Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • June 16, 1860
  • Page 8
  • INTERESTING REMINISCENCE.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, June 16, 1860: Page 8

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, June 16, 1860
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article EARLY HISTORY OF MASONRY IN NEW YORK. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article A DEFENCE OF MASONIC SECRECY. Page 1 of 1
    Article A DEFENCE OF MASONIC SECRECY. Page 1 of 1
    Article INTERESTING REMINISCENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 8

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Early History Of Masonry In New York.

I intended . I may renew the subject at some future time . — American Voice of Masonry .

A Defence Of Masonic Secrecy.

A DEFENCE OF MASONIC SECRECY .

AA ' rc are condemned for keeping the essentials of our institution from the knowledge of those ivho arc not members of it ; ivhich , it is said , must sufficiently prove them to be of a bad nature and tendency , else why arc they not made public for the satisfaction of mankind . If secrecy be a virtue—a thing never yet denied—can that be imputed to us as a crime , which has been considered an excellence in all ages ? Does not Solomon , the wisest of men , tell us , " He that discovers secrets is a traitor , but a . man of a faithful spirit , concealeth tbe matter , "

In conducting all worldly affairs , secrecy is not only essential , but absolutely necessary ; and was ever esteemed a quality of the greatest worth . Thus ire find the great Fenelon makes Ul ysses , in the system ofthe education which he delivers to his friends for his son ' Telemachus , particularly enjoin them , above all , to render him just , beneficent , sincere , and faithful in keeping secrets ; a precept ' that afterwards

produced the best of consequences to tbe youno- prince , of whom it is recorded , that with this great excellence of ° taciturnity , he not only divested himself of that close mysterious air , so common to the reserved , but also constantly avoided tellin" - the least untruth in support of this part of his character . A conduct highly worthy the imitation of every one to whom secrets are intrustedaffording them a pattern of easeand sin

, openness , , - cerity ; for while he seemed to carry his whole heart upon his lips , communicating what was of no importance , yet he knew howto stop just in the proper moment , without proceeding to those things which might raise any suspicion , or furnish even a hint to discover the purposes of his mind . If we turn our eyes back to antiquity , we shall find the old Egyptians had so great a regard for silence and secrecy in the of their reliion

mysteries g , that they set up the god Harpocrates ( vid . imagines deorian a vic . enlio cltartario ) , to whom they paid peculiar honour and veneration , who was represented with his right hand placed near the heart , and the left down by bis side covered ivith a skm before , full of eyes ancl ears , to signify that of many things to be seen and heard , few are to be published . And among the same letheir great goddess Isisthe

peop , , Minerva of the Greeks , bad always an image of a Sphynx placed at the entrance of her temples , to denote that secrets were there preserved under sacred coverings , that they might be kept from the knoivledge of the vulgar , as much as the riddles of that

creature . Jamblicus , iti bis life of P ythagoras , confirms the above opinion by observing , that from the mysterious knowled ge ofthe Eo-yptians that philosopher drew the system of bis symbolical , learnim- ami instructive tenets , seeing that the princi ples ancl wise doctrines ol this nation ivere ever kept secret among themselves , and were delivered down , not in writing , but onl y ' by oral tradition 'And indeed cautious and th

so prudent were ey in these matters that every disciple admitted to their wise and scientific mysteries was bound m the most solemn manner to conceal such mysteries from the vulgar , or those whose ideas were not sufficiently exalted to receive them . As a proof of this , we need onl y recollect the story of Ilipparcbus a P ythagorean , who , having out of spleen and resentment , violated and broke through the several ennao-c-ments of the held

society , was in the utmost detestation , expelled the school as one most infamous and abandoned , anel as he was dead to the principles of virtue ancl philosophy , had a tomb erected for him according to their custom , as though he had been natnralhclcad Ihe shame ami disgrace that justly attended so rrrcata breach of truth ancl fidelit y drove the unhappy wretch to such despair that he proved his own executioner and abhorred

; so was even Ins memory , that be was denied the rights ancl ceremonies of burial used to the dead in those times ; instead of which , his body was suHcrcd to he upon tbe shore of the isle of Samos Among the Greek nations , the Athenians bad a statue of brass , winch they awfully revered ; this fi gure was Avithout a tongue by winch secrecy was intimated .

Ihe Romans had a goddess of silence , named Angcroiia , represented with her forefinger on her lips . n . symbol of ' prudence anil taciturnity . ' ' Aiinaxarchu . s ivho , according to Pliny , was apprehended in order to extort his secrets from him , bit bis tongue in the midst ami afterwards spit it in the tyrant ' s face , rather choosiim- to lose that organ than to discover those things ivhich he had nronii « ed to conceal . L

A Defence Of Masonic Secrecy.

AVe read likewise thai C ; ito , the Censor , often said to his friends , of three things ivhich be had good reason to repent , the principal was , divulging a secret . The Druids in our OAVU nation—who were the only priests among the Ancient Britons—committed nothing to writing . And Cir-sar observes that they had a head or chief , who exercised a sort of excommunication , attended with dreadful penalties , on those

who cither published or profaned their mysteries . Therefore , since it evidently appears from the foregoing instances —among many other—that there ever ivere secrets amongst mankind , as well respecting societies as individuals , and that the keeping those inviolable ivas always reputed an indispensable dut y , and attended with an honourable estimation , it must be very difficult to assign a sufficient reason why the same practice

should be at all wondered at or less approved in the Free and Accepted Masons of the present age , than they were among the wisest men and greatest philosophers of antiquity . The general practice and constant applause of the ancients , as well as the customs of the moderns , one would naturally imagine should be sufficient to justify Masons against any charge of singularity or innovation on this account ; for how can this be thought

singular , or neiv , I 13 ' any one who will but calmly allow himself the smallest time for reflection . Do not all incorporated bodies amongst us enjoy this liberty without impeachment or censure ? An apprentice is bound to keep the secrets of his master ; a free man is obliged to consult the interests of his company , and not prostitute in common the mysteries of his profession ; secret committees and privy councils

are solemnly enjoined not to publish abroad their debates and resolutions . In courts martial , the members are bound to secrecy ; and in many cases for more effectual security an oath is administered .

As in society in general , ire are united together b 3 ' our indigencies and infirmities , ancl a vast variety of circumstances contributing to our mutual and necessary dependence on each other ¦ —ivhich lays a grand foundation for terrestrial happiness , by securing general amity and the reciprocation of good offices in the world—so , iu all particular societies , of whatever denomination , they are all conjoined by a sort of cement ; by bonds and

laws that are peculiar to each of them , from the highest assemblies to the loAvest . Consequently the injunctions of secrecy among Freemasons , can be no more unwarrantable than in the societies and cases already pointed out ; and to report , or even to insinuate , that they are , must argue a want of candour , a want of reason , and a want of charity . For by the laws of nature , and of nations , every individual and every society has a ri ght to be supposed

innocent till proved otherwise . Yet , notwithstanding the mysteries of our profession are kept inviolable , none are excluded from a full knowledge of them , hi due time and manner , upon proper application , and being found capable and worthy of tbe trust . To form other designs and expectations , is building on a sandy foundation , and ivill only serve to testify , that like a rash man , their discretion is always out ofthe way when they have most occasion to make use of it . — Wellins Calcoll , 1709 .

Interesting Reminiscence.

INTERESTING REMINISCENCE .

[ W F . copy the following from an address delivered before the Grand Lodge of Virginia , 011 the 10 th of December , 1815 , by M . AV . Robert G . Scott , P . G . M . ] In peace and in war , in the camp or tbe peaceful village , among civilized man or with the untamed spirits of the ivilderness , Masonry , genuine , true Masonry , will be found to qualify us the better to render service to our ' fellow man or grateful obedience

to our God . Valued and venerated for its nnticpiity , as well as the great moral doctrines it inculcates , Masonry has provided and furnished to its followers a common language—one that is intelligible to Masons alone—one by which intercourse can be held and wants be made known in safety and in secrecy from the rest of mankind . By ivhich the Egyptian and tlie Englishman , the Frenchman and the Otahitian may communicate without speaking

or understanding a word of the language of their respective nations . Through this common language ' the most deadl y strife is quieted—brother embraces brother , oi- rushes to his relief at . the most imminent hazard of his own life or safety . The arm that is raised against a prostrate brother , which in another instant ivould drive the deadly steel to his heart , falls subdued and palsied , by the mystic influence of a single r-vy . Blessed , glorious institution , that can thus tame the mad passions of men . even in the bloody battle strife . Yes , my friends and brothers , this is no fancy sketch , no idle

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1860-06-16, Page 8” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 10 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_16061860/page/8/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CLASSICAL THEOLOGY.—XXI. Article 1
THE RIGHTS OF FREEMASONS. Article 2
TEMPLAR CLOTHING IN THE UNITED STATES. Article 5
EARLY HISTORY OF MASONRY IN NEW YORK. Article 7
A DEFENCE OF MASONIC SECRECY. Article 8
INTERESTING REMINISCENCE. Article 8
THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY Article 9
ARCHÆOLOGY. Article 9
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 10
Literature. Article 11
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 13
METROPOLITAN. Article 13
PROVINCIAL. Article 13
MARK MASONRY. Article 14
ROYAL ARCH. Article 14
GIBRALTAR. Article 15
CANADA. Article 16
AMERICA, Article 18
THE WEEK. Article 18
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

4 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

4 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

4 Articles
Page 8

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Early History Of Masonry In New York.

I intended . I may renew the subject at some future time . — American Voice of Masonry .

A Defence Of Masonic Secrecy.

A DEFENCE OF MASONIC SECRECY .

AA ' rc are condemned for keeping the essentials of our institution from the knowledge of those ivho arc not members of it ; ivhich , it is said , must sufficiently prove them to be of a bad nature and tendency , else why arc they not made public for the satisfaction of mankind . If secrecy be a virtue—a thing never yet denied—can that be imputed to us as a crime , which has been considered an excellence in all ages ? Does not Solomon , the wisest of men , tell us , " He that discovers secrets is a traitor , but a . man of a faithful spirit , concealeth tbe matter , "

In conducting all worldly affairs , secrecy is not only essential , but absolutely necessary ; and was ever esteemed a quality of the greatest worth . Thus ire find the great Fenelon makes Ul ysses , in the system ofthe education which he delivers to his friends for his son ' Telemachus , particularly enjoin them , above all , to render him just , beneficent , sincere , and faithful in keeping secrets ; a precept ' that afterwards

produced the best of consequences to tbe youno- prince , of whom it is recorded , that with this great excellence of ° taciturnity , he not only divested himself of that close mysterious air , so common to the reserved , but also constantly avoided tellin" - the least untruth in support of this part of his character . A conduct highly worthy the imitation of every one to whom secrets are intrustedaffording them a pattern of easeand sin

, openness , , - cerity ; for while he seemed to carry his whole heart upon his lips , communicating what was of no importance , yet he knew howto stop just in the proper moment , without proceeding to those things which might raise any suspicion , or furnish even a hint to discover the purposes of his mind . If we turn our eyes back to antiquity , we shall find the old Egyptians had so great a regard for silence and secrecy in the of their reliion

mysteries g , that they set up the god Harpocrates ( vid . imagines deorian a vic . enlio cltartario ) , to whom they paid peculiar honour and veneration , who was represented with his right hand placed near the heart , and the left down by bis side covered ivith a skm before , full of eyes ancl ears , to signify that of many things to be seen and heard , few are to be published . And among the same letheir great goddess Isisthe

peop , , Minerva of the Greeks , bad always an image of a Sphynx placed at the entrance of her temples , to denote that secrets were there preserved under sacred coverings , that they might be kept from the knoivledge of the vulgar , as much as the riddles of that

creature . Jamblicus , iti bis life of P ythagoras , confirms the above opinion by observing , that from the mysterious knowled ge ofthe Eo-yptians that philosopher drew the system of bis symbolical , learnim- ami instructive tenets , seeing that the princi ples ancl wise doctrines ol this nation ivere ever kept secret among themselves , and were delivered down , not in writing , but onl y ' by oral tradition 'And indeed cautious and th

so prudent were ey in these matters that every disciple admitted to their wise and scientific mysteries was bound m the most solemn manner to conceal such mysteries from the vulgar , or those whose ideas were not sufficiently exalted to receive them . As a proof of this , we need onl y recollect the story of Ilipparcbus a P ythagorean , who , having out of spleen and resentment , violated and broke through the several ennao-c-ments of the held

society , was in the utmost detestation , expelled the school as one most infamous and abandoned , anel as he was dead to the principles of virtue ancl philosophy , had a tomb erected for him according to their custom , as though he had been natnralhclcad Ihe shame ami disgrace that justly attended so rrrcata breach of truth ancl fidelit y drove the unhappy wretch to such despair that he proved his own executioner and abhorred

; so was even Ins memory , that be was denied the rights ancl ceremonies of burial used to the dead in those times ; instead of which , his body was suHcrcd to he upon tbe shore of the isle of Samos Among the Greek nations , the Athenians bad a statue of brass , winch they awfully revered ; this fi gure was Avithout a tongue by winch secrecy was intimated .

Ihe Romans had a goddess of silence , named Angcroiia , represented with her forefinger on her lips . n . symbol of ' prudence anil taciturnity . ' ' Aiinaxarchu . s ivho , according to Pliny , was apprehended in order to extort his secrets from him , bit bis tongue in the midst ami afterwards spit it in the tyrant ' s face , rather choosiim- to lose that organ than to discover those things ivhich he had nronii « ed to conceal . L

A Defence Of Masonic Secrecy.

AVe read likewise thai C ; ito , the Censor , often said to his friends , of three things ivhich be had good reason to repent , the principal was , divulging a secret . The Druids in our OAVU nation—who were the only priests among the Ancient Britons—committed nothing to writing . And Cir-sar observes that they had a head or chief , who exercised a sort of excommunication , attended with dreadful penalties , on those

who cither published or profaned their mysteries . Therefore , since it evidently appears from the foregoing instances —among many other—that there ever ivere secrets amongst mankind , as well respecting societies as individuals , and that the keeping those inviolable ivas always reputed an indispensable dut y , and attended with an honourable estimation , it must be very difficult to assign a sufficient reason why the same practice

should be at all wondered at or less approved in the Free and Accepted Masons of the present age , than they were among the wisest men and greatest philosophers of antiquity . The general practice and constant applause of the ancients , as well as the customs of the moderns , one would naturally imagine should be sufficient to justify Masons against any charge of singularity or innovation on this account ; for how can this be thought

singular , or neiv , I 13 ' any one who will but calmly allow himself the smallest time for reflection . Do not all incorporated bodies amongst us enjoy this liberty without impeachment or censure ? An apprentice is bound to keep the secrets of his master ; a free man is obliged to consult the interests of his company , and not prostitute in common the mysteries of his profession ; secret committees and privy councils

are solemnly enjoined not to publish abroad their debates and resolutions . In courts martial , the members are bound to secrecy ; and in many cases for more effectual security an oath is administered .

As in society in general , ire are united together b 3 ' our indigencies and infirmities , ancl a vast variety of circumstances contributing to our mutual and necessary dependence on each other ¦ —ivhich lays a grand foundation for terrestrial happiness , by securing general amity and the reciprocation of good offices in the world—so , iu all particular societies , of whatever denomination , they are all conjoined by a sort of cement ; by bonds and

laws that are peculiar to each of them , from the highest assemblies to the loAvest . Consequently the injunctions of secrecy among Freemasons , can be no more unwarrantable than in the societies and cases already pointed out ; and to report , or even to insinuate , that they are , must argue a want of candour , a want of reason , and a want of charity . For by the laws of nature , and of nations , every individual and every society has a ri ght to be supposed

innocent till proved otherwise . Yet , notwithstanding the mysteries of our profession are kept inviolable , none are excluded from a full knowledge of them , hi due time and manner , upon proper application , and being found capable and worthy of tbe trust . To form other designs and expectations , is building on a sandy foundation , and ivill only serve to testify , that like a rash man , their discretion is always out ofthe way when they have most occasion to make use of it . — Wellins Calcoll , 1709 .

Interesting Reminiscence.

INTERESTING REMINISCENCE .

[ W F . copy the following from an address delivered before the Grand Lodge of Virginia , 011 the 10 th of December , 1815 , by M . AV . Robert G . Scott , P . G . M . ] In peace and in war , in the camp or tbe peaceful village , among civilized man or with the untamed spirits of the ivilderness , Masonry , genuine , true Masonry , will be found to qualify us the better to render service to our ' fellow man or grateful obedience

to our God . Valued and venerated for its nnticpiity , as well as the great moral doctrines it inculcates , Masonry has provided and furnished to its followers a common language—one that is intelligible to Masons alone—one by which intercourse can be held and wants be made known in safety and in secrecy from the rest of mankind . By ivhich the Egyptian and tlie Englishman , the Frenchman and the Otahitian may communicate without speaking

or understanding a word of the language of their respective nations . Through this common language ' the most deadl y strife is quieted—brother embraces brother , oi- rushes to his relief at . the most imminent hazard of his own life or safety . The arm that is raised against a prostrate brother , which in another instant ivould drive the deadly steel to his heart , falls subdued and palsied , by the mystic influence of a single r-vy . Blessed , glorious institution , that can thus tame the mad passions of men . even in the bloody battle strife . Yes , my friends and brothers , this is no fancy sketch , no idle

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 7
  • You're on page8
  • 9
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy