Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Dec. 20, 1873
  • Page 10
Current:

The Freemason, Dec. 20, 1873: Page 10

  • Back to The Freemason, Dec. 20, 1873
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article WEEKLY SUMMARY. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article Original Correspondence. Page 1 of 2
    Article Original Correspondence. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Weekly Summary.

Westminster Abbey , the consecration sermon being preached by Archdeacon Pott . Mr . Jean Luie , a very important witness for the prisoner in the Tichborne trial , has been discovered to be a convict with a ticket-of-leave , of

the name of Lundgren , and has been committed accordingly by Sir Thomas Henry to the Middle sex House of Detention , on the charge of" having forfeited his licence as a convict of ticket-of-leave , by neglecting to report ^ himself at intervals to the proper authorities . "

Four railway accidents , more or less serious , have occurred during the last few days , the worst being a double collision near Bolton , on the Lancashire and Yorkshire , by which ten passengers were severely injured , and several others slightly . The news from- the Gold Coast is not

important . Sir Garnet Wolseley is still aboard the Simoom , but able to attend to business , and is awaiting the fine brigade now on their way . In the meantime every preparation is made for an advance , and every precaution is taken to ensure the health of the troops . Commodore Hewitt has assumed the naval command .

At the Cape of Good Hope , a skirmish has ensued in Natal , between " Langilabile , " a Caffre chief , and some thirty carabineers , under Major Durnford ; in which three Englishmen lost their lives . It is to be hoped that this unfortunate event may not lead to another " little

Caffre War . " Sir S . R . Baker has given a most interesting account of his expedition , before a select audience presided over by H . R . H . the Duke of Cambridge , the Commander-in-Chief .

A furious gale has raged since early Tuesday morning , all through Yorkshire , and extending into Scotland , causing much damage to property . In Foreign news , there is not a great deal to notice .

Marshal Bazaine , despite thc eloquence of Maitre Lachaud , has been unanimously condemned to death and military degradation by the court martial , but Marshal McMnhon has commuted the sentence into seclusion for twenty years , and removal from thc army .

We are not politicians , anel only profess to record events , but we cannot help thinking this prosecution of Marshal Bazaine a great mistake , as it is impossible after the event to judge of much that a General commanding has to take into account .

The French joke about poor Admiral Byng returns to our memory , for certainly it would seem , as if the intense desire manifested by some to punish and shoot an old soldier was " pour encourager les autres" !

The Dutch have hael a successful landing at Acheen—and will probably soon master the outbreak in their colony . Carthagena has not yet surrendered , and the Carlist movement seems at a stand still .

The Virginius has been surrendered to the United Stales , so that all possibility e ) f war is arrested . But the great question of compensation remains for British anel American subjectsille-gally put to death .

We have to announce with regret thc death of Mr . Winterbotham , M . P ., Uiv !< r Secretary of State in the Home Department , who dieel at Rome , where he had geme for the benefit of his health , on Saturday .

The death of the Queen Dowager of Prussia is also announced , as also that of Professor Agassiz .

Thc Editor of the" Bauhutte" has founded at Florence an establishment for the sale eif German anel English books . We have much pleasure in introducing the same to the notice of our mam' readers who may visit the fair city ,

feeling assured that they will meet with every attention from those in charge . The address is •Messrs . Flor and Findel , German and Foreign

Booksellers , 24 , Lung Arno Acciajoli Florence , Italy . Prints , photographs , pictures , and English stationery , are also kept in stock . — AllVT .

Original Correspondence.

Original Correspondence .

FRUGALITY AND PHILANTHROPE

To the Editor of the Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother , — BrodGottheil , in his able letter ' of Saturday last , though he has put forward his view of the subject with great power and perspicuity , has not quite represented the whole truth of

the matter . I quite agree with Bro . Gottheil that it would be most undesirable if even it were possible , to curtailthe " amusements of the people , " or to interfere ' unnecessarily with the social arrangements of our lodges , which I quite admit are not

only most needful but most beneficial for our Craft . But the real question is , whether our system may not admit of some little amendment , and whether , in our present regulations on ' the subject , we quite do justice either to our lodges or our own feelings , or best promote the interests

of charity , and the general welfare and progress of Freemasonry . I quite endorse Bro . Gottheil ' s view that where the bye-laws of a lodge require a certain amount of annual subscripfion , and that for that sum certain banquets are specified among the

privileges of the members , they receive in fact , only their " quid pro quo , " and cannot fairly be said to employ the lotige funds for eating and drinking . At thc same time I say this , I do not think those good bye-laws , which provide for any banquets out eif the lodge subscriptions .

For let us see how this system works . Phere are three systems in fact at present in vogue amongst us . One is the system which fixes the subscription at a given sum , and provides in the bye-laws for so many banquets gratis to thc brethren yearly . l'he second is the system

which calls upon the members of the lodge for a certain annual subscription , but says nothing about banquets , and when in conseejuence the expenses for refreshment are paid by the brethren personally each lodge night , and collected by the Stewards .

' We must always bear in mind that while in London , and a few of our larger towns thc loelges may be termed , without offc-nce , dinner lodges , that is , where work is followed by a regular dinner , the great majority of our Provincial Lodges only have as a general rule supper after

their labours , a much lighter and less expensive kind of refreshment . There is a third system where the subscription is at the minimum , and where the loelge provides the " eatables , " but where the Stewards provide the " drinkables , "

and each brother , lo use a homely term , " pays his own shot . " I do not purpose in this letter to pass any jutlgment , anel least of all to cast any imputation upon either of these systems , or the Brethren who uphold advisedly , one or the other of them .

But the ellect certainl y of the present system is , that a large proportion of our lodges do not subscribe as lodges to any of the Masonic Charities , and though the names of the brethren appear tin the list , the loelges themselves are not to be found there—with some happy anel

honourable exceptions . Bros . Hughan and Iloelge's , in their remarks , have been actuated by a desire tei increase our charitable returns , anel certainly tlie fact stated , if true , ought to suggest serious thought , namely that more than one loelge is in debt for the dinner fund , and is unable to do anything for charity .

I his discussitm will have this one good result . Let us hope that it will make some of us think , and if it only elicits one or two more as able letters as Bro . Gottheil ' s is , it will shew what I have always said , how great is the latent and dormant talent ofthe Craft . I am , yours fraternally , AN - OLD P . M . AND P . Z .

NOT GENERALLY KNOWN . To the Editor of ihe I ' iceiiiasoii . Dear Sir and Brother , — I elo not , I confess , at all appreciate 01

admire liro . Jacob Norton ' s constant allusion to his " credulous brethren" in America , of whom , according to his own view , many " thousands " exist . If our good brother possesses so much more

Original Correspondence.

light than his brethren generally , he should seek to enlighten them in a kind , courteous , and Masonic way . It is not Masonic always to be dwelling on the supposed ignorance or credulity of others ; when some might think , that , Bro . Jacob Norton ,

earnest as he is , pushes his cavils to the verge of absolute scepticism , and might say , fairly enough , " It is better to believe too much than too little . " T am , yours fraternally , NEMO .

HONORARY MEMBERS . To the Editor of the Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother ,- — In reply to " An Enquirer , " honorary members cannot vote in lodge , and certainly cannot ballot for candidates for admission .

None but bona fide subscribing members to the lodge can vote or ballot . I am , yours fraternally , DRACO .

BRO . BIGG AND THE MIDDLESEX LODGE .

To the Editor of The Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother , — The letter of " P . M . " , which appears in your columns of the 1 , 3 th inst , courts a reply from me to two questions , whicli I have no

hesitation in giving , though I confess I have a dislike to anonymous correspondents . Possibly our worthy brother witholds his name , lest Bro . Salmon or myself should offer him the opportunity of enjoying our hospitality and thus disturb the balance of his fraternal impartiality .

ist . When the W . M . of the Middlesex , came over to where I stood , and asked me to retire from the lodge until my introducer arrived , I said " All Masons were eligible to attend lodges and that it was not the rule of my lodge to expel brethren under such circumstances . " Bro . Salmon told me in courteous terms ; ' It is our rule , and I advise you to withdraw . "

2 nd . The W . M . never hinted at the idea of " trying anel proving" me , nor did I in the face of such a peremptory rule as the above , venture to obt . ude myself on the brethren of the Middlesex Lodge . I respectfully submit that the question at

issue is not one involving " boorishness and inhospitality either , or caution and fidelity . " It goes at the very root of " Masonry and its princi ples . " It proclaims that the " Equality among Masons " is an axiom enforced in theory , but eschewed in practice ,

and that the maxims of " meeting on the level and parting on the square " isa practical Masonic joke . It admits of class lodges encouraging exclusiveness , and divests Masonry of its most attractive characteristic .

I never did , and I trust never shall attempt to thrust myself into any society where my presence would be objectionable , hence I withdrew on this occasion to the " convenient room adjoining the loelge , " awaiting the arrival of my introducers .

In conclusion I may remark that had thc W . M . and his Wardens performed the duties expected of them by Granel Loelge , they would have attended the last quarterly communication , and would have recognised me as the mover of the first resolution on tho Agenda , but possibly I may be too much like the editor of the

Eatunswill Gazette , who , when he had written a slashing leader denouncing everything anel everybody , finding he had created no sensation , and was unrecognised , remarked " Good God ! and this is popularity !" Yours fraternally , FREDERICK BIGG , W . M .. 1261 . P . M . 66 .

To lite Editor 0 / The Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother , — I waited till your publication succeeding that which gave an account of Bro . P . M . Bigg ' s reception and dismissal at ihe Middlesex Lodge

appeared , and which 1 de not hesitate to say was an outrage on the principles of Freemasonry , and may now be fitl y so called ; no explanation or apology having appeared in your columns from any member of that lodge .

“The Freemason: 1873-12-20, Page 10” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 25 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_20121873/page/10/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 3
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 3
Scotland. Article 6
Royal Arch. Article 7
Mark Masonry. Article 7
Ancient and Accepted Rite . Article 7
MASONIC FEMALE ORPHAN SCHOOL, DUBLIN. Article 7
Untitled Article 8
Answers to Correspondents. Article 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Ad 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Article 8
THE LATE PAPAL RESCRIPT. Article 8
OTHER ATTACKS ON FREEMASONRY. Article 9
WEEKLY SUMMARY. Article 9
Original Correspondence. Article 10
PROVINCIAL GRAND MARK LODGE. Article 12
CONSECRATION OF A NEW LODGE AT PORT WILLIAM, WIGTOWNSHIRE. Article 12
RESTORATION OF ST. ALBAN'S ABBEY. Article 12
Reviews. Article 13
Masonic Tidings. Article 13
THE FIRST GRAND LODGE IN AMERICA. Article 14
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 14
MASONIC MEETINGS IN LIVERPOOL,&c. Article 15
MASONIC MEETINGS IN GLASGOW. Article 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Article 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

20 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

24 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

4 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

6 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

11 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

5 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

7 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

15 Articles
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Weekly Summary.

Westminster Abbey , the consecration sermon being preached by Archdeacon Pott . Mr . Jean Luie , a very important witness for the prisoner in the Tichborne trial , has been discovered to be a convict with a ticket-of-leave , of

the name of Lundgren , and has been committed accordingly by Sir Thomas Henry to the Middle sex House of Detention , on the charge of" having forfeited his licence as a convict of ticket-of-leave , by neglecting to report ^ himself at intervals to the proper authorities . "

Four railway accidents , more or less serious , have occurred during the last few days , the worst being a double collision near Bolton , on the Lancashire and Yorkshire , by which ten passengers were severely injured , and several others slightly . The news from- the Gold Coast is not

important . Sir Garnet Wolseley is still aboard the Simoom , but able to attend to business , and is awaiting the fine brigade now on their way . In the meantime every preparation is made for an advance , and every precaution is taken to ensure the health of the troops . Commodore Hewitt has assumed the naval command .

At the Cape of Good Hope , a skirmish has ensued in Natal , between " Langilabile , " a Caffre chief , and some thirty carabineers , under Major Durnford ; in which three Englishmen lost their lives . It is to be hoped that this unfortunate event may not lead to another " little

Caffre War . " Sir S . R . Baker has given a most interesting account of his expedition , before a select audience presided over by H . R . H . the Duke of Cambridge , the Commander-in-Chief .

A furious gale has raged since early Tuesday morning , all through Yorkshire , and extending into Scotland , causing much damage to property . In Foreign news , there is not a great deal to notice .

Marshal Bazaine , despite thc eloquence of Maitre Lachaud , has been unanimously condemned to death and military degradation by the court martial , but Marshal McMnhon has commuted the sentence into seclusion for twenty years , and removal from thc army .

We are not politicians , anel only profess to record events , but we cannot help thinking this prosecution of Marshal Bazaine a great mistake , as it is impossible after the event to judge of much that a General commanding has to take into account .

The French joke about poor Admiral Byng returns to our memory , for certainly it would seem , as if the intense desire manifested by some to punish and shoot an old soldier was " pour encourager les autres" !

The Dutch have hael a successful landing at Acheen—and will probably soon master the outbreak in their colony . Carthagena has not yet surrendered , and the Carlist movement seems at a stand still .

The Virginius has been surrendered to the United Stales , so that all possibility e ) f war is arrested . But the great question of compensation remains for British anel American subjectsille-gally put to death .

We have to announce with regret thc death of Mr . Winterbotham , M . P ., Uiv !< r Secretary of State in the Home Department , who dieel at Rome , where he had geme for the benefit of his health , on Saturday .

The death of the Queen Dowager of Prussia is also announced , as also that of Professor Agassiz .

Thc Editor of the" Bauhutte" has founded at Florence an establishment for the sale eif German anel English books . We have much pleasure in introducing the same to the notice of our mam' readers who may visit the fair city ,

feeling assured that they will meet with every attention from those in charge . The address is •Messrs . Flor and Findel , German and Foreign

Booksellers , 24 , Lung Arno Acciajoli Florence , Italy . Prints , photographs , pictures , and English stationery , are also kept in stock . — AllVT .

Original Correspondence.

Original Correspondence .

FRUGALITY AND PHILANTHROPE

To the Editor of the Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother , — BrodGottheil , in his able letter ' of Saturday last , though he has put forward his view of the subject with great power and perspicuity , has not quite represented the whole truth of

the matter . I quite agree with Bro . Gottheil that it would be most undesirable if even it were possible , to curtailthe " amusements of the people , " or to interfere ' unnecessarily with the social arrangements of our lodges , which I quite admit are not

only most needful but most beneficial for our Craft . But the real question is , whether our system may not admit of some little amendment , and whether , in our present regulations on ' the subject , we quite do justice either to our lodges or our own feelings , or best promote the interests

of charity , and the general welfare and progress of Freemasonry . I quite endorse Bro . Gottheil ' s view that where the bye-laws of a lodge require a certain amount of annual subscripfion , and that for that sum certain banquets are specified among the

privileges of the members , they receive in fact , only their " quid pro quo , " and cannot fairly be said to employ the lotige funds for eating and drinking . At thc same time I say this , I do not think those good bye-laws , which provide for any banquets out eif the lodge subscriptions .

For let us see how this system works . Phere are three systems in fact at present in vogue amongst us . One is the system which fixes the subscription at a given sum , and provides in the bye-laws for so many banquets gratis to thc brethren yearly . l'he second is the system

which calls upon the members of the lodge for a certain annual subscription , but says nothing about banquets , and when in conseejuence the expenses for refreshment are paid by the brethren personally each lodge night , and collected by the Stewards .

' We must always bear in mind that while in London , and a few of our larger towns thc loelges may be termed , without offc-nce , dinner lodges , that is , where work is followed by a regular dinner , the great majority of our Provincial Lodges only have as a general rule supper after

their labours , a much lighter and less expensive kind of refreshment . There is a third system where the subscription is at the minimum , and where the loelge provides the " eatables , " but where the Stewards provide the " drinkables , "

and each brother , lo use a homely term , " pays his own shot . " I do not purpose in this letter to pass any jutlgment , anel least of all to cast any imputation upon either of these systems , or the Brethren who uphold advisedly , one or the other of them .

But the ellect certainl y of the present system is , that a large proportion of our lodges do not subscribe as lodges to any of the Masonic Charities , and though the names of the brethren appear tin the list , the loelges themselves are not to be found there—with some happy anel

honourable exceptions . Bros . Hughan and Iloelge's , in their remarks , have been actuated by a desire tei increase our charitable returns , anel certainly tlie fact stated , if true , ought to suggest serious thought , namely that more than one loelge is in debt for the dinner fund , and is unable to do anything for charity .

I his discussitm will have this one good result . Let us hope that it will make some of us think , and if it only elicits one or two more as able letters as Bro . Gottheil ' s is , it will shew what I have always said , how great is the latent and dormant talent ofthe Craft . I am , yours fraternally , AN - OLD P . M . AND P . Z .

NOT GENERALLY KNOWN . To the Editor of ihe I ' iceiiiasoii . Dear Sir and Brother , — I elo not , I confess , at all appreciate 01

admire liro . Jacob Norton ' s constant allusion to his " credulous brethren" in America , of whom , according to his own view , many " thousands " exist . If our good brother possesses so much more

Original Correspondence.

light than his brethren generally , he should seek to enlighten them in a kind , courteous , and Masonic way . It is not Masonic always to be dwelling on the supposed ignorance or credulity of others ; when some might think , that , Bro . Jacob Norton ,

earnest as he is , pushes his cavils to the verge of absolute scepticism , and might say , fairly enough , " It is better to believe too much than too little . " T am , yours fraternally , NEMO .

HONORARY MEMBERS . To the Editor of the Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother ,- — In reply to " An Enquirer , " honorary members cannot vote in lodge , and certainly cannot ballot for candidates for admission .

None but bona fide subscribing members to the lodge can vote or ballot . I am , yours fraternally , DRACO .

BRO . BIGG AND THE MIDDLESEX LODGE .

To the Editor of The Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother , — The letter of " P . M . " , which appears in your columns of the 1 , 3 th inst , courts a reply from me to two questions , whicli I have no

hesitation in giving , though I confess I have a dislike to anonymous correspondents . Possibly our worthy brother witholds his name , lest Bro . Salmon or myself should offer him the opportunity of enjoying our hospitality and thus disturb the balance of his fraternal impartiality .

ist . When the W . M . of the Middlesex , came over to where I stood , and asked me to retire from the lodge until my introducer arrived , I said " All Masons were eligible to attend lodges and that it was not the rule of my lodge to expel brethren under such circumstances . " Bro . Salmon told me in courteous terms ; ' It is our rule , and I advise you to withdraw . "

2 nd . The W . M . never hinted at the idea of " trying anel proving" me , nor did I in the face of such a peremptory rule as the above , venture to obt . ude myself on the brethren of the Middlesex Lodge . I respectfully submit that the question at

issue is not one involving " boorishness and inhospitality either , or caution and fidelity . " It goes at the very root of " Masonry and its princi ples . " It proclaims that the " Equality among Masons " is an axiom enforced in theory , but eschewed in practice ,

and that the maxims of " meeting on the level and parting on the square " isa practical Masonic joke . It admits of class lodges encouraging exclusiveness , and divests Masonry of its most attractive characteristic .

I never did , and I trust never shall attempt to thrust myself into any society where my presence would be objectionable , hence I withdrew on this occasion to the " convenient room adjoining the loelge , " awaiting the arrival of my introducers .

In conclusion I may remark that had thc W . M . and his Wardens performed the duties expected of them by Granel Loelge , they would have attended the last quarterly communication , and would have recognised me as the mover of the first resolution on tho Agenda , but possibly I may be too much like the editor of the

Eatunswill Gazette , who , when he had written a slashing leader denouncing everything anel everybody , finding he had created no sensation , and was unrecognised , remarked " Good God ! and this is popularity !" Yours fraternally , FREDERICK BIGG , W . M .. 1261 . P . M . 66 .

To lite Editor 0 / The Freemason . Dear Sir and Brother , — I waited till your publication succeeding that which gave an account of Bro . P . M . Bigg ' s reception and dismissal at ihe Middlesex Lodge

appeared , and which 1 de not hesitate to say was an outrage on the principles of Freemasonry , and may now be fitl y so called ; no explanation or apology having appeared in your columns from any member of that lodge .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 9
  • You're on page10
  • 11
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy