Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • May 21, 1870
  • Page 5
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 21, 1870: Page 5

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 21, 1870
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article CORRESPONDENCE. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The Editor is not responsible for ihe opinions expressed by Correspondent ! . "CONFIRMED" AND "AFFIRMED . " 10 THE EDITOE OF THE FREEMASONS' MAGAZINE AUD MASONIC MIEK 0 I 1 . Dear Sir and Brother , — "Week after week I see in your reports of various loclge meetings that " the

minutes of the previous meeting have been read and ¦ confirmed . The word confirmed I believe to be out of place here—it should be affirmed ; and in support of this I give you an extract from " Cox ' s Law of Joint Stock Companies . He says : — " It is not , as is generally supposed , a confirmation by the present Board of

the acts of the last Board , for that would imply that the concurrence of two Boards is necessary to the validity of any vote , and it would involve the absurdity of empowering those who were not present when the subject was discussed to rescind a resolution formally carried . The proceediug is , in truth , nothing more

than an affirmation hy the present Board that the Secretary had rightly entered the minutes of the proceedings of the last Board , and that they were as they appear upon the book , and , as a voucher for this , the -chairman signs it . Yours fraternally , J . H . KEEBIE , S . TV . 1 , 131 .

A COUNCIL OF RITES . TO THE EDITOR OF THE FREEMASONS * MAGAZINE AND MASONIC MIRROR . Dear Sir and Brother , —I am pleased to see that aome of our most distinguished brethren are interesting themselves upon the subject of a " Council of Uites" with the object of obtaining a mutual support

, and recognition by the diiFerent groups of " high grade" Masons . It does seem to me a great anomaly that the Grand Lodge of England should declare that Masonry shall consist of three degrees and no more , including the Holy Royal Arch , while at the same time it should

wink at the exercise , by some of its leading members , of the ' ' high grades , " which its constitutions not only decline to recognise , but in a measure prohibit . In my humble opinion , the course of the United Grand Lodge of Ancient Free and Accepted Masons ¦ of England and TVales should take one of two directions—there should be no via media in the matter .

Either the high grades should be recognised , ackuow .. ledged , aud governed over by the Grand Lodge of England , or , on the other hand , be , as far as our Grand Lodge is concerned , declared , as Masonic bodies , spurious , and the practice of them should be denounced and prohibited . "We find in some countries that the 33 rd degree is

the crowning point of Craft Masonry ; that all these degrees ( as in Sweden and France ) are recognised , and the conferring them is made the reward of assiduous labour in the lower degrees . The system seems to work well . The great aim and end of Masonic work through all

ages has been the universality of Freemasonry , aud I cannot see how this great object can be accomplished while Masons in different nations each agree to differ in the mode of conducting their work . I would suggest that not only a " Council of Rites " should be appointed , but that a " Universal Congress

of Masons" should be held , and that efforts should be made to reduce Masonry to one uniform system throughout the world , so that , knowing the language of the country , there would be no difficulty for a Mason to join in the great work in any part of the globe in which he might happen to bo sojourning .

I must confess that I am not myself a high grade Mason . I have a great admiration for our beautiful Craft degrees , and the ceremonial of the Royal Arch , aud I do not feel I should be doing right in penetrating into further mysteries , while the Grand Lodge to which I owe obedience fails to support or recommend ,

and which it seems to me is by her forbidden to be exercised . If the sanction , approval , recognition , ancl supervision of these high grades should be accomplished , I have no doubt a laudable ambition would lead me , with thousands moreto seek another and yet higher

, " summit of perfection" than the one I once fondly imagined I had attained . But I feel in this some sense of disappointment as in days gone by , while erasing mountainous passes , I have climbed up hill after hill , fondly imagining that each oue must be summit , only to findon the accomplishment of every fancied

, victory , that I was apparently farther than ever from the goal of my hopes and aspirations . Tours fraternally , PEOQ-EESS .

MASONIC SAYINGS AUD DOINGS ASEOAD .

The Masonic Record of Western India has entered upon the seventh year of its labours . The conductors " fully appreciate the kind and encouraging words of praise bestowed upon their humble exertions by contemporaries in England , France , aud America . " News reaches us of the severe illness of Bro . TV .

H . Hoff , the talented editor of the Indian Freemason ' s Friend , who is obliged to proceed to the Straits for change of air . Masonry is laying for itself a sure foundation , and

establishing a healthy ancl vigorous existence in Hungary . La Chaine d'Union welcomes this great triumph , and hope for our noble institution . Our principles of humanity , progress , and liberty meet with devoted hearts and willing hands iu that country .

From Italy we learn that the Lodge Giorgi " Washington , of the Rite Ecossais , has declared itself independent , haying retired from the jurisdiction of the Supreme Council of that Rite iu Italy . The lodge had protested against a sentence which affected Bro .

Crispo , editor of L'llumanilaro . In answer to this protest , the Supreme Council passed a judgment , condemnatory of the course taken by Lodge Giorgi "Washington . This lodge , feeling its dignity affected , withdrew itself from the jurisdiction of the Supreme Council condemning it .

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1870-05-21, Page 5” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 24 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_21051870/page/5/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
THE HISTORY OF FREEMASONRY IN PORTUGAL. Article 1
MASONIC JOTTINGS.—No. 20. Article 3
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 4
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 5
LADIES AT OUR MASONIC BANQUETS. Article 6
Untitled Article 7
MASONIC MEMS. Article 7
INSTALLATION OF THE EARL DE GREY AND RIPON AS MOST WORSHIPFUL GRAND MASTER, AND GRAND FESTIVAL. Article 7
Craft Masonry. Article 11
PROVINCIAL. Article 12
SCOTTISH CONSTITUTION. Article 13
ROYAL ARCH. Article 14
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 14
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 15
TESTIMONIAL TO BRO. R. H. D. JOHNSON, M.R-C.S, P.M. & P.Z. 1,004. Article 16
CONSECRATION OF THE FREEMASONS' HALL, ADELAIDE, SOUTH AUSTRALIA. Article 16
PALESTINE EXPLORATION FUND. Article 18
Obituary. Article 19
SCIENTIFIC MEETINGS FOR THE WEEK. Article 20
LIST OF LODGE, MEETINGS , &c., FOR WEEK ENDING 28TH MAY, 1870. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

2 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

2 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

4 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

2 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

2 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 5

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

CORRESPONDENCE .

The Editor is not responsible for ihe opinions expressed by Correspondent ! . "CONFIRMED" AND "AFFIRMED . " 10 THE EDITOE OF THE FREEMASONS' MAGAZINE AUD MASONIC MIEK 0 I 1 . Dear Sir and Brother , — "Week after week I see in your reports of various loclge meetings that " the

minutes of the previous meeting have been read and ¦ confirmed . The word confirmed I believe to be out of place here—it should be affirmed ; and in support of this I give you an extract from " Cox ' s Law of Joint Stock Companies . He says : — " It is not , as is generally supposed , a confirmation by the present Board of

the acts of the last Board , for that would imply that the concurrence of two Boards is necessary to the validity of any vote , and it would involve the absurdity of empowering those who were not present when the subject was discussed to rescind a resolution formally carried . The proceediug is , in truth , nothing more

than an affirmation hy the present Board that the Secretary had rightly entered the minutes of the proceedings of the last Board , and that they were as they appear upon the book , and , as a voucher for this , the -chairman signs it . Yours fraternally , J . H . KEEBIE , S . TV . 1 , 131 .

A COUNCIL OF RITES . TO THE EDITOR OF THE FREEMASONS * MAGAZINE AND MASONIC MIRROR . Dear Sir and Brother , —I am pleased to see that aome of our most distinguished brethren are interesting themselves upon the subject of a " Council of Uites" with the object of obtaining a mutual support

, and recognition by the diiFerent groups of " high grade" Masons . It does seem to me a great anomaly that the Grand Lodge of England should declare that Masonry shall consist of three degrees and no more , including the Holy Royal Arch , while at the same time it should

wink at the exercise , by some of its leading members , of the ' ' high grades , " which its constitutions not only decline to recognise , but in a measure prohibit . In my humble opinion , the course of the United Grand Lodge of Ancient Free and Accepted Masons ¦ of England and TVales should take one of two directions—there should be no via media in the matter .

Either the high grades should be recognised , ackuow .. ledged , aud governed over by the Grand Lodge of England , or , on the other hand , be , as far as our Grand Lodge is concerned , declared , as Masonic bodies , spurious , and the practice of them should be denounced and prohibited . "We find in some countries that the 33 rd degree is

the crowning point of Craft Masonry ; that all these degrees ( as in Sweden and France ) are recognised , and the conferring them is made the reward of assiduous labour in the lower degrees . The system seems to work well . The great aim and end of Masonic work through all

ages has been the universality of Freemasonry , aud I cannot see how this great object can be accomplished while Masons in different nations each agree to differ in the mode of conducting their work . I would suggest that not only a " Council of Rites " should be appointed , but that a " Universal Congress

of Masons" should be held , and that efforts should be made to reduce Masonry to one uniform system throughout the world , so that , knowing the language of the country , there would be no difficulty for a Mason to join in the great work in any part of the globe in which he might happen to bo sojourning .

I must confess that I am not myself a high grade Mason . I have a great admiration for our beautiful Craft degrees , and the ceremonial of the Royal Arch , aud I do not feel I should be doing right in penetrating into further mysteries , while the Grand Lodge to which I owe obedience fails to support or recommend ,

and which it seems to me is by her forbidden to be exercised . If the sanction , approval , recognition , ancl supervision of these high grades should be accomplished , I have no doubt a laudable ambition would lead me , with thousands moreto seek another and yet higher

, " summit of perfection" than the one I once fondly imagined I had attained . But I feel in this some sense of disappointment as in days gone by , while erasing mountainous passes , I have climbed up hill after hill , fondly imagining that each oue must be summit , only to findon the accomplishment of every fancied

, victory , that I was apparently farther than ever from the goal of my hopes and aspirations . Tours fraternally , PEOQ-EESS .

MASONIC SAYINGS AUD DOINGS ASEOAD .

The Masonic Record of Western India has entered upon the seventh year of its labours . The conductors " fully appreciate the kind and encouraging words of praise bestowed upon their humble exertions by contemporaries in England , France , aud America . " News reaches us of the severe illness of Bro . TV .

H . Hoff , the talented editor of the Indian Freemason ' s Friend , who is obliged to proceed to the Straits for change of air . Masonry is laying for itself a sure foundation , and

establishing a healthy ancl vigorous existence in Hungary . La Chaine d'Union welcomes this great triumph , and hope for our noble institution . Our principles of humanity , progress , and liberty meet with devoted hearts and willing hands iu that country .

From Italy we learn that the Lodge Giorgi " Washington , of the Rite Ecossais , has declared itself independent , haying retired from the jurisdiction of the Supreme Council of that Rite iu Italy . The lodge had protested against a sentence which affected Bro .

Crispo , editor of L'llumanilaro . In answer to this protest , the Supreme Council passed a judgment , condemnatory of the course taken by Lodge Giorgi "Washington . This lodge , feeling its dignity affected , withdrew itself from the jurisdiction of the Supreme Council condemning it .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 4
  • You're on page5
  • 6
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy