Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Aug. 20, 1859
  • Page 14
  • REVIEWS OF NEW BOOKS.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Aug. 20, 1859: Page 14

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Aug. 20, 1859
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article REVIEWS OF NEW BOOKS. ← Page 2 of 3 →
Page 14

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Reviews Of New Books.

eludes capital punishment , but this , we presume , must be an error , for have not the Jews themselves , at various times , repudiated the power of condemning criminals V They also profess , and really make noble efforts , to relieve the poor , but all their attempts are neutralized by a bad and vicious system of administration . Our traveller expresses his complete horror at the condition of the Jewish hospital at Smyrnaand tells

, us that when the Sultan granted them a site at Constantinople , on which to erect an hospital , they commenced the building , but have left it unfinished to this hour . Their schools , he tells us , are of the very worst description ; ' education is looked upon with a distrustful eye , and any interference on its behalf hy the -western brethren is jealousl y resented as coming from a source suspiciously liberal . Early marriages seem to be the curse of the

. Jewish ' race in the east , inducing premature decay , and the dependence of a family on parents who are themselves little else but children . This is sought to be palliated on the ground of preventing worse consequences , but it weakens the community so much that in some places they seem to be gradually dying out under its effects . To the surprise and indignation of the ' western and more civilized Jew , polygamy , to the extent of a second wife ,

is pot uncommon where tiie first wife has no children , or the children are all females . They arc also a very superstitious race , and Dr . Erankl is a minute recorder and indefatigable collector of strange stories of their belief in the supernatural . The most prominent notion of this kind is the belief that women are regarded by spirits ancl demons with love and jealousy . The Hatti Humayoum is more feared ancl dislikedthan looked upon as a-

, hopeful indication in their favour . The military sen-ice which they are called upon to render to the sultan is hateful in the extreme , as thej' believe it to be a secret attempt to undermine their reli gion . So far has this feeling extended , that in the Hebrew slums of Constantinople Dr . Erankl heard it made the subject of a song , and tells us : —•

" 1 asked the man if he knew any new songs . " ' You have come to a king in the realm of' song . ' " We laughed at this haughty Spanish answer , aud ordered him to sing . He sang a song , just out . tho production of some unknown poet , the subject of which is the Jews of the place , showing how they have violated all that is old ond highly prized , have cast aside their piety and their reverence for tbe Supreme Being , ancl lieen rendered apostate and godless by the Tansimat and Hat Humayoum . "

This feeling also coincides with a subject that , at the time , wrought the most dismal dismay among them when the chalebi ivas prohibited , of which he says ' : — " The chalebi is the old traditional head-dress of the Jewish women ; its ugliness is only equalled by the difficulty of describing it . Imagine a ball of linen rags , about the size of an ostrich ' s egg . tightly compressed , and placed on the crown of the head of the woman who is about to be

adorned with the chalebi . Then a female attendant holds this ball in its place , while another winds a shawl over it in curious folds . Thus the . chalebi rises aloft like a tower , and carefully conceals the hair of the wearer ; it not only detracts from the personal appearance of those who wear it , but also exposes them to the derision of the Mohammedans , by showing that they are Jewesses . _ " Redschid Pasha signified , when the Ohaeham of Nischnn paid him his official visit

, that it would be agreeable to hiin if the women reformed their style of dress , and laid aside the chalebi . On this the Ohaeham Baschi ordered the chalebi to bo prohibited in the synagogues . The old women shed tears , and lamented as if they were about to lose a favourite child , and persisted in wearing tho chalebi . Then the Chacham Baschi gave forth an anathema against it , and the souls of the old women were overwhelmed with a feeling of profound sorrow , as they . saw iu this innovation the prestige of the ruin and decay of the sacred Jewish religion , in the same way as tho old Polish . Tews , when the young men laid aside the long black caftan , and impiously cropped their long unshorn locks .

" But there is a tale of mystery connected with the ehnlebi . " Soon after the anathema had been hurled at the heads of the aged women , one night , a female , concealed by a grey veil , made her appearance at a place of embarkation on the Bosphorus . and stepped into a caique . When the boatman asked her where he should row , her answer was , 'Row on . ' Having arrived at a landing-place , he ceased rowing , and asked her if she would land . 'Bow on , ' was her only answer , ami this occurred several times . It struck the boatman that his boat passed h the water

throug as lightly as if there had been no one in it . At length they arrived at the landing-place at Ohaskoi , where most of the . lews reside . The woman with tiie grey veil stepped from the caique to tho land , and said to the boatman' 'Know that I am the cholera , ami that I have come to punish the Jews , because their women havo laid aside the chalebi . ' " There followed a fearful outbreak of cholera at Chaskoi . " On Dr . Frank !' s journey to Jerusalem , whither he has been commissioned to go b y a benevolent Austrian lady in order to open a

school there fi-r the benefit of the Jewish children , he experienced a proof how a poetical and touching custom had degenerated into a burlesque ; and he gives the following account of his approach to the holy city : — " I was now some hundred yards in advance of the caravan , and quite close to the walls of the city . . Suddenly a man . whom I had not

previously observed , rushed upon me , and seized the collar of my great coat with his left hand , while he brandished a long glittering knife in his right . My reverie , from which I was suddenly roused by this unexpected attack , gave place to a feeling of indescribable terror , and I wns almost mechanically drawing my pistols from the holster , when the man quickly loosened his hold , lowered his arms , and , with pale lips ,

exclaimed" ' Schema Israel ! what are you going to do ? " All this happened in less than a minute , and recognizing one of the same creed , I , who may have been just as pale with terror myself , could not help bursting into a laugh . He explained to me that every Jewish pilgrim , before he enters the city , must tear his dress from sorrow at its destruction , in the same way as on the occasion of the death of a relative . So I allowed Mr . Mosche Kural , who derives a small income from this office , ' a krie cut '—i . e .. I allowed him to make a rent in my dress , while I repeated after him the usual f ormula— ' Zion is turned into a desert , in lies in ruins . ""

At Jerusalem he found the degradation , degeneration , immorality , and superstition of his race at the lowest possible depth : ancl however accustomed we may be to the denunciations of the Christians of the Latin and Greek churches located there , among themselves , or to the slanders of the Anglo-Prussian Bishop Gobat , with all the abuse the latter has heaped on those who differ from him—yet in comparison to Dr . Frankl ' s indignant

description of the ways and doings of the Jews at Jerusalem , the former are comparatively mild and inoffensive . The Jews have a favourite practice , particularly those of Germany ancl Poland , and they leave the lands of their birth when advancing in years , in order to lay their bones in the tomb of their forefathers at Jerusalem ; and as many of them reach the holy city not overburthened with wealththey arc supported by alms collected for that

pur-, pose in almost every city of Europe . Three consequences follow this continual immigration ancl collection . The first is an immense amount of peculation and fraud amongst the rabbis and other persons through whose hands the money passes . Another is the idleness , falsehood , sycophancy and selfishness of professed mendicants , which inflames the ferocious party quarrels among the various sects of eastern ancl western origin , who fight their battles

in the holy city , each to secure the greatest amount of assistance derived from the pious offerings of their people abroad . And lastly , these immigrants bring their families with them , who lapse into the evil habits of the country , contract premature marriages , lose all habits of industry , ancl add to the number of the enfeebled and depraved race who prey on the benevolence , and frustrateall the munificent plans for their welfare , formed by such nobleminded Jews as Sir Afoscs Alontefiore , who came with barrels of

dollars to distribute among his people , but all whose schemes for permanent ]) - improving them have wellnigh come to nought , ancl who was ultimately excommunicated by them for offending their superstition by visiting the Mosque of Omar . Dr . Erankl , though a Jew , does not consider himself bound to accept the ideas , or hide the faults of his race . Even while conforniingto their customs , he expresses no respect for some of them .

He openly proclaims the iinworthiness , fraud and rascallity of most of their rabbis . He enumerates , with bitter precision , the varieties of their parties . He descants at large on the greediness , the unfitness for anything useful or good , of the poorer population ; and though he does not tell us that bis own benevolent errand was unsuccessful , he dwells on what he had to endure from the malice and calumnies of unscrupulous opponents , and

scarcely leaves much reason to hope that his schemes would prove more lasting than those of his noble and openhearted predecessors , Sir Afoscs Montefiore ancl Air . Cohen . A darker ancl more miserable picture could hardl y be drawn of a race lost to every feeling of self-respect ancl good , sinking deeper and deeper each generation into sensuality and corruption of mind and body , eaten up with the grossest superstitions , and

grossly , ruthlessly , and systematicall y oppressed and plundered by rulers professing to govern , ancl even to feed them , in the name of God ! He epiotes the indignant expression of a Polish merchant who went to Jerusalem expecting to find it the seat of sanctity , but found nothing there save immorality , hypocrisy , ancl utter ' helplcssness . The Pole said : — " He tliat will enjoy ituhm haze ( the p leasures of this world ) , must live in Moldavia " ; he that wishes to renounce them ayid to obtain auhmi iutl'o , ( the pleasures of the

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1859-08-20, Page 14” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 21 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_20081859/page/14/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
MASONIC MISSIONS. Article 1
MASONRY IN INDIA. Article 4
MUSIC AND THE MASONIC RITUAL. Article 5
THE TWIN BEECH TREES.* Article 8
Poetry. Article 9
OUR ARCHITECTURAL CHAPTER. Article 10
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES . Article 10
Literature. Article 12
REVIEWS OF NEW BOOKS. Article 13
Untitled Article 13
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 15
MARK MASONRY Article 19
THE WEEK. Article 19
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

4 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

4 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 14

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Reviews Of New Books.

eludes capital punishment , but this , we presume , must be an error , for have not the Jews themselves , at various times , repudiated the power of condemning criminals V They also profess , and really make noble efforts , to relieve the poor , but all their attempts are neutralized by a bad and vicious system of administration . Our traveller expresses his complete horror at the condition of the Jewish hospital at Smyrnaand tells

, us that when the Sultan granted them a site at Constantinople , on which to erect an hospital , they commenced the building , but have left it unfinished to this hour . Their schools , he tells us , are of the very worst description ; ' education is looked upon with a distrustful eye , and any interference on its behalf hy the -western brethren is jealousl y resented as coming from a source suspiciously liberal . Early marriages seem to be the curse of the

. Jewish ' race in the east , inducing premature decay , and the dependence of a family on parents who are themselves little else but children . This is sought to be palliated on the ground of preventing worse consequences , but it weakens the community so much that in some places they seem to be gradually dying out under its effects . To the surprise and indignation of the ' western and more civilized Jew , polygamy , to the extent of a second wife ,

is pot uncommon where tiie first wife has no children , or the children are all females . They arc also a very superstitious race , and Dr . Erankl is a minute recorder and indefatigable collector of strange stories of their belief in the supernatural . The most prominent notion of this kind is the belief that women are regarded by spirits ancl demons with love and jealousy . The Hatti Humayoum is more feared ancl dislikedthan looked upon as a-

, hopeful indication in their favour . The military sen-ice which they are called upon to render to the sultan is hateful in the extreme , as thej' believe it to be a secret attempt to undermine their reli gion . So far has this feeling extended , that in the Hebrew slums of Constantinople Dr . Erankl heard it made the subject of a song , and tells us : —•

" 1 asked the man if he knew any new songs . " ' You have come to a king in the realm of' song . ' " We laughed at this haughty Spanish answer , aud ordered him to sing . He sang a song , just out . tho production of some unknown poet , the subject of which is the Jews of the place , showing how they have violated all that is old ond highly prized , have cast aside their piety and their reverence for tbe Supreme Being , ancl lieen rendered apostate and godless by the Tansimat and Hat Humayoum . "

This feeling also coincides with a subject that , at the time , wrought the most dismal dismay among them when the chalebi ivas prohibited , of which he says ' : — " The chalebi is the old traditional head-dress of the Jewish women ; its ugliness is only equalled by the difficulty of describing it . Imagine a ball of linen rags , about the size of an ostrich ' s egg . tightly compressed , and placed on the crown of the head of the woman who is about to be

adorned with the chalebi . Then a female attendant holds this ball in its place , while another winds a shawl over it in curious folds . Thus the . chalebi rises aloft like a tower , and carefully conceals the hair of the wearer ; it not only detracts from the personal appearance of those who wear it , but also exposes them to the derision of the Mohammedans , by showing that they are Jewesses . _ " Redschid Pasha signified , when the Ohaeham of Nischnn paid him his official visit

, that it would be agreeable to hiin if the women reformed their style of dress , and laid aside the chalebi . On this the Ohaeham Baschi ordered the chalebi to bo prohibited in the synagogues . The old women shed tears , and lamented as if they were about to lose a favourite child , and persisted in wearing tho chalebi . Then the Chacham Baschi gave forth an anathema against it , and the souls of the old women were overwhelmed with a feeling of profound sorrow , as they . saw iu this innovation the prestige of the ruin and decay of the sacred Jewish religion , in the same way as tho old Polish . Tews , when the young men laid aside the long black caftan , and impiously cropped their long unshorn locks .

" But there is a tale of mystery connected with the ehnlebi . " Soon after the anathema had been hurled at the heads of the aged women , one night , a female , concealed by a grey veil , made her appearance at a place of embarkation on the Bosphorus . and stepped into a caique . When the boatman asked her where he should row , her answer was , 'Row on . ' Having arrived at a landing-place , he ceased rowing , and asked her if she would land . 'Bow on , ' was her only answer , ami this occurred several times . It struck the boatman that his boat passed h the water

throug as lightly as if there had been no one in it . At length they arrived at the landing-place at Ohaskoi , where most of the . lews reside . The woman with tiie grey veil stepped from the caique to tho land , and said to the boatman' 'Know that I am the cholera , ami that I have come to punish the Jews , because their women havo laid aside the chalebi . ' " There followed a fearful outbreak of cholera at Chaskoi . " On Dr . Frank !' s journey to Jerusalem , whither he has been commissioned to go b y a benevolent Austrian lady in order to open a

school there fi-r the benefit of the Jewish children , he experienced a proof how a poetical and touching custom had degenerated into a burlesque ; and he gives the following account of his approach to the holy city : — " I was now some hundred yards in advance of the caravan , and quite close to the walls of the city . . Suddenly a man . whom I had not

previously observed , rushed upon me , and seized the collar of my great coat with his left hand , while he brandished a long glittering knife in his right . My reverie , from which I was suddenly roused by this unexpected attack , gave place to a feeling of indescribable terror , and I wns almost mechanically drawing my pistols from the holster , when the man quickly loosened his hold , lowered his arms , and , with pale lips ,

exclaimed" ' Schema Israel ! what are you going to do ? " All this happened in less than a minute , and recognizing one of the same creed , I , who may have been just as pale with terror myself , could not help bursting into a laugh . He explained to me that every Jewish pilgrim , before he enters the city , must tear his dress from sorrow at its destruction , in the same way as on the occasion of the death of a relative . So I allowed Mr . Mosche Kural , who derives a small income from this office , ' a krie cut '—i . e .. I allowed him to make a rent in my dress , while I repeated after him the usual f ormula— ' Zion is turned into a desert , in lies in ruins . ""

At Jerusalem he found the degradation , degeneration , immorality , and superstition of his race at the lowest possible depth : ancl however accustomed we may be to the denunciations of the Christians of the Latin and Greek churches located there , among themselves , or to the slanders of the Anglo-Prussian Bishop Gobat , with all the abuse the latter has heaped on those who differ from him—yet in comparison to Dr . Frankl ' s indignant

description of the ways and doings of the Jews at Jerusalem , the former are comparatively mild and inoffensive . The Jews have a favourite practice , particularly those of Germany ancl Poland , and they leave the lands of their birth when advancing in years , in order to lay their bones in the tomb of their forefathers at Jerusalem ; and as many of them reach the holy city not overburthened with wealththey arc supported by alms collected for that

pur-, pose in almost every city of Europe . Three consequences follow this continual immigration ancl collection . The first is an immense amount of peculation and fraud amongst the rabbis and other persons through whose hands the money passes . Another is the idleness , falsehood , sycophancy and selfishness of professed mendicants , which inflames the ferocious party quarrels among the various sects of eastern ancl western origin , who fight their battles

in the holy city , each to secure the greatest amount of assistance derived from the pious offerings of their people abroad . And lastly , these immigrants bring their families with them , who lapse into the evil habits of the country , contract premature marriages , lose all habits of industry , ancl add to the number of the enfeebled and depraved race who prey on the benevolence , and frustrateall the munificent plans for their welfare , formed by such nobleminded Jews as Sir Afoscs Alontefiore , who came with barrels of

dollars to distribute among his people , but all whose schemes for permanent ]) - improving them have wellnigh come to nought , ancl who was ultimately excommunicated by them for offending their superstition by visiting the Mosque of Omar . Dr . Erankl , though a Jew , does not consider himself bound to accept the ideas , or hide the faults of his race . Even while conforniingto their customs , he expresses no respect for some of them .

He openly proclaims the iinworthiness , fraud and rascallity of most of their rabbis . He enumerates , with bitter precision , the varieties of their parties . He descants at large on the greediness , the unfitness for anything useful or good , of the poorer population ; and though he does not tell us that bis own benevolent errand was unsuccessful , he dwells on what he had to endure from the malice and calumnies of unscrupulous opponents , and

scarcely leaves much reason to hope that his schemes would prove more lasting than those of his noble and openhearted predecessors , Sir Afoscs Montefiore ancl Air . Cohen . A darker ancl more miserable picture could hardl y be drawn of a race lost to every feeling of self-respect ancl good , sinking deeper and deeper each generation into sensuality and corruption of mind and body , eaten up with the grossest superstitions , and

grossly , ruthlessly , and systematicall y oppressed and plundered by rulers professing to govern , ancl even to feed them , in the name of God ! He epiotes the indignant expression of a Polish merchant who went to Jerusalem expecting to find it the seat of sanctity , but found nothing there save immorality , hypocrisy , ancl utter ' helplcssness . The Pole said : — " He tliat will enjoy ituhm haze ( the p leasures of this world ) , must live in Moldavia " ; he that wishes to renounce them ayid to obtain auhmi iutl'o , ( the pleasures of the

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 13
  • You're on page14
  • 15
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy