Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Jan. 26, 1901
  • Page 12
  • MASONIC JURISPRUDENCE.
Current:

The Freemason, Jan. 26, 1901: Page 12

  • Back to The Freemason, Jan. 26, 1901
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE EASTERN DIVISION OF SOUTH AFRICA. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article MASONIC JURISPRUDENCE. Page 1 of 2
    Article MASONIC JURISPRUDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 12

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Eastern Division Of South Africa.

passed , but more particularly from the District Grand Master ' s address , we judge that , in spite of the adverse circumstances of the time , Freemasonry has fared better than might have been expected . Speaking generally , Bro . EGAN was able to congratulate

the meeting on the excellent spirit that had been shown by the lodges and brethren during the progress of the war . As regards the lodges in those localities which have been more immediately affected , Lodge Rising Star , No . 1022 , Bloemfontein , had been kept "in working order by the energies of their W . M ., Bro .

HAARBURGHER , but no working was recorded until after the occupation" of the town by the English army , and since then there had been four joinings and two initiations . Bro . HAARBURGHER , though he has been W . M . for two years in succession , still continues to occupy the chair , but this is due to the fact

of no one having been elected in his stead . The lodge at Burghersdorp , for which Bro . EGAN , just before the war broke out , had granted a Provisional Warrant , and the M . W . G . Master has since granted a Regular Warrant , did no work at all while the town was in the occupation of the Boers , but since British

rule has been established it has met and framed bye-laws , and will , at no distant date , be regularly constituted . Frere Lodge , No . 2089 , Aliwal North , at the outbreak of the war applied for a Dispensation to cease work , and as no Returns had been received , the Dist . G . Master inferred that work had not been

resumed . Wodehouse Lodge , No . 1467 , Dordrecht , was in a somewhat similar position , and the St . Paul ' s , No . 9 8 9 , Adelaide , was only held together by a few brethren who paid the customary dues in the hope that more prosperous times might come , and the lodge be once again on the road to prosperity .

Bro . EGAN also referred at some length to the steps which had been taken during the year for relieving the distresses of brethren who had suffered by the war , and especially to the appointment of a Sub-Committee to administer relief in the District derived from the South African Masonic Relief Fund

which was started early last year by United Grand Lodge ; but on the whole there does not appear so much distress as might have been anticipated , though no doubt , as the country becomes more settled , cases will turn up of which , under present

circumstances , no report is possible . Indeed , of all the various Funds connected with or fostered by the District Grand Lodge the Educational appears to have fared the worst , the subscriptions during tne ye ' ar having fallen to £ 315 as ' compared with £ 485 in the previous year .

As regards the general financial position , it seems to be on the whole satisfactory , the balances in bank and on deposit totalling up ^ 2286 , made up of—^ 150 on General Fund ; ^ 905 on Reserve Fund ; £ 1113 on Benevolent Fund ; and £ 112 on Special Relief Fund . We may also mention that the year ' s-

Statement of Receipts and Expenditure in respect of the Masonic Education . Fund , is , save in the particular we have specified favourable , there being balances of £ 237 and £ 4 in Standarc Bank and Savings Bank respectively , at the close of account , in

addition to Mortgage Bonds to the value of £ 1500 and Fixed Deposit in Standard Bank of £ 200 . The number of children at present on the Fund is 26 , while as many as 148 have been elected recipients of its benefits since the Fund was established

Masonic Jurisprudence.

MASONIC JURISPRUDENCE .

[ COMMUNICATED . ! RULES OF DEBATE .

( Continued . ) It should be remembered that collective expressions ol approval—as we may call them for want of a better termsuch as applause and clapping of the hands , as well as similai expressions of disapproval , are quite out of place in a lodge

room . A single clap is sometimes permitted , the origin of which is obvious . Article 72 refers to a particular form of expressing disapproval , and describes it very fittingly as un-Masonic , and

conduct which demands exclusion ipso facto without vote taken . Whilst Article 72 refers to Grand Lodge only , the conduc ; referred to would doubtless be considered as " sufficient cause " in Article 210 , and even come under the summary jurisdiction of

Article 209 . It is a general impression that the speaker may at any point of his remarks be interrupted by any one who " rises to a point of order . " This is strictly true , but it is very desirable that the brother who acts in such a manner should first of all have accurate

knowledge of what constitutes disorder , and , secondly , that his motive should be beyond suspicion . The W . M . is after all the best judge of what is Masonieally decorous or otherwise , and the frequent interposition of other brelhren , where they are not personally concerned , is somewhat of a reflection upon tht Master ' s capacity .

Masonic Jurisprudence.

As a matter of fact , the occurrence of disorder within the lodge-does not usually arise from the conduct of a brother speaking , but from those who ought to be listening . We might with advantage read No . VI . of the Ancient Charges and

Regulations"You are not to hold private committees or separate conversation without leave from the Master , nor to talk of anything impertinently or unseemly , nor to interrupt the Master or Wardens , or any brother speaking to the Master , nor behave yourself

ludicrously or jestingly while the lodge is engaged upon what is serious and solemn , nor use any unbecoming language upon any pretence whatsoever , but to pay due reverence to your Master , Wardens , and fellows , and put them to worship . "

The frequent occurrence of private conversation during the progress of lodge work is a serious nuisance , and one which demands the stern interposition of the Master . It is somewhat noticeable that the brethren on the dais are often offenders in this respect , and so long as this is so , how can humbler brethren be expected to maintain due decorum .

All business other than routine should be notified in the summons , and , having in view the possibility of non-confirmation at a succeeding meeting , the Worshipful Master should think twice before he allows this rule to be broken . It would form a very good ground indeed for a motion to that effect if it were

found that contentious business had been sprung upon the lodge is it were , and a vote taken in the absence of brethren who might possibly have the keenest interest in the subject , and who would have made strenuous efforts to be present had they known

it was coming on . The moral weight of a snatch vote is not much , and even if the Master ' s action be acquiesced in , brethren are discontented , and feel that they have not been treated with proper respect .

Many lodges have a wholesome bye-law limiting the hour at which business of any kind—other than ceremonial—may be entered upon , and unless such bye-law expressly gives the Master a discretionary power to suspend it , there ought to be no question as to its observance . A lodge is bound b y its own

bye-laws quite as much as by the Constitutions , and , in fact , the Grand Master ' s approval of the bye-laws has the practical effect of making them constitutions as far as the particular lodge is concerned . In addition to its entry in the summons there is business of a certain kind which demands notice of motion in

open lodge . Propositions are , of course , included in such , and . he suspension of the rule is hedged about with such formalities ( Art . 185 ) as to show that only very real emergencies are contemplated . In Grand . Lodge there is no option . Articles 52 and following require that no business shall be considered in Grand

Lodge of which notice has not been given to the General Committee . We . hold that a Worshi pful Master would act within his legal right in declining to admit any proposition of

which notice had not been given in open lodge , but inasmuch as he writer cannot recollect any official decision as to that effect , he opinion must be regarded as a personal one , and taken / Itanium valeat .

The brother who gives notice of motion should not make a speech . First of all , by so doing he forestalls what he has to say when the time comes for it to be put forward . Then he gives his opponents , if any , a whole month in which to work up

a case against him , with the advantage of knowing what line he is going to take . And , again , if it be notice of a motion to the prejudice of any brother , as , for instance , a question of exclusion , he has no right to make an ex parte statement , possibl y in that brother ' s absence .

Notice of motion necessaril y secures precedence The writer once had to contend with a very obstinate bye-law of his lodge which said that no opposed motion could be considered after eight o ' clock . As certain official brethren were anxious to avoid the discussion of a question which he was equally anxious

to bring forward , the ceremonial work was protracted each evening of lodge meeting until the hour named was reached , when he was blandly informed that the bye-law referred to stood in the way of the business being brought on . A reference Lo the Provincial authority elicited the opinion that as it did not

matter apparently at what hour ceremonial work was undertaken , the writer ' s notice of motion gave it a claim to be heard immediately after the opening routine was despatched . The opinion may be right or it may be wrong , but it served its purpose . Article 55 , which deals with the comparative priority of

motions , would seem to indicate its correctness , but then there is no ceremonial work in Grand Lodge , and , as a general principle , no proposition , however important , ought to interpose between a candidate and the Light . A very important part of lod ge proceedings is the con-

“The Freemason: 1901-01-26, Page 12” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 31 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_26011901/page/12/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
INDEX TO VOL. XXXIX. Article 3
THE CHRISTMAS NUMBER OF "THE FREEMASON.'' Article 6
LIST OF PORTRAITS & ILLUSTRATIONS. Article 7
HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN. Article 8
THE LATE QUEEN VICTORIA. Article 9
HIS MAJESTY KING EDWARD VII. Article 10
COURT CIRCULAR. Article 11
THE LATE QUEEN VICTORIA. Article 11
UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ANCIENT FREE AND ACCEPTED MASONS OF ENGLAND. Article 11
THE EASTERN DIVISION OF SOUTH AFRICA. Article 11
MASONIC JURISPRUDENCE. Article 12
CONSECRATION OF THE DARTMOUTH MARK LODGE, No. 545, AT SLAITHWAITE, WEST YORKSHIRE. Article 13
BOARD OF BENEVOLENCE. Article 14
IN MEMORIAM. Article 14
Knights Templar. Article 14
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 15
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Ad 16
Untitled Article 16
Masonic Notes. Article 16
Reviews. Article 17
Craft Masonry. Article 17
Science, Art, and the Drama. Article 18
MINOR ARTISTS AND ARCHITECTS IN THE REIGN OF ELIZABETH. Article 18
ST. JOHN'S WOOD AND SOME OF ITS CELEBRITIES. Article 18
GENERAL NOTES. Article 18
Craft Masonry. Article 19
Instruction. Article 21
Royal Arch. Article 21
WILLS AND BEQUESTS. Article 21
Untitled Article 22
Untitled Ad 22
Untitled Ad 22
Untitled Ad 22
Untitled Ad 22
Untitled Article 23
Masonic and General Tidings. Article 23
The Craft Abroad. Article 23
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

4 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

4 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

6 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

5 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

16 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

8 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

5 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

2 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

2 Articles
Page 21

Page 21

5 Articles
Page 22

Page 22

7 Articles
Page 23

Page 23

4 Articles
Page 12

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Eastern Division Of South Africa.

passed , but more particularly from the District Grand Master ' s address , we judge that , in spite of the adverse circumstances of the time , Freemasonry has fared better than might have been expected . Speaking generally , Bro . EGAN was able to congratulate

the meeting on the excellent spirit that had been shown by the lodges and brethren during the progress of the war . As regards the lodges in those localities which have been more immediately affected , Lodge Rising Star , No . 1022 , Bloemfontein , had been kept "in working order by the energies of their W . M ., Bro .

HAARBURGHER , but no working was recorded until after the occupation" of the town by the English army , and since then there had been four joinings and two initiations . Bro . HAARBURGHER , though he has been W . M . for two years in succession , still continues to occupy the chair , but this is due to the fact

of no one having been elected in his stead . The lodge at Burghersdorp , for which Bro . EGAN , just before the war broke out , had granted a Provisional Warrant , and the M . W . G . Master has since granted a Regular Warrant , did no work at all while the town was in the occupation of the Boers , but since British

rule has been established it has met and framed bye-laws , and will , at no distant date , be regularly constituted . Frere Lodge , No . 2089 , Aliwal North , at the outbreak of the war applied for a Dispensation to cease work , and as no Returns had been received , the Dist . G . Master inferred that work had not been

resumed . Wodehouse Lodge , No . 1467 , Dordrecht , was in a somewhat similar position , and the St . Paul ' s , No . 9 8 9 , Adelaide , was only held together by a few brethren who paid the customary dues in the hope that more prosperous times might come , and the lodge be once again on the road to prosperity .

Bro . EGAN also referred at some length to the steps which had been taken during the year for relieving the distresses of brethren who had suffered by the war , and especially to the appointment of a Sub-Committee to administer relief in the District derived from the South African Masonic Relief Fund

which was started early last year by United Grand Lodge ; but on the whole there does not appear so much distress as might have been anticipated , though no doubt , as the country becomes more settled , cases will turn up of which , under present

circumstances , no report is possible . Indeed , of all the various Funds connected with or fostered by the District Grand Lodge the Educational appears to have fared the worst , the subscriptions during tne ye ' ar having fallen to £ 315 as ' compared with £ 485 in the previous year .

As regards the general financial position , it seems to be on the whole satisfactory , the balances in bank and on deposit totalling up ^ 2286 , made up of—^ 150 on General Fund ; ^ 905 on Reserve Fund ; £ 1113 on Benevolent Fund ; and £ 112 on Special Relief Fund . We may also mention that the year ' s-

Statement of Receipts and Expenditure in respect of the Masonic Education . Fund , is , save in the particular we have specified favourable , there being balances of £ 237 and £ 4 in Standarc Bank and Savings Bank respectively , at the close of account , in

addition to Mortgage Bonds to the value of £ 1500 and Fixed Deposit in Standard Bank of £ 200 . The number of children at present on the Fund is 26 , while as many as 148 have been elected recipients of its benefits since the Fund was established

Masonic Jurisprudence.

MASONIC JURISPRUDENCE .

[ COMMUNICATED . ! RULES OF DEBATE .

( Continued . ) It should be remembered that collective expressions ol approval—as we may call them for want of a better termsuch as applause and clapping of the hands , as well as similai expressions of disapproval , are quite out of place in a lodge

room . A single clap is sometimes permitted , the origin of which is obvious . Article 72 refers to a particular form of expressing disapproval , and describes it very fittingly as un-Masonic , and

conduct which demands exclusion ipso facto without vote taken . Whilst Article 72 refers to Grand Lodge only , the conduc ; referred to would doubtless be considered as " sufficient cause " in Article 210 , and even come under the summary jurisdiction of

Article 209 . It is a general impression that the speaker may at any point of his remarks be interrupted by any one who " rises to a point of order . " This is strictly true , but it is very desirable that the brother who acts in such a manner should first of all have accurate

knowledge of what constitutes disorder , and , secondly , that his motive should be beyond suspicion . The W . M . is after all the best judge of what is Masonieally decorous or otherwise , and the frequent interposition of other brelhren , where they are not personally concerned , is somewhat of a reflection upon tht Master ' s capacity .

Masonic Jurisprudence.

As a matter of fact , the occurrence of disorder within the lodge-does not usually arise from the conduct of a brother speaking , but from those who ought to be listening . We might with advantage read No . VI . of the Ancient Charges and

Regulations"You are not to hold private committees or separate conversation without leave from the Master , nor to talk of anything impertinently or unseemly , nor to interrupt the Master or Wardens , or any brother speaking to the Master , nor behave yourself

ludicrously or jestingly while the lodge is engaged upon what is serious and solemn , nor use any unbecoming language upon any pretence whatsoever , but to pay due reverence to your Master , Wardens , and fellows , and put them to worship . "

The frequent occurrence of private conversation during the progress of lodge work is a serious nuisance , and one which demands the stern interposition of the Master . It is somewhat noticeable that the brethren on the dais are often offenders in this respect , and so long as this is so , how can humbler brethren be expected to maintain due decorum .

All business other than routine should be notified in the summons , and , having in view the possibility of non-confirmation at a succeeding meeting , the Worshipful Master should think twice before he allows this rule to be broken . It would form a very good ground indeed for a motion to that effect if it were

found that contentious business had been sprung upon the lodge is it were , and a vote taken in the absence of brethren who might possibly have the keenest interest in the subject , and who would have made strenuous efforts to be present had they known

it was coming on . The moral weight of a snatch vote is not much , and even if the Master ' s action be acquiesced in , brethren are discontented , and feel that they have not been treated with proper respect .

Many lodges have a wholesome bye-law limiting the hour at which business of any kind—other than ceremonial—may be entered upon , and unless such bye-law expressly gives the Master a discretionary power to suspend it , there ought to be no question as to its observance . A lodge is bound b y its own

bye-laws quite as much as by the Constitutions , and , in fact , the Grand Master ' s approval of the bye-laws has the practical effect of making them constitutions as far as the particular lodge is concerned . In addition to its entry in the summons there is business of a certain kind which demands notice of motion in

open lodge . Propositions are , of course , included in such , and . he suspension of the rule is hedged about with such formalities ( Art . 185 ) as to show that only very real emergencies are contemplated . In Grand . Lodge there is no option . Articles 52 and following require that no business shall be considered in Grand

Lodge of which notice has not been given to the General Committee . We . hold that a Worshi pful Master would act within his legal right in declining to admit any proposition of

which notice had not been given in open lodge , but inasmuch as he writer cannot recollect any official decision as to that effect , he opinion must be regarded as a personal one , and taken / Itanium valeat .

The brother who gives notice of motion should not make a speech . First of all , by so doing he forestalls what he has to say when the time comes for it to be put forward . Then he gives his opponents , if any , a whole month in which to work up

a case against him , with the advantage of knowing what line he is going to take . And , again , if it be notice of a motion to the prejudice of any brother , as , for instance , a question of exclusion , he has no right to make an ex parte statement , possibl y in that brother ' s absence .

Notice of motion necessaril y secures precedence The writer once had to contend with a very obstinate bye-law of his lodge which said that no opposed motion could be considered after eight o ' clock . As certain official brethren were anxious to avoid the discussion of a question which he was equally anxious

to bring forward , the ceremonial work was protracted each evening of lodge meeting until the hour named was reached , when he was blandly informed that the bye-law referred to stood in the way of the business being brought on . A reference Lo the Provincial authority elicited the opinion that as it did not

matter apparently at what hour ceremonial work was undertaken , the writer ' s notice of motion gave it a claim to be heard immediately after the opening routine was despatched . The opinion may be right or it may be wrong , but it served its purpose . Article 55 , which deals with the comparative priority of

motions , would seem to indicate its correctness , but then there is no ceremonial work in Grand Lodge , and , as a general principle , no proposition , however important , ought to interpose between a candidate and the Light . A very important part of lod ge proceedings is the con-

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 11
  • You're on page12
  • 13
  • 23
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy