Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • May 24, 1873
  • Page 11
  • Multum in Parbo, or Masonic Notes and Queries.
Current:

The Freemason, May 24, 1873: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemason, May 24, 1873
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article INTERESTING MASONIC PRESENTATIONS IN LIVERPOOL. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article CONSECRATION OF A NEW MARK LODGE AT ROCK FERRY. Page 1 of 1
    Article Red Cross of Constantine. Page 1 of 1
    Article Masonic Tidings. Page 1 of 1
    Article Multum in Parbo, or Masonic Notes and Queries. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Interesting Masonic Presentations In Liverpool.

spoke in eloquent terms of his many excellent qualities . Bro . Danson briefly thanked the W . M . and brethren for their kindness , spoke of his beincr

connected with the lodge since its beginning , assured everyone that he had , to the best of his ability , endeavoured to perform his duty in whatever position he was placed , and would strive in the future to make any amends for past

shortcomings . During thc evening , on the motion of Bro . P . M . Marsh , seconded by Bro . R . Washington , J . ., the lodge unanimously agreed to the recommendation that Bro . Danson should be made a Life Governor of the West Lancashire

Masonic Educational Institution , the necessary amount being furnished from the " charity-box , " which has already done good work in this respect on many previous occasions . The brethren , after business , sat down to an excellent banquet .

Consecration Of A New Mark Lodge At Rock Ferry.

CONSECRATION OF A NEW MARK LODGE AT ROCK FERRY .

That this degree is making good progress in Cheshire cannot be doubted , for little more than a month has elapsed since the Provincial Grand Mark Lodge of Cheshire and North Wales was established , under the rule of Bro . the Hon .

Wilbrahani Egerton , M . P ., the present W . M ., of the Joppa Mark Lodge , No . n , Birkenhead , and on Monday ,: the 12 th inst ., a new Mark Lodge was consecrated at the Rock Ferry Hotel , the first riewr . one ! under Bro . Egerton ' s jurisdiction , and bearing his name .

; " The . Egerton Lodge , No . 165 , was formed b y those-who some four years ago inaugurated the Craft Lodge at Rock Ferry , now thriving so well , and there can be little doubt that the new Mark Lodge will be equally successful . It was a matter of great regret that owing to

a very important engagement , the D . P . G . M ., Bro . the Rev . C . W . Spencer Stanhope , who had been appointed by the M . W . G . M . M . to perform the ceremonies , was unable to be present , but a very able substitute was there in the person of Bro . W . Romaine Callender , R . W . P . G . M . M . of

Lancashire . He was supported by the following Provincial Officers of Cheshire and North Wales : Bros . Rev . J . W . Newell Tanner , P . G . Chaplain ; Wm . Bullev , P . J . G . W . ; R . Newhouse , P . G . Sec . ; Thos . Piatt , P . G . Treas . ; Jos . Sillitoe , P . G . S . O . ; Capt . Watson , P . G . f . O .

E . Friend , P . G . D . C . ; Geo . Higgins , P . G . S . B . ; J . S . Mort , P . G . P . ; Thos . Kent , J . Heap , G . H . Wilson , P . Grand Stewards ; and John Worthington , P . G . Tyler . Among the visitors were Bros . J . P . Piatt ,

P . P . G . M . O ., Lancashire ; Tysilio Johnson and J . M . Radcliffe , of the Joppa Lodge , No . ir . The Mark Lodge was opened in due form by Bro . F . K . Stevenson , P . M . 11 , P . G . S . D ., and Bro . Callender and Officers admitted , and greeted with the usual honours .

Bro . Callender then proceeded to consecrate and constitute the Egerton Lodge of Mark Masons , according to ancient form , after which he installed Bro . Friend in the chair , who received the customary salutes .

The W . M . then appointed and invested his officers , Bro . S . Spratly , M . D ., being unanimously elected Treasurer , and Bro . Holtoway , Tyler . Bros . F . K . Stevenson , S . W . j R . H . Moore , J . W . j Lilley Ellis , Sec ; Spratly , Treas . ; G . H . Wilson , M . O . ; F . L . Bolton , S . O . ; Alex . Low , J . O . ; J . W . Paton , M . D ., S . D . ; Stanton

J . D . j Sanderson , I . G . ; Holtoway , Tyler . Bro . Tysilio Johnson was elected an honorary member , A cordial vote of thanks was then recorded on the minutes to the R . W . Bro . Callender , for his extreme kindness in coming at great inconvenience to perform the ceremonies , also to the Rev . C . W . Spencer Stanhope , for his present of a handsome bible .

Several brethren were proposed for advancement , and the P . G . M . M . and officers then withdrew . Thelodge was then closed , and the brethren dined together . Bro . Friend , W . M ., presided , and was

supported b y Bro . Callender , and the other Provincial officers and brethren . The usual loyal and Masonic toasts were heartil y responded to , and the brethren separated at an earl y hour , after a most harmonious meeting .

Red Cross Of Constantine.

Red Cross of Constantine .

CONSECRATION OF A RED CROSS CONCLAVE ATBROOKLYN , NEW YORK . The interesting and imposing ceremonies of inaugurating , dedicating , and installing the officers

of a new conclave of the Imperial Ecclesiastical , and Military Order of Knights ofthe Red Cross of Constantine and Rome , and K . H . S ., under the title of Saxa Rubra Conclave , No . 6 9 , were

performed on Tuesday evening last , in the elegant rooms of Dr . Witt Clinton Commandery , No . 27 , Brooklyn , under the auspices and by the authority of Sir Albert G . Goodall , 33 ° , Most Illustrious Grand Sovereign ofthe State . After the ceremonies of inaugurating and

dedicating the conclave , the following officers and members were installed and constituted in ample form , with full power to do and perform all proper and lawful acts thereunto belonging : —E . Sir Robert Macoy , Grand Recorder of the State Conclave , First Sovereign ; Charles Aikman , First Viceroy ; J . Anson Foster , G . W . Gritman ,

John Z . Johnson . Erskine H . Dickey , Robert P . Lethbridge , Charles II . Peck , James D . Kingsland , Caleb A . Eairy , and Joseph L . Edwards . The charter , authorizing the establishment of this conclave , emanates from the Grand Imperial Council at London , the Right Hon . the Earl of Bective , Grand Sovereign .

1 his ancient and chivalric Order of Constantine having for many years enjoyed the patronage and protection of the most distinguished members of the Masonic body , the Grand Mastership having been held for many years , and up to the time of his death , by the Duke of Sussex . None but Knights Templar are admitted to membership in this country . —New York Dispatch .

MANCHESTER . —County Palatine Conclave ( No . 50 ) . —The meeting of this conclave took place on Saturday , the 17 th inst ., at Freemasons ' Hall . Thc chair of C . was occupied by 111 . Sir Knt . C . Fitzgerald Matier , P . S ., in the absence of 111 . Sir Knt . W . Romaine Callender , M . P . S .,

who was unfortunately prevented by illness from being present . E . Sir Knt . Hargreaves discharged the duties of V . E . Among the other Sir Knts . present were Thomas Entwistle , P . S . ; J . B . Robinson , Liverpool Conclave , and others . Bros . J . M . Beaton , and John Duffield , having been approved

of , were received as Knights of Rome , and afterwards dubbed Knights of the Red Cross . Sir Kit . Hargreaves was then elected as M . P . S ., for tl * J ensuing year , and Sir Knt . Duffield as V . E . A college of Viceroys was then opened , and Sir Knt . Duffield was placed in the chair of E . b y

Sir Knt . Matier . The duties of Hi gh Prelate were most efficientl y discharged by Sir Knt . Entwistle . All Viceroys having retired , a Senate of Sovereigns was then formed , and Sir Knt . Hargreaves was installed in the supreme chair

with the accustomed solemnities , and saluted with the mystic number . On the conclave being resumed in the first grade , Sir Knt . Matier presented the warrant to the M . P . S . It was then resolved the installation fee should be raised to

two guineas , and the subscription to one guinea . Several apologies were then read , and propositions made , after which the conclave was closed with the usual ceremony . The Kni ghts Companions afterwards partook of the cup of cheerfulness , when the usual loyal and Masonic toasts were

given , and heartily responded to . We have every reason to believe that this conclave will be worked in a most efficient manner , and that with the assistance and support of the Past Sovereigns , the M . P . S . may look forward to a most prosperous term of office .

Masonic Tidings.

Masonic Tidings .

The Fifteen Sections will be worked in thc New Concord Lodge of Instruction , held . ' at Bro , Gabb ' s , Rosemary Branch Tavern , Hoxton , on the first Wednesday iu June , by Bro . Austin , W . M . of the Doric Lodge , No . 933 , and other brethren . Business to commence at 7 p . m .

precisely . Brethren of other lodges are respectfull y invited . Bro . T . W . Boord has been introduced to the Conservative electors of Greenwich as a candidate in that interest for the representation of the borough .

Multum In Parbo, Or Masonic Notes And Queries.

Multum in Parbo , or Masonic Notes and Queries .

THE ST . CLAIR CHARTERS . In a communication , which appeared in the Freemason of June 8 , 1872 , Bro . Chalmers Izett Paton gave copies ofthe St . Clair Charters , which he alleged to be " from Hay ' s MSS . in the Advocates' Library . " On March 29 , 187 , 3 , I

published through the same medium a note on the subject , which is here reproduced to enable the reader to judge whether its tone is either unmasonic or unbecoming , as Bro . Paton alleges * . — - These copies , minus thc copyist ' s or printers' errors which they contain , appeared to me at the time

to be a literal transcript of the copies from the originals made by myself for the " History of the Lodge of Edinburgh ( Mary ' s Chapel ) , " and published in the Freemason of August 27 , 1870 . I have since examined the Hay MS ., and I am confirmed in that opinion . The document given

by Bro . Paton is not a copy made from the Hay MS . It differs considerably from it in orthography , in abbreviations , and in the arrangement and rendering of some of the signatures , and is simply a copy of my transcript ofthe originals published two years ago . I had previously , through the Freemason informed Bro . Paton of

the existence of the ori ginal Charters—a fact of which he was ignorant . If Bro . Paton was unable to deci pher the ori ginal Hay MSS ., he should not have palmed off my transcription of the ori ginal charters as copies of them , nor should he have appropriated my work in any case without the courtesy of acknowledgment . "

Bro . Paton has published in the Freemason of April 26 , a rambling statement in which after indulging his taste for personalities , he in the most ungraceful manner pleads guilty to the charge of having published my transcripts of the original charters as lanajide copies of these

documents from the Hay MS . He says , " I preferred to send printed copies rather than take the trouble of transcribing them , and I do not hesitate to say I cut them out of the Freemason , instead of cutting them as I mi ght have clone , out of a valuable book , " In other words he deliberately

presented to the Craft copies of the originals , representing them to be transcripts of the St . Clair Charters from the Hay MSS . It will be readily admitted that it is of importance to the history of Freemasonry that copies of ancient documents should bc honest transcripts

of what they purport to be ; and it is therefore less upon personal grounds than from a regard to historical accuracy , that I impeach Bro . Paton for deliberately publishing as a copy of a particular document , what is in reality the transcript of another and diffierent document .

Bro . Paton denies my statement that he was ignorant ofthe existence ofthe original charter till I informed him ofthe fact through the Freemason . His ignorance in this repect was communicated by himself in the Freemason of July 30 th , 1870 , where he says : — " I frankly admit that I was not

aware that the originals of these charters were known to be in existence , and 1 would feel greatly obliged to Bro . D . M . L yon or any one else for any information where they are to be found , as I would be glad to take the first possible opportunity of examining them . The copies made by

the industrious Father Hay , and now to be found in one ofthe volumes of MSS . in the Advocates ' Library , alone seem to have been known to the historians of Freemasonry , and other writers on the subject to the present time . " The information asked b y Bro . Paton I gave through the

I'reemasou of August 27111 , 1870 . And now , in 1873 , Bro . Paton , forgetful of what he himself had written , and to wriggle out a difficulty in which he had placed himself , declares that copies ofthe originals had been published many years

agofirst 111 Hay ' s 'Genealogies , ' and also in Laurie ' s ' History of Freemasonry '—and that he himself had seen the ori ginals long before 1 had heard of them . I forbear from characterising conduct like this .

vV ill Bro . Paton have the goodness to give the name of the person who borrowed the original charters from Professor Aytoun , and state whether it was before or after he himself became a mason that he saw them in the hands of the alleged borrower . Bro . Paton ' s statement that

“The Freemason: 1873-05-24, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 4 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_24051873/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 1
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
Untitled Ad 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS. Article 3
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 3
Royal Arch. Article 4
Scotland. Article 4
THE FUTURE OF FREEMASONRY IN IREIAND. Article 4
Original Correspondence. Article 5
THE NEW GRAND OFFICERS. Article 6
NEW ZEALAND. Article 6
PROCEEDINGS OF GRAND LODGE OF MASSACHUSETTS, 1872. Article 7
Untitled Article 8
United States of America. Article 8
Untitled Article 8
Answers to Correspondents. Article 8
Births, Marriages and Deaths. Article 8
LIVERPOOL THEATRES, &c. Article 8
Untitled Article 8
ESPECIAL GRAND LODGE. Article 8
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR GIRLS. Article 9
INTERESTING MASONIC PRESENTATIONS IN LIVERPOOL. Article 10
CONSECRATION OF A NEW MARK LODGE AT ROCK FERRY. Article 11
Red Cross of Constantine. Article 11
Masonic Tidings. Article 11
Multum in Parbo, or Masonic Notes and Queries. Article 11
SOUTH LONDON MASONIC HALL. Article 12
"THE INITIATE'S WELCOME." Article 12
Obituary. Article 12
THE NEW GRAND OFFICERS. Article 13
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 13
MASONIC MEETINGS IN LIVERPOOL, &c. Article 14
MASONIC MEETINGS IN GLASGOW. Article 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Article 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Page 1

Page 1

10 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

14 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

6 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

5 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

10 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

5 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

5 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

11 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

18 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

14 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Interesting Masonic Presentations In Liverpool.

spoke in eloquent terms of his many excellent qualities . Bro . Danson briefly thanked the W . M . and brethren for their kindness , spoke of his beincr

connected with the lodge since its beginning , assured everyone that he had , to the best of his ability , endeavoured to perform his duty in whatever position he was placed , and would strive in the future to make any amends for past

shortcomings . During thc evening , on the motion of Bro . P . M . Marsh , seconded by Bro . R . Washington , J . ., the lodge unanimously agreed to the recommendation that Bro . Danson should be made a Life Governor of the West Lancashire

Masonic Educational Institution , the necessary amount being furnished from the " charity-box , " which has already done good work in this respect on many previous occasions . The brethren , after business , sat down to an excellent banquet .

Consecration Of A New Mark Lodge At Rock Ferry.

CONSECRATION OF A NEW MARK LODGE AT ROCK FERRY .

That this degree is making good progress in Cheshire cannot be doubted , for little more than a month has elapsed since the Provincial Grand Mark Lodge of Cheshire and North Wales was established , under the rule of Bro . the Hon .

Wilbrahani Egerton , M . P ., the present W . M ., of the Joppa Mark Lodge , No . n , Birkenhead , and on Monday ,: the 12 th inst ., a new Mark Lodge was consecrated at the Rock Ferry Hotel , the first riewr . one ! under Bro . Egerton ' s jurisdiction , and bearing his name .

; " The . Egerton Lodge , No . 165 , was formed b y those-who some four years ago inaugurated the Craft Lodge at Rock Ferry , now thriving so well , and there can be little doubt that the new Mark Lodge will be equally successful . It was a matter of great regret that owing to

a very important engagement , the D . P . G . M ., Bro . the Rev . C . W . Spencer Stanhope , who had been appointed by the M . W . G . M . M . to perform the ceremonies , was unable to be present , but a very able substitute was there in the person of Bro . W . Romaine Callender , R . W . P . G . M . M . of

Lancashire . He was supported by the following Provincial Officers of Cheshire and North Wales : Bros . Rev . J . W . Newell Tanner , P . G . Chaplain ; Wm . Bullev , P . J . G . W . ; R . Newhouse , P . G . Sec . ; Thos . Piatt , P . G . Treas . ; Jos . Sillitoe , P . G . S . O . ; Capt . Watson , P . G . f . O .

E . Friend , P . G . D . C . ; Geo . Higgins , P . G . S . B . ; J . S . Mort , P . G . P . ; Thos . Kent , J . Heap , G . H . Wilson , P . Grand Stewards ; and John Worthington , P . G . Tyler . Among the visitors were Bros . J . P . Piatt ,

P . P . G . M . O ., Lancashire ; Tysilio Johnson and J . M . Radcliffe , of the Joppa Lodge , No . ir . The Mark Lodge was opened in due form by Bro . F . K . Stevenson , P . M . 11 , P . G . S . D ., and Bro . Callender and Officers admitted , and greeted with the usual honours .

Bro . Callender then proceeded to consecrate and constitute the Egerton Lodge of Mark Masons , according to ancient form , after which he installed Bro . Friend in the chair , who received the customary salutes .

The W . M . then appointed and invested his officers , Bro . S . Spratly , M . D ., being unanimously elected Treasurer , and Bro . Holtoway , Tyler . Bros . F . K . Stevenson , S . W . j R . H . Moore , J . W . j Lilley Ellis , Sec ; Spratly , Treas . ; G . H . Wilson , M . O . ; F . L . Bolton , S . O . ; Alex . Low , J . O . ; J . W . Paton , M . D ., S . D . ; Stanton

J . D . j Sanderson , I . G . ; Holtoway , Tyler . Bro . Tysilio Johnson was elected an honorary member , A cordial vote of thanks was then recorded on the minutes to the R . W . Bro . Callender , for his extreme kindness in coming at great inconvenience to perform the ceremonies , also to the Rev . C . W . Spencer Stanhope , for his present of a handsome bible .

Several brethren were proposed for advancement , and the P . G . M . M . and officers then withdrew . Thelodge was then closed , and the brethren dined together . Bro . Friend , W . M ., presided , and was

supported b y Bro . Callender , and the other Provincial officers and brethren . The usual loyal and Masonic toasts were heartil y responded to , and the brethren separated at an earl y hour , after a most harmonious meeting .

Red Cross Of Constantine.

Red Cross of Constantine .

CONSECRATION OF A RED CROSS CONCLAVE ATBROOKLYN , NEW YORK . The interesting and imposing ceremonies of inaugurating , dedicating , and installing the officers

of a new conclave of the Imperial Ecclesiastical , and Military Order of Knights ofthe Red Cross of Constantine and Rome , and K . H . S ., under the title of Saxa Rubra Conclave , No . 6 9 , were

performed on Tuesday evening last , in the elegant rooms of Dr . Witt Clinton Commandery , No . 27 , Brooklyn , under the auspices and by the authority of Sir Albert G . Goodall , 33 ° , Most Illustrious Grand Sovereign ofthe State . After the ceremonies of inaugurating and

dedicating the conclave , the following officers and members were installed and constituted in ample form , with full power to do and perform all proper and lawful acts thereunto belonging : —E . Sir Robert Macoy , Grand Recorder of the State Conclave , First Sovereign ; Charles Aikman , First Viceroy ; J . Anson Foster , G . W . Gritman ,

John Z . Johnson . Erskine H . Dickey , Robert P . Lethbridge , Charles II . Peck , James D . Kingsland , Caleb A . Eairy , and Joseph L . Edwards . The charter , authorizing the establishment of this conclave , emanates from the Grand Imperial Council at London , the Right Hon . the Earl of Bective , Grand Sovereign .

1 his ancient and chivalric Order of Constantine having for many years enjoyed the patronage and protection of the most distinguished members of the Masonic body , the Grand Mastership having been held for many years , and up to the time of his death , by the Duke of Sussex . None but Knights Templar are admitted to membership in this country . —New York Dispatch .

MANCHESTER . —County Palatine Conclave ( No . 50 ) . —The meeting of this conclave took place on Saturday , the 17 th inst ., at Freemasons ' Hall . Thc chair of C . was occupied by 111 . Sir Knt . C . Fitzgerald Matier , P . S ., in the absence of 111 . Sir Knt . W . Romaine Callender , M . P . S .,

who was unfortunately prevented by illness from being present . E . Sir Knt . Hargreaves discharged the duties of V . E . Among the other Sir Knts . present were Thomas Entwistle , P . S . ; J . B . Robinson , Liverpool Conclave , and others . Bros . J . M . Beaton , and John Duffield , having been approved

of , were received as Knights of Rome , and afterwards dubbed Knights of the Red Cross . Sir Kit . Hargreaves was then elected as M . P . S ., for tl * J ensuing year , and Sir Knt . Duffield as V . E . A college of Viceroys was then opened , and Sir Knt . Duffield was placed in the chair of E . b y

Sir Knt . Matier . The duties of Hi gh Prelate were most efficientl y discharged by Sir Knt . Entwistle . All Viceroys having retired , a Senate of Sovereigns was then formed , and Sir Knt . Hargreaves was installed in the supreme chair

with the accustomed solemnities , and saluted with the mystic number . On the conclave being resumed in the first grade , Sir Knt . Matier presented the warrant to the M . P . S . It was then resolved the installation fee should be raised to

two guineas , and the subscription to one guinea . Several apologies were then read , and propositions made , after which the conclave was closed with the usual ceremony . The Kni ghts Companions afterwards partook of the cup of cheerfulness , when the usual loyal and Masonic toasts were

given , and heartily responded to . We have every reason to believe that this conclave will be worked in a most efficient manner , and that with the assistance and support of the Past Sovereigns , the M . P . S . may look forward to a most prosperous term of office .

Masonic Tidings.

Masonic Tidings .

The Fifteen Sections will be worked in thc New Concord Lodge of Instruction , held . ' at Bro , Gabb ' s , Rosemary Branch Tavern , Hoxton , on the first Wednesday iu June , by Bro . Austin , W . M . of the Doric Lodge , No . 933 , and other brethren . Business to commence at 7 p . m .

precisely . Brethren of other lodges are respectfull y invited . Bro . T . W . Boord has been introduced to the Conservative electors of Greenwich as a candidate in that interest for the representation of the borough .

Multum In Parbo, Or Masonic Notes And Queries.

Multum in Parbo , or Masonic Notes and Queries .

THE ST . CLAIR CHARTERS . In a communication , which appeared in the Freemason of June 8 , 1872 , Bro . Chalmers Izett Paton gave copies ofthe St . Clair Charters , which he alleged to be " from Hay ' s MSS . in the Advocates' Library . " On March 29 , 187 , 3 , I

published through the same medium a note on the subject , which is here reproduced to enable the reader to judge whether its tone is either unmasonic or unbecoming , as Bro . Paton alleges * . — - These copies , minus thc copyist ' s or printers' errors which they contain , appeared to me at the time

to be a literal transcript of the copies from the originals made by myself for the " History of the Lodge of Edinburgh ( Mary ' s Chapel ) , " and published in the Freemason of August 27 , 1870 . I have since examined the Hay MS ., and I am confirmed in that opinion . The document given

by Bro . Paton is not a copy made from the Hay MS . It differs considerably from it in orthography , in abbreviations , and in the arrangement and rendering of some of the signatures , and is simply a copy of my transcript ofthe originals published two years ago . I had previously , through the Freemason informed Bro . Paton of

the existence of the ori ginal Charters—a fact of which he was ignorant . If Bro . Paton was unable to deci pher the ori ginal Hay MSS ., he should not have palmed off my transcription of the ori ginal charters as copies of them , nor should he have appropriated my work in any case without the courtesy of acknowledgment . "

Bro . Paton has published in the Freemason of April 26 , a rambling statement in which after indulging his taste for personalities , he in the most ungraceful manner pleads guilty to the charge of having published my transcripts of the original charters as lanajide copies of these

documents from the Hay MS . He says , " I preferred to send printed copies rather than take the trouble of transcribing them , and I do not hesitate to say I cut them out of the Freemason , instead of cutting them as I mi ght have clone , out of a valuable book , " In other words he deliberately

presented to the Craft copies of the originals , representing them to be transcripts of the St . Clair Charters from the Hay MSS . It will be readily admitted that it is of importance to the history of Freemasonry that copies of ancient documents should bc honest transcripts

of what they purport to be ; and it is therefore less upon personal grounds than from a regard to historical accuracy , that I impeach Bro . Paton for deliberately publishing as a copy of a particular document , what is in reality the transcript of another and diffierent document .

Bro . Paton denies my statement that he was ignorant ofthe existence ofthe original charter till I informed him ofthe fact through the Freemason . His ignorance in this repect was communicated by himself in the Freemason of July 30 th , 1870 , where he says : — " I frankly admit that I was not

aware that the originals of these charters were known to be in existence , and 1 would feel greatly obliged to Bro . D . M . L yon or any one else for any information where they are to be found , as I would be glad to take the first possible opportunity of examining them . The copies made by

the industrious Father Hay , and now to be found in one ofthe volumes of MSS . in the Advocates ' Library , alone seem to have been known to the historians of Freemasonry , and other writers on the subject to the present time . " The information asked b y Bro . Paton I gave through the

I'reemasou of August 27111 , 1870 . And now , in 1873 , Bro . Paton , forgetful of what he himself had written , and to wriggle out a difficulty in which he had placed himself , declares that copies ofthe originals had been published many years

agofirst 111 Hay ' s 'Genealogies , ' and also in Laurie ' s ' History of Freemasonry '—and that he himself had seen the ori ginals long before 1 had heard of them . I forbear from characterising conduct like this .

vV ill Bro . Paton have the goodness to give the name of the person who borrowed the original charters from Professor Aytoun , and state whether it was before or after he himself became a mason that he saw them in the hands of the alleged borrower . Bro . Paton ' s statement that

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 16
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy