Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Oct. 18, 1862
  • Page 4
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 18, 1862: Page 4

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 18, 1862
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article "MY STARS AND GARTERS." — PAST MASTERS AND THE PAST MASTERS DEGREE. ← Page 4 of 4
    Article SCOTLAND.—THE ROYAL ARCH SCHISM. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

"My Stars And Garters." — Past Masters And The Past Masters Degree.

open lodge" being notified , at the back of the summons . Eor non-compliance with the laws AVO are informed by the brethren , Avho complained that an unfair advantage was taken of them , ancl at their last meeting , subsequent to the Provincial Grand

Lodge , at which Bro . Nicholson was appointed to office , they refused to confirm the minutes , ancl as the lodge now stands adjourned to January next , a regular ballot cannot be proceeded with until that time .

We are open to any correction in our facts , but , we haA'e stated them as we received them , leaving it to the proper authorities to determine the actual position in which Bro . Nicholson stands in the Craft . We are sorry to have to make such statements at all , but after the letter we have received from Bro .

Nicholson , we feel it a justice , both to him and the Craft , to place all we have heard before the brethren , feeling , as we do , that he has only been led away by an excess of zeal for the Order , and that he has been more sinned against than sinning by those who were bound by their standing in the Craft to have pointed out to him the false position in which he was being placed .

Scotland.—The Royal Arch Schism.

SCOTLAND . —THE ROYAL ARCH SCHISM .

We have been requested to insert the followingletter : — DEAE SIE AXD OO _ _ . _ O 3 S , — -Be so kind as to insert the annexed in your valuable publication , as explanatory of the present position of the Companions of the West of Scotland . I think it gives

the most correct A'iew of the matter that has yet appeared , and speaks for itself . I am , dear Sir and Companion , ONE or TIIE CO _ 5 IPAKIO _ " S 01 ? THE WEST OE SCOTLAND . Report of Comp . Walker Arnotl as to the Disjunction of Ayrshire as a Province . Glasgow , 12 th May , 1862 .

In the deliverance of tho Supreme Chapter of Sth March , it is not stated in AA'hat capacity the remit was made to Comp . Walker Arnott , but as he is Grand Superintendent of the West of Scotland , he understands that it was partly in that capacity , ancl partly as a private companion to AA'hom the Supreme Chapter has delegated its own powers , that he was requested to report . ' He

accepted the remit most unwillingly , not only from having been most of the winter in bad health , but because in the spring and summer he ought to devote his whole time to professional and more remunerating duties , and also hecause as Ayrshire was at present under his jurisdiction , the Ayrshire Chapters might suppose that he would be swayed by interested motives , if he disapproved of the

disjunction ; besides he had already stated in a letter to the G . S . E ., on the 1 st March , his objections to the disjunction , so far as could be done , without examining the books of tho Ayrshire Chapters ; but notwithstanding Avhich objections , the Supreme Committee reported unanimously on Srd March , in favour of the disjunction , Avithout , hoAvever , stating a single reason for it . Although

the remit was "to giA'e a report as to the statements of the petition , and what he would recommend to bo done in the circumstances , " yet , as mere opinions from him can be of no more weight to the Supreme Chapter , than , it had been to Supreme Committee , unless he made a careful investigation into various matters , besides tho mere statements ( in themselves oi little or no importance ) , and Avhether the statements in the those of

petition were the different Ayrshire Chapters in general , or only of a few individuals ; as also , Avhether those who signed the petition had a right to do so by being full attending members of the chapters they claim to belong to . Whether from not yielding obedience the chap . xvi . ofthe laws , they wished to enquiryho found it to

conescape , necessary sult AA'ith and request the assistance of the Prov . Grand Chapter of tho West of Scotland , being perfectly satisfied that if it was the desire of a great majority of the Ayrshire companions to separate themselves , and if it were shoAvn to conduce to the prosperity of Royal Arch Masonry there , no opposition Avould be made by it , A meeting of _ he Prov . Grand Chapter was therefore

called on the 18 th March , ivhen the Prov . Grand S . E . Avas instructed to request tho Grand S . E . to send a copy of the petition , and also to write ( in addition to the usual circular ) , to the three First Principals of the three chai . ters of

Ayrshire requestingthemtoattendat another meetingtobe held on the 28 th March , or , if not convenient , to transmit then their reasons for the proposed disjunction in a letter . G . S . E . stated that he had already sent a copy of the petition some time previously to the Grand Superintendent . This , no doubt , had been done on the 25 th February , before it had heen laid before the Supreme *

Commitee ; but the letter accompanying it Avas marked private , so that the Provincial Grand Superintendent did not feel at liberty to lay it at the time before the Provincial Grand Chapter : the letter of G . S . E . made this necessary . The reply from No . 80 referred the Provincial Grand Chapter to the petition itself . That from Gerran Chapter states that in their opinion no good

could arise from the disjunction , and that they were about to resign their charter . That from Ayr , No . 18 , Avas twofold—a letter and a minute ; and expressed their previous ignorance of any petition for disjunction , their indignation at such , AA'ithout consulting with them , and deprecating the proposed disjunction unless the Chapter No . 18 Avas allowed to remain as part of the

pre sent Provincial Grand Chapter . A petition from thirtytwo members of No . 18 ( including all the Office-bearers ) against the disjunction has been since transmitted to the Grand Superintendent for presentation , and is presented hereAvith .

It thus appearing on the 28 fch March that almost the only parties desirous of the disjunction belonged to Chapter No . 80 , it became necessary that their books should be examined in the hope that some light might be thrown on their anxiety for a separation . A small committee was appointed , consisting of the Provincial Grand Superintendent , Provincial Grand H . J ., and

Scribe E ., to report on the books ; and the Provincial Grand Superintendent , not only in virtue of cap . X ., sec . 9 , which gives the same powers to them within their province that the Supreme Chapter has over all Scotland , but also in consequence of the special remit to him by the Supreme Chapter , he gave written orders to Provincial Grand S . E . to go to Ayr next day ( 29 th March )

and bring the books to him . The GrancTSuperintendent himself examined the books on the 1 st and 2 nd April , ancl inserted on them the reports , of which a copy is hereAvith produced ; he also drew up a second report , derived from the former—afterwards adopted by the committee at their report . This more immediately relates to the proposed disjunctionand renders it

unne-, cessary to prepare a third report to the same eifect for the Supreme Chapter : it is produced herewith . It will be remembered that the Supreme Committee on Srd March recommended to the Supreme Chapter to

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1862-10-18, Page 4” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 21 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_18101862/page/4/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
"MY STARS AND GARTERS." — PAST MASTERS AND THE PAST MASTERS DEGREE. Article 1
SCOTLAND.—THE ROYAL ARCH SCHISM. Article 4
NORTHAMPTONSHIRE ARCHITECTURAL SOCIETY. Article 5
NEW CONTRIVANCES ANCILLARY TO ENGINEERING.* Article 7
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 11
SCOTTISH KNIGHTS TEMPLAR AND THE UNINITIATED. Article 12
"MY STARS AND GARTERS." Article 13
RECENT CORRESPONDENCE. Article 14
WHO HAVE THE RIGHT OF BALLOT? Article 14
Untitled Article 14
METROPOLITAN. Article 14
PROVINCIAL. Article 15
MARK MASONRY. Article 16
MASONIC FESTIVITIES. Article 16
NOTES ON MUSIC AND THE DRAMA. Article 17
Poetry. Article 17
THE WEEK. Article 18
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

5 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

4 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

2 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 4

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

"My Stars And Garters." — Past Masters And The Past Masters Degree.

open lodge" being notified , at the back of the summons . Eor non-compliance with the laws AVO are informed by the brethren , Avho complained that an unfair advantage was taken of them , ancl at their last meeting , subsequent to the Provincial Grand

Lodge , at which Bro . Nicholson was appointed to office , they refused to confirm the minutes , ancl as the lodge now stands adjourned to January next , a regular ballot cannot be proceeded with until that time .

We are open to any correction in our facts , but , we haA'e stated them as we received them , leaving it to the proper authorities to determine the actual position in which Bro . Nicholson stands in the Craft . We are sorry to have to make such statements at all , but after the letter we have received from Bro .

Nicholson , we feel it a justice , both to him and the Craft , to place all we have heard before the brethren , feeling , as we do , that he has only been led away by an excess of zeal for the Order , and that he has been more sinned against than sinning by those who were bound by their standing in the Craft to have pointed out to him the false position in which he was being placed .

Scotland.—The Royal Arch Schism.

SCOTLAND . —THE ROYAL ARCH SCHISM .

We have been requested to insert the followingletter : — DEAE SIE AXD OO _ _ . _ O 3 S , — -Be so kind as to insert the annexed in your valuable publication , as explanatory of the present position of the Companions of the West of Scotland . I think it gives

the most correct A'iew of the matter that has yet appeared , and speaks for itself . I am , dear Sir and Companion , ONE or TIIE CO _ 5 IPAKIO _ " S 01 ? THE WEST OE SCOTLAND . Report of Comp . Walker Arnotl as to the Disjunction of Ayrshire as a Province . Glasgow , 12 th May , 1862 .

In the deliverance of tho Supreme Chapter of Sth March , it is not stated in AA'hat capacity the remit was made to Comp . Walker Arnott , but as he is Grand Superintendent of the West of Scotland , he understands that it was partly in that capacity , ancl partly as a private companion to AA'hom the Supreme Chapter has delegated its own powers , that he was requested to report . ' He

accepted the remit most unwillingly , not only from having been most of the winter in bad health , but because in the spring and summer he ought to devote his whole time to professional and more remunerating duties , and also hecause as Ayrshire was at present under his jurisdiction , the Ayrshire Chapters might suppose that he would be swayed by interested motives , if he disapproved of the

disjunction ; besides he had already stated in a letter to the G . S . E ., on the 1 st March , his objections to the disjunction , so far as could be done , without examining the books of tho Ayrshire Chapters ; but notwithstanding Avhich objections , the Supreme Committee reported unanimously on Srd March , in favour of the disjunction , Avithout , hoAvever , stating a single reason for it . Although

the remit was "to giA'e a report as to the statements of the petition , and what he would recommend to bo done in the circumstances , " yet , as mere opinions from him can be of no more weight to the Supreme Chapter , than , it had been to Supreme Committee , unless he made a careful investigation into various matters , besides tho mere statements ( in themselves oi little or no importance ) , and Avhether the statements in the those of

petition were the different Ayrshire Chapters in general , or only of a few individuals ; as also , Avhether those who signed the petition had a right to do so by being full attending members of the chapters they claim to belong to . Whether from not yielding obedience the chap . xvi . ofthe laws , they wished to enquiryho found it to

conescape , necessary sult AA'ith and request the assistance of the Prov . Grand Chapter of tho West of Scotland , being perfectly satisfied that if it was the desire of a great majority of the Ayrshire companions to separate themselves , and if it were shoAvn to conduce to the prosperity of Royal Arch Masonry there , no opposition Avould be made by it , A meeting of _ he Prov . Grand Chapter was therefore

called on the 18 th March , ivhen the Prov . Grand S . E . Avas instructed to request tho Grand S . E . to send a copy of the petition , and also to write ( in addition to the usual circular ) , to the three First Principals of the three chai . ters of

Ayrshire requestingthemtoattendat another meetingtobe held on the 28 th March , or , if not convenient , to transmit then their reasons for the proposed disjunction in a letter . G . S . E . stated that he had already sent a copy of the petition some time previously to the Grand Superintendent . This , no doubt , had been done on the 25 th February , before it had heen laid before the Supreme *

Commitee ; but the letter accompanying it Avas marked private , so that the Provincial Grand Superintendent did not feel at liberty to lay it at the time before the Provincial Grand Chapter : the letter of G . S . E . made this necessary . The reply from No . 80 referred the Provincial Grand Chapter to the petition itself . That from Gerran Chapter states that in their opinion no good

could arise from the disjunction , and that they were about to resign their charter . That from Ayr , No . 18 , Avas twofold—a letter and a minute ; and expressed their previous ignorance of any petition for disjunction , their indignation at such , AA'ithout consulting with them , and deprecating the proposed disjunction unless the Chapter No . 18 Avas allowed to remain as part of the

pre sent Provincial Grand Chapter . A petition from thirtytwo members of No . 18 ( including all the Office-bearers ) against the disjunction has been since transmitted to the Grand Superintendent for presentation , and is presented hereAvith .

It thus appearing on the 28 fch March that almost the only parties desirous of the disjunction belonged to Chapter No . 80 , it became necessary that their books should be examined in the hope that some light might be thrown on their anxiety for a separation . A small committee was appointed , consisting of the Provincial Grand Superintendent , Provincial Grand H . J ., and

Scribe E ., to report on the books ; and the Provincial Grand Superintendent , not only in virtue of cap . X ., sec . 9 , which gives the same powers to them within their province that the Supreme Chapter has over all Scotland , but also in consequence of the special remit to him by the Supreme Chapter , he gave written orders to Provincial Grand S . E . to go to Ayr next day ( 29 th March )

and bring the books to him . The GrancTSuperintendent himself examined the books on the 1 st and 2 nd April , ancl inserted on them the reports , of which a copy is hereAvith produced ; he also drew up a second report , derived from the former—afterwards adopted by the committee at their report . This more immediately relates to the proposed disjunctionand renders it

unne-, cessary to prepare a third report to the same eifect for the Supreme Chapter : it is produced herewith . It will be remembered that the Supreme Committee on Srd March recommended to the Supreme Chapter to

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 3
  • You're on page4
  • 5
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy