Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • July 16, 1881
  • Page 3
Current:

The Freemason, July 16, 1881: Page 3

  • Back to The Freemason, July 16, 1881
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article PROVINCIAL GRAND MARK LODGE OF MIDDLESEX AND SURREY. Page 1 of 1
    Article PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF KENT. Page 1 of 1
    Article ALDERSGATE LODGE, No. 1657. Page 1 of 1
    Article MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS. Page 1 of 1
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Provincial Grand Mark Lodge Of Middlesex And Surrey.

PROVINCIAL GRAND MARK LODGE OF MIDDLESEX AND SURREY .

The annual meeting of the Prov . Grand Mark Lodge of Middlesex and Surrey was held at the Star and Garter , Hotel , Richmond , on Saturday , the 2 nd inst . The D . G . M . M . presided , in thc unavoidable absence of the R . W . P . G . M . M ., Sir F . Burdett , Bart ., and there were present Bros . Dr . F . W . Ramsay , P . G . D ., Prov . S . G . W . ; D . M . Dewar , P . G . M . O ., G . Asst . Sec ; Jno . Stevens , P . G . O ., * W . G . Brighten , P . G . L of W ., Prov . G . Sec . ; H . Lovegrove , G . Supt . of Works ; C . Pulman , G . Steward ; T .

W . Adams , P . G . Steward ; H . J . Lardner , P . G . Steward ; Chas . Hammerton , Prov . G . Treas . ; Sir Charles Palmer , Prov G . M . O . ; j ' . Rhodes , Piov . G . Org . ; W . Ackland , Prov . G . Steward ; G . Lilley , P . M . ; J . Curtis , E . B . Florence , and many others , including Bros . J . Gilbert , Grand Tyler , and Harrison , Asst . Tyler . Sixteen of thc twenty-one lodges in the province were represented . The minutes of the previous meeting were read and confirmed .

The Treasurer ' s accounts were presented , and , on a motion made by Bro . J STEVENS , seconded by Bro . 1-1 . LOVEGROVE , were received and accepted . Bro . Davison , Dep . P . G . M . M ., then proceeded lo invest thc Prov . Grand Officers for thc year as follows : —

Bro . W . G . Brighten ----- Prov , G . S . W . „ J . B . Batten Prov . G . J . W . ,, Rev . F . de Crespigny ; Bro . Rev . C . Weldon - Prov . G . Chaps . .. H . H . Birch * - - - - - Prov . G . M . O .

„ H . C . Jopps Prov . G . S . O . „ Lawrence ... - - Prov . G . J . O . ,, C . Hammerton . . . - - - Prov . G . Treas . „ W . Basnetl --- -- Prov . G . R . of M . ., ] . M . Klenck --- -- Prov . G . Sec . ' .. T . W . Adams - Prov . G . S . D .

„ W . J . Nicolls Prov . G . J . D . „ I . C . Cox - - - - - Prov . G . D . C" . „ G . Lilley Prov . G . A . D . C . „ Hopwood -- - - - Prov . G . S . ot W . .. 'J " . Richnell Prov . G . Swd . B .

„ W . Ackland Prov . G . Std . B . „ J . S . Gabriel Prov . G . Org . „ II . J . Lardner ---- - Prov . G . I . G . Bros . R . Lewis , ] . Mills , Jas . Curtis , E . B . Florence , J . Willis And W . G . T . Kipling - - - Prov . G . . Tlwds . ,, John Gilbert ---- - Prov . G . Tyler .

After thc Prov . Grand Officers had been saluted by the brethren , under thc directions of Bro . J . Stevens , the Prov . Grand Lodge was closed , and about twenty of the brethren sat down to an elegant banquet , after which the usual toasts were duly honoured . The enthusiasm with which the toast of " Thc Prov . G . M . M . " was received showed lhat though unavoidably absent

he was not forgotten . In Middlesex and Surrey , as elsewhere , the Mark Degree is making rapid progress .

Provincial Grand Lodge Of Kent.

PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF KENT .

The annual gathering of thc Provincial Grand Lodge of Kent look place at Rochester on Wednesday , the 13 th inst ., and was attended by several hundreds of the brethren . Unusual interest was this year imparted to ihe meeting , the occasion serving to present Bro . Lord Holmesdale with a testimonial of the value of five hundred guineas by thc Freemasons of Kent , in consideration of his lordship having presided over the province for a period

of twenty-one years , duiing which Freemasonry has flourished in an unprecedented manner throughout the province . A valuable gold bracelet was at ihe same time presented by the Freemasons to Lady Holmesdale . It had been intended that the Provincial Grand Lodge should attend Divine Service in Rochester Cathedral , but the cathedral officials insisted on certain conditions as

to clergymen who are Freemasons not taking pari in the service as made it impossible for the Provincial Lodge to hold a service in the cathedral , and the service took p lace in St . Margaret ' s Church instead . The brethren had intended presenting a stained glass window to the cathedral in commemoration of the event , but they have , in consequence of the action of the Dean and Chapter , abandoned the intention . The Provincial Grand Lodge voted a sum of seveial hundred pounds to the Charities .

In the evening thc brethren assembled at a banquet , when a testimonial , consisting of a piece of plate emblematical of the Craft , and of the value of 500 guineas , was presented to thc noble Viscount to celebrate his having rilled thc chair twenty-one years , there being onl y one other instance of the Provincial Grand Master having filled the office lor so long a time . We hope to give a full report in our next .

Aldersgate Lodge, No. 1657.

ALDERSGATE LODGE , No . 1657 .

Mr . and Mrs . George Kenning entertained the members of the above lodge , wilh their ladies and other friends , at dinner at the Royal Crown

Hotel , Sevenoaks , ou Wednesday last . The afternoon being very line , much pleasure was experienced by the party in strolling over the beautiful grounds of the hotel and Knowle Park , from which some charming views of the surrounding scenery are obtained .

A good selection ol music was performed , under the able conduclorshi p of Iiro . J . -iiiic :, Weaver . An ample number of saloon carriages had been provided by Bio . George Abbott , ol the Cannon-siteea Station , wliieh rendered the journey lo and

from very pleasant—the weather being hot . About liftv ladies and gentlemen -, nt flown to dinner , including f ol Shadwell H . Clerke and Mis . Gierke , Hon . K . W . 11 . C . kldv and Mv Giddy , II . C . Levander , ancl Miss Biookman .

Masonic History And Historians.

MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS .

BY MASONIC STUDENT . s I think lhat our esteemed Bro . Jacob Norton in * his Impeachment o Bro . Dr . Anderson has found what is commonly called a " tnare's nest , ' in all deference lo his critical acumen , be it said . At least I do not interpret Anderson ' s words as he apparently does . If Anderson has altered or garbled thc " old Regulations " of 1721 , published in 1733 , " proprio molu , " and for some mysterious reason of his own , he deserves all that Bro . Jacob

Norton says of him , and not only this , but P . G . M . Payne must come in for the same censure , inasmuch as he was alive and active in Masonry in 1738 , and , therefore , must have seen thc " New Regulations " as well as the "Old Regulations , " as represented in 1738 , in which he took an active part of arrangement . But the truth is , lhat Bro . Jacob Norton in his great zeal has " gone beyond his brief , " always , depend upon il , a great mistake , alike in matters legal as in essays Masonic .

Anderson guards himself carefully against this charge of unau thorized alterations and interpolations , by these words , which convey a great deal , and cover a considerable amount of ground , by terming the fresh edition " Thc New Regulations , or Rc-AItcrations , Improvement , and Explications of the Old , made by several Grand Lodges since the Firft Edition . " I admit lhat at first sight these words would seem to apply only to the New Regulations , but a little reflection shows that they apply equal ly to "New "and "Old . "

It may be remembered here , lo illustrate this portion of our Masonic history , thai so far back as June 24 th , 1718 , a movement under Payne began , lo collect thc Regulations , & c , of Masonry , tn 1720 , June 24 th , two years later , G . Payne slill G . M ., the question was again mooted ? nd attended to ( " for they had nothing yet in print , " il is specially observed ) , and no doubt then the first issue was made . Again on ' . it . John the Baptist's Day , June

241 I 1 , 1 7 , the rules of 1720 were re-i * -sucd , and on September 2 (* th , 1721 , on thc motion of the Duke of Montague , G . M ., Bro . John Anderson was directed lo digest the "Old" Gothic Constitutions on a " new and belief method . " On December 17 th , 1 7 21 , Bro . Anderson's MS . was submitted to a committee , of fourteen , and this " communication , " we are told , " was

made very interesting by the lectures of some old Masons . " On March , 25 th , 1 7 22 , the Committee of fourteen reported in favour of Bro . Anderson ' s MS ., and on the mil January , 1723 , thc Book of Constitutions was submitted lo thc Grand Lodge in print by " G . W arden Anderson , " nnd "again approved . "

On February , 24 th , 1 735 , Bro . Anderson s " new materials" for a " new edition" of the "Book of Constitutions" th . cn become necessary , were ordered lo be submitted lo the " Picsenl and Past Grand Officers , " and , on "the 25 th of January , 1738 , the Grand Lodge approved of the " new Book of Constitutions , " ( Darnley . Grand Master , ) and ordered the " same lo bc printed ; " and the approbation of thc Grand Master and the Wardens is

given in 1738 . The preface is dated November 4 th that year . Now , it may be observed that , since November 251 I 1 , 1723 , until January 251 I 1 , 1738 , there had been no less than fifty-six or lilly-scvei- Grand Lodges , so that Anderson ' s sta lenient is evident ! } ' correct when he alludes to successive " alterations , improvements , and explications made by several Grand Lodges since the first edition . " There is , therefore , no justice in thc charge that Anderson

garbled them or altered theni lo suit his own or any one else ' s purpose , and there is no likelihood , inasmuch as assuming that Anderson was not present in 1720 or 171 * 1 , Payne undoubtedly was , and Payne as D . G . M . was clearly responsible before the English Craft for Anderson's explicit assertions in tlid edition of 1 738 . Hacl they not been true Payne must have protested against them .

1 hus thc revised copy of the Old Regulations represent the Old Rcgulalations of 1720 , 1 7 , 1723 , wilh llic alterations and explanations and additions , or subtractions , made in them in thc intervening Grand Lodges , and incorporated wilh them , and the New Regulations represent those passed by Grand Lodge since 1723 , which explain ihe alterations of the Old . I admit

Anderson s " selling out " is not quite clear , but he clearly guards himself al p . 176—173 S against any alteration without the " consent of all the brethren , " ancl , therefore , he only , perhaps not in the most skilful way , sets out the general character of the Old Regulations , with subsequent expansion or addition , as made by proper authority .

Of course , Bro . Jacob Norton may fairly ask , How is it that we have these variations between the Regulations ot 1723 and the Regulations announced to be the same , and termed the Old , in 1738 , and why not keep tlie Old exactly as they were issued by Payne ? I answer , remembering that Anderson had the arrangement of both—that in 1723 and 1738 it is quite clear that Anderson acted fairly and deliberately " coram" the Grand

Lodge ; indeed , he could nol act otherwise , and as Payne must have approved of these changes , it is impossible that there can be any unauthorized change . It is also as clear lo me lhat we have in the Old Regulations as published in 1723 the actual representation of the original Regulation of 1 7 and 1721 . The Okl Regulations as published in 1738 are these , plus certain additions and subtractions made by authority .

I hope in ) - readers have followed me . The Regulations of 1723 are the Regulations of 1720 , 1 7 21 , and 1722 ; tin : " Old Regulations" of 1 738 are these " plus" successive modifications by Grand Lodge . The New Regulations of 1 73 S arc " explanations " of what the changes have been . I never could undei > tand why Anderson is to be attacked . He did what Grand Lotlge ordered him to do ; he digested the " Gothic Constitutions , "

or "Guild Legends , " into readable form and modernized verbiage ; and his history of Freemasonry is merely an amplification , flowing as it is , of the old " Guild History" and the " Masonic Legends" of Freemasonry . I could say a good deal more on the Regulations selected for illustration , because il i : > entile , clear to uie llial my esteemed Bro . Jacob Norton has not

quite mastered their ( rue bearing ; but I cannot hope to be permitted to-day to lie :. pas :, longer in these pages . All I can concede to Bro . Norton is that , perhaps , il would bc better to reprint NOIIIC day if neccssar } the alteration-, ; the Regulations of 1720 and 1721 , as publi-hed in 172 . *;; thc revi . eel ropy oi tbem , published in 173 ^ , wilh die New Regulations , or e \ planations of them , in lh . it year .

“The Freemason: 1881-07-16, Page 3” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 17 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_16071881/page/3/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CONTENTS. Article 1
Untitled Article 1
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Article 2
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS. Article 2
ROYAL MASONIC BENEVOLENT INSTITUTION. Article 2
PROVINCIAL GRAND MARK LODGE OF HAMPSHIRE AND THE ISLE OF WIGHT. Article 2
PROVINCIAL GRAND MARK LODGE OF MIDDLESEX AND SURREY. Article 3
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF KENT. Article 3
ALDERSGATE LODGE, No. 1657. Article 3
MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS. Article 3
To Correspondents. Article 4
Untitled Article 4
Original Correspondence. Article 4
KING KALAKAUA AND THE NATIONAL GRAND LODGE OF EGYPT. Article 4
Reviews. Article 5
Masonic Notes and Queries. Article 5
CONSECRATION OF THE DERWENT MARK LODGE, No. 282. Article 5
FREEMASONRY IN EGYPT. Article 6
CONSECRATION OF THE UNITED BRETHREN LODGE, AT MALTA. Article 6
THE DORSET MASONIC CHARITY. Article 7
MEMORIAL TO THE LATE BRO. CHARLES COOTE, P.M. Article 7
EARLY USE OF THE TERM FREEMASON. Article 7
Amusements. Article 7
New Zealand. Article 7
Jamaica. Article 7
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 8
Mark Masonry. Article 9
Red Cross of Constantine. Article 9
Scotland. Article 9
Australasia. Article 9
TESTIMONIAL TO BRO. R. PIERPOINT. Article 9
Obituary. Article 9
Masonic and General Tidings. Article 10
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS Article 11
MASONIC MEETINGS IN WEST LANCASHIRE AND CHESHIRE Article 11
Births, Marriages, and Deaths. Article 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 11
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

5 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

5 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

6 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

5 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

8 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

9 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

12 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

7 Articles
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Provincial Grand Mark Lodge Of Middlesex And Surrey.

PROVINCIAL GRAND MARK LODGE OF MIDDLESEX AND SURREY .

The annual meeting of the Prov . Grand Mark Lodge of Middlesex and Surrey was held at the Star and Garter , Hotel , Richmond , on Saturday , the 2 nd inst . The D . G . M . M . presided , in thc unavoidable absence of the R . W . P . G . M . M ., Sir F . Burdett , Bart ., and there were present Bros . Dr . F . W . Ramsay , P . G . D ., Prov . S . G . W . ; D . M . Dewar , P . G . M . O ., G . Asst . Sec ; Jno . Stevens , P . G . O ., * W . G . Brighten , P . G . L of W ., Prov . G . Sec . ; H . Lovegrove , G . Supt . of Works ; C . Pulman , G . Steward ; T .

W . Adams , P . G . Steward ; H . J . Lardner , P . G . Steward ; Chas . Hammerton , Prov . G . Treas . ; Sir Charles Palmer , Prov G . M . O . ; j ' . Rhodes , Piov . G . Org . ; W . Ackland , Prov . G . Steward ; G . Lilley , P . M . ; J . Curtis , E . B . Florence , and many others , including Bros . J . Gilbert , Grand Tyler , and Harrison , Asst . Tyler . Sixteen of thc twenty-one lodges in the province were represented . The minutes of the previous meeting were read and confirmed .

The Treasurer ' s accounts were presented , and , on a motion made by Bro . J STEVENS , seconded by Bro . 1-1 . LOVEGROVE , were received and accepted . Bro . Davison , Dep . P . G . M . M ., then proceeded lo invest thc Prov . Grand Officers for thc year as follows : —

Bro . W . G . Brighten ----- Prov , G . S . W . „ J . B . Batten Prov . G . J . W . ,, Rev . F . de Crespigny ; Bro . Rev . C . Weldon - Prov . G . Chaps . .. H . H . Birch * - - - - - Prov . G . M . O .

„ H . C . Jopps Prov . G . S . O . „ Lawrence ... - - Prov . G . J . O . ,, C . Hammerton . . . - - - Prov . G . Treas . „ W . Basnetl --- -- Prov . G . R . of M . ., ] . M . Klenck --- -- Prov . G . Sec . ' .. T . W . Adams - Prov . G . S . D .

„ W . J . Nicolls Prov . G . J . D . „ I . C . Cox - - - - - Prov . G . D . C" . „ G . Lilley Prov . G . A . D . C . „ Hopwood -- - - - Prov . G . S . ot W . .. 'J " . Richnell Prov . G . Swd . B .

„ W . Ackland Prov . G . Std . B . „ J . S . Gabriel Prov . G . Org . „ II . J . Lardner ---- - Prov . G . I . G . Bros . R . Lewis , ] . Mills , Jas . Curtis , E . B . Florence , J . Willis And W . G . T . Kipling - - - Prov . G . . Tlwds . ,, John Gilbert ---- - Prov . G . Tyler .

After thc Prov . Grand Officers had been saluted by the brethren , under thc directions of Bro . J . Stevens , the Prov . Grand Lodge was closed , and about twenty of the brethren sat down to an elegant banquet , after which the usual toasts were duly honoured . The enthusiasm with which the toast of " Thc Prov . G . M . M . " was received showed lhat though unavoidably absent

he was not forgotten . In Middlesex and Surrey , as elsewhere , the Mark Degree is making rapid progress .

Provincial Grand Lodge Of Kent.

PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGE OF KENT .

The annual gathering of thc Provincial Grand Lodge of Kent look place at Rochester on Wednesday , the 13 th inst ., and was attended by several hundreds of the brethren . Unusual interest was this year imparted to ihe meeting , the occasion serving to present Bro . Lord Holmesdale with a testimonial of the value of five hundred guineas by thc Freemasons of Kent , in consideration of his lordship having presided over the province for a period

of twenty-one years , duiing which Freemasonry has flourished in an unprecedented manner throughout the province . A valuable gold bracelet was at ihe same time presented by the Freemasons to Lady Holmesdale . It had been intended that the Provincial Grand Lodge should attend Divine Service in Rochester Cathedral , but the cathedral officials insisted on certain conditions as

to clergymen who are Freemasons not taking pari in the service as made it impossible for the Provincial Lodge to hold a service in the cathedral , and the service took p lace in St . Margaret ' s Church instead . The brethren had intended presenting a stained glass window to the cathedral in commemoration of the event , but they have , in consequence of the action of the Dean and Chapter , abandoned the intention . The Provincial Grand Lodge voted a sum of seveial hundred pounds to the Charities .

In the evening thc brethren assembled at a banquet , when a testimonial , consisting of a piece of plate emblematical of the Craft , and of the value of 500 guineas , was presented to thc noble Viscount to celebrate his having rilled thc chair twenty-one years , there being onl y one other instance of the Provincial Grand Master having filled the office lor so long a time . We hope to give a full report in our next .

Aldersgate Lodge, No. 1657.

ALDERSGATE LODGE , No . 1657 .

Mr . and Mrs . George Kenning entertained the members of the above lodge , wilh their ladies and other friends , at dinner at the Royal Crown

Hotel , Sevenoaks , ou Wednesday last . The afternoon being very line , much pleasure was experienced by the party in strolling over the beautiful grounds of the hotel and Knowle Park , from which some charming views of the surrounding scenery are obtained .

A good selection ol music was performed , under the able conduclorshi p of Iiro . J . -iiiic :, Weaver . An ample number of saloon carriages had been provided by Bio . George Abbott , ol the Cannon-siteea Station , wliieh rendered the journey lo and

from very pleasant—the weather being hot . About liftv ladies and gentlemen -, nt flown to dinner , including f ol Shadwell H . Clerke and Mis . Gierke , Hon . K . W . 11 . C . kldv and Mv Giddy , II . C . Levander , ancl Miss Biookman .

Masonic History And Historians.

MASONIC HISTORY AND HISTORIANS .

BY MASONIC STUDENT . s I think lhat our esteemed Bro . Jacob Norton in * his Impeachment o Bro . Dr . Anderson has found what is commonly called a " tnare's nest , ' in all deference lo his critical acumen , be it said . At least I do not interpret Anderson ' s words as he apparently does . If Anderson has altered or garbled thc " old Regulations " of 1721 , published in 1733 , " proprio molu , " and for some mysterious reason of his own , he deserves all that Bro . Jacob

Norton says of him , and not only this , but P . G . M . Payne must come in for the same censure , inasmuch as he was alive and active in Masonry in 1738 , and , therefore , must have seen thc " New Regulations " as well as the "Old Regulations , " as represented in 1738 , in which he took an active part of arrangement . But the truth is , lhat Bro . Jacob Norton in his great zeal has " gone beyond his brief , " always , depend upon il , a great mistake , alike in matters legal as in essays Masonic .

Anderson guards himself carefully against this charge of unau thorized alterations and interpolations , by these words , which convey a great deal , and cover a considerable amount of ground , by terming the fresh edition " Thc New Regulations , or Rc-AItcrations , Improvement , and Explications of the Old , made by several Grand Lodges since the Firft Edition . " I admit lhat at first sight these words would seem to apply only to the New Regulations , but a little reflection shows that they apply equal ly to "New "and "Old . "

It may be remembered here , lo illustrate this portion of our Masonic history , thai so far back as June 24 th , 1718 , a movement under Payne began , lo collect thc Regulations , & c , of Masonry , tn 1720 , June 24 th , two years later , G . Payne slill G . M ., the question was again mooted ? nd attended to ( " for they had nothing yet in print , " il is specially observed ) , and no doubt then the first issue was made . Again on ' . it . John the Baptist's Day , June

241 I 1 , 1 7 , the rules of 1720 were re-i * -sucd , and on September 2 (* th , 1721 , on thc motion of the Duke of Montague , G . M ., Bro . John Anderson was directed lo digest the "Old" Gothic Constitutions on a " new and belief method . " On December 17 th , 1 7 21 , Bro . Anderson's MS . was submitted to a committee , of fourteen , and this " communication , " we are told , " was

made very interesting by the lectures of some old Masons . " On March , 25 th , 1 7 22 , the Committee of fourteen reported in favour of Bro . Anderson ' s MS ., and on the mil January , 1723 , thc Book of Constitutions was submitted lo thc Grand Lodge in print by " G . W arden Anderson , " nnd "again approved . "

On February , 24 th , 1 735 , Bro . Anderson s " new materials" for a " new edition" of the "Book of Constitutions" th . cn become necessary , were ordered lo be submitted lo the " Picsenl and Past Grand Officers , " and , on "the 25 th of January , 1738 , the Grand Lodge approved of the " new Book of Constitutions , " ( Darnley . Grand Master , ) and ordered the " same lo bc printed ; " and the approbation of thc Grand Master and the Wardens is

given in 1738 . The preface is dated November 4 th that year . Now , it may be observed that , since November 251 I 1 , 1723 , until January 251 I 1 , 1738 , there had been no less than fifty-six or lilly-scvei- Grand Lodges , so that Anderson ' s sta lenient is evident ! } ' correct when he alludes to successive " alterations , improvements , and explications made by several Grand Lodges since the first edition . " There is , therefore , no justice in thc charge that Anderson

garbled them or altered theni lo suit his own or any one else ' s purpose , and there is no likelihood , inasmuch as assuming that Anderson was not present in 1720 or 171 * 1 , Payne undoubtedly was , and Payne as D . G . M . was clearly responsible before the English Craft for Anderson's explicit assertions in tlid edition of 1 738 . Hacl they not been true Payne must have protested against them .

1 hus thc revised copy of the Old Regulations represent the Old Rcgulalations of 1720 , 1 7 , 1723 , wilh llic alterations and explanations and additions , or subtractions , made in them in thc intervening Grand Lodges , and incorporated wilh them , and the New Regulations represent those passed by Grand Lodge since 1723 , which explain ihe alterations of the Old . I admit

Anderson s " selling out " is not quite clear , but he clearly guards himself al p . 176—173 S against any alteration without the " consent of all the brethren , " ancl , therefore , he only , perhaps not in the most skilful way , sets out the general character of the Old Regulations , with subsequent expansion or addition , as made by proper authority .

Of course , Bro . Jacob Norton may fairly ask , How is it that we have these variations between the Regulations ot 1723 and the Regulations announced to be the same , and termed the Old , in 1738 , and why not keep tlie Old exactly as they were issued by Payne ? I answer , remembering that Anderson had the arrangement of both—that in 1723 and 1738 it is quite clear that Anderson acted fairly and deliberately " coram" the Grand

Lodge ; indeed , he could nol act otherwise , and as Payne must have approved of these changes , it is impossible that there can be any unauthorized change . It is also as clear lo me lhat we have in the Old Regulations as published in 1723 the actual representation of the original Regulation of 1 7 and 1721 . The Okl Regulations as published in 1738 are these , plus certain additions and subtractions made by authority .

I hope in ) - readers have followed me . The Regulations of 1723 are the Regulations of 1720 , 1 7 21 , and 1722 ; tin : " Old Regulations" of 1 738 are these " plus" successive modifications by Grand Lodge . The New Regulations of 1 73 S arc " explanations " of what the changes have been . I never could undei > tand why Anderson is to be attacked . He did what Grand Lotlge ordered him to do ; he digested the " Gothic Constitutions , "

or "Guild Legends , " into readable form and modernized verbiage ; and his history of Freemasonry is merely an amplification , flowing as it is , of the old " Guild History" and the " Masonic Legends" of Freemasonry . I could say a good deal more on the Regulations selected for illustration , because il i : > entile , clear to uie llial my esteemed Bro . Jacob Norton has not

quite mastered their ( rue bearing ; but I cannot hope to be permitted to-day to lie :. pas :, longer in these pages . All I can concede to Bro . Norton is that , perhaps , il would bc better to reprint NOIIIC day if neccssar } the alteration-, ; the Regulations of 1720 and 1721 , as publi-hed in 172 . *;; thc revi . eel ropy oi tbem , published in 173 ^ , wilh die New Regulations , or e \ planations of them , in lh . it year .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 2
  • You're on page3
  • 4
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy