Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Sept. 16, 1871
  • Page 3
  • FREEMASONRY & ISRAELITISM.
Current:

The Freemason, Sept. 16, 1871: Page 3

  • Back to The Freemason, Sept. 16, 1871
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article FREEMASONRY & ISRAELITISM. ← Page 3 of 3
    Article THE FORTHCOMING EDITION OF THE IRISH A HIMAN REZON. Page 1 of 2
    Article THE FORTHCOMING EDITION OF THE IRISH A HIMAN REZON. Page 1 of 2
    Article THE FORTHCOMING EDITION OF THE IRISH A HIMAN REZON. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemasonry & Israelitism.

While thus recounting the philanthropic and benevolent deeds of our race , I am not forgetful that there is another side to the picture . I have already said , we have much ignorance , much vice , and much misery amongst us , which challenge the attention

of all who are capable—and who is not ?—of aiding in their suppression . Much of the ignorance , and much of the , vice and crime which are its natural fruits , will be removed by the Education Act of 1871 , and by the extension of the Factory Acts to all children employed in trades and other occupations ;

while the modifications made , from time to time , in the Poor Law are bringing it much more in harmony with the national character for sympathy and benevolence . We have much to do before we shall fully recognise our obligations and faithfully discharge them . But we are going forward .

Meanwhile , " Let us all be up and , doing , With a heart for any fate ; Still achieving , still pursuing , Learn to labour and to wait ! "

The Forthcoming Edition Of The Irish A Himan Rezon.

THE FORTHCOMING EDITION OF THE IRISH A HIMAN REZON .

The article by our esteemed Bro . Hughan , on "The New Constitutions of Grand Lodge of Ireland , " in THE FREEMASON of

Sept . 2 nd , is another added to the many contributions for which the Craft at large have to thank him . It is useful , especially just now , as it calls attention to several

points that require careful consideration , and will help to " straighten" matters somewhat for the discussion of the various rules when they shall be submitted for confirmation to our Grand Lodge .

I have to thank him , personally , for the communication , as it enables me to say something on the subject , it having been brought forward and published by a brother not under the jurisdiction of our G . L . One

of our G . L . Rules prohibits the printing or publishing of any of the transactions of G . L ., of any private lodge , or of any Masonic committee , and also prohibits " any comment thereon , or reference thereto '' without

the permission of the G . L ., the G . M ., or the D . G . M ., and thus practically shuts us out from legally bringing before the Craft at

large many matters that might be advantageously considered in the pages of a Masonic journal . I hold that in Masonry , as in other organisations , free and full

discussion is most useful , and that there ought to be as little restriction as possible on Masonic discussion , which does not touch too closely on the " secrets and mysteries " of the Order ; but while the law exists , I of

course , feel bound to obey it , and might have felt some scruple in bringing forward , in the first instance , comments on our new laws . But as Bro . Hughan has opened the consideration of the subject , I feci myself

quite at liberty to deal with the matters referred to in his article . I quite agree with our valued brother , that " too much care cannot be observed in the making of new laws , " and as some of

the new laws now proposed mean more than , perhaps , appears at first sight , it would be well for the members of our Irish G . L . to be " wise in time , " so as to be prepared to deal at the proper time with regulations

that , if passed , may be applied so as to ' conserve" existing objectionable tendencies , and so as to interfere unwarrantably with the " rights and privileges" of individual

brethren . The first allusion to the new laws made £ y Bro . Hughan refers to the "Prayers to , be used in lodges . " He states that ,

The Forthcoming Edition Of The Irish A Himan Rezon.

" Although several are of a Christian character ( and actually as those used generally during the last century ) , other prayers ,

suitable for the most particular , are likewise inserted , and can be delivered by Jews , Turks , or Parsees with the greatest propriety . "

Now , I contend that the Grand Lodge should not put forward or sanction any prayer that could not be joined in conscientiously by not only " Jews , Turks , or Parsees , " but by any believer in God , no matter

under what form of worship or in what frame of words his religious belief may find expression . The grand leading idea of Masonry is , its unlimited tolerance in religious matters . Elsewhere , men may and do

differ widely and mischievously as to their estimate of the Supreme Being , and religious intolerance is at the bottom of many of those unhappy convulsions that in all ages and under various circumstances have

rent asunder the human race . Masonry holds out to us the one platform , ascending to which we leave behind us our differences of faith and creed , and meet together " on the level " as brethren of one universal

family , acknowledging one creating and protecting Parent . Prayer is an address to that Great Being whom we all acknowledge , and the Mason ' s prayer should be as simple and as comprehensive as the Mason ' s creed .

" I believe in one God , the Father Almighty , Maker of Heaven and Earth , and of all things visible and invisible , " is a creed to which every Mason can subscribe , but there it stops , and any attempt to Christianize

ourprayers , or to add to them the teachings of any of our "isms , " is a departure from our ancient landmarks , and an innovation dangerous to the stability of the Craft and insulting to many " good and true "

brethren . I have frequently been pained to hear the name of Him , whom I , as well as the great majority of our brethren here , acknowledge as the Saviour , used in Masonic prayers when those were present who do

not—and from their stand-point , cannotlook on Him in the same light ; and I cannot think that the introduction of His name on such occasions is altogether out of place in a Society that professes to admit all but

those who proclaim themselves Atheists . I know that there are those who would be , perhaps , disposed to look upon the expunging of Christian prayers from the Ritual of Craft and Royal Arch Masonry ( to which

alone my objections apply ) as an abandonment of " Christian principle , " and who would consider it their duty , "in seasonand out of season , " to advance what they believe to be " the truth . " To them I would sug-______ o

gest that it should be a matter for consideration of their conscience whether they should remain members of a Society which places all creeds and all doctrines on the same level , and refuses to allow either the

true or the false , as they consider them , expression within their boundaries ; and I would refer them to His teaching , " who spoke as never man spake , " Himself a Jew , while at the same the Founder of

Christianity , and remind them that he gave to His disciples a model prayer , which we Masons might , without the slightest inconsistency , adopt as ours . I knoiv that the use of Christian prayers at our lodges and in our

public meetings does give annoyance to our Jewish brethren , for example ; and trust that Grand Lodge will deal practically with the matter , bystriking out or altering the

alternative prayer where it assumes a Christian character . In Templar and Rose Croix Masonry , as a profession of Christianity is necessary , in Ireland , Christian prayers are of course useful and appropriate .

The Forthcoming Edition Of The Irish A Himan Rezon.

The law requiring P . M . 's to take out a certificate at a cost of 5 s . has been recently introduced , and whether it be the fee or the novelty , comparatively few P . M . ' s have since qualified themselves in that respect as

members of G . L . I trust they will see the necessity of at once doing this , so as to be entitled to give theirvotes on the new laws . As to the law by which Grand Officers and P . M . ' s retain their place in G . L . by a

payment of two pounds annually , without being at the same time subscribing members of any subordinate lodge , I agree with Bro . Hughan that it requires alteration . All

members of G . L . taking part , as they do , in thegovernment of the subordinate lodges , should be members of , and contribute to , the funds of some one or other of those

private lodges , and when they lose sight of what is , to some extent , their representative capacity , they are very apt to " give themselves airs , " and to assume a bearing which would in some cases be offensive , if it were not also ludicrous .

Rule No . 9 provides that visitors to G . L . shall not be admitted , except by permission of the presiding officers . It seems to me that an improvement would be , to give the right of admission to G . L . to all M . M . 's of

good standing . They must obey the rules made by G . L . They have an interest in knowing what is going on in the Craft at large , and as they cannot speak or vote in G . L . as M M . ' s , their presence would not be

likely to do any harm . Practically , they have always been admitted , with , I believe , one solitary exception , when they were for a short period of the meeting excluded to enable the presiding officer to keep out an

English visiting brother , whose presence , he was informed , might lead to discord . The wisdom of the course adopted on that occasion has been much questioned , and if any occasion should arise wherein it might

be deemed expedient to confine the meeting to G . L . members , all others might be directed to withdraw , by a resolution put to , and carried by , G . L . The rule giving into the hands of the

Grand Officers the nomination of their successors , is an innovation . Heretofore " The Board of General Purposes , " composed of representatives from the various lodges , nominated the Grand Officers , subject to

the vote of G . L ., any member of which could previously propose another candidate for any position . It is not the only point

on which an attempt is being made to curtail the privileges and action of the Board , and I am much mistaken if innovations in that direction will be submitted to .

Bro . Hughan s query on the 24 th proposed law is very pertinent , and I , for one , am of opinion that it is not " desirable to leave such an arbitrary power in the hands of the presiding officer . " I would be

disposed toadd to the rule givingdiscretionary power to the presiding officer to reject any notice of motion which he may deem "improper , unlawful , or inconsistent with

the ancient landmarks of the Order , " a clause giving the right of appeal to the next meeting of Grand Lodge , which meeting shall decide whether such notice of motion

shall , or shall not , be received . There will probably be a good deal of discussion on the 30 th rule , and I am not so sure as Bro . Hughan appears to be that " the members can , and no doubt will , carry

this regulation ; " at least , I think it will be modified in some such way as he suggests . As the rule is a very important one , and contains an " innovation" evidently contrived for a particular purpose , I quote it as it stands : — " 30 . The Grand Lodge strictly prohibits ai

“The Freemason: 1871-09-16, Page 3” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_16091871/page/3/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 1
FREEMASONRY & ISRAELITISM. Article 1
THE FORTHCOMING EDITION OF THE IRISH A HIMAN REZON. Article 3
CONSECRATION OF THE PANMURE MARK LODGE, No. No.I39. Article 4
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Ad 6
Untitled Article 6
GRAND LODGE. Article 6
THE "FREEMASON" LIFE BOAT. Article 7
Multum in Parbo, or Masonic Notes and Queries. Article 7
Original Correspondence. Article 8
THE FREEMASONS' LIFE BOAT. Article 9
COARSE ORATION OF THE .UNITED SERVICE LODGE, No. I36I. Article 9
Reports of Masonic Meetings. Article 9
ORDERS OF CHIVALRY. Article 10
Foreign Masonic Intelligence. Article 10
CANADA. Article 10
NEW ZEALAND. Article 11
Poetry. Article 12
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS Article 12
Untitled Ad 12
Untitled Ad 12
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

8 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

4 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

5 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 3

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemasonry & Israelitism.

While thus recounting the philanthropic and benevolent deeds of our race , I am not forgetful that there is another side to the picture . I have already said , we have much ignorance , much vice , and much misery amongst us , which challenge the attention

of all who are capable—and who is not ?—of aiding in their suppression . Much of the ignorance , and much of the , vice and crime which are its natural fruits , will be removed by the Education Act of 1871 , and by the extension of the Factory Acts to all children employed in trades and other occupations ;

while the modifications made , from time to time , in the Poor Law are bringing it much more in harmony with the national character for sympathy and benevolence . We have much to do before we shall fully recognise our obligations and faithfully discharge them . But we are going forward .

Meanwhile , " Let us all be up and , doing , With a heart for any fate ; Still achieving , still pursuing , Learn to labour and to wait ! "

The Forthcoming Edition Of The Irish A Himan Rezon.

THE FORTHCOMING EDITION OF THE IRISH A HIMAN REZON .

The article by our esteemed Bro . Hughan , on "The New Constitutions of Grand Lodge of Ireland , " in THE FREEMASON of

Sept . 2 nd , is another added to the many contributions for which the Craft at large have to thank him . It is useful , especially just now , as it calls attention to several

points that require careful consideration , and will help to " straighten" matters somewhat for the discussion of the various rules when they shall be submitted for confirmation to our Grand Lodge .

I have to thank him , personally , for the communication , as it enables me to say something on the subject , it having been brought forward and published by a brother not under the jurisdiction of our G . L . One

of our G . L . Rules prohibits the printing or publishing of any of the transactions of G . L ., of any private lodge , or of any Masonic committee , and also prohibits " any comment thereon , or reference thereto '' without

the permission of the G . L ., the G . M ., or the D . G . M ., and thus practically shuts us out from legally bringing before the Craft at

large many matters that might be advantageously considered in the pages of a Masonic journal . I hold that in Masonry , as in other organisations , free and full

discussion is most useful , and that there ought to be as little restriction as possible on Masonic discussion , which does not touch too closely on the " secrets and mysteries " of the Order ; but while the law exists , I of

course , feel bound to obey it , and might have felt some scruple in bringing forward , in the first instance , comments on our new laws . But as Bro . Hughan has opened the consideration of the subject , I feci myself

quite at liberty to deal with the matters referred to in his article . I quite agree with our valued brother , that " too much care cannot be observed in the making of new laws , " and as some of

the new laws now proposed mean more than , perhaps , appears at first sight , it would be well for the members of our Irish G . L . to be " wise in time , " so as to be prepared to deal at the proper time with regulations

that , if passed , may be applied so as to ' conserve" existing objectionable tendencies , and so as to interfere unwarrantably with the " rights and privileges" of individual

brethren . The first allusion to the new laws made £ y Bro . Hughan refers to the "Prayers to , be used in lodges . " He states that ,

The Forthcoming Edition Of The Irish A Himan Rezon.

" Although several are of a Christian character ( and actually as those used generally during the last century ) , other prayers ,

suitable for the most particular , are likewise inserted , and can be delivered by Jews , Turks , or Parsees with the greatest propriety . "

Now , I contend that the Grand Lodge should not put forward or sanction any prayer that could not be joined in conscientiously by not only " Jews , Turks , or Parsees , " but by any believer in God , no matter

under what form of worship or in what frame of words his religious belief may find expression . The grand leading idea of Masonry is , its unlimited tolerance in religious matters . Elsewhere , men may and do

differ widely and mischievously as to their estimate of the Supreme Being , and religious intolerance is at the bottom of many of those unhappy convulsions that in all ages and under various circumstances have

rent asunder the human race . Masonry holds out to us the one platform , ascending to which we leave behind us our differences of faith and creed , and meet together " on the level " as brethren of one universal

family , acknowledging one creating and protecting Parent . Prayer is an address to that Great Being whom we all acknowledge , and the Mason ' s prayer should be as simple and as comprehensive as the Mason ' s creed .

" I believe in one God , the Father Almighty , Maker of Heaven and Earth , and of all things visible and invisible , " is a creed to which every Mason can subscribe , but there it stops , and any attempt to Christianize

ourprayers , or to add to them the teachings of any of our "isms , " is a departure from our ancient landmarks , and an innovation dangerous to the stability of the Craft and insulting to many " good and true "

brethren . I have frequently been pained to hear the name of Him , whom I , as well as the great majority of our brethren here , acknowledge as the Saviour , used in Masonic prayers when those were present who do

not—and from their stand-point , cannotlook on Him in the same light ; and I cannot think that the introduction of His name on such occasions is altogether out of place in a Society that professes to admit all but

those who proclaim themselves Atheists . I know that there are those who would be , perhaps , disposed to look upon the expunging of Christian prayers from the Ritual of Craft and Royal Arch Masonry ( to which

alone my objections apply ) as an abandonment of " Christian principle , " and who would consider it their duty , "in seasonand out of season , " to advance what they believe to be " the truth . " To them I would sug-______ o

gest that it should be a matter for consideration of their conscience whether they should remain members of a Society which places all creeds and all doctrines on the same level , and refuses to allow either the

true or the false , as they consider them , expression within their boundaries ; and I would refer them to His teaching , " who spoke as never man spake , " Himself a Jew , while at the same the Founder of

Christianity , and remind them that he gave to His disciples a model prayer , which we Masons might , without the slightest inconsistency , adopt as ours . I knoiv that the use of Christian prayers at our lodges and in our

public meetings does give annoyance to our Jewish brethren , for example ; and trust that Grand Lodge will deal practically with the matter , bystriking out or altering the

alternative prayer where it assumes a Christian character . In Templar and Rose Croix Masonry , as a profession of Christianity is necessary , in Ireland , Christian prayers are of course useful and appropriate .

The Forthcoming Edition Of The Irish A Himan Rezon.

The law requiring P . M . 's to take out a certificate at a cost of 5 s . has been recently introduced , and whether it be the fee or the novelty , comparatively few P . M . ' s have since qualified themselves in that respect as

members of G . L . I trust they will see the necessity of at once doing this , so as to be entitled to give theirvotes on the new laws . As to the law by which Grand Officers and P . M . ' s retain their place in G . L . by a

payment of two pounds annually , without being at the same time subscribing members of any subordinate lodge , I agree with Bro . Hughan that it requires alteration . All

members of G . L . taking part , as they do , in thegovernment of the subordinate lodges , should be members of , and contribute to , the funds of some one or other of those

private lodges , and when they lose sight of what is , to some extent , their representative capacity , they are very apt to " give themselves airs , " and to assume a bearing which would in some cases be offensive , if it were not also ludicrous .

Rule No . 9 provides that visitors to G . L . shall not be admitted , except by permission of the presiding officers . It seems to me that an improvement would be , to give the right of admission to G . L . to all M . M . 's of

good standing . They must obey the rules made by G . L . They have an interest in knowing what is going on in the Craft at large , and as they cannot speak or vote in G . L . as M M . ' s , their presence would not be

likely to do any harm . Practically , they have always been admitted , with , I believe , one solitary exception , when they were for a short period of the meeting excluded to enable the presiding officer to keep out an

English visiting brother , whose presence , he was informed , might lead to discord . The wisdom of the course adopted on that occasion has been much questioned , and if any occasion should arise wherein it might

be deemed expedient to confine the meeting to G . L . members , all others might be directed to withdraw , by a resolution put to , and carried by , G . L . The rule giving into the hands of the

Grand Officers the nomination of their successors , is an innovation . Heretofore " The Board of General Purposes , " composed of representatives from the various lodges , nominated the Grand Officers , subject to

the vote of G . L ., any member of which could previously propose another candidate for any position . It is not the only point

on which an attempt is being made to curtail the privileges and action of the Board , and I am much mistaken if innovations in that direction will be submitted to .

Bro . Hughan s query on the 24 th proposed law is very pertinent , and I , for one , am of opinion that it is not " desirable to leave such an arbitrary power in the hands of the presiding officer . " I would be

disposed toadd to the rule givingdiscretionary power to the presiding officer to reject any notice of motion which he may deem "improper , unlawful , or inconsistent with

the ancient landmarks of the Order , " a clause giving the right of appeal to the next meeting of Grand Lodge , which meeting shall decide whether such notice of motion

shall , or shall not , be received . There will probably be a good deal of discussion on the 30 th rule , and I am not so sure as Bro . Hughan appears to be that " the members can , and no doubt will , carry

this regulation ; " at least , I think it will be modified in some such way as he suggests . As the rule is a very important one , and contains an " innovation" evidently contrived for a particular purpose , I quote it as it stands : — " 30 . The Grand Lodge strictly prohibits ai

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 2
  • You're on page3
  • 4
  • 12
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy