal amount of New Orleans , Jackson , and Great Northern

Railroad and Mississippi Central Seven per Cent . Bonds , by means of which the Illinois company will gain 2 per cent , annually , thereby providing a sinking fund sufficient to redeem the whole of the present issue in about 2 , 6 years ,

and the bonds so purchased are to be held as security for the payment of the loan . This arrangement will give to the Illinois company through communication between Chicago and New Orleans . The total income of the Illinois company last year amounted to 2 , 860 , 742 . dols .

“The Freemason: 1874-02-14, Page 7” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 11 Oct. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_14021874/page/7/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 3
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 3
Royal Arch. Article 4
Scotland. Article 4
Original Correspondence. Article 5
MASONIC BALL IN WEST LANCASHIRE. Article 5
MASONIC BIBLIOGRAPHY. Article 5
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Article 6
FREEMASONRY IN ITALY AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH. Article 6
REFUSAL TO BURY A ROMAN CATHOLIC SOLDIER, A FREEMASON. Article 7
WEEKLY SUMMARY. Article 8
RED CROSS BALL. Article 8
GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND. Article 8
Untitled Article 9
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 9
Untitled Article 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

13 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

29 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

5 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

5 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

10 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

4 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

5 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

17 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

17 Articles
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemasonry In Italy And The Roman Catholic Church.

The other Grand Lodge of Berlin , called the '" Royal York , " is represented in Rome by General Duke Filippo Lante di Montefeltro . There is thus an intimate connection between the Prussian and Italian lodges , not to speak of

the common bond -which unites together in obedience the members of aU the lodges in all parts ofthe world . Yet , although the Pope has no allies amongst the rulers of this world , who seemed to have combined together to ignore or

destroy the Pontifical authority , Catholics have no fear for the issue of this unequal combat . The aged Pontiff may be dethroned , his servants may be cast into prison or exiled , or even persecuted unto death . Yet the triumph eventually

is certain and beyond doubt . The material conquests of the kings of the earth are destined , now as ever , to vanish before the moral might of that strength which is made perfect in weakness . The promise of the King of kings and Lord of

lords to be with His Church to the end ofthe world is as valid now as when first uttered . And the victory of Christianity over brute force , of faith over scepticism , of life over death , is to Catholics as certain as the existence of God and the reality of the mission of Christ . —Tablet . "

Now we will only permit ourselves to-day , to remark , that , the writer of this long-winded article

entirely mistakes and misunderstands the position of English Freemasonry . It is not only tolerated , as he would put it , by our lenient laws , but it is , for its well-known spirit of loyalty and peaceful submission to the " ordinances of this

realm , " specially exempted by name from the operation of the Secret Societies' Act . In the next place , as we said before , we have nothing to do with tha proceedings of foreign Grand Lodges . Our own course of action is

• well known to all , our principles of entire neutrality in all matters relating to politics or religion , ( that is as regards denominational differences ) , are admitted even by those who differ from us in England .

Indeed , our very abnegation on such topics , especially religious teaching , is one of the complaints curiously enough , most frequently brought against us .

But we cannot and do not profess to legislate for foreign Grand Lodges , and we are not responsible , therefore , for the differences which are to be traced between their proceedings and

our own . "We can hardly believe that Bro . Guiseppe Garibaldi , or Bro . Ferrari used the words

attributed to them , and we would like to see a verification of them before we condemn the Speakers on the ipse dixit of the writer in the Tablet .

If these are the opinions of these two brethren , Mid the formal utterance of tbe Italian Grand Lodge , we deeply deplore the fact , and have no hesitation whatever , as Freemasons , in saying that by the tolerating and charitable principles of our

Order , they are equally indefensible and improper . We do not think that there ever was any intention in the use of particular words to ridicule or parody the religious ceremonies or organization of the Church of Rome . The words were

chosen , because , they were convenient words to the Masonic Order , and are used , we believe , simply with that intent and end . At the same time , we have often felt , that

some of the foreign high grades , are so very peculiar in their forms and ceremonies , that , they may appear objectionable to religiousminded persons . Hence a strong argument , as it appears to us ,

Freemasonry In Italy And The Roman Catholic Church.

for the simple forms and ritual of Craft Masonry . Neither do we believe , that , there is any foundation for the idea of a common crusade nf the Italian and German Freemasons as

against ths Supreme Pontiff , the Roman Catholic Church , society in general , and legitimate authority in particular . This seems to be the chimera which is agitating Roman Catholics

everywhere , at the moment , and the Masonic Order appears just now to be the bugbear of the whole Roman Catholic Hierarchy . One should have thought that

they had something better to do than fulminate ceaseless anathemas against Freemasons . But in the meantime the writer of this lachrymose jeremiad forgets this undoubted truth , that the Roman Catholic Church has commenced a

most unseemly attack on the Freemasons . In Brazil , in Belgium , in America , and even in England , the Roman Catholb Hierarchy have unceasingly proclaimed that the wicked

Freemasons are the cause of all the present evils , and above all of the serious conflict between the state in Prussia , and the Roman Catholic

Church . We believe , that , never in their history , though they have made many great mistakes , has the Roman Catholic Curia and the Roman

Catholic Dignitaries committed-so great a blunder . There may be in Germany , as elsewhere , some who seem to think they never can be

satisfied , unless they are attacking " Ultramontanism and Ultramontanes . " But such uneasy Masons are in a very great minority . The great majority of our Order , true to their

old teachings , are ever most opposed to the " debasing practice of persecution , " from whatever quarter it comes , and are most anxious to live

in peace and amity with all men , and above all , are seeking in all of sincerity , loyalty , and submission to the laws of their several countries ,

to pursue their honest callings , their one banner being the banner of toleration , sincerity , and charity , their watchword being ever , and under all circumstances , and alone—brotherly love .

Refusal To Bury A Roman Catholic Soldier, A Freemason.

REFUSAL TO BURY A ROMAN CATHOLIC SOLDIER , A FREEMASON .

As a very remarkable corollary on our preceding article , and a very striking commentary on the recent denunciations , and overt acts of

Roman Catholic prelates , against our unoffending Order , we beg to call the attention of our readers particularly to the following extract from the Times ' s military and naval intelligence of

February jth : — " Some excitement has been caused in Chatham Garrison by the refusal of the Rev . M . Cuffe , Roman Catholic Chaplain to the Forces , to perform the burial service over

Armourer-Sergeant , J . V . Johnstone , of the 82 d Regiment , a Roman Catholic Freemason , who died in Fort Pitt Hospital . The deceased had been a member of the Buckley Lodge of Freemasons , which met at the Soldiers' Institute . A resident

Roman Catholic priest also declined , as the Rev . M . Cuffe was his senior . The Rev . Mr . Phillips , a Protestant clergyman , performed the

Church service when the deceased was interred in the military burial ground near Fort Pitt . The deceased was much respected , and hundreds of soldiers attended the funeral . "

Refusal To Bury A Roman Catholic Soldier, A Freemason.

Where then will this persecution of Freemasons end ? Though protected by the laws of the country , peaceable and loyal citizens , a Roman Catholic

Chaplain , paid by the Government , actually refuses to perform the Roman Catholic Burial service , over a gallant Roman Catholic soldier , simply because he is a

Freemason . To say nothing of the evident illegality of the above proceeding , even according to Roman Catholic canon law , we have in this

act ofthe Rev . Mr . Cuffe , a most painful violation of the great Christian law of kindness and brotherly love .

It is not the first time Roman Catholic Clergy and Prelates have refused to bury Roman Catholic Freemasons . A case occurred at Gibraltar some

years back , when Bishop Hughes , though a very kindly man himself , then the Roman Catholic Bishop at Gibraltar , declined to allow extreme unction to be admin'Stered to a Roman Catholic

unless he abjured Freemasonry , and then after the poor man ' s death , refused to bury him . Dr . Burrows , then the Resident Civil Chaplain

at Gibraltar , and P . G . M ., read the service over our brother , in the presence of thousands of spectators .

What good the Roman Catholic clergy can think will accrue to their Church or themselves by such unwise proceedings , we are altogether

at a loss to guess , but of this they may rest assured , that such acts are utterly repugnant to the true spirit of that religion they profess to believe in . Matters however cannot be allowed

to rest here , and the attention of the G . M . and the Grand Lodge ought at once to be called , to a course of action on the part of the Roman Catholic clergy , which is most subversive of the

rig hts of Freemasons as peaceable citizens of the country , most derogatory to religion , and most unjustifiable ' on every ground of peace and toleration , and in the general interests of civiliza ^

tion and humanity . Mr . Cuffe ' s refusal to bury Sergeant Johnstone is quite unprecedented in this country , and

must be looked at in a most serious light , as in itself a most irreligious and unrighteous proceeding .

We feel quite certain that our Grand Master and our Grand lodge , will , on a proper representation from the Buckley Lodge , take such steps

as will tend to uphold the right or our Roman Catholic brethren , as , be they ever so humble , they equally claim our sympathy , and deserve our support .

Messrs . Morton , Rose and Co . announce an issue of a ^ i jOoo . ooo Five per Cent . Sterling Sinking Fund Bonds or the Illinois Central Railway Company , at the price of 84 per cent . The proceeds are to purchase an equal amount of New Orleans , Jackson , and Great Northern

Railroad and Mississippi Central Seven per Cent . Bonds , by means of which the Illinois company will gain 2 per cent , annually , thereby providing a sinking fund sufficient to redeem the whole of the present issue in about 2 , 6 years ,

and the bonds so purchased are to be held as security for the payment of the loan . This arrangement will give to the Illinois company through communication between Chicago and New Orleans . The total income of the Illinois company last year amounted to 2 , 860 , 742 . dols .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 6
  • You're on page7
  • 8
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy