Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • June 20, 1863
  • Page 10
  • UNIFORMITY OF WORKING.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, June 20, 1863: Page 10

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, June 20, 1863
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE PLANS AND DESIGNS FOR FREEMASONS' HALL. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article UNIFORMITY OF WORKING. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Plans And Designs For Freemasons' Hall.

the lodge rooms were not lighted , as it was supposed they would only be used at night , and gas would be sufficient . " 100 , " sent in eleven drawings . The elevation consisted of a pretentions building in three patches , and the coffee room opened into the street at once . The plans 23 resented nothing remarkable . ied ten

"Concord , " by Mr . "Wyatt Papworfch , occup drawings . His great dining hall was roomy enon 500 to dine , and took in the whole width of the pr The plans were very carefully considered and well suited to the requirements . The front elevation was remarkably neat and looked like a public building . Its only blot was that the door had four windows on one

side of it and three on the other . " Ich dien " sent in ten drawings . His new hall was the same size as the present , so he could not dine the 500 . The front was a pretty dose reproduction of Covent Garden Theatre , and the view of the banquetting hall showed just as many pillars as would be required for the iiave and side aisles of a church , a feature where dining

and speaking were to be carried on not only objectionable but fatal . " Finetn respice " sent in eight drawings . At any rate he could dine the 500 with ease , for his plan of the hall was 132 ft . by 43 fc . The elevation showed three genteel brick mansions , with pediments on the two end houses , and another in the centre . ¦

"Delta" was a gothic plan , well devised , and looking very attractive , but it was out of court by dealing with the whole of the property . " Labor ipse voluptas " sent in ten drawings . This was the best series of plans , giving admirable lights all over the building , and rendering every room easy of access , and well ventilated . There was no other disposition of the property half as good for light , ventilation , ingress , egress , and general compactness . The hall ,

however , could only dine 470 , and the elevation was particularly dumpy and heavy . "Usque ad astra" had seven drawings . He could not find space to dine 500 , and made the new grand hall the same size as the old , but contracted that space even by rounding off the ends , and so low was the roof that it appeared like a long corridor filled with tables ,

which , when the viands were placed upon thom , the steam and odour must , of necessity , be beaten back on the heads of those dining . The elevation was a five-storied fairy scene , resembling one of those marvellous scenic effects which are supposed to represent" Venus rising from the sea , " witb a stately mansion-in the back ground , all crimson lakeshellsand mist .

, , "A circle" was confined to five plans only . These were very careful studies of the ground for disposal , and had some valuable suggestions . There was no elevation . " Eoyal Gloucester " and " Ne cede Malis " were simply absurd . From theforegoing remarks it will bo seen how fewthere wei'e that complied with therequircddining hall

accommofor 500 persons , and if , a selection had to bo made , without regard to the main feature of the specification , general opinion pronounced that " Double Triangle" ought to have been first for his design ; " Labor ipse voluptas " second , for the value of the plans alone , and " L'Uhion fait la force " third , for the gem marked elevation No . 4 . The exhibition , as a whole , could not bo looked upon

as any compliment to Freemasons , who , to some extent , were once regarded as the architects and designers of Europe , but now arc sunk so low in the art that they have been obliged to ask for aid from professional architects , whose treatment of them show that they believe any design good enough to pass muster with the Craft , and viewing the exhibition , not as an architect , but as an interested brother , the writer grieves to say that it was , in his opinion , a failure . COMMON SENSE .

Uniformity Of Working.

UNIFORMITY OF WORKING .

TO THE EDITOR OF THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE AND MASONIC MIRROR . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —As a W . M . anxious to know and to act upon the laws by which the Craft is governed , happening one day to be studying the Booh of Constitutions for my own guidance in the management of the lodge , I read the following : — " All lodges are particularly bound to observe the same usages and customs ;

every departure , therefore , from the established mode of working is highly improper , and cannot be justified or countenanced . " Hence materially spring a question and a duty . The question on the part of all rulers in the Craft , what is "the established mode of working , " and how is a knowledge of it to be obtained ? The duty on . the part of Grand Lodge is to provide means by which

this law may be observed . Of course , generally speaking , there is a uniformity in the landmarks of the Order , not only in all lodges under warrant from the Grand Lodge of England , but in those of other countries under recognised Grand Lodges ; but I presume that the law to which reference has been made bears a more restricted interpretationand that its meaning isthat such

uni-, , formity ought to exist , as that any officer of a lodge may be able to take part in the duties , in any other lodge than his own , without thereby appearing irregular , by departures from the usual mode of conducting the ceremonies . If this be the case , I fear that the law is more honoured in the breach . than in' the observance , and that there are very considerable differences in the

mode of working without any notice being taken of the matter . These arise from two causes ; first from intentional alterations conformable to circumstances , or to peculiar notions , as to what should be the form adopted ; and secondly from ignorance in remote localities , where it is difficult to obtain instruction . On one occasion , two years ago , two Past Masters , with myself , were called upon to install , under the' latter' circumstances , ' in a

district where such laxity had prevailed as would have incurred severe censure , had it been reported at head quarters , since it had long existed , but measures were taken by one or two members , who were not till then aware of their errors , to prevent a recurrence . It is well known that there are two distinct forms of ritual existing in London , the one being that adopted in

the eastern , and the other in the western district , distinguished , the one as that of Peter Thompson , and the other that of Peter Gilkes . Yet no measures are taken by the authorities to assimilate them- * At the time I was initiated , more than fifteen years ago , considerable differences existed in the lodges of the town in which I resided , which wore brought into uniformity , still

maintained , by obtaining' a qualified instructor on the Peter Gilkes' system from the Lodge of Unions , which meets under sanction of the Lodge of Emulation , at Freemasons ' Hall every Friday evening . A year or two after this , on a casual visit to the district in which I have since come to reside , I found one lodge carrying out the same system with great correctnesshavingas I was informedadopted

, , , a similar course some time previously . Now , however , circumstances have altered , for when occasionally visiting the other lodges of the town , I find changes introduced ; some on the plea that more complete details are desirable in giving the ceremonies , which has led to the admission of portions of the Lectures as part of the ritual ; others ou the ground that the form generally adopted is

incorrect on some points , which as is obvious cannot be here particularized . I have reason to believe that departures from the usual method of working are by no means uncommon in England , and thus , as changes are made in occupants of the chair of Master , if each one , or indeed only occasionally a few , vary from the established form , in order to carry out their own ideas , in time it will be hardly possible to recognize any thing beyond the land-

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1863-06-20, Page 10” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 21 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_20061863/page/10/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE. Article 1
GEOMETRICAL AND OTHER SYMBOLS. Article 1
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 8
THE PLANS AND DESIGNS FOR FREEMASONS' HALL. Article 9
UNIFORMITY OF WORKING. Article 10
YORK FREEMASONS AND FREEMASONS OF YORK. Article 11
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 12
METROPOLITAN. Article 12
PROVINCIAL. Article 12
AUSTRALIA. Article 14
MARK MASONRY. Article 16
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 17
THE WEEK. Article 17
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

4 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Plans And Designs For Freemasons' Hall.

the lodge rooms were not lighted , as it was supposed they would only be used at night , and gas would be sufficient . " 100 , " sent in eleven drawings . The elevation consisted of a pretentions building in three patches , and the coffee room opened into the street at once . The plans 23 resented nothing remarkable . ied ten

"Concord , " by Mr . "Wyatt Papworfch , occup drawings . His great dining hall was roomy enon 500 to dine , and took in the whole width of the pr The plans were very carefully considered and well suited to the requirements . The front elevation was remarkably neat and looked like a public building . Its only blot was that the door had four windows on one

side of it and three on the other . " Ich dien " sent in ten drawings . His new hall was the same size as the present , so he could not dine the 500 . The front was a pretty dose reproduction of Covent Garden Theatre , and the view of the banquetting hall showed just as many pillars as would be required for the iiave and side aisles of a church , a feature where dining

and speaking were to be carried on not only objectionable but fatal . " Finetn respice " sent in eight drawings . At any rate he could dine the 500 with ease , for his plan of the hall was 132 ft . by 43 fc . The elevation showed three genteel brick mansions , with pediments on the two end houses , and another in the centre . ¦

"Delta" was a gothic plan , well devised , and looking very attractive , but it was out of court by dealing with the whole of the property . " Labor ipse voluptas " sent in ten drawings . This was the best series of plans , giving admirable lights all over the building , and rendering every room easy of access , and well ventilated . There was no other disposition of the property half as good for light , ventilation , ingress , egress , and general compactness . The hall ,

however , could only dine 470 , and the elevation was particularly dumpy and heavy . "Usque ad astra" had seven drawings . He could not find space to dine 500 , and made the new grand hall the same size as the old , but contracted that space even by rounding off the ends , and so low was the roof that it appeared like a long corridor filled with tables ,

which , when the viands were placed upon thom , the steam and odour must , of necessity , be beaten back on the heads of those dining . The elevation was a five-storied fairy scene , resembling one of those marvellous scenic effects which are supposed to represent" Venus rising from the sea , " witb a stately mansion-in the back ground , all crimson lakeshellsand mist .

, , "A circle" was confined to five plans only . These were very careful studies of the ground for disposal , and had some valuable suggestions . There was no elevation . " Eoyal Gloucester " and " Ne cede Malis " were simply absurd . From theforegoing remarks it will bo seen how fewthere wei'e that complied with therequircddining hall

accommofor 500 persons , and if , a selection had to bo made , without regard to the main feature of the specification , general opinion pronounced that " Double Triangle" ought to have been first for his design ; " Labor ipse voluptas " second , for the value of the plans alone , and " L'Uhion fait la force " third , for the gem marked elevation No . 4 . The exhibition , as a whole , could not bo looked upon

as any compliment to Freemasons , who , to some extent , were once regarded as the architects and designers of Europe , but now arc sunk so low in the art that they have been obliged to ask for aid from professional architects , whose treatment of them show that they believe any design good enough to pass muster with the Craft , and viewing the exhibition , not as an architect , but as an interested brother , the writer grieves to say that it was , in his opinion , a failure . COMMON SENSE .

Uniformity Of Working.

UNIFORMITY OF WORKING .

TO THE EDITOR OF THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE AND MASONIC MIRROR . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —As a W . M . anxious to know and to act upon the laws by which the Craft is governed , happening one day to be studying the Booh of Constitutions for my own guidance in the management of the lodge , I read the following : — " All lodges are particularly bound to observe the same usages and customs ;

every departure , therefore , from the established mode of working is highly improper , and cannot be justified or countenanced . " Hence materially spring a question and a duty . The question on the part of all rulers in the Craft , what is "the established mode of working , " and how is a knowledge of it to be obtained ? The duty on . the part of Grand Lodge is to provide means by which

this law may be observed . Of course , generally speaking , there is a uniformity in the landmarks of the Order , not only in all lodges under warrant from the Grand Lodge of England , but in those of other countries under recognised Grand Lodges ; but I presume that the law to which reference has been made bears a more restricted interpretationand that its meaning isthat such

uni-, , formity ought to exist , as that any officer of a lodge may be able to take part in the duties , in any other lodge than his own , without thereby appearing irregular , by departures from the usual mode of conducting the ceremonies . If this be the case , I fear that the law is more honoured in the breach . than in' the observance , and that there are very considerable differences in the

mode of working without any notice being taken of the matter . These arise from two causes ; first from intentional alterations conformable to circumstances , or to peculiar notions , as to what should be the form adopted ; and secondly from ignorance in remote localities , where it is difficult to obtain instruction . On one occasion , two years ago , two Past Masters , with myself , were called upon to install , under the' latter' circumstances , ' in a

district where such laxity had prevailed as would have incurred severe censure , had it been reported at head quarters , since it had long existed , but measures were taken by one or two members , who were not till then aware of their errors , to prevent a recurrence . It is well known that there are two distinct forms of ritual existing in London , the one being that adopted in

the eastern , and the other in the western district , distinguished , the one as that of Peter Thompson , and the other that of Peter Gilkes . Yet no measures are taken by the authorities to assimilate them- * At the time I was initiated , more than fifteen years ago , considerable differences existed in the lodges of the town in which I resided , which wore brought into uniformity , still

maintained , by obtaining' a qualified instructor on the Peter Gilkes' system from the Lodge of Unions , which meets under sanction of the Lodge of Emulation , at Freemasons ' Hall every Friday evening . A year or two after this , on a casual visit to the district in which I have since come to reside , I found one lodge carrying out the same system with great correctnesshavingas I was informedadopted

, , , a similar course some time previously . Now , however , circumstances have altered , for when occasionally visiting the other lodges of the town , I find changes introduced ; some on the plea that more complete details are desirable in giving the ceremonies , which has led to the admission of portions of the Lectures as part of the ritual ; others ou the ground that the form generally adopted is

incorrect on some points , which as is obvious cannot be here particularized . I have reason to believe that departures from the usual method of working are by no means uncommon in England , and thus , as changes are made in occupants of the chair of Master , if each one , or indeed only occasionally a few , vary from the established form , in order to carry out their own ideas , in time it will be hardly possible to recognize any thing beyond the land-

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 9
  • You're on page10
  • 11
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy