Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Aug. 18, 1866
  • Page 11
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Aug. 18, 1866: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Aug. 18, 1866
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. ← Page 2 of 3 →
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

part of them not to agree with the state of things in England . First , as regards tlie oath question . I remember what struggles took place in the British Parliament with reference to the modification of the form of oath in favour of Hebrews . On the present day this form exists no longer , and yet old England has not fallen to pieces . It vail be the same ivith the form of oath in the Masonic fraternity ; the Order will continue to exist even wiih a rectified oath .

Should the brethren in some lodges insist on tfie preservation of the present formula , there is an easy way of getting over the difficulty- Let the old formula he read to- the candidate at his initiation as an "historical document , " aud let him be obligated on a new , short , and less horrid formula . The honest Mason will be as much bound bhis lain word of

y p honour as he would by the most dismal oatli ; the dishonest brother , on the other hand , will break his word notwithstanding ail possible oaths . This is evidenced by the many traitorous ivritings , laying open our rituals before the profane world , so that secrecy has become impossible in some countries

, after some hundred thousands of pamphlets had been published containing the rituals of all symbolical and high degrees . All booksellers supply them on the Continent , and I have no doubt in Englaud too . This horrid oath also rendered our Society suspicious in the eyes of governments , that used to say with

truth that no oaths of this kind were requisite to profess such sublime principles as those laid down in our laws ; that it was to be presumed that aspirations of a very questionable character were hidden under the cloak of humanity , charity , and education . But in order to attain some of our humane objects , we do certainly want a member to pledge his word of honour not to communicate to strangers anything taking place in the lodge , without the acquiescence of

the lodge , and to such a pledge nobody can object . The rectification of the oath should not , therefore , be looked upon as an enormity . Scripture itself says , " Let your communication be yea , yea ; nay , nay ; tor whatsoever is more than these , eometh of evil . " As regards the admission to lodges , it should be

borne in mind that some persons ivho have , for a certain reason , been refused in one lodge , apply for admission into another . We often see them , having been turned away at the door , walking in through the window . There ought to be a general law for the Eraternity , that every candidate for admission should

formally declare not to have ever before applied to any other lodge , and that no lodge in A should admit anyone from B without the previous assent of the lodge in B . Persons who have been repelled here on one day , Ave find a few months later ivalking in as visitors , with European diplomas in their pockets . This

irregularity , I have no doubt , might easily be put a stop to . As regards the mode of promotion , grave objections are urged in many lodges . The adherents of reform wish promotions to be aivarded gratuitously , as honorary distinctions of prominent merit " either for

, special labour for the benefit of the lodge , or for good works done in public , or for excellent moral conduct . In the ancient stonemasons' corporations no _ man was admitted as an E . C . or an M . M . without being possessed of a superior knoAvledge of the art .

Should promotions take place with us , Avithout a full previous knowledge of the moral and intellectual importance of the respective degree ? We are , therefore , of opinion that the shortest interval should be five months for raising to the degree of E . G ., and seven months for the degree of M . M ., but , as a rule , a full year should elapse betiveen two several promotions .

We should also wish a better agreement to be arrived at with reference to signs , watchwords , and grips . It is highly inconvenient in Easts like those of the Levant , where there are lodges of all systems at work , that there should be so much variation ia the most- requisite means of recognition that Ave get into the greatest confusion as to the degrees of the

various brethren . An agreement between the respective authorities might readily bring about this most desirable uniformity . As regards the mental cultivation to be fostered in the lodges , it is the wish of the friends of reform that the labours should not consist only iu initiations ,

promotions , ancl dinners ; every initiation , promotion , or Masonic festival should be endowed with an intellectual character by means of some instructive lecture , ancl thus the collapse ancl mental stagnation prevented to which many lodges are reduced by the mere mechanical recital of rituals and "Mason

making . " It is a very general complaint among brethren that since their initiation they have never received any authentic information on the history of the Craft , any proper explanation of the rituals , and that , notwithstanding their Mastership , they know so little about matters Masonic ( save

signswatch-, words , and grips ) , that they become discouraged and keep aloof . We have so many eminent Masonic authors , and enjoy such au excellent periodical literature , that even the most overworked W . M . might

do a little more in the direction pointed out . I do not mean to say by this that every loclge should cultivate philosophical reveries ; the kind of mental labour to be performed ivould depend ou the choice of the majority of the members . A loclge consisting of authors ivill require a different kind of instructive entertainment than one whose members belong chiefl

y to the military , commercial , or industrial professions . Surely our literature is rich enough in useful and beautiful books to bestoAv some intellectual charms and attractions upon our labours . Let Bros , read only Bro . Oliver's " Freemason ' s Treasury , " and they will admit that the tendencies of the adherents of

reform are not so very devoid of objects and purpose . As regards the appointment of officials , ive object to the too frequent re-elections , not to speak of permanent appointments , as practised in some lodges . This grievance hardly applies to our English brethren in most of Avhose lodges there exists the laudable

habit of renewing the lists of officials once every year . It is to be hoped that this practice will soon become general . With us there still exist difficulties in the relations between the Grand Lodges ancl working lodges . The present practice is that each lodge appoints a

representative residing at the seat of the Grand Lodge , whose duty it is to attend at the quarterly communications . The reformers want , besides the latter , au annual and general meeting to which each working lodge would have to depute a direct repre-

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1866-08-18, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 20 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_18081866/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE CHOLERA. Article 1
FREEMASONRY IN BRITISH NORTH AMERICA. Article 2
BENJAMIN FRANKLIN, Article 3
FESTIVALS OF ST. JOHN, THE BAPTIST, AND ST. JOHN THE EVANGELIST. Article 7
THE ROYAL INSURANCE COMPANY. Article 8
THE SEWING MACHINE. Article 9
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 10
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 10
Untitled Article 12
Untitled Article 12
MASONIC MEMS. Article 12
METROPOLITAMT. Article 12
PROVINCIAL. Article 13
ROYAL ARCH. Article 14
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 15
INDIA. Article 15
REVIEWS. Article 17
THE WEEK. Article 18
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

4 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

5 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

4 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

2 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

part of them not to agree with the state of things in England . First , as regards tlie oath question . I remember what struggles took place in the British Parliament with reference to the modification of the form of oath in favour of Hebrews . On the present day this form exists no longer , and yet old England has not fallen to pieces . It vail be the same ivith the form of oath in the Masonic fraternity ; the Order will continue to exist even wiih a rectified oath .

Should the brethren in some lodges insist on tfie preservation of the present formula , there is an easy way of getting over the difficulty- Let the old formula he read to- the candidate at his initiation as an "historical document , " aud let him be obligated on a new , short , and less horrid formula . The honest Mason will be as much bound bhis lain word of

y p honour as he would by the most dismal oatli ; the dishonest brother , on the other hand , will break his word notwithstanding ail possible oaths . This is evidenced by the many traitorous ivritings , laying open our rituals before the profane world , so that secrecy has become impossible in some countries

, after some hundred thousands of pamphlets had been published containing the rituals of all symbolical and high degrees . All booksellers supply them on the Continent , and I have no doubt in Englaud too . This horrid oath also rendered our Society suspicious in the eyes of governments , that used to say with

truth that no oaths of this kind were requisite to profess such sublime principles as those laid down in our laws ; that it was to be presumed that aspirations of a very questionable character were hidden under the cloak of humanity , charity , and education . But in order to attain some of our humane objects , we do certainly want a member to pledge his word of honour not to communicate to strangers anything taking place in the lodge , without the acquiescence of

the lodge , and to such a pledge nobody can object . The rectification of the oath should not , therefore , be looked upon as an enormity . Scripture itself says , " Let your communication be yea , yea ; nay , nay ; tor whatsoever is more than these , eometh of evil . " As regards the admission to lodges , it should be

borne in mind that some persons ivho have , for a certain reason , been refused in one lodge , apply for admission into another . We often see them , having been turned away at the door , walking in through the window . There ought to be a general law for the Eraternity , that every candidate for admission should

formally declare not to have ever before applied to any other lodge , and that no lodge in A should admit anyone from B without the previous assent of the lodge in B . Persons who have been repelled here on one day , Ave find a few months later ivalking in as visitors , with European diplomas in their pockets . This

irregularity , I have no doubt , might easily be put a stop to . As regards the mode of promotion , grave objections are urged in many lodges . The adherents of reform wish promotions to be aivarded gratuitously , as honorary distinctions of prominent merit " either for

, special labour for the benefit of the lodge , or for good works done in public , or for excellent moral conduct . In the ancient stonemasons' corporations no _ man was admitted as an E . C . or an M . M . without being possessed of a superior knoAvledge of the art .

Should promotions take place with us , Avithout a full previous knowledge of the moral and intellectual importance of the respective degree ? We are , therefore , of opinion that the shortest interval should be five months for raising to the degree of E . G ., and seven months for the degree of M . M ., but , as a rule , a full year should elapse betiveen two several promotions .

We should also wish a better agreement to be arrived at with reference to signs , watchwords , and grips . It is highly inconvenient in Easts like those of the Levant , where there are lodges of all systems at work , that there should be so much variation ia the most- requisite means of recognition that Ave get into the greatest confusion as to the degrees of the

various brethren . An agreement between the respective authorities might readily bring about this most desirable uniformity . As regards the mental cultivation to be fostered in the lodges , it is the wish of the friends of reform that the labours should not consist only iu initiations ,

promotions , ancl dinners ; every initiation , promotion , or Masonic festival should be endowed with an intellectual character by means of some instructive lecture , ancl thus the collapse ancl mental stagnation prevented to which many lodges are reduced by the mere mechanical recital of rituals and "Mason

making . " It is a very general complaint among brethren that since their initiation they have never received any authentic information on the history of the Craft , any proper explanation of the rituals , and that , notwithstanding their Mastership , they know so little about matters Masonic ( save

signswatch-, words , and grips ) , that they become discouraged and keep aloof . We have so many eminent Masonic authors , and enjoy such au excellent periodical literature , that even the most overworked W . M . might

do a little more in the direction pointed out . I do not mean to say by this that every loclge should cultivate philosophical reveries ; the kind of mental labour to be performed ivould depend ou the choice of the majority of the members . A loclge consisting of authors ivill require a different kind of instructive entertainment than one whose members belong chiefl

y to the military , commercial , or industrial professions . Surely our literature is rich enough in useful and beautiful books to bestoAv some intellectual charms and attractions upon our labours . Let Bros , read only Bro . Oliver's " Freemason ' s Treasury , " and they will admit that the tendencies of the adherents of

reform are not so very devoid of objects and purpose . As regards the appointment of officials , ive object to the too frequent re-elections , not to speak of permanent appointments , as practised in some lodges . This grievance hardly applies to our English brethren in most of Avhose lodges there exists the laudable

habit of renewing the lists of officials once every year . It is to be hoped that this practice will soon become general . With us there still exist difficulties in the relations between the Grand Lodges ancl working lodges . The present practice is that each lodge appoints a

representative residing at the seat of the Grand Lodge , whose duty it is to attend at the quarterly communications . The reformers want , besides the latter , au annual and general meeting to which each working lodge would have to depute a direct repre-

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy