Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Illustrated
  • Nov. 1, 1903
  • Page 10
  • Ad01002
Current:

The Masonic Illustrated, Nov. 1, 1903: Page 10

  • Back to The Masonic Illustrated, Nov. 1, 1903
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Ad Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Non-Christian Freemasons. Page 1 of 1
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ad01001

LONDON , N . W . otel , H Grand Midland Venetian Rooms now available for Masonic Dinners , etc . Other Midland Railway Hotels at Liverpool , Leeds , Bradford , Derby , Morecombe , and Hey sham . Chief Office : W . TOWLE , Midland Grand Hotel , Manager . London , N . W . IV * . R . Hotels , etc .

Ad01003

PERRIER-JOUET & Co ' s . CHAMPAGNES . FINEST VINTAGE RESERVE-CUVEES . THE FAVOURITE MASONIC BRAND . Agent—A . BOURSOT , 9 , Hart Street , Hark Lane , London .

Ad01002

ASSURANCE . EXCHANGE L ROYA IXCOKPOKATKI ) . A . I ) . 1 / 20 . Funds in Hand Exceed - - , £ 4 , 900 , 000 Claims Paid Exceed - - £ 41 , 000 , 000 FIRE , LIFE , MARINE , ANNUITIES , ACCIDENTS , BURGLARY , EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY . New and Special Concession to Private House Insurers . Apply for full Prospectus to Hie Sccnimy . Head Office : —ROYAL EXCHANGE , LONDON , E . G .

Ad01004

ffi ^ Sc tavanrana

Non-Christian Freemasons.

Non-Christian Freemasons .

THA 1 persons who do not acknowledge the Christian Faith are not on that account alone , ineligible for admission to our Order , litis long ago been decided by competent authority , it is not , therefore , of any practical value to discuss the question from the legal standpoint . Such persons are not only freely admitted , subject

always to the chances of ballot , but many lodges have been warranted for their exclusive enjoyment . One of the earliest examples of a non-Christian being made a Freemason was on April 14 th , 18 35 , when the ambassador of the King of Oudh was initiated in " Lodge Friendship , No . 6 . " The

Grand Master himself supplied a copy of the Koran for purposes of obligation , and the Worshipful Master Avas a clergyman . This might be regarded as exceptional , for it was not till 1865 that the admission of Hindus , Parsis and Muhammadans became common . No legal enactment , of

course , can override the landmarks , but , seeing that a belief in a Supreme Being is a fundamental part of the religions named , these may be said to be safeguarded .

It may , however , be profitable to ask whether sufficient safeguards exist , that those who differ from us so much in religious belief can adequately comprehend the obligations of a Freemason . Up to 18 9 8 , it was always possible to ask whether a

non-Christian could accept the Holy Bible as the great light of the Order . It was possible that he did not believe a word of it , but , nevertheless , up to the year mentioned , it always lay exposed even in lodges warranted as non-Christian , as that whereon the Order was founded , but the Grand Registrar

gave a wider definition of the V . S . L . than before existed in Masonic circles , and allowed it to include the Koran , the Zendavesta , the Shasters , etc ., whatever book , in fact , contained the religious belief of the brother concerned . This ruling had the great advantage that it cleared away one

great initial difficulty , and made it possible to consider the accession of the heathen to our Order with reference to first principles . The V . S . L . is used in two different ways in English lodges . First of all it represents the first great fight ,, and secondly it is used for the purposes of obligation . This

latter employment is the survival of an old custom , and has its counterpart in many other communities . But are the terms of our obligations comprehensible to a non-Christian ? The Hindu , for instance , is morally and intellectually on quite a different plane from his European brother . His ideas of honour , for instance , are not such as would commend themselves to the traditions

of a public school , unless he has been brought into intimate contact Avith Europeans . We doubt whether he would appreciate the beautiful lessons of the Hiramic legend . His conception of what is meant by brotherly love is in the great majority of cases bounded by the extent of his family connections . As to the third of our great principles , no one who

knows the oriental well will be found to contend that an overpowering appreciation of the beauty of the truth is a prominent characteristic of Eastern races . It must be further remembered that practically all our ceremonial references and legends are founded on biblical

incidents , and these references are used in a way that presupposes a knowledge of the event alluded to and its attendant circumstances . So long as the bible held a place of honour in the lodge as the great light of the Order , all these references , or rather their existence in our ceremonies ,

could be explained . But now that a person may enter the Order without knowing that there is such a book in the world as the bible , it would seem as if the ceremonies which accompany his admission must be absolutely meaningless . Then , again , Freemasonry is defined as inculcating the

practice of every moral and social virtue . This comes to the Christian , when he hears the expression for the first time , as but emphasizing what he has been told ever since he could understand anything at all . But it comes to the Hindu as something new . The religion of the Vedas is not one of practising virtue for its own sake . Probably no religions but the Christians and the Buddhist are .

to found a ceremonial system which should be the visible means of conveying what Freemasonry is intended to convey , or any book but the bible , is absolutely impossible . No other religion but the Christian teaches either the Fatherhood of God or the Brotherhood of Man . If the Order is to be open to every sect of every

religion , justice would demand that in India a moulvic , or a Brahman guru , should be appointed at intervals to this high office of Grand Chaplain , and in this connection there seems to be some consistency in the procedure of the Grand Lodge of Scotland , or , we should say , of all Scottish Freemasonry in

India , which numbers among its Grand Officers a Koran bearer , a Zendavesta bearer , and the like . With our present ritual and lectures and traditions , a non-Christian cannot possibly become a Freemason unless a concession lias been made on one side or the other . He will have to modif y

many of his beliefs , to the extent of recasting many of them , or else we shall have to put till our lectures and traditions and beliefs in the melting-pot and recast them , and the latter alternative we do not think either probable or possible .

“The Masonic Illustrated: 1903-11-01, Page 10” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 9 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mil/issues/mil_01111903/page/10/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Freemasonry in Scotland. Article 2
Masonic Bazaar at Glasgow. Article 2
Consecration of the University of Edinburgh Lodge, No. 2974. Article 4
Consecration of the United Wards Lodge. Article 5
Somersetshire Lodge, No. 2925. Article 6
Untitled Ad 7
Untitled Ad 7
London Welsh Lodge, No. 2867, Article 8
Consecration of the Empress Preceptory. Article 9
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Untitled Ad 10
Non-Christian Freemasons. Article 10
At the Sign of the Perfect Ashlar. Article 11
Untitled Article 14
Oration Delivered at the Consecration of the Empress Preceptory Article 15
Two Remarkable Patents. Article 16
"Where Masons do Congregate." Article 19
Godfroi de Bouillon Preceptory of Knights Templar. Article 20
Untitled Ad 20
Untitled Ad 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

5 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Ad01001

LONDON , N . W . otel , H Grand Midland Venetian Rooms now available for Masonic Dinners , etc . Other Midland Railway Hotels at Liverpool , Leeds , Bradford , Derby , Morecombe , and Hey sham . Chief Office : W . TOWLE , Midland Grand Hotel , Manager . London , N . W . IV * . R . Hotels , etc .

Ad01003

PERRIER-JOUET & Co ' s . CHAMPAGNES . FINEST VINTAGE RESERVE-CUVEES . THE FAVOURITE MASONIC BRAND . Agent—A . BOURSOT , 9 , Hart Street , Hark Lane , London .

Ad01002

ASSURANCE . EXCHANGE L ROYA IXCOKPOKATKI ) . A . I ) . 1 / 20 . Funds in Hand Exceed - - , £ 4 , 900 , 000 Claims Paid Exceed - - £ 41 , 000 , 000 FIRE , LIFE , MARINE , ANNUITIES , ACCIDENTS , BURGLARY , EMPLOYERS' LIABILITY . New and Special Concession to Private House Insurers . Apply for full Prospectus to Hie Sccnimy . Head Office : —ROYAL EXCHANGE , LONDON , E . G .

Ad01004

ffi ^ Sc tavanrana

Non-Christian Freemasons.

Non-Christian Freemasons .

THA 1 persons who do not acknowledge the Christian Faith are not on that account alone , ineligible for admission to our Order , litis long ago been decided by competent authority , it is not , therefore , of any practical value to discuss the question from the legal standpoint . Such persons are not only freely admitted , subject

always to the chances of ballot , but many lodges have been warranted for their exclusive enjoyment . One of the earliest examples of a non-Christian being made a Freemason was on April 14 th , 18 35 , when the ambassador of the King of Oudh was initiated in " Lodge Friendship , No . 6 . " The

Grand Master himself supplied a copy of the Koran for purposes of obligation , and the Worshipful Master Avas a clergyman . This might be regarded as exceptional , for it was not till 1865 that the admission of Hindus , Parsis and Muhammadans became common . No legal enactment , of

course , can override the landmarks , but , seeing that a belief in a Supreme Being is a fundamental part of the religions named , these may be said to be safeguarded .

It may , however , be profitable to ask whether sufficient safeguards exist , that those who differ from us so much in religious belief can adequately comprehend the obligations of a Freemason . Up to 18 9 8 , it was always possible to ask whether a

non-Christian could accept the Holy Bible as the great light of the Order . It was possible that he did not believe a word of it , but , nevertheless , up to the year mentioned , it always lay exposed even in lodges warranted as non-Christian , as that whereon the Order was founded , but the Grand Registrar

gave a wider definition of the V . S . L . than before existed in Masonic circles , and allowed it to include the Koran , the Zendavesta , the Shasters , etc ., whatever book , in fact , contained the religious belief of the brother concerned . This ruling had the great advantage that it cleared away one

great initial difficulty , and made it possible to consider the accession of the heathen to our Order with reference to first principles . The V . S . L . is used in two different ways in English lodges . First of all it represents the first great fight ,, and secondly it is used for the purposes of obligation . This

latter employment is the survival of an old custom , and has its counterpart in many other communities . But are the terms of our obligations comprehensible to a non-Christian ? The Hindu , for instance , is morally and intellectually on quite a different plane from his European brother . His ideas of honour , for instance , are not such as would commend themselves to the traditions

of a public school , unless he has been brought into intimate contact Avith Europeans . We doubt whether he would appreciate the beautiful lessons of the Hiramic legend . His conception of what is meant by brotherly love is in the great majority of cases bounded by the extent of his family connections . As to the third of our great principles , no one who

knows the oriental well will be found to contend that an overpowering appreciation of the beauty of the truth is a prominent characteristic of Eastern races . It must be further remembered that practically all our ceremonial references and legends are founded on biblical

incidents , and these references are used in a way that presupposes a knowledge of the event alluded to and its attendant circumstances . So long as the bible held a place of honour in the lodge as the great light of the Order , all these references , or rather their existence in our ceremonies ,

could be explained . But now that a person may enter the Order without knowing that there is such a book in the world as the bible , it would seem as if the ceremonies which accompany his admission must be absolutely meaningless . Then , again , Freemasonry is defined as inculcating the

practice of every moral and social virtue . This comes to the Christian , when he hears the expression for the first time , as but emphasizing what he has been told ever since he could understand anything at all . But it comes to the Hindu as something new . The religion of the Vedas is not one of practising virtue for its own sake . Probably no religions but the Christians and the Buddhist are .

to found a ceremonial system which should be the visible means of conveying what Freemasonry is intended to convey , or any book but the bible , is absolutely impossible . No other religion but the Christian teaches either the Fatherhood of God or the Brotherhood of Man . If the Order is to be open to every sect of every

religion , justice would demand that in India a moulvic , or a Brahman guru , should be appointed at intervals to this high office of Grand Chaplain , and in this connection there seems to be some consistency in the procedure of the Grand Lodge of Scotland , or , we should say , of all Scottish Freemasonry in

India , which numbers among its Grand Officers a Koran bearer , a Zendavesta bearer , and the like . With our present ritual and lectures and traditions , a non-Christian cannot possibly become a Freemason unless a concession lias been made on one side or the other . He will have to modif y

many of his beliefs , to the extent of recasting many of them , or else we shall have to put till our lectures and traditions and beliefs in the melting-pot and recast them , and the latter alternative we do not think either probable or possible .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 9
  • You're on page10
  • 11
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy