Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Nov. 24, 1877
  • Page 5
Current:

The Freemason, Nov. 24, 1877: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemason, Nov. 24, 1877
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. Page 2 of 2
    Article THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. Page 2 of 2
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Grand Orient Of France.

-el . The Assembly suppresses , as constituting a useless repetition with the 2 d paragraph modified , Paragraph 3 , thus expressed ; " Freemasonry regards liberty of conscience as a right belcng ing to every man , and excludes no person on account of his beliefs . " 4 th . The Assembly decides finally that Art . 1 of the

Constitution shall hereafter have the following tenor : " Freemasonry , an essentially philanthropies ! , philosophical , and progressive institution , has for its object the search after truth , the study of universal ethics , of the sciences and of arts , and the exercise of beneficence . " It holds as a principle absolute liberty of conscience ¦ uid human solielarity . It has for device : Liberty ,

Equality , Fraternity . " If these propositions are adopted by the Assembly , your Committee decides to propose to the Council of the Order to g ive the question to be studied relative to the revision of the rituals at present in use . This report , it must be acknowledged , is admirably

drawn up , and therefore it was often applauded by a large majority of the assembly . A great number of BB . in the Assembly demand that they should immediately proceed to the vote . The President , Bro . de Saint Jean , opposes this course ; he is desirous of submitting an observation . Silence is restored with difficulty . Bre > . de Saint Jean

has the floor . He would consider himself wanting in all his duties as a Mason , and not sufficiently to appreciate his respo . isibility as Presiding Officer of the Grand Orient , if he did not make known the agitation which filled him . Yes , he forsees mischief for our Institution in the immediate vote on the adoption of Proposition No . IX ., and he cannot , he

must not hide his opinion . It is this : The Assembly must weig h this reflection ; anel adopt the wisest expedient in the interest of the Institution . 'The clamour for the question is renewed with great vigour . Bro . Dalsace wishes to speak ; he obtains silence only with diriicuity . For four days , said he , I have served an actual

campaign in favour of postponement ,. but the report which we have just beard , and which has won us by its moderation , by its wiselom , by its forcible and irrefutable consideration in favour of an immediate vote , by its very Masonic and conciliatory resolutions , all make it my duty , my BB . to inform you , that I am no longer for postponement ; that I am for an immediate vote . And I am pleased to hope

hat all this Assembly will come rounel to tins opinion . It is necessary , in order that the results of our vote should be efficacious , that it should not meet with any opposing factions . Bie > . Aubert-Bouche : does not share the opinion ot Bro . Dalsace ; he deduces with rapidity the great cemsiderations of security which are inducements to ask the

postponement to another session . Often interrupted , he withstands energetically the interrupters who wish to impose silence on him . In Masonry , we must know how to listen to each other . Besides , my BB ., I am the representative here of 100 Masons , which is quite a number , and I only give expression to what is expected by these Masons of the

wiselom and foresight of the Assernbly . Bro . Ferdeuil thinks that we must put an end to this question , which , for too long a time , has been a source of agitation and trouble in Masonry . He embraces the proposition of the Committee un the vote , whose adoption will bring about pacification in our ranks , and will disengage us from a text of law which gives satisfaction

to no one . Again , the cries : "The closing ! the closing ! to the vote ! to the vote ! " come from all parts of the Temple . Unquestionably the majority is won over to the Proposition No . IX . Bro . Jabouille demands the floor . He is compelled to struggle quite a long lime to succeed in making

himself heard . Finally , he can proceed , although interrupted ; he then sets forth with much talent and appositeness the best of reasons for the Assembly to grant the postponement . He says with good reason that even while reading with the greatest care the report so well entitled to consideration of Bro . Desmons , it is evident from it that the question which is agitated is not a question of principle , but of

formula .... and again .... He shows that the Assembly is giving way to an impulse of sentiment and nothing more , and in this case the greatest victory would be that gained over itself . He skilfully makes it evident that the declaration which has been in the Constitution since 1849 has in no wise trammelled Masonry , at any period , at anv moment j what inconvenience then in

deferring it ? There is no inconvenience in that ; on the contrary , every advantage . The orator would have had still many more considerations to plead , but the Assembly is impatient , and on the Piesieling Officer himself insisting , Bro . jabouille curtails and breaks off his discourse . Bro . Jouault : The solution of the question exists . The declaration of the lodges rises imperiously before us . We

have an imperative mandate ; we have only to assent to the declaration of our lodges . To postpone would be pusillanimity . It is time to make an end of it . Bro . Du Hamcl explaining the Constitution , and stopping specially at Article 5 , demonstrates the unconstitutionality and the danger of the imperative mandate . This brother cannot get to the end of his argumentation , any more than the preceding ones .

Besides , he is told that he is outside of the question . This is not the opinion of Bro . de Saint-Jean , who , himself , thinks , on the contrary , that Bro . Du Hamel reasoneei justly . Bro . Dalsace returns to the charge , but such is the disposition of the Assembly that it does not listen , that it will not listen even to those who reflect its thought . At last Bro . Dalsace uses such energy and persistency , that finally he is able to emphasise in a . louder tone the

The Grand Orient Of France.

considerations which he developed in his first address . Acceding at the last moment to Proposition No . IX ., he could see a very great advantage in the Assembly ' s being unanimous in its vote . A brother whose name I regret not knowing , proceeded to explain what had already been said , that , ci-ncerning article 8 , the Assembly could not escape from the necessity

of a definitive solution of the question of Proposition No . IX . As the orator still kept on , although he was interrupted at every instant , the call for the closing became so urgent and general , that the Presiding Officer was obliged to put it to the vote : it was adopted almost unanimously . The President demands the conclusions of the Orator , Bro . Vie ' not , on the postponement .

The conclusions are against postponement . These conclusions are adopted by a large majority . The Presielent gives notice that he will put to the vote in succession the resolutions of the report of Bro Desmons . Bro . Minot and some other BB . demand a vote by call of the roll . His insistence on this demand produces some tumult ; finally the law prevails , and the vote is taken by rising or remaining seated .

No . r . —No . 2 . —No . 3 . 1 st . The Assembly , considering that Freemasonry is not a religion ; that , consequently , it is not called upon to assert in its Constitution doctrines or dogmas , Adopts Proposition No . IX . 2 d . The Assembly decides that the 2 d section of Article rst o £ . the Constitution shall have the following tenor :

It holds as pi inciplcs , absolute freedom of conscience and human solidarity , " 3 d . The Assembly suppresses , as constituting a useless repetition of the 2 d section as modified , section 3 , thus expressed : " It considers liberty of conscience as a right belonging to every man and excludes no one for hiscreeel . "

T he s-sction " . . . . and excludes no one for his creed . . . . " was introduceel into No . 3 by request of Bro . de Saint Jean . This amendment , at first rejected by the Committee , but defendeel by Bro . Cauzard , of the Lodge la Renaissance anel other BB ., was accepted by it ; which facilitated its adoption . Being accustomed to remain an exact and impartial

narrator , we have no difficulty in acknowledging that the minority against the adoption of the vote was feeble , and we acknowledge that we are of that minority and we persist in it ; we remain convinced that the vote of the Gr . Or . is a mistake , anel a very great mistake . We

shall never understand an Institution having morality fir its object , for its teaching , which commences by cutting off what is its law and sanction . The revision of the Statutes and Rituals was decided upon so as to place them in accortlance with the preceding vote .

Session of Friefay , 14 th September . Some explanations are exchanged 011 the subject of the number of the Majority and of the Minority , in the case of Proposition No . IX , adoption of the resolutions of the Committee nn this Proposition . The official report will state the fact that the adoption hael a large majority .

No one disputes the fact . Certainly the very great majority voted the aeloption of Proposition No . IX . Bro . Marchal , of Nancy , wishes to ask a question on this subject . " It remains , then , well establisheel that the Masonry of the Granel Oiient is disengaged from all religious principles ?" This is not disputed .

Our readers have before them the labuors of the Session of the Masonic year 5877 . It was feared that it would not take place . Let us acknowledge that these sessions have been dignified , and that the resolutions adopted have been so after serious study and thorough eliscussion . One vote has distressed us , this is the vote No . IX ; we believe it to be prejudicial to true Masonic interests , and we have

been anel glory in being in that minority which voted against this adoption . But our regr : t should not render us unjust ; if anything can afford any alleviation , any palliation of our grief on this point , it is the sentiment of moderation , the spirit of conciliation which are to be discerned in the report of Bro . Desmons . We have applauded this report , without having been willing to adopt its

conclusions , for it sanctioned a suppression in our Masonic law , which is , for me , with my full conviction , a derogation from one ot the fundamental principles of Freemasonry , such as it has been established from all time , such as it appears in the known Universe , because the report of Bro . Desmons is that of a loyal Mason , of a Mason who knows how to speak with a wholly fraternal heart .

We must likewise thank Brother de Saint-Jean for having proposed to add to the 3 d resolution of the Committee on Proposition No . IX , the paragraph : " Freemasonry cnnsielers liberty of conscience as a right belonging to every man , and it excludes no one on account ot his creed . " It is a real weighing and fortunate attenuation of the textual wording of the resolutions as they came

from the deliberations of the Committee on Proposition No . IX . Let us thank Bro . Cauzard , who , by his intervention in the debate , contributed powerfully to the adoption of the amendment of Bro . de Saint-Jean . I « an early number , we shall examine the report of Bro . Desmons ; we will point out the historical errors in

point of fact which are to be found therein . We must net do that through respect for the opinion which we have defended and which is still ours . H UBERT . The Members of the Grand Orient of France are entitled to the full benefit of their declaration , that the suppression of the declaration of belief in God and in the immortality of the Soul cannot without injustice be taken as a profession

The Grand Orient Of France.

of Materialism or Atheism . It is , no doubt , not so for most of them . It is so , no doubt for some . Anel on the other hand , they must all bear the full burthen of the declarations that it is a proclamation of entire liberty of conscience ; that one of the reasons for the suppression , has been , to relieve Masters of Lodges from embarrassment . and from the necessity which " in certain

circumstances , " constrained them either to elude or violate the law ; and another , to relieve profanes applying for initiation , who might find the clause suppressed a barrier which their conscience would not permit them , to surmount . For the meaning of all this is , that it shall be no obstacle in France to the admission of a profane into Masonry , that

he is a pronounced and avowed Atheist , who cannot declare that he puts his trust in God , because he believes that there is no God ; and the clause suppressed must no longer embarrass Masters and Lodges desirous to initiate Atheists , nor Atheists who desire initiation . It has always been a landmark of the genuine English and American Freemasonry , that no Atheist , equally with

no woman , can be admitted a Mason . That Order , in any country , into which avowed Atheists can be admitted , and the Members whereof need not believe that there is a God or that the Soul of man lives after his body , cannot be Freemasonry for us . Notwithstanding the disclaimer by the G . Orient of France , of Atheistical profession , it is not deniable that the

suppression of the declaration of faith in question is a concession to Atheism . It announces to the Masonic world , that in France it is , so far as the power of the Grand Orient extends , no longer necessary that a Mason should believe that there is a God , or that man is more than an animal . Nothing can be conceived of , more ridiculous than reading the lessons of our Rituals of the Ancient and

Accepted Scottish Rite would be , to an Atheist . The belief in a Supreme Intelligence , Creator and Preserver of the Universe , a Beneficent God , to whom it is no folly to pray for aid and comfort , a Father , who loves us as his children , is the basis upon which all oar ritualism , in all our degrees , rests . Take it away , and they become less than nought , the very babbling of incoherent and disjointed

folly . We put our trust in GOD ; and not in a " Supreme Force , " or " Greater-Principle ; " and cannot hold that to be Freemasonry which does not do the same . The Grand Orient of France claims to have in itsbosom a Supreme Council of the 33 d Degree . There is also a legitimate Supreme Council of France , distinct from the

Granel Orient , of which Mons Adolphe Cre ' mieux , ( whose predecessor was M . Viennet , and his the Due Decuzcs , ) is Grand Commander , and Mons . G . Guiffrey is Secretary General . We have not for several years had any relations of amity or correspondence with the Grand Orient of France , in consequence of its recognition of the so-called Supreme Council of Louisiana . We have suspended such

communication with the Supreme Council of France , for what we deemed just causes of complaint ; but the BB . - . of its obedience are nevertheless entitled to be welcomed as visitors in bodies under our jurisdiction . The recognition by the Grand Orient of the illegitimate body in Louisiana , excludes all who are of its obedience from our bodies , and forbids our BB . to visit bodies of any degree ,

any where , that are of obedience of the Grand Orient of France . It is not so as to those that are of the obedience of the Supreme Council of France . It has not allied itself with a spurious body within our jurisdiction . As each has symbolic lodges under it , and bodies of the higher elegrees , in France and elsewhere , you will be cateful to bear in mind the difference between them , since

the Granel Orient has now made it impossible for us to recognise it as a Masonic Power , or the bodies of its obceiience as Masonic bodies . We cannot recognise an atheist as a Mason , permit him to visit as such , or sit in a Masonic Body with him j and but for the existence in France of a lawful Power of the Scottish Freemasonry , the Supreme Council o ! France , which has not yet declared the belief

in a God and in the immortality of the soul unnecessary for one seeking initiation , the Masonic Powers of the world might justly proclaim Franco to be unoccupied Masonic teiritory , and grant charters for Masonic bodies to work therein , composed of Masons obligated not to receive into the brotherhood any " old man in his dotage , or young man in his nonage , an atheist or irreligious libertine , a

Jesuit , a madman , or a fool . " The Supreme Council of France , has , it is true , taken a step in the same direction with the Grand Orient of France . It has , as a concession to Atheism , substituted the phrases , " Force Supe ' rieure" and " Principe Cre ' ateur , " for the name of God , in a declaration of principles concurred in by other Powers ; but it has retained the phrase , " known

Dy the name of Great Architect of the Universe ; " and has not avowed that its Lodges are at liberty to initiate avowed Atheists , nor found it necessary , as yet , to change its Rituals , in order that nothing in them may offend the teneler consciences of those whom what they call " reason " compels to believe that there is no God . If it should imitate the Grand Orient , there will be no Freemasonry in France .

You will therefore henceforth admit as visitors of your bodies none who are of the obetlunce of the Grand Orient of France j nor sit with any sucli in the blue lodges ; nor will you , in any country , visit symbolic lodges or other I odies of its obedience , until further order of the Supreme Cojnci ] , And may our Father which is in Heaven have you always in His holy keeping 1 ALBERT PIKE , Sov . G . Com .

Mr . Frederick Stokes has been appointed Admiralty Proctor in succession to his father , Mr . Heiiry Graham Stokes , deceased .

“The Freemason: 1877-11-24, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 12 Aug. 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_24111877/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CONTENTS. Article 1
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETING S. Article 1
Royal Arch. Article 4
Ancient and Accepted Rite. Article 4
Royal Arch. Article 4
THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. Article 4
BRO.THE REV. H. A.PICKARD, GRAND CHAPLAIN. Article 6
ROYAL MASONIC BOYS' SCHOOL. Article 6
Masonic and General Tidings. Article 6
LODGE OF BENEVOLENCE. Article 7
GRAND LODGE OF IRELAND. Article 7
Public Amusements. Article 7
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Article 8
Untitled Article 8
Answers to Correspondents. Article 8
Births ,Marriages and Deaths. Article 8
Untitled Article 8
THE CENTENARY OF THE YORK LODGE. Article 8
FOREWARNED IS FOREARMED Article 8
WHAT IS PLATONIC FRIENDSHIP? Article 9
THE NEW GRAND CHAPLAIN Article 9
UNE AMENDE HONORABLE. Article 9
Original Correspondence. Article 9
CONSECRATION OF THE ST. GEORGE'S LODGE, No. 1723. Article 10
DEDICATION OF A MASONIC HALL AT GALASHIELS, N.B. Article 10
REMINISCENCES OF ST. JOHN'S LODGE, No. 58, KELSO, N.B. Article 10
MASONIC SERMON. Article 11
GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. Article 12
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETING Article 12
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

6 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

4 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

5 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

10 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

7 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

5 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

10 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

21 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Grand Orient Of France.

-el . The Assembly suppresses , as constituting a useless repetition with the 2 d paragraph modified , Paragraph 3 , thus expressed ; " Freemasonry regards liberty of conscience as a right belcng ing to every man , and excludes no person on account of his beliefs . " 4 th . The Assembly decides finally that Art . 1 of the

Constitution shall hereafter have the following tenor : " Freemasonry , an essentially philanthropies ! , philosophical , and progressive institution , has for its object the search after truth , the study of universal ethics , of the sciences and of arts , and the exercise of beneficence . " It holds as a principle absolute liberty of conscience ¦ uid human solielarity . It has for device : Liberty ,

Equality , Fraternity . " If these propositions are adopted by the Assembly , your Committee decides to propose to the Council of the Order to g ive the question to be studied relative to the revision of the rituals at present in use . This report , it must be acknowledged , is admirably

drawn up , and therefore it was often applauded by a large majority of the assembly . A great number of BB . in the Assembly demand that they should immediately proceed to the vote . The President , Bro . de Saint Jean , opposes this course ; he is desirous of submitting an observation . Silence is restored with difficulty . Bre > . de Saint Jean

has the floor . He would consider himself wanting in all his duties as a Mason , and not sufficiently to appreciate his respo . isibility as Presiding Officer of the Grand Orient , if he did not make known the agitation which filled him . Yes , he forsees mischief for our Institution in the immediate vote on the adoption of Proposition No . IX ., and he cannot , he

must not hide his opinion . It is this : The Assembly must weig h this reflection ; anel adopt the wisest expedient in the interest of the Institution . 'The clamour for the question is renewed with great vigour . Bro . Dalsace wishes to speak ; he obtains silence only with diriicuity . For four days , said he , I have served an actual

campaign in favour of postponement ,. but the report which we have just beard , and which has won us by its moderation , by its wiselom , by its forcible and irrefutable consideration in favour of an immediate vote , by its very Masonic and conciliatory resolutions , all make it my duty , my BB . to inform you , that I am no longer for postponement ; that I am for an immediate vote . And I am pleased to hope

hat all this Assembly will come rounel to tins opinion . It is necessary , in order that the results of our vote should be efficacious , that it should not meet with any opposing factions . Bie > . Aubert-Bouche : does not share the opinion ot Bro . Dalsace ; he deduces with rapidity the great cemsiderations of security which are inducements to ask the

postponement to another session . Often interrupted , he withstands energetically the interrupters who wish to impose silence on him . In Masonry , we must know how to listen to each other . Besides , my BB ., I am the representative here of 100 Masons , which is quite a number , and I only give expression to what is expected by these Masons of the

wiselom and foresight of the Assernbly . Bro . Ferdeuil thinks that we must put an end to this question , which , for too long a time , has been a source of agitation and trouble in Masonry . He embraces the proposition of the Committee un the vote , whose adoption will bring about pacification in our ranks , and will disengage us from a text of law which gives satisfaction

to no one . Again , the cries : "The closing ! the closing ! to the vote ! to the vote ! " come from all parts of the Temple . Unquestionably the majority is won over to the Proposition No . IX . Bro . Jabouille demands the floor . He is compelled to struggle quite a long lime to succeed in making

himself heard . Finally , he can proceed , although interrupted ; he then sets forth with much talent and appositeness the best of reasons for the Assembly to grant the postponement . He says with good reason that even while reading with the greatest care the report so well entitled to consideration of Bro . Desmons , it is evident from it that the question which is agitated is not a question of principle , but of

formula .... and again .... He shows that the Assembly is giving way to an impulse of sentiment and nothing more , and in this case the greatest victory would be that gained over itself . He skilfully makes it evident that the declaration which has been in the Constitution since 1849 has in no wise trammelled Masonry , at any period , at anv moment j what inconvenience then in

deferring it ? There is no inconvenience in that ; on the contrary , every advantage . The orator would have had still many more considerations to plead , but the Assembly is impatient , and on the Piesieling Officer himself insisting , Bro . jabouille curtails and breaks off his discourse . Bro . Jouault : The solution of the question exists . The declaration of the lodges rises imperiously before us . We

have an imperative mandate ; we have only to assent to the declaration of our lodges . To postpone would be pusillanimity . It is time to make an end of it . Bro . Du Hamcl explaining the Constitution , and stopping specially at Article 5 , demonstrates the unconstitutionality and the danger of the imperative mandate . This brother cannot get to the end of his argumentation , any more than the preceding ones .

Besides , he is told that he is outside of the question . This is not the opinion of Bro . de Saint-Jean , who , himself , thinks , on the contrary , that Bro . Du Hamel reasoneei justly . Bro . Dalsace returns to the charge , but such is the disposition of the Assembly that it does not listen , that it will not listen even to those who reflect its thought . At last Bro . Dalsace uses such energy and persistency , that finally he is able to emphasise in a . louder tone the

The Grand Orient Of France.

considerations which he developed in his first address . Acceding at the last moment to Proposition No . IX ., he could see a very great advantage in the Assembly ' s being unanimous in its vote . A brother whose name I regret not knowing , proceeded to explain what had already been said , that , ci-ncerning article 8 , the Assembly could not escape from the necessity

of a definitive solution of the question of Proposition No . IX . As the orator still kept on , although he was interrupted at every instant , the call for the closing became so urgent and general , that the Presiding Officer was obliged to put it to the vote : it was adopted almost unanimously . The President demands the conclusions of the Orator , Bro . Vie ' not , on the postponement .

The conclusions are against postponement . These conclusions are adopted by a large majority . The Presielent gives notice that he will put to the vote in succession the resolutions of the report of Bro Desmons . Bro . Minot and some other BB . demand a vote by call of the roll . His insistence on this demand produces some tumult ; finally the law prevails , and the vote is taken by rising or remaining seated .

No . r . —No . 2 . —No . 3 . 1 st . The Assembly , considering that Freemasonry is not a religion ; that , consequently , it is not called upon to assert in its Constitution doctrines or dogmas , Adopts Proposition No . IX . 2 d . The Assembly decides that the 2 d section of Article rst o £ . the Constitution shall have the following tenor :

It holds as pi inciplcs , absolute freedom of conscience and human solidarity , " 3 d . The Assembly suppresses , as constituting a useless repetition of the 2 d section as modified , section 3 , thus expressed : " It considers liberty of conscience as a right belonging to every man and excludes no one for hiscreeel . "

T he s-sction " . . . . and excludes no one for his creed . . . . " was introduceel into No . 3 by request of Bro . de Saint Jean . This amendment , at first rejected by the Committee , but defendeel by Bro . Cauzard , of the Lodge la Renaissance anel other BB ., was accepted by it ; which facilitated its adoption . Being accustomed to remain an exact and impartial

narrator , we have no difficulty in acknowledging that the minority against the adoption of the vote was feeble , and we acknowledge that we are of that minority and we persist in it ; we remain convinced that the vote of the Gr . Or . is a mistake , anel a very great mistake . We

shall never understand an Institution having morality fir its object , for its teaching , which commences by cutting off what is its law and sanction . The revision of the Statutes and Rituals was decided upon so as to place them in accortlance with the preceding vote .

Session of Friefay , 14 th September . Some explanations are exchanged 011 the subject of the number of the Majority and of the Minority , in the case of Proposition No . IX , adoption of the resolutions of the Committee nn this Proposition . The official report will state the fact that the adoption hael a large majority .

No one disputes the fact . Certainly the very great majority voted the aeloption of Proposition No . IX . Bro . Marchal , of Nancy , wishes to ask a question on this subject . " It remains , then , well establisheel that the Masonry of the Granel Oiient is disengaged from all religious principles ?" This is not disputed .

Our readers have before them the labuors of the Session of the Masonic year 5877 . It was feared that it would not take place . Let us acknowledge that these sessions have been dignified , and that the resolutions adopted have been so after serious study and thorough eliscussion . One vote has distressed us , this is the vote No . IX ; we believe it to be prejudicial to true Masonic interests , and we have

been anel glory in being in that minority which voted against this adoption . But our regr : t should not render us unjust ; if anything can afford any alleviation , any palliation of our grief on this point , it is the sentiment of moderation , the spirit of conciliation which are to be discerned in the report of Bro . Desmons . We have applauded this report , without having been willing to adopt its

conclusions , for it sanctioned a suppression in our Masonic law , which is , for me , with my full conviction , a derogation from one ot the fundamental principles of Freemasonry , such as it has been established from all time , such as it appears in the known Universe , because the report of Bro . Desmons is that of a loyal Mason , of a Mason who knows how to speak with a wholly fraternal heart .

We must likewise thank Brother de Saint-Jean for having proposed to add to the 3 d resolution of the Committee on Proposition No . IX , the paragraph : " Freemasonry cnnsielers liberty of conscience as a right belonging to every man , and it excludes no one on account ot his creed . " It is a real weighing and fortunate attenuation of the textual wording of the resolutions as they came

from the deliberations of the Committee on Proposition No . IX . Let us thank Bro . Cauzard , who , by his intervention in the debate , contributed powerfully to the adoption of the amendment of Bro . de Saint-Jean . I « an early number , we shall examine the report of Bro . Desmons ; we will point out the historical errors in

point of fact which are to be found therein . We must net do that through respect for the opinion which we have defended and which is still ours . H UBERT . The Members of the Grand Orient of France are entitled to the full benefit of their declaration , that the suppression of the declaration of belief in God and in the immortality of the Soul cannot without injustice be taken as a profession

The Grand Orient Of France.

of Materialism or Atheism . It is , no doubt , not so for most of them . It is so , no doubt for some . Anel on the other hand , they must all bear the full burthen of the declarations that it is a proclamation of entire liberty of conscience ; that one of the reasons for the suppression , has been , to relieve Masters of Lodges from embarrassment . and from the necessity which " in certain

circumstances , " constrained them either to elude or violate the law ; and another , to relieve profanes applying for initiation , who might find the clause suppressed a barrier which their conscience would not permit them , to surmount . For the meaning of all this is , that it shall be no obstacle in France to the admission of a profane into Masonry , that

he is a pronounced and avowed Atheist , who cannot declare that he puts his trust in God , because he believes that there is no God ; and the clause suppressed must no longer embarrass Masters and Lodges desirous to initiate Atheists , nor Atheists who desire initiation . It has always been a landmark of the genuine English and American Freemasonry , that no Atheist , equally with

no woman , can be admitted a Mason . That Order , in any country , into which avowed Atheists can be admitted , and the Members whereof need not believe that there is a God or that the Soul of man lives after his body , cannot be Freemasonry for us . Notwithstanding the disclaimer by the G . Orient of France , of Atheistical profession , it is not deniable that the

suppression of the declaration of faith in question is a concession to Atheism . It announces to the Masonic world , that in France it is , so far as the power of the Grand Orient extends , no longer necessary that a Mason should believe that there is a God , or that man is more than an animal . Nothing can be conceived of , more ridiculous than reading the lessons of our Rituals of the Ancient and

Accepted Scottish Rite would be , to an Atheist . The belief in a Supreme Intelligence , Creator and Preserver of the Universe , a Beneficent God , to whom it is no folly to pray for aid and comfort , a Father , who loves us as his children , is the basis upon which all oar ritualism , in all our degrees , rests . Take it away , and they become less than nought , the very babbling of incoherent and disjointed

folly . We put our trust in GOD ; and not in a " Supreme Force , " or " Greater-Principle ; " and cannot hold that to be Freemasonry which does not do the same . The Grand Orient of France claims to have in itsbosom a Supreme Council of the 33 d Degree . There is also a legitimate Supreme Council of France , distinct from the

Granel Orient , of which Mons Adolphe Cre ' mieux , ( whose predecessor was M . Viennet , and his the Due Decuzcs , ) is Grand Commander , and Mons . G . Guiffrey is Secretary General . We have not for several years had any relations of amity or correspondence with the Grand Orient of France , in consequence of its recognition of the so-called Supreme Council of Louisiana . We have suspended such

communication with the Supreme Council of France , for what we deemed just causes of complaint ; but the BB . - . of its obedience are nevertheless entitled to be welcomed as visitors in bodies under our jurisdiction . The recognition by the Grand Orient of the illegitimate body in Louisiana , excludes all who are of its obedience from our bodies , and forbids our BB . to visit bodies of any degree ,

any where , that are of obedience of the Grand Orient of France . It is not so as to those that are of the obedience of the Supreme Council of France . It has not allied itself with a spurious body within our jurisdiction . As each has symbolic lodges under it , and bodies of the higher elegrees , in France and elsewhere , you will be cateful to bear in mind the difference between them , since

the Granel Orient has now made it impossible for us to recognise it as a Masonic Power , or the bodies of its obceiience as Masonic bodies . We cannot recognise an atheist as a Mason , permit him to visit as such , or sit in a Masonic Body with him j and but for the existence in France of a lawful Power of the Scottish Freemasonry , the Supreme Council o ! France , which has not yet declared the belief

in a God and in the immortality of the soul unnecessary for one seeking initiation , the Masonic Powers of the world might justly proclaim Franco to be unoccupied Masonic teiritory , and grant charters for Masonic bodies to work therein , composed of Masons obligated not to receive into the brotherhood any " old man in his dotage , or young man in his nonage , an atheist or irreligious libertine , a

Jesuit , a madman , or a fool . " The Supreme Council of France , has , it is true , taken a step in the same direction with the Grand Orient of France . It has , as a concession to Atheism , substituted the phrases , " Force Supe ' rieure" and " Principe Cre ' ateur , " for the name of God , in a declaration of principles concurred in by other Powers ; but it has retained the phrase , " known

Dy the name of Great Architect of the Universe ; " and has not avowed that its Lodges are at liberty to initiate avowed Atheists , nor found it necessary , as yet , to change its Rituals , in order that nothing in them may offend the teneler consciences of those whom what they call " reason " compels to believe that there is no God . If it should imitate the Grand Orient , there will be no Freemasonry in France .

You will therefore henceforth admit as visitors of your bodies none who are of the obetlunce of the Grand Orient of France j nor sit with any sucli in the blue lodges ; nor will you , in any country , visit symbolic lodges or other I odies of its obedience , until further order of the Supreme Cojnci ] , And may our Father which is in Heaven have you always in His holy keeping 1 ALBERT PIKE , Sov . G . Com .

Mr . Frederick Stokes has been appointed Admiralty Proctor in succession to his father , Mr . Heiiry Graham Stokes , deceased .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 14
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy