Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • April 7, 1866
  • Page 7
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, April 7, 1866: Page 7

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, April 7, 1866
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. ← Page 2 of 3 →
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

tatingly admitted the fact , but before I would endorse the word "touting , " I requested of one of the pretendedly aggrieved brethren , professedly learned in the law , a definition of that word . This brother stated the meaning to be " soliciting for customers . " I affirmed that , in this sense , Avith the information I had I could notas a man of common sensebut

, , believe my assertion true , although I utterly disclaimed charging any brother individually of touting , and Avhich fact , was unreservedly corroborated by each of the three brethren to whom I madetli ^ admitted statement . So far as regarded the proposer and seconder-I most distinctladmitted thatafter the

, y , statements they bad made , I could not suppose they bad been ' guilty of touting . At the same time I offered unreservedly to communicate fully and freely my reasons for coming to the conclusions I had expressed , viz ., that undue influence had been used by some party—if tho brethren would treat my

statements Avith that Masonic secrecy in which 1 would only reveal them , because a non-Mason Avas involved in the disclosure . This proviso the W ; M . and the proposer utterly repudiated , the latter declaring that , as the charge had been made public ( by himself ) , so should any explanation be made public . I then made the additional offer to name to the Master of

the lodge , m his official capacity , the facts which hacl come to my knowledge , leaving it to him to make any use he thought proper of the information . This offer the W . M . indignantly refused , ancl in his reply disgraced his position by charging me with evasion , subterfuge , and falsehood , Avinding up with a recommendation to the lodt . exclude me . The excluded

ge member of another lodge took up the challenge , and gave notice of motion to that effect . Then follows a scene which Avould , I believe , disgrace a bear garden or a prize fight , and the lodge is closed in perfect harmonv .

The next production is a printed circular summons ( of Avhich you have already a copy ) , printed to the order of the W . M . by the " gentleman withdraAvn ( although the Secretary of the " lodge is a printer ) , charging me , in large type , with gross un-Masonic conduct , and being , as I am advised , an

actionable libel . At the meeting for which this circular ivas a summons , there Avas an unusually large muster of the regular attendants at the lodge . As soon as the minutes had been confirmed , the excluded member of another lodge and not legally member of any lodge , proposed , and a brother , Avho hacl not

thought proper to speak to me for more than a year on account of a business dispute , seconded , that I h ^ excluded the lodge ; not the sli ghtest attempt having been made to oiler anything in the shape o £ proof of the charge trumped up against me ! After waiting ¦ some time iu vainfor at least some allusion to the

, charge , and after informing the W . M . that I believed it Avas usual to prefer some pretence of a charge against an Englishman before expecting him to make a defence , I nevertheless gave a full , fair , simple , and truthful explanation of the whole affair . Again and again utterldenying the false charge of accusing

y any individual member . of the lodge of touting ( whatever good cause I might raise for doing so ) , but at the same time producing such clear and uumistakeable evidence tending to any fears I had expressed , generally , of undue influence that every unprejudiced

brother was perfectly satisfied , a fact manifested , as stated iu my former letter , by brethren jumping up on all sides , and ( although they avowed they came to the lodge , having heard only one side of the story , prejudiced against me ) , begging the motion might be withdrawn and the subject dropped . The only voice raised a ? ainst this course was that of the Quondam

prosecutor ; and seeing the stream taking a direction quite contrary to his Avishes , this Sir Oracle of the lodge , with a design so deep that many of tho brethren did not fathom it , proposed that the discussion be postponed for a month : aud although I protested that a jury having been empanelled to try a certain charge having heard the defence and the Master having

summed up , a verdict ought at once to be delivered : although I denounced the course proposed as a flagrant outrage upon simple justice , which could only have been devised by a brother of the long robe , the lodge , evidently viewing this as an easy method of disposing of the question , fell into the trap and

consented to the proposition ; many of my friends assuring me of their belief that nothing more Avould be heard of the matter . Unfortunately , instead of this being the case , the whole thing Avas a ruse as I expected , and when I arrived at the adjourned lodge I found it so evidentlpacked thatbut for ulterior

y , objects in vieAv , I should have immediately retired iu disgust . Instead of the regular attendants there were only a few besides the clique I hacl ever seen in this lodge , although for many years a constant attendant myself , Avhilst there Avere some I did not even know to be Masons at all . I have said unfortunately

only because it Avill inflict upon me au additional loss of time and expense in order to right myself in so simple aud straightforward a matter before an impartial ancl honest tribunal . And UOAV , briefly , to the details of this mock trial . I commenced by inquiring of the Master if this were a trial by jury or what Avas it ? This impartial brother immediately put

me doAvn by the thunder of his gavel , at the same time informing rae that he knew nothing about trial by jury , but that the brother AVIIO had moved the adjournment of the debate , although he had made a long speech already to the question , would address the lodge ( notwithstanding one of the regulations of

the Graft " that no brother shall speak twice to the same question" ) . Sir Oracle taking advantage of this sagacious ruling , proceeded to enlighten the numerous brethren who appeared hi the lodge for the first time of late , and Avho were , consequentl y : in blissful igno ° ranee of the wnole affair , with " the exact position in

Which matters stood . " And considering he professed to be the principally aggrieved party in the transaction , his narrative was , of course , perfectly unA'arnished , unbiassed , and unprejudiced . Although well knowing it Avas utterly out of his poAver , he did not attempt in any shape or form to offer a shadow of proof iu respect to the charge trumped up by himself against

me . Upon the learned brother resuming his seat , I instincti \ ely rose to make some reply before this entirely new jury ; to defend myself against the charge was simply needless . As no attempt to substantiate it had been made , I Avas most ruthlessly aud outrageously ordered to resume my seat , the representative of K . S . informing mo that 1 had spoken once for' an hour and a half , and not another word I had

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1866-04-07, Page 7” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 6 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_07041866/page/7/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE DOCTRINES OF JESUITISM. Article 1
THOUGHTS ON THE BEAUTIFUL. Article 3
THE NEW ORDER OF MERIT. Article 5
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 6
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 6
FREEMASONRY IN JERSEY. Article 8
MASONIC HYMNS. Article 9
THE MASONIC MIRROR Article 9
METROPOLITAN. Article 9
PROVINCIAL. Article 10
ROYAL ARCH. Article 12
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 12
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR Article 12
CHANNEL ISLANDS. Article 12
AMERICA. Article 13
WEST INDIES. Article 13
CHINA. Article 13
Obituary. Article 14
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 14
NOTES ON LITERATURE, SCIENCE, MUSIC, DRAMA, AND THE FINE ARTS. Article 15
MEETINGS OF THE SCIENTIFIC AND LEARNED SOCIETIES FOR THE WEEK ENDING APRIL 14TH, 1866. Article 16
THE WEEK. Article 17
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

tatingly admitted the fact , but before I would endorse the word "touting , " I requested of one of the pretendedly aggrieved brethren , professedly learned in the law , a definition of that word . This brother stated the meaning to be " soliciting for customers . " I affirmed that , in this sense , Avith the information I had I could notas a man of common sensebut

, , believe my assertion true , although I utterly disclaimed charging any brother individually of touting , and Avhich fact , was unreservedly corroborated by each of the three brethren to whom I madetli ^ admitted statement . So far as regarded the proposer and seconder-I most distinctladmitted thatafter the

, y , statements they bad made , I could not suppose they bad been ' guilty of touting . At the same time I offered unreservedly to communicate fully and freely my reasons for coming to the conclusions I had expressed , viz ., that undue influence had been used by some party—if tho brethren would treat my

statements Avith that Masonic secrecy in which 1 would only reveal them , because a non-Mason Avas involved in the disclosure . This proviso the W ; M . and the proposer utterly repudiated , the latter declaring that , as the charge had been made public ( by himself ) , so should any explanation be made public . I then made the additional offer to name to the Master of

the lodge , m his official capacity , the facts which hacl come to my knowledge , leaving it to him to make any use he thought proper of the information . This offer the W . M . indignantly refused , ancl in his reply disgraced his position by charging me with evasion , subterfuge , and falsehood , Avinding up with a recommendation to the lodt . exclude me . The excluded

ge member of another lodge took up the challenge , and gave notice of motion to that effect . Then follows a scene which Avould , I believe , disgrace a bear garden or a prize fight , and the lodge is closed in perfect harmonv .

The next production is a printed circular summons ( of Avhich you have already a copy ) , printed to the order of the W . M . by the " gentleman withdraAvn ( although the Secretary of the " lodge is a printer ) , charging me , in large type , with gross un-Masonic conduct , and being , as I am advised , an

actionable libel . At the meeting for which this circular ivas a summons , there Avas an unusually large muster of the regular attendants at the lodge . As soon as the minutes had been confirmed , the excluded member of another lodge and not legally member of any lodge , proposed , and a brother , Avho hacl not

thought proper to speak to me for more than a year on account of a business dispute , seconded , that I h ^ excluded the lodge ; not the sli ghtest attempt having been made to oiler anything in the shape o £ proof of the charge trumped up against me ! After waiting ¦ some time iu vainfor at least some allusion to the

, charge , and after informing the W . M . that I believed it Avas usual to prefer some pretence of a charge against an Englishman before expecting him to make a defence , I nevertheless gave a full , fair , simple , and truthful explanation of the whole affair . Again and again utterldenying the false charge of accusing

y any individual member . of the lodge of touting ( whatever good cause I might raise for doing so ) , but at the same time producing such clear and uumistakeable evidence tending to any fears I had expressed , generally , of undue influence that every unprejudiced

brother was perfectly satisfied , a fact manifested , as stated iu my former letter , by brethren jumping up on all sides , and ( although they avowed they came to the lodge , having heard only one side of the story , prejudiced against me ) , begging the motion might be withdrawn and the subject dropped . The only voice raised a ? ainst this course was that of the Quondam

prosecutor ; and seeing the stream taking a direction quite contrary to his Avishes , this Sir Oracle of the lodge , with a design so deep that many of tho brethren did not fathom it , proposed that the discussion be postponed for a month : aud although I protested that a jury having been empanelled to try a certain charge having heard the defence and the Master having

summed up , a verdict ought at once to be delivered : although I denounced the course proposed as a flagrant outrage upon simple justice , which could only have been devised by a brother of the long robe , the lodge , evidently viewing this as an easy method of disposing of the question , fell into the trap and

consented to the proposition ; many of my friends assuring me of their belief that nothing more Avould be heard of the matter . Unfortunately , instead of this being the case , the whole thing Avas a ruse as I expected , and when I arrived at the adjourned lodge I found it so evidentlpacked thatbut for ulterior

y , objects in vieAv , I should have immediately retired iu disgust . Instead of the regular attendants there were only a few besides the clique I hacl ever seen in this lodge , although for many years a constant attendant myself , Avhilst there Avere some I did not even know to be Masons at all . I have said unfortunately

only because it Avill inflict upon me au additional loss of time and expense in order to right myself in so simple aud straightforward a matter before an impartial ancl honest tribunal . And UOAV , briefly , to the details of this mock trial . I commenced by inquiring of the Master if this were a trial by jury or what Avas it ? This impartial brother immediately put

me doAvn by the thunder of his gavel , at the same time informing rae that he knew nothing about trial by jury , but that the brother AVIIO had moved the adjournment of the debate , although he had made a long speech already to the question , would address the lodge ( notwithstanding one of the regulations of

the Graft " that no brother shall speak twice to the same question" ) . Sir Oracle taking advantage of this sagacious ruling , proceeded to enlighten the numerous brethren who appeared hi the lodge for the first time of late , and Avho were , consequentl y : in blissful igno ° ranee of the wnole affair , with " the exact position in

Which matters stood . " And considering he professed to be the principally aggrieved party in the transaction , his narrative was , of course , perfectly unA'arnished , unbiassed , and unprejudiced . Although well knowing it Avas utterly out of his poAver , he did not attempt in any shape or form to offer a shadow of proof iu respect to the charge trumped up by himself against

me . Upon the learned brother resuming his seat , I instincti \ ely rose to make some reply before this entirely new jury ; to defend myself against the charge was simply needless . As no attempt to substantiate it had been made , I Avas most ruthlessly aud outrageously ordered to resume my seat , the representative of K . S . informing mo that 1 had spoken once for' an hour and a half , and not another word I had

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 6
  • You're on page7
  • 8
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy