Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Dec. 12, 1868
  • Page 10
  • MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Dec. 12, 1868: Page 10

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Dec. 12, 1868
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. ← Page 2 of 5 →
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

pally because they had sworn to each other to be as brothers . " * Saga of Sigurd the Crusader , 1103—30 . —There is a ceremonial connected with Masonry which the following remark shows the origin of : — " AVhen you rose up out of Jordanafter bathing in the same

, waters as God himself , with palm leaves in your hands and the cross upon your breast , it was something else you promised , sire , than to eat flesh meat on a Eridav . "—A

WII . HAH THE EIOX S CHAUTEE . Malcolm ' s Charter has been consigned to the tomb of all the Capulets—Bequicscat in iwce—and , after going the pace so heavily , we may sorrowfully surmise that after " life ' s fitful fever , it sleeps well ! " We come now to a more serious document , the Charter from William the Lion . This document being genuine , the question for discussion is the import of its contents .

I may premise that whatever qualms of conscience our good friend , Bro . Buchau , entertains for his share iu the slaughtering of the Innocent Malcolm Charter , they will be more than compensated for in the additional respect which his indomitable p luck , perseverance , and love of truth , compel the brethren of all

opinions to entertain for him . With regard to Mother Kilwinning aud the Canongage Kilwinning , he will find me a willing coadjutor in stri pping them of any false plumes they may be possessed of . I do not think any reader of the Magazine , whether an antagonist or not , will doubt that in all the

discussions which have taken place in which I have shared , but that I have been actuated b y the sole desire of benefitting our beloved Order , by ' getting rid as much as possible of the fuugus quackery which has overgrown capital aud base . I may also be permitted to say that the reign of William the Liou is one with

which I am intimately acquainted , because I discard much to the chagrin of my family , the beautiful fiction of the rise of the Hayes at the Battle of Luucarty , and maintain that the true homo prcepositus of the

house is William de la Haya , principal cupbearer to Malcolm the Fourth and William the Lion , and witness ^ to many of their charters . If , then , as a relative told me , I " have no respect for the ashes of my fathers , " it is not likely that predilections will lead me to bolster up a lie on the part of my mothers .

Aud , aftar this piece of famil y bunkum , let us consider the Glasgow Charter of William the Lion . I am prepared in the first place to accept Bro . Buehan ' s translation of the charter as given in 4 < 73 of the Magazine as correct , having compared it with the original Latin . I have several objections to the

construction put upon it by Bro . Buchan . 1 st . It is not a charter ^ of confirmation iu the exact aud strict terms of the word , as it confirms no previous charter , document , or gift appearing in writing . 2 ud . It is not a charter at all , but a simple letter of safe conduct . Eor the sake of classificationit have

, may been endorsed " carta ;' ' but a " carta " means a very different form of document from the present . 3 rd . It was granted to the Bishop , aud as he might see fit , for his use alone . 4 th . The Fraternity , properly

Sodality , was not one of builders ; and , 5 th . The document was of a provisional character , and not granted in perpetuity . Every student of history knows that the reign of William the Lion was anything but peaceful ; the nobles were fierce aud turbulent , aud the northern

clans distracted by deadly feuds . Neither was the south in a better condition , where the Scots and English Borderers were driving daily forays into each other's territories . The scene as displayed by the charter opens thus . The Glasgow Cathedral has been destroyed by fire , the King is applied to for assistance

in rebuilding it , and his influence solicited with other good men to procure the requisite sum . Glasgow Cathedral ' s revenues , we are told , were not in the most flourishing condition prior to the fire , and it is easy to assume that the fire did not improve them . The King sympathises with the prayer of the petition , and grants a letter of safeguard to the Bishop for those who mig ht be sent forth to collect subscriptions . So far there is no cavil as to the details .

Now we find a fraternity has been authorised by the Bishop and his suffragan Court , to collect the money , aud the King devoutly receives and encourages with the support of his royal protection , its members . Bro . Buchan says that this fraternity was composed of builders . Is this a likely case ? The builders had to

rear the Cathedral , aud to be paid for so doing ; the . Bishop had to find the sinews of war . Bro . Buchan would have us believe that , not only did the builders rear the Cathedral , but they reared it at their own cost , by money obtained by begging . How was the money principally raised ? I should say by preaching

at celebrated and wealthy monasteries and shrines , where the faithful most " congregated . This could only have been done by monks , by those who , having no longer a roof to shelter them , went in search of the means wherewith to pay the builders , then busy in rearing a new one . The Masons could not at the

same time be both builders aud beggars . It was therefore a safeconduct to his monks which was granted by the King to the Bishop , and this is all the more evident froai the provisional character of the documeut , which bears that the King ' s protection

is granted " until the completion of the building itself' ' When the Cathedral was finished , the documeut then became so much waste parchment for any good it could serve . The fraternity , iu my opiniou , consisted of monks , or , in some cases , notorious sinners , who , to win pardon and be relieved from the ban of

excommunication , helped in the good work ; and there might also have been devotees , who to win grace and favour in the eyes of God , assisted iu obtaining money for the erection of a temple to His name . The fraternity is not said to be composed of builders , and it is impossible to put such a construction upon it .

But , as I have formerly said , there is no proof that the builders of Glasgow Cathedral were the predecessors of 3 ' - ' , aud even if it could be proved that the charter was granted for tbe protection of builders , 3- must proved its descent . In the consideration of all these circumstances , it is clear to my

mind that the Lodge of Gfasgow cannot found upon the charter of William the Lion . William the Lion , in 1190 , converted Glasgow into a burgh , but for a century and a half after it was an insignificant town of not more than 1 , 500 inhabitants . —A . ONEAL HATE .

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1868-12-12, Page 10” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 24 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_12121868/page/10/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
SKETCHES OF NOTABLE MASONIC WORKS. Article 1
CHIPS OF FOREIGN ASHLAR. Article 6
MASONIC DISCIPLINE.—II. Article 8
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 14
THE MASONIC LIFEBOAT. Article 14
CANADIAN HIGH DEGREES. Article 14
BRO. MANNINGHAM. Article 15
MASONIC MEMS. Article 15
METROPOLITAN. Article 16
PROVINCIAL. Article 17
CHANNEL ISLANDS. Article 18
SCOTLAND. Article 19
ROYAL ARCH. Article 19
MARK MASONRY. Article 19
RED CROSS OF ROME AND CONSTANTINE. Article 20
METROPOLITAN LODGE MEETINGS, ETC.. FOR THE WEEK ENDING DECEMBER 19TH , 1868. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

2 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

5 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

5 Articles
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

pally because they had sworn to each other to be as brothers . " * Saga of Sigurd the Crusader , 1103—30 . —There is a ceremonial connected with Masonry which the following remark shows the origin of : — " AVhen you rose up out of Jordanafter bathing in the same

, waters as God himself , with palm leaves in your hands and the cross upon your breast , it was something else you promised , sire , than to eat flesh meat on a Eridav . "—A

WII . HAH THE EIOX S CHAUTEE . Malcolm ' s Charter has been consigned to the tomb of all the Capulets—Bequicscat in iwce—and , after going the pace so heavily , we may sorrowfully surmise that after " life ' s fitful fever , it sleeps well ! " We come now to a more serious document , the Charter from William the Lion . This document being genuine , the question for discussion is the import of its contents .

I may premise that whatever qualms of conscience our good friend , Bro . Buchau , entertains for his share iu the slaughtering of the Innocent Malcolm Charter , they will be more than compensated for in the additional respect which his indomitable p luck , perseverance , and love of truth , compel the brethren of all

opinions to entertain for him . With regard to Mother Kilwinning aud the Canongage Kilwinning , he will find me a willing coadjutor in stri pping them of any false plumes they may be possessed of . I do not think any reader of the Magazine , whether an antagonist or not , will doubt that in all the

discussions which have taken place in which I have shared , but that I have been actuated b y the sole desire of benefitting our beloved Order , by ' getting rid as much as possible of the fuugus quackery which has overgrown capital aud base . I may also be permitted to say that the reign of William the Liou is one with

which I am intimately acquainted , because I discard much to the chagrin of my family , the beautiful fiction of the rise of the Hayes at the Battle of Luucarty , and maintain that the true homo prcepositus of the

house is William de la Haya , principal cupbearer to Malcolm the Fourth and William the Lion , and witness ^ to many of their charters . If , then , as a relative told me , I " have no respect for the ashes of my fathers , " it is not likely that predilections will lead me to bolster up a lie on the part of my mothers .

Aud , aftar this piece of famil y bunkum , let us consider the Glasgow Charter of William the Lion . I am prepared in the first place to accept Bro . Buehan ' s translation of the charter as given in 4 < 73 of the Magazine as correct , having compared it with the original Latin . I have several objections to the

construction put upon it by Bro . Buchan . 1 st . It is not a charter ^ of confirmation iu the exact aud strict terms of the word , as it confirms no previous charter , document , or gift appearing in writing . 2 ud . It is not a charter at all , but a simple letter of safe conduct . Eor the sake of classificationit have

, may been endorsed " carta ;' ' but a " carta " means a very different form of document from the present . 3 rd . It was granted to the Bishop , aud as he might see fit , for his use alone . 4 th . The Fraternity , properly

Sodality , was not one of builders ; and , 5 th . The document was of a provisional character , and not granted in perpetuity . Every student of history knows that the reign of William the Lion was anything but peaceful ; the nobles were fierce aud turbulent , aud the northern

clans distracted by deadly feuds . Neither was the south in a better condition , where the Scots and English Borderers were driving daily forays into each other's territories . The scene as displayed by the charter opens thus . The Glasgow Cathedral has been destroyed by fire , the King is applied to for assistance

in rebuilding it , and his influence solicited with other good men to procure the requisite sum . Glasgow Cathedral ' s revenues , we are told , were not in the most flourishing condition prior to the fire , and it is easy to assume that the fire did not improve them . The King sympathises with the prayer of the petition , and grants a letter of safeguard to the Bishop for those who mig ht be sent forth to collect subscriptions . So far there is no cavil as to the details .

Now we find a fraternity has been authorised by the Bishop and his suffragan Court , to collect the money , aud the King devoutly receives and encourages with the support of his royal protection , its members . Bro . Buchan says that this fraternity was composed of builders . Is this a likely case ? The builders had to

rear the Cathedral , aud to be paid for so doing ; the . Bishop had to find the sinews of war . Bro . Buchan would have us believe that , not only did the builders rear the Cathedral , but they reared it at their own cost , by money obtained by begging . How was the money principally raised ? I should say by preaching

at celebrated and wealthy monasteries and shrines , where the faithful most " congregated . This could only have been done by monks , by those who , having no longer a roof to shelter them , went in search of the means wherewith to pay the builders , then busy in rearing a new one . The Masons could not at the

same time be both builders aud beggars . It was therefore a safeconduct to his monks which was granted by the King to the Bishop , and this is all the more evident froai the provisional character of the documeut , which bears that the King ' s protection

is granted " until the completion of the building itself' ' When the Cathedral was finished , the documeut then became so much waste parchment for any good it could serve . The fraternity , iu my opiniou , consisted of monks , or , in some cases , notorious sinners , who , to win pardon and be relieved from the ban of

excommunication , helped in the good work ; and there might also have been devotees , who to win grace and favour in the eyes of God , assisted iu obtaining money for the erection of a temple to His name . The fraternity is not said to be composed of builders , and it is impossible to put such a construction upon it .

But , as I have formerly said , there is no proof that the builders of Glasgow Cathedral were the predecessors of 3 ' - ' , aud even if it could be proved that the charter was granted for tbe protection of builders , 3- must proved its descent . In the consideration of all these circumstances , it is clear to my

mind that the Lodge of Gfasgow cannot found upon the charter of William the Lion . William the Lion , in 1190 , converted Glasgow into a burgh , but for a century and a half after it was an insignificant town of not more than 1 , 500 inhabitants . —A . ONEAL HATE .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 9
  • You're on page10
  • 11
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy