Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Jan. 25, 1879
  • Page 6
  • THE LONDON MASONIC CHARITY ASSOCIATION.
Current:

The Freemason, Jan. 25, 1879: Page 6

  • Back to The Freemason, Jan. 25, 1879
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article TO OUR READERS. Page 1 of 1
    Article TO ADVERTISERS. Page 1 of 1
    Article Answers to Correspondents. Page 1 of 1
    Article Births, Marriages, and Deaths. Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article IN MEMORIAM. Page 1 of 1
    Article AN ERROR CORRECTED. Page 1 of 1
    Article THE LONDON MASONIC CHARITY ASSOCIATION. Page 1 of 1
    Article THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 1
    Article THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 1
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

To Our Readers.

TO OUR READERS .

The FREEMASON is a Weekly News paper , price 2 d . It is published every Friday morning , and contains the most important , interesting , and useful information relating to Freemasonry in every degree . Subscription , including postage : United America , India , India , China , & c .

Kingdom , the Continent , & c . Via Bnndisi . Twelve Months ios . 6 d . 12 s . od . 17 s . 4 d . Six „ 5 s . 3 d . 6 s . 6 d . 8 s . 8 d . Three „ 2 s . 8 d . 3 s . 3 d . 4 s . 6 d . ' Subscriptions may be paid for in stamps , but Post Office Orders or Cheques are preferred , the former payable to GEORGE KENNING , CHIEF OFFICE , LONDON , the latter crossed London Joint Stock Bank .

To Advertisers.

TO ADVERTISERS .

The FREEMASON has a large circulation in all parts of the Globe , its advantages as an advertising medium can therefore scarcely be overrated . ADVERTISEMENTS to ensure insertion in current week's issue should reach the Office , 198 , Fleet-street , by 12 o ' clock on "Wednesdays .

SCALE OF CHARGES FOR ADVERTISEMENTS . Whole of backpage ... £ 12 12 o Half ,, „ 6 10 o Inside pages ... ... 7 7 ° Half of ditto 400 Quarter ditto ... ... ... ... 2 10 o Whole column ... ... ... 2 10 o

Half „ 1 10 o Quarter „ ... ... ... ... ... 1 o o Per inch ... ... ... 050 These prices are for single insertions . A liberal reduction is made for a series of 13 , 26 , and 32 insertions . Further particulars may be obtained of the Publisher , 198 , Fleet-street , London .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

P . M . —You will find all you appear to require in Kenning ' s Masonic Cyclopaedia . ATLAS . —At Freemasons' Tavern , on the 12 th proximo . W . M . —Yours is a ritual question which , we think , it is unaavisa ' ole to discuss in The Freemason . The Editor will wiite privately .

The following reports stand over : —Royal Sussex , 342 ; Mount Sinai , Penzance , 121 ; Sun , 106 , Exmouth ; Seacombe , Combermere , 605 ; Chester , Independence , 721 ; Liverpool , Ancient Union , 203 ; Hammersmith Mark , 211 ; Hemming Lodge , 1512 ; Lodge of Faith , Openshaw , c 8 i

Holmesdale , 874 ; Henry , Mark , 216 , Frizington ; Manchester , 570 ; Lodge of Temperance , 169 ; Hundred of Elloe , 469 ; South Saxon Lodge , Lewes , 311 ; Fowey , 977 ; Peace and Harmony , Southampton , 359 ; St . James's , Halifax , 448 .

BOOKS & c , RECEIVED . "The Exeter and Plymouth Gazette , " "The Middlesborough News , " " Liverpool Porcupine , " "The Fountain , " " Our Home , " " City Press , " " Corner Stone , " " Mayfair , " " Buffalo , " " Liverpool Mail , " " Australian Freemason , " " Bye-Laws of the A . and A . Scottish Rite , " Oritnt of Philadelphia , ' Impediments of Speech , by Wm . Abbotts , M . D ., " " Brief , " " Hull Packet , " " Kelet Orient , " " The

Fondon Express , " "The Erasl , " "The Scottish Freemason , " "The Hebrew Leader , " "The Broad Arrow , " "Touchstone , " "The Citizen , " " Freeman , " " New York Dispatch , " " Report of the Thirty-Fourth Half-Ycarly Communication of the District Grand Lodge of Bombay , " " Bundes Prcsse , " " Risorgimcnto , " " Der Triangcl , " " East Anglican Handbook , " " Sheldrake ' s Aldershot and Sandhurst Military Gazette , " " The Boy ' s Own Paper , " ' The Liverpool Mail . "

Births, Marriages, And Deaths.

Births , Marriages , and Deaths .

BIRTHS . BROWN . —On the 13 th inst ., at Durham Hall , Bootle , near Liverpool , the wife of R . Brown , P . M . 241 , Hon . Sec . of the West Lancashire Masonic Educational Institution , of a son . BUSHELL . —On the 14 th inst ., at 24 , Wakefield-st .,

Liverpool , the wife of Samuel Bushell of a daughter . NICHOLSON . —On the 22 nd inst , at Old Bank , Otley , the wife of J . H . Nicholson , of a daughter . PURVIS . —On the 17 th inst ., at Dale-st ., Liveipool , the wife of James Purvis , of Lodge 823 , of a daughter .

SHEEN . —On the 15 thinst ., at 54 , Grove-st ., Liverpool , the wife of Councillor T . H . Sheen , S . W . 241 , of a son . WILKINSON . —On the 17 th inst , at 17 , | Erskine-st ., Liverpool , the wife of Fred . Wilkinson , S . D . Dramatic Lodge , 1609 , Treas . of the Royal Alexandra Theatre , of a daughter .

MARRIAGE . OXI . AUE-STANTON . — On October 13 th ., 1878 , it the Cathedral , Nelson , New Zealand ,, R . Oxlad' ^ , of Sydney , to Sara , eldest daughter of W . M . Stanton , W . M . Loilge 725 , Nelson , New Zealand .

DEATHS . BAUTI . E . —On the 20 th inst . at 236 , Lancaster-rd ., Notting-hill , Bro . W . H . Bailie , only son of Bro . H . Bartie , aged 26 . J ACKSON . —On the 16 th inst ., at 29 , Addington-road , Bow , Mrs . Ann Jackson , aged 62 . Deeply regretted ,

Ar00609

I NOTICE . Owing to the great pressure on our columns of Installation Reports , kc , the Publisher will issue next week ( Feb . est ) four extra pages , in which he hopes to include much matter that unavoidably stands over .

Ar00610

THE FREEMASONSATURDAY , J ANUARY 1 $ , 1879 .

In Memoriam.

IN MEMORIAM .

As week succeeds to week we have to deplore the loss of worthy brethren , whose place in the lodge knows them no more . We announced in our last the death of Commander Scott , R . N ., J . P ., of Strathroy , Omagh , Ireland , and we call attention to it with deep regret . He formed one of that too limited number of enquiring Masons

who sympathize with Masonic literature and hail Masonic Investigation . A kind hearted and friendly brother , he was always anxious to extend the teaching and influence of Freemasonry , to raise its intellectual character , to uphold its civilizing influences . We condole with our Irish brethren on the loss of so true a brother and so good a Mason .

An Error Corrected.

AN ERROR CORRECTED .

A correspondent very kindly calls our attention to a prevalent error , which may do some harm to the Educational Charities , unless pointed out , namely , that lady Life Governors are deprived by the amended rules of their votes in General

Committee . Thatis not so , and was so distinctly decided on Monday last . By the wording of the amended law , as quoted by our correspondent , Lady Life Governors have the same right they had previously under the laws of the two Schools .

The London Masonic Charity Association.

THE LONDON MASONIC CHARITY ASSOCIATION .

We are glad to call attention to the first report of this Association for 1879 , which we were asked to publish last week , and which we think both by its ' modest words and simple statements , and straightforward explanations will commend itself to very many of our London brethren .

We ask the London voters for the Chanties not to be led away by childish canards or personal feelings , but simply to read the report , to think it over carefully , and we have no fear of the result . Moderation and good sense , right reason

and straight running are generally commended by men , and , we feel sure , will be by Masons . Indeed , the need of the Association is so obvious to all who will only condescend to look beneath the surface , that we think the Association is destined to be a great success .

The Origin Of Freemasonry.

THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY .

The origin of that remarkable society , to which it is our privilege to belong , is still a " vexata qutetio " amid Masonic students and non-Masonic enquirers . So peculiar is its organization , and so undoubted its existence , that numerous most contradicting , and even absurd

theories have been broached , from time to time , with dogmatic certainty , as to its rise and progress , its first beginning , its later developement . We may pass over a host of puerile and ridiculous suppositions , and confine ourselves to-day to those within the domain of credibility , evidence , common sense , and even possibility . A

modern magazine writer , ' so late as this last year , propounds this new theory , or rather an old theory in a new dress , in the following words ' - — ' ¦ Saracen architects became scattered during a considerable epoch through Greece , Italy , Sicily , and other countries ; a considerable number of Christian artificers , chiefly Greeks , joined them , forming a corporation , which had its secret laws

The Origin Of Freemasonry.

and statutes , and whose members recognized each other by signs , this was the origin of Freemasonry . " We prefer on this head the theory of Bro . Fort , of " Byzantine Revival , " so to say , but we allude to this passage to point out how , from time to time , such explanations are given of the

orig in of our mysterious brotherhood , and how they should be noted by all , who , not blindly prejudiced by foregone conclusions , are still open to historical evidence and matter of fact , while they are equally unmoved by fantastic explanations or childish and uncritical suggestions . It

may be well to remind our readers here , with the commencement of 18 79 , where we stand in the progressing road of " Masonic investigation . " The theories of Masonic origin , which really deserve attention and study , may , we think , be

safely reduced to three , ist the Guild Theory ; and the Hermetic Theory ; 3 rd the Adaptation Theory . If we wish to study the Guild theory in its past or complete developement , we must read the works of Preston , Findel , Steinbrenner , and above all Fort . Neither must we overlook the

remarkable labours of Bro . David Murray Ljon , the contributions of Bro . Hughan , and other modern writers on the same subject , whose papers are still only to be found in Masonic journals and magazines . The Hermetic theory is mainly to be gathered by implication , as we are

aware of no writer who calmly arrays all the evidence in favour of it . The Adaptation Theory , started by Bro . Buchan , has recently gained a new ally in Bro . Findel and one or two other well known Masons , but we apprehend , " pace " such authorites , that it cannotjface the fire of a

remorseless and destructive criticism . It is altogether hazy and unsatisfactory , and entirely based on " ex post facto" assumptions and preposessions . " It is because it is . " We have often before expressed our view in favour of the Guild Theory , though we have never for one moment shut our eyes

to its many and salient difficulties . It is still , however , the most simple , the most rational , and proceeding more than any other on historical evidence alone best answers to the needful requirements of " cause and effect . " But it is fair to observe , that latterly a good deal of evidence has

" cropped up which seems to give some " colouring" at any rate to the Hermetic view . We say nothing here of the old view of Oliver which links our Freemasonry to the mysteries , or to the skilful use which Bro . Fort has made of this theory , in his remarks on the

Scandinavian mysteries . That is a separate question , and may well even be admitted in part , at any rate by those who accept the guild theory . But what we wish to point out is this , that we have to m odify certain views , which have to this time been universally held as correct , by all modern

critical students of Masonic history . The high grade movement , with its Hermeticism and speci he " colouring matter , " has generally been ascribed to Ramsay , alike in as its first " fautor , " and in its later development under these German mysteries which did such harm to Freemasonry .

Thus Masonic Hermeticism dates from 1750 or thereabouts . But now we have the fact , that in 1721 a Hermetic Society , connected too with Masonry , was apparently existing in London , of which all previous writers have taken no account , being seemingly ignorant of it , and which ,

therefore disturbs all existing calculations and disquisitions on this " moot point . " What this Hermetic Society was we are not told . It may have been the Royal Arch , or it may have been a traditional re-adaptation of the Rosicrucian Hermeticism , which in the times of Lily and

Ashmole , seems to have had many " adepts , " and to form the basis of "Nicolais' " untenable theory of a Baconian - Caroline politico - Hermetico fraternity . We can never too often repeat that the Rose Croix of the A . and A . S . Rite has nothing to do with Rosicrucian Hermeticism ,

though it may be the use of a name . Thus it will be seen how " open " is still the question , and how much ground there is for investigation and , above all , "tolerance , " as regards diverging views and contrasted schools . Freemasons , who are always preaching toleration , should not be

" intolerant " in respect of differing schools of Masonic history , and , as Freemasons , not being too " dogmatic , " above all we should welcome all honest theories and differences , and " agree " to " differ , " if need be harmoniously , sincerely , and fraternally .

“The Freemason: 1879-01-25, Page 6” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 30 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_25011879/page/6/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CONTENTS. Article 1
Untitled Article 1
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 1
Royal Arch. Article 5
Mark Masonry. Article 5
TO OUR READERS. Article 6
TO ADVERTISERS. Article 6
Answers to Correspondents. Article 6
Births, Marriages, and Deaths. Article 6
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 6
IN MEMORIAM. Article 6
AN ERROR CORRECTED. Article 6
THE LONDON MASONIC CHARITY ASSOCIATION. Article 6
THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY. Article 6
Original Correspondence. Article 7
MASONIC CHARITY AND ITINERANTS. Article 7
PROVINCIAL GRAND CHAPTER OF CUMBERLAND AND WESTMORLAND. Article 8
LONDON MASONIC CHARITY ASSOCIATION. Article 8
LODGE OF BENEVOLENCE. Article 8
WYLIE'S HISTORY OF "MOTHER LODGE KILWINNING." Article 8
THE PRINCESS ALICE AND THE FREEMASONS. Article 8
GRAND MASONIC BALL IN LIVERPOOL. Article 8
ORDER OF ST. LAWRENCE. Article 9
Obituary. Article 9
Knights Templar. Article 9
Masonic and General Tidings. Article 9
Notes on Art. Article 10
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS Article 10
MASONIC MEETINGS IN WEST LANCASHIRE AND CHESHIRE. Article 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Page 1

Page 1

5 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

5 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

11 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

7 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

7 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

10 Articles
Page 6

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

To Our Readers.

TO OUR READERS .

The FREEMASON is a Weekly News paper , price 2 d . It is published every Friday morning , and contains the most important , interesting , and useful information relating to Freemasonry in every degree . Subscription , including postage : United America , India , India , China , & c .

Kingdom , the Continent , & c . Via Bnndisi . Twelve Months ios . 6 d . 12 s . od . 17 s . 4 d . Six „ 5 s . 3 d . 6 s . 6 d . 8 s . 8 d . Three „ 2 s . 8 d . 3 s . 3 d . 4 s . 6 d . ' Subscriptions may be paid for in stamps , but Post Office Orders or Cheques are preferred , the former payable to GEORGE KENNING , CHIEF OFFICE , LONDON , the latter crossed London Joint Stock Bank .

To Advertisers.

TO ADVERTISERS .

The FREEMASON has a large circulation in all parts of the Globe , its advantages as an advertising medium can therefore scarcely be overrated . ADVERTISEMENTS to ensure insertion in current week's issue should reach the Office , 198 , Fleet-street , by 12 o ' clock on "Wednesdays .

SCALE OF CHARGES FOR ADVERTISEMENTS . Whole of backpage ... £ 12 12 o Half ,, „ 6 10 o Inside pages ... ... 7 7 ° Half of ditto 400 Quarter ditto ... ... ... ... 2 10 o Whole column ... ... ... 2 10 o

Half „ 1 10 o Quarter „ ... ... ... ... ... 1 o o Per inch ... ... ... 050 These prices are for single insertions . A liberal reduction is made for a series of 13 , 26 , and 32 insertions . Further particulars may be obtained of the Publisher , 198 , Fleet-street , London .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

P . M . —You will find all you appear to require in Kenning ' s Masonic Cyclopaedia . ATLAS . —At Freemasons' Tavern , on the 12 th proximo . W . M . —Yours is a ritual question which , we think , it is unaavisa ' ole to discuss in The Freemason . The Editor will wiite privately .

The following reports stand over : —Royal Sussex , 342 ; Mount Sinai , Penzance , 121 ; Sun , 106 , Exmouth ; Seacombe , Combermere , 605 ; Chester , Independence , 721 ; Liverpool , Ancient Union , 203 ; Hammersmith Mark , 211 ; Hemming Lodge , 1512 ; Lodge of Faith , Openshaw , c 8 i

Holmesdale , 874 ; Henry , Mark , 216 , Frizington ; Manchester , 570 ; Lodge of Temperance , 169 ; Hundred of Elloe , 469 ; South Saxon Lodge , Lewes , 311 ; Fowey , 977 ; Peace and Harmony , Southampton , 359 ; St . James's , Halifax , 448 .

BOOKS & c , RECEIVED . "The Exeter and Plymouth Gazette , " "The Middlesborough News , " " Liverpool Porcupine , " "The Fountain , " " Our Home , " " City Press , " " Corner Stone , " " Mayfair , " " Buffalo , " " Liverpool Mail , " " Australian Freemason , " " Bye-Laws of the A . and A . Scottish Rite , " Oritnt of Philadelphia , ' Impediments of Speech , by Wm . Abbotts , M . D ., " " Brief , " " Hull Packet , " " Kelet Orient , " " The

Fondon Express , " "The Erasl , " "The Scottish Freemason , " "The Hebrew Leader , " "The Broad Arrow , " "Touchstone , " "The Citizen , " " Freeman , " " New York Dispatch , " " Report of the Thirty-Fourth Half-Ycarly Communication of the District Grand Lodge of Bombay , " " Bundes Prcsse , " " Risorgimcnto , " " Der Triangcl , " " East Anglican Handbook , " " Sheldrake ' s Aldershot and Sandhurst Military Gazette , " " The Boy ' s Own Paper , " ' The Liverpool Mail . "

Births, Marriages, And Deaths.

Births , Marriages , and Deaths .

BIRTHS . BROWN . —On the 13 th inst ., at Durham Hall , Bootle , near Liverpool , the wife of R . Brown , P . M . 241 , Hon . Sec . of the West Lancashire Masonic Educational Institution , of a son . BUSHELL . —On the 14 th inst ., at 24 , Wakefield-st .,

Liverpool , the wife of Samuel Bushell of a daughter . NICHOLSON . —On the 22 nd inst , at Old Bank , Otley , the wife of J . H . Nicholson , of a daughter . PURVIS . —On the 17 th inst ., at Dale-st ., Liveipool , the wife of James Purvis , of Lodge 823 , of a daughter .

SHEEN . —On the 15 thinst ., at 54 , Grove-st ., Liverpool , the wife of Councillor T . H . Sheen , S . W . 241 , of a son . WILKINSON . —On the 17 th inst , at 17 , | Erskine-st ., Liverpool , the wife of Fred . Wilkinson , S . D . Dramatic Lodge , 1609 , Treas . of the Royal Alexandra Theatre , of a daughter .

MARRIAGE . OXI . AUE-STANTON . — On October 13 th ., 1878 , it the Cathedral , Nelson , New Zealand ,, R . Oxlad' ^ , of Sydney , to Sara , eldest daughter of W . M . Stanton , W . M . Loilge 725 , Nelson , New Zealand .

DEATHS . BAUTI . E . —On the 20 th inst . at 236 , Lancaster-rd ., Notting-hill , Bro . W . H . Bailie , only son of Bro . H . Bartie , aged 26 . J ACKSON . —On the 16 th inst ., at 29 , Addington-road , Bow , Mrs . Ann Jackson , aged 62 . Deeply regretted ,

Ar00609

I NOTICE . Owing to the great pressure on our columns of Installation Reports , kc , the Publisher will issue next week ( Feb . est ) four extra pages , in which he hopes to include much matter that unavoidably stands over .

Ar00610

THE FREEMASONSATURDAY , J ANUARY 1 $ , 1879 .

In Memoriam.

IN MEMORIAM .

As week succeeds to week we have to deplore the loss of worthy brethren , whose place in the lodge knows them no more . We announced in our last the death of Commander Scott , R . N ., J . P ., of Strathroy , Omagh , Ireland , and we call attention to it with deep regret . He formed one of that too limited number of enquiring Masons

who sympathize with Masonic literature and hail Masonic Investigation . A kind hearted and friendly brother , he was always anxious to extend the teaching and influence of Freemasonry , to raise its intellectual character , to uphold its civilizing influences . We condole with our Irish brethren on the loss of so true a brother and so good a Mason .

An Error Corrected.

AN ERROR CORRECTED .

A correspondent very kindly calls our attention to a prevalent error , which may do some harm to the Educational Charities , unless pointed out , namely , that lady Life Governors are deprived by the amended rules of their votes in General

Committee . Thatis not so , and was so distinctly decided on Monday last . By the wording of the amended law , as quoted by our correspondent , Lady Life Governors have the same right they had previously under the laws of the two Schools .

The London Masonic Charity Association.

THE LONDON MASONIC CHARITY ASSOCIATION .

We are glad to call attention to the first report of this Association for 1879 , which we were asked to publish last week , and which we think both by its ' modest words and simple statements , and straightforward explanations will commend itself to very many of our London brethren .

We ask the London voters for the Chanties not to be led away by childish canards or personal feelings , but simply to read the report , to think it over carefully , and we have no fear of the result . Moderation and good sense , right reason

and straight running are generally commended by men , and , we feel sure , will be by Masons . Indeed , the need of the Association is so obvious to all who will only condescend to look beneath the surface , that we think the Association is destined to be a great success .

The Origin Of Freemasonry.

THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY .

The origin of that remarkable society , to which it is our privilege to belong , is still a " vexata qutetio " amid Masonic students and non-Masonic enquirers . So peculiar is its organization , and so undoubted its existence , that numerous most contradicting , and even absurd

theories have been broached , from time to time , with dogmatic certainty , as to its rise and progress , its first beginning , its later developement . We may pass over a host of puerile and ridiculous suppositions , and confine ourselves to-day to those within the domain of credibility , evidence , common sense , and even possibility . A

modern magazine writer , ' so late as this last year , propounds this new theory , or rather an old theory in a new dress , in the following words ' - — ' ¦ Saracen architects became scattered during a considerable epoch through Greece , Italy , Sicily , and other countries ; a considerable number of Christian artificers , chiefly Greeks , joined them , forming a corporation , which had its secret laws

The Origin Of Freemasonry.

and statutes , and whose members recognized each other by signs , this was the origin of Freemasonry . " We prefer on this head the theory of Bro . Fort , of " Byzantine Revival , " so to say , but we allude to this passage to point out how , from time to time , such explanations are given of the

orig in of our mysterious brotherhood , and how they should be noted by all , who , not blindly prejudiced by foregone conclusions , are still open to historical evidence and matter of fact , while they are equally unmoved by fantastic explanations or childish and uncritical suggestions . It

may be well to remind our readers here , with the commencement of 18 79 , where we stand in the progressing road of " Masonic investigation . " The theories of Masonic origin , which really deserve attention and study , may , we think , be

safely reduced to three , ist the Guild Theory ; and the Hermetic Theory ; 3 rd the Adaptation Theory . If we wish to study the Guild theory in its past or complete developement , we must read the works of Preston , Findel , Steinbrenner , and above all Fort . Neither must we overlook the

remarkable labours of Bro . David Murray Ljon , the contributions of Bro . Hughan , and other modern writers on the same subject , whose papers are still only to be found in Masonic journals and magazines . The Hermetic theory is mainly to be gathered by implication , as we are

aware of no writer who calmly arrays all the evidence in favour of it . The Adaptation Theory , started by Bro . Buchan , has recently gained a new ally in Bro . Findel and one or two other well known Masons , but we apprehend , " pace " such authorites , that it cannotjface the fire of a

remorseless and destructive criticism . It is altogether hazy and unsatisfactory , and entirely based on " ex post facto" assumptions and preposessions . " It is because it is . " We have often before expressed our view in favour of the Guild Theory , though we have never for one moment shut our eyes

to its many and salient difficulties . It is still , however , the most simple , the most rational , and proceeding more than any other on historical evidence alone best answers to the needful requirements of " cause and effect . " But it is fair to observe , that latterly a good deal of evidence has

" cropped up which seems to give some " colouring" at any rate to the Hermetic view . We say nothing here of the old view of Oliver which links our Freemasonry to the mysteries , or to the skilful use which Bro . Fort has made of this theory , in his remarks on the

Scandinavian mysteries . That is a separate question , and may well even be admitted in part , at any rate by those who accept the guild theory . But what we wish to point out is this , that we have to m odify certain views , which have to this time been universally held as correct , by all modern

critical students of Masonic history . The high grade movement , with its Hermeticism and speci he " colouring matter , " has generally been ascribed to Ramsay , alike in as its first " fautor , " and in its later development under these German mysteries which did such harm to Freemasonry .

Thus Masonic Hermeticism dates from 1750 or thereabouts . But now we have the fact , that in 1721 a Hermetic Society , connected too with Masonry , was apparently existing in London , of which all previous writers have taken no account , being seemingly ignorant of it , and which ,

therefore disturbs all existing calculations and disquisitions on this " moot point . " What this Hermetic Society was we are not told . It may have been the Royal Arch , or it may have been a traditional re-adaptation of the Rosicrucian Hermeticism , which in the times of Lily and

Ashmole , seems to have had many " adepts , " and to form the basis of "Nicolais' " untenable theory of a Baconian - Caroline politico - Hermetico fraternity . We can never too often repeat that the Rose Croix of the A . and A . S . Rite has nothing to do with Rosicrucian Hermeticism ,

though it may be the use of a name . Thus it will be seen how " open " is still the question , and how much ground there is for investigation and , above all , "tolerance , " as regards diverging views and contrasted schools . Freemasons , who are always preaching toleration , should not be

" intolerant " in respect of differing schools of Masonic history , and , as Freemasons , not being too " dogmatic , " above all we should welcome all honest theories and differences , and " agree " to " differ , " if need be harmoniously , sincerely , and fraternally .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 5
  • You're on page6
  • 7
  • 10
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy