Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • June 20, 1863
  • Page 8
  • CORRESPONDENCE.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, June 20, 1863: Page 8

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, June 20, 1863
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Page 2 of 2
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 8

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

fanaticism of the times could possibly excuse , I feel happy m an opportunity of mentioning many particulars on the subject ; and of acquainting the reader , contrary to the opinion generally received , that the Order of Malta , though it regrets the motives which have occasioned its separation from the Knights of a different religion , does not refuse them a place among its members to fight against the enemies of Jesus Christ . Pope Pius the Sixthwhose virtues struck with awe even the cruel

, monsters his persecutors , was of the same opinion , and approved the association of the Russian Knights of the Greek Church with the Order of Malta . It may , indeed , be reasonably expected that such an union will be attended by the most edifying consequences . " These noble and judicious sentiments , from the pen of a member of the Catholic faith , put to flight Sir George

Bowyer's obstinate objection to open the door of the Order widely to Protestants . Another historian of the Order , John Taaffe , himself also a Catholic and a Knight-Commander of St . John , thus expresses himself on the subject of religion : — " Wars with the Turks would now be uselesss and ridiculous ; and the basis of our Order is not such warsbut utilitin

, y general , and neutrality between all Christians . At the Confession of Augsberg , a deputation of our Knights was sent to declare that all Christian religions were indifferent to ns ; and one of the latest acts at Malta was to receive both Protestant Germans and Greek Kussians into the Order as integeral members of it , we not being theologians , but soldiers . " Had the election of the " schismatic " Paul , as Grand

Master , been the act of the authorized rulers of the Order , it would only have been another instance of the flexibility of the statutes , in obedience to the emergency of the times ; and the competency of the measure would never have been questioned by ourselves , on the ground of the Pope ' s refusal to confirm the election ; but , as impartial observers of history , we hold the appointment of Paul

to the Mastership as invalidated by the fact of the election having taken place before the resignation of De Hompesch , the existing Grand Master . The Order of St . John was not created by the Pope ;

and we , as Protestants , deny his right to interfere with it . " There are men , doubtless , " writes a worthy and able member of the English Larigue , " who would take us back to the days of King John , when the Pope disposed of kingdoms ; and who , considering everything sanctified that is done by his authority , would—on the same principle that prevailed at Rome a century backwhen Cardinal York was held to be Henry IX

, ., King of England—maintain that the Catanian Council , and those claiming representation from it [ the present Eomish branch of the Order of St . John ] , constituted the only lawful Mastership of the Order of St . John ; but even admitting that the Pope adhered exclusively to that Council , and disowned the Paris Commission [ the authority that revived the English Langue ]—which does not appear , inasmuch as his Bull of the 10 th August ,

1814 , sanctioning its establishment , was never rescinded—he must indeed be a recreant Knight of the Order , ignorant of its history and glory , who would support such a doctrine . To an Englishman the principle is as clear as day , that the legitimacy in this case was inherent in the Order itself , to the utter exclusion of the Pope ; who had no more right to appoint a Master , or Lieutenant of the SovereiOrder of St . John of Jerusalem

gn , than he . has to instal a Lord-Lieutenant of Ireland ; and this great principle could not be invalidated by the fact of a few Italian Knights his own subjects , having prostrated themselves hefore him in the midst of their distress . Such a proceeding could not implicate the Order at large , and was virtually annulled and rectified by the convocation of its members at Paris in 1814 ; when the Order once more showed itself sovereign

and self-supporting , entitled to conduct its own affairs and to elect its own rulers , independently of all princes and potentates ¦ whatever . After that convocation took place , the Italian party still adhered to the Pope ; but , by doing so , unquestionably deserted the order and its principles : and , this being the case , can no more be regarded a legitimate branch of it , than the Knights of St . John in Spain and Prussia , who , like themselves , have

sought the protection of their own sovereigns , and thereby become mere state subordinates . While the Langue of England , on the other hand , being derived from the Order in its integrity , and not from the Pope , may claim to be the only legitimate

Masonic Notes And Queries.

branch of the venerable and illustrious institution now in existence : thus proving England still to be , as admitted by the gallant French Knights more than thirty years ago , * the protectress of all oppressed greatness '—and even the last asylum for the far-famed Order of St . John of Jerusalem !" In my next communication I will draw a parallel between the respective titles of legitimacy claimed by the

Roman Council and the English Langue . In the present , I think that a satisfactory response has been made to Sir George Bowyer ' s objections on the score of differences in religious faith . ANTIQUARIUS . ARK , MARK , LINK , AND ROYAL ARCH . The New York papers sometimes indulge in a little Masonic enquiry a specimen of which , relating to the Ark , Mark , Link , and Royal Arch , I enclose . —Ex . Ex ..

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed . It / Correspondents ; . PROVINCE OF EAST LANCASHIRE . TO THE EDITOR OF THE FREEMASONS' HAGAZIIfE AlfD MASONIC MIRROR . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —In your last week's publication is a very brief and imperfect account of the annual ! meeting of the Grand Lodge of the above provinceat

, which I was privileged to assist , and which deserved a fuller and more worthy report than appears to havereached you . On the principle of j rendering honour to > whom honour is due , I request your permission to supply one or two important omissions . The grants proposed in Grand Lodge , in addition tothose for the relief of some cases of local distress , were

fifty guineas to the Royal Freemasons' School for Female-Children , and fifty guineas to the Royal Masonic Institution for Boys . I was encouraged by the kindness of " the R . W . Prov . G . M ., Bro . Stephen Blair , to address a few remarks to the assembled brethren , in the course of which I thankfully acknowledged their present liberality ,, and entered into an explanation of the two schools ,-

especially urging the claims of the latter . At the banquet which followed , though at a comparatively late hour of the evening , and when the two hundred brethren who sat down were reduced in number to about sixty , another opportunity was afforded me , and my appeal was so cordially responded to , that in the course of a very few minutes 1 § 0 guineas were subscribed , and at a smalll meeting on the following day and evening 80 guineas ; additional were subscribed , and since my return I have

received 30 guineas more , with every probability of afurther large addition . This assistance spontaneously given , without organised effort , or notice , or preparation , of any kind , and in the face of the severe distress which , has for so long a period paralysed the industry of the manufacturing districts , speaks volumes in favour of the willingness of our provincial brethren to continue their

exertions in behalf our Charitable Institutions , in the welfare and prosperity of which it is now abundantly proved they feel an equal interest with the brethren ins the metropolis . The business of the Charity Committee of this province—at the deliberations of which I was invited to attend—is admirably conducted under the able

management of the president , Bro . Laurence Newall , and the vice-president , Bro . John Chadwick , from whom a most valuable report was read , more immediately referring to the Royal Benevolent Institution for Aged Freemasons and their Widows , an institution which the untiring efforts of the first-named brother have succeeded in thoroughlcommending to the attention of the members

y of tbe province . To the same brother _ I feel myself mainly indebted for the success of my visit , and only in . a less degree to Bro . Chadwick and other brethren whose kindness , attention , and courtesy I shall ever bear in grateful remembrance . Let me avail myself of this opportunity of correcting

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1863-06-20, Page 8” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 21 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_20061863/page/8/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE FREEMASONS MAGAZINE. Article 1
GEOMETRICAL AND OTHER SYMBOLS. Article 1
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 8
THE PLANS AND DESIGNS FOR FREEMASONS' HALL. Article 9
UNIFORMITY OF WORKING. Article 10
YORK FREEMASONS AND FREEMASONS OF YORK. Article 11
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 12
METROPOLITAN. Article 12
PROVINCIAL. Article 12
AUSTRALIA. Article 14
MARK MASONRY. Article 16
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 17
THE WEEK. Article 17
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

3 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

3 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

3 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

4 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 8

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Masonic Notes And Queries.

fanaticism of the times could possibly excuse , I feel happy m an opportunity of mentioning many particulars on the subject ; and of acquainting the reader , contrary to the opinion generally received , that the Order of Malta , though it regrets the motives which have occasioned its separation from the Knights of a different religion , does not refuse them a place among its members to fight against the enemies of Jesus Christ . Pope Pius the Sixthwhose virtues struck with awe even the cruel

, monsters his persecutors , was of the same opinion , and approved the association of the Russian Knights of the Greek Church with the Order of Malta . It may , indeed , be reasonably expected that such an union will be attended by the most edifying consequences . " These noble and judicious sentiments , from the pen of a member of the Catholic faith , put to flight Sir George

Bowyer's obstinate objection to open the door of the Order widely to Protestants . Another historian of the Order , John Taaffe , himself also a Catholic and a Knight-Commander of St . John , thus expresses himself on the subject of religion : — " Wars with the Turks would now be uselesss and ridiculous ; and the basis of our Order is not such warsbut utilitin

, y general , and neutrality between all Christians . At the Confession of Augsberg , a deputation of our Knights was sent to declare that all Christian religions were indifferent to ns ; and one of the latest acts at Malta was to receive both Protestant Germans and Greek Kussians into the Order as integeral members of it , we not being theologians , but soldiers . " Had the election of the " schismatic " Paul , as Grand

Master , been the act of the authorized rulers of the Order , it would only have been another instance of the flexibility of the statutes , in obedience to the emergency of the times ; and the competency of the measure would never have been questioned by ourselves , on the ground of the Pope ' s refusal to confirm the election ; but , as impartial observers of history , we hold the appointment of Paul

to the Mastership as invalidated by the fact of the election having taken place before the resignation of De Hompesch , the existing Grand Master . The Order of St . John was not created by the Pope ;

and we , as Protestants , deny his right to interfere with it . " There are men , doubtless , " writes a worthy and able member of the English Larigue , " who would take us back to the days of King John , when the Pope disposed of kingdoms ; and who , considering everything sanctified that is done by his authority , would—on the same principle that prevailed at Rome a century backwhen Cardinal York was held to be Henry IX

, ., King of England—maintain that the Catanian Council , and those claiming representation from it [ the present Eomish branch of the Order of St . John ] , constituted the only lawful Mastership of the Order of St . John ; but even admitting that the Pope adhered exclusively to that Council , and disowned the Paris Commission [ the authority that revived the English Langue ]—which does not appear , inasmuch as his Bull of the 10 th August ,

1814 , sanctioning its establishment , was never rescinded—he must indeed be a recreant Knight of the Order , ignorant of its history and glory , who would support such a doctrine . To an Englishman the principle is as clear as day , that the legitimacy in this case was inherent in the Order itself , to the utter exclusion of the Pope ; who had no more right to appoint a Master , or Lieutenant of the SovereiOrder of St . John of Jerusalem

gn , than he . has to instal a Lord-Lieutenant of Ireland ; and this great principle could not be invalidated by the fact of a few Italian Knights his own subjects , having prostrated themselves hefore him in the midst of their distress . Such a proceeding could not implicate the Order at large , and was virtually annulled and rectified by the convocation of its members at Paris in 1814 ; when the Order once more showed itself sovereign

and self-supporting , entitled to conduct its own affairs and to elect its own rulers , independently of all princes and potentates ¦ whatever . After that convocation took place , the Italian party still adhered to the Pope ; but , by doing so , unquestionably deserted the order and its principles : and , this being the case , can no more be regarded a legitimate branch of it , than the Knights of St . John in Spain and Prussia , who , like themselves , have

sought the protection of their own sovereigns , and thereby become mere state subordinates . While the Langue of England , on the other hand , being derived from the Order in its integrity , and not from the Pope , may claim to be the only legitimate

Masonic Notes And Queries.

branch of the venerable and illustrious institution now in existence : thus proving England still to be , as admitted by the gallant French Knights more than thirty years ago , * the protectress of all oppressed greatness '—and even the last asylum for the far-famed Order of St . John of Jerusalem !" In my next communication I will draw a parallel between the respective titles of legitimacy claimed by the

Roman Council and the English Langue . In the present , I think that a satisfactory response has been made to Sir George Bowyer ' s objections on the score of differences in religious faith . ANTIQUARIUS . ARK , MARK , LINK , AND ROYAL ARCH . The New York papers sometimes indulge in a little Masonic enquiry a specimen of which , relating to the Ark , Mark , Link , and Royal Arch , I enclose . —Ex . Ex ..

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed . It / Correspondents ; . PROVINCE OF EAST LANCASHIRE . TO THE EDITOR OF THE FREEMASONS' HAGAZIIfE AlfD MASONIC MIRROR . DEAR SIR AND BROTHER , —In your last week's publication is a very brief and imperfect account of the annual ! meeting of the Grand Lodge of the above provinceat

, which I was privileged to assist , and which deserved a fuller and more worthy report than appears to havereached you . On the principle of j rendering honour to > whom honour is due , I request your permission to supply one or two important omissions . The grants proposed in Grand Lodge , in addition tothose for the relief of some cases of local distress , were

fifty guineas to the Royal Freemasons' School for Female-Children , and fifty guineas to the Royal Masonic Institution for Boys . I was encouraged by the kindness of " the R . W . Prov . G . M ., Bro . Stephen Blair , to address a few remarks to the assembled brethren , in the course of which I thankfully acknowledged their present liberality ,, and entered into an explanation of the two schools ,-

especially urging the claims of the latter . At the banquet which followed , though at a comparatively late hour of the evening , and when the two hundred brethren who sat down were reduced in number to about sixty , another opportunity was afforded me , and my appeal was so cordially responded to , that in the course of a very few minutes 1 § 0 guineas were subscribed , and at a smalll meeting on the following day and evening 80 guineas ; additional were subscribed , and since my return I have

received 30 guineas more , with every probability of afurther large addition . This assistance spontaneously given , without organised effort , or notice , or preparation , of any kind , and in the face of the severe distress which , has for so long a period paralysed the industry of the manufacturing districts , speaks volumes in favour of the willingness of our provincial brethren to continue their

exertions in behalf our Charitable Institutions , in the welfare and prosperity of which it is now abundantly proved they feel an equal interest with the brethren ins the metropolis . The business of the Charity Committee of this province—at the deliberations of which I was invited to attend—is admirably conducted under the able

management of the president , Bro . Laurence Newall , and the vice-president , Bro . John Chadwick , from whom a most valuable report was read , more immediately referring to the Royal Benevolent Institution for Aged Freemasons and their Widows , an institution which the untiring efforts of the first-named brother have succeeded in thoroughlcommending to the attention of the members

y of tbe province . To the same brother _ I feel myself mainly indebted for the success of my visit , and only in . a less degree to Bro . Chadwick and other brethren whose kindness , attention , and courtesy I shall ever bear in grateful remembrance . Let me avail myself of this opportunity of correcting

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 7
  • You're on page8
  • 9
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy