Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Aug. 21, 1869
  • Page 8
  • BIBLES, &c., AND DECAPITATION OF BRO. MELVILLE (p. 129.)
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Aug. 21, 1869: Page 8

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Aug. 21, 1869
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article FREEMASONRY ABOUT ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY-TWO TEARS OLD. ← Page 3 of 3
    Article BIBLES, &c., AND DECAPITATION OF BRO. MELVILLE (p. 129.) Page 1 of 2 →
Page 8

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemasonry About One Hundred And Fifty-Two Tears Old.

monger ' s Society . Such admission had something to do in paving the way for the more easy adoption of the speculative Freemasonry that was afterwards manufactured by Desaguliers & Co . From what I have seen of Mary ' s Chapel records I am convinced

that this is ri ght , and that 1721 may be pointed to as the date of the formal inauguration ' in Scotland of the English system of Freemasonry as manufactured b y Desaguliers , Anderson , & Co . ' " Then let us hear what our talented Brother W . J . Hughau , of Truro , says , viz .: — ' The crafts were

provided for from the 15 th century , and afterwards , without any special distinctions for masons . " Wrichtes aud maisones" were often classed together , and certainl y there was nothing special in the latter , so far as may he gathered by the A . ets of Parliament . We read of the wardens and deaknes of craftsbut

, never as applied exclusivel y to Masonry . Why ? Surely because that as a bodv it contained nothing requiring different legislation " to the others . Some centuries ago it was provided that the sums of money "Imployed by any corporation , guild , fraternity , company ,, or fellowshi of mystery or craft

p any towards % he maintenance of any priest , anniversary , obit , lamp , light , or the like , " had to be paid yearly as a rent charge to the King , his heirs , ' & c . " From the foregoing we learn two things- First , that there is no documentary evidence yet discovered , nor , I fear , discoverable , of the existence of Free .

masonry previous to the last century ; but that the mass of documentary evidence extant points to the period , t ; f the rei gn of George I . ( 1714 to 1727 ) as the time when Freemasonry , its doctrines and rituals included , was instituted . Second , without going further back at present , the mass of documentary evidence extantfrom the 14 th to the 17 th centuries

, , proves that the mason ' s lodge , societv , corporation , or fraternity , was just the same as the other trades societies or fraternities ; ancl the ' luge' at first was simply the shed or erection in which the masons worked , as in the Aberdeen Burgh Records , fifteenth century , we read of a mason contracting ' to mak glide service in the

luge and vteuche to the bisin , ' & c . ( That is to say—that he engaged to work in a faithful and tradesmanlike manner , both in the lodge and out of it , towards the erection of a certain building then going on ) . And not only was the fraternity idea strong m the crafts , but even the whole communit

y of a town was sometimes taken as a brotherhood , as at page 448 of Aberdeen Burgh Records , Spalding Club , date 1530 , it speaks of ' brithers withm ane gude tonne dwelland . ' The whole of the extracts upon this page are of the utmost interest to the Masonic student as showing how ideas , & c , that openl in

were y practised the sixteenth century , were afterwards adopted by the Masons in the eighteenth century as part of their special secrets ancl private property . I might have copied it off , but I fear I am perhaps talcing up too much of your space as it is . * " Lastly , now a few words anent the Master Mason degree . In the old operative lodge there was the apprentice who came to learn his trade , then the

fellow-of-craft and master , who employed men to work for him . There was also the master of the lodge , which was an office not a degree . When admitted into the lodge the apprentice seems to have received a wordand any ceremony used in iving it was simple

, g indeed ; in fact , I am not prepared to say that the entry of an apprentice mason , in the fifteenth or sixteenth centuries , say , was in any particular point different from that of an apprentice cordiner . However , being once admitted , our apprentices were now eligible to be present at all meetings , no matter what

business was transacting . Previous to the eighteenth century there was no such thing as a 'Master Mason ' s degree , ' at which none but those who had received that' degree ' were present ; for at the admission of all masters and fellows , apprentices were bound to be present by the rulesconsequentlyhad

, , any ' degree ' been worked , the apprentice would have seen it . It could not , therefore , be a secret or separate degree . In reference to this , Bro . Hughan says , 'No proof of the 3 rd degree having been worked as a degree , apart from any other degree , and confined to members only of that degreeanterior to the 18 th

, century has ever been given . Let those that say that such ever occurred before produce the necessary documentary evidence . Mere traditions and legends can be produced to prove the greatest absurdities , and the most palpable lies in creation . ' Then Bro . Lyon says , ' It has hitherto been pointed to in proof of

the antiquity of the 3 rd degree that Robert Moray , a soldier , was made a Master Mason in 1641 , iu Mary ' s Chapel . He was not made a Master Mason , but , like some other non-operatives , had an honorary connexion with that Mason ' s society . " Bro . Lyon also positively asserts that the ' Master Masons' of operative times were simply bona fide employers of

labour , and not until after 1717 , but in or before 1735 , was the ' degree ' of Master Mason ever worked in Mother Kilwinning Lodge . " I may here observe that Desaguliers visited Mary ' s Chapel Lodge in Edinburgh 1721 . He was Grand Master of England in 1719 . He was a great

mathematician , mechanic , and natural philosopher , ancl no doubt to his position and influence Freemasonry was greatly indebted at its start . In Buckle ' s ' History of Civilisation , ' Desaguliers is said to have been ' the first who popularized natural philosophy . ' All thisthereforebrings me to the conclusion I

, , started with , viz ., that the Reformation preceded Freemasonry , and that said Freemasonry is only about a century and a half old , and that there was no Master Mason ' degree , ' or anything like it , worked until after 1717 . I challenge all and sundry to bring forward the least substantial proof of the contrary . And as

for Royal Arch Masonry and the whole host of chivalric degrees , they are all based upon speculative Masonry , and sprang up after it , and are all less than a century and a half old . —I am , & c , " Glasgow , 12 th August , 1869 . " W . P . B . "

Bibles, &C., And Decapitation Of Bro. Melville (P. 129.)

BIBLES , & c ., AND DECAPITATION OF BRO . MELVILLE ( p . 129 . )

TO THE EDITOK 01- THE FI . EE 3 USO . rs' 2 TAGAZINE AND MASONIC SIIKEOE .

Dear Sir and Brother , — Our mystery-monger , adopter , and mudifier of other people ' s ideas is at

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1869-08-21, Page 8” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 21 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_21081869/page/8/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
THE INAUGURATION FESTIVAL JEWEL. Article 1
THE PALESTINE EXPLORATION FUND. Article 1
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 4
FREEMASONRY ABOUT ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY-TWO TEARS OLD. Article 6
BIBLES, &c., AND DECAPITATION OF BRO. MELVILLE (p. 129.) Article 8
REVISION OF THE RITUALS. Article 9
NEW LODGES AND NEW MEMBERS. Article 9
Untitled Article 10
MASONIC MEMS Article 10
METROPOLITAN. Article 11
PROVINCIAL. Article 11
MARK MASONRY. Article 13
LAYING THE FOUNDATION STONE OF THE SHERIFF COURT-HOUSE AND NEW HALL AT FORFAR. Article 14
MASONIC PRESENTATION AT THE WORCESTER CATHEDRAL. Article 16
LAYING THE CORNER STONE OF THE MASONIC HALL, CARLETON, NEW BRUNSWICK. Article 17
LITERATURE, SCIENCE, MUSIC, DRAMA, AND THE FINE ARTS. Article 19
Poetry. Article 20
LIST OF LODGE, &c., MEETINGS FOR WEEK ENDING 28TH AUGUST, 1869. Article 20
TO CORESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

4 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

3 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

5 Articles
Page 8

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Freemasonry About One Hundred And Fifty-Two Tears Old.

monger ' s Society . Such admission had something to do in paving the way for the more easy adoption of the speculative Freemasonry that was afterwards manufactured by Desaguliers & Co . From what I have seen of Mary ' s Chapel records I am convinced

that this is ri ght , and that 1721 may be pointed to as the date of the formal inauguration ' in Scotland of the English system of Freemasonry as manufactured b y Desaguliers , Anderson , & Co . ' " Then let us hear what our talented Brother W . J . Hughau , of Truro , says , viz .: — ' The crafts were

provided for from the 15 th century , and afterwards , without any special distinctions for masons . " Wrichtes aud maisones" were often classed together , and certainl y there was nothing special in the latter , so far as may he gathered by the A . ets of Parliament . We read of the wardens and deaknes of craftsbut

, never as applied exclusivel y to Masonry . Why ? Surely because that as a bodv it contained nothing requiring different legislation " to the others . Some centuries ago it was provided that the sums of money "Imployed by any corporation , guild , fraternity , company ,, or fellowshi of mystery or craft

p any towards % he maintenance of any priest , anniversary , obit , lamp , light , or the like , " had to be paid yearly as a rent charge to the King , his heirs , ' & c . " From the foregoing we learn two things- First , that there is no documentary evidence yet discovered , nor , I fear , discoverable , of the existence of Free .

masonry previous to the last century ; but that the mass of documentary evidence extant points to the period , t ; f the rei gn of George I . ( 1714 to 1727 ) as the time when Freemasonry , its doctrines and rituals included , was instituted . Second , without going further back at present , the mass of documentary evidence extantfrom the 14 th to the 17 th centuries

, , proves that the mason ' s lodge , societv , corporation , or fraternity , was just the same as the other trades societies or fraternities ; ancl the ' luge' at first was simply the shed or erection in which the masons worked , as in the Aberdeen Burgh Records , fifteenth century , we read of a mason contracting ' to mak glide service in the

luge and vteuche to the bisin , ' & c . ( That is to say—that he engaged to work in a faithful and tradesmanlike manner , both in the lodge and out of it , towards the erection of a certain building then going on ) . And not only was the fraternity idea strong m the crafts , but even the whole communit

y of a town was sometimes taken as a brotherhood , as at page 448 of Aberdeen Burgh Records , Spalding Club , date 1530 , it speaks of ' brithers withm ane gude tonne dwelland . ' The whole of the extracts upon this page are of the utmost interest to the Masonic student as showing how ideas , & c , that openl in

were y practised the sixteenth century , were afterwards adopted by the Masons in the eighteenth century as part of their special secrets ancl private property . I might have copied it off , but I fear I am perhaps talcing up too much of your space as it is . * " Lastly , now a few words anent the Master Mason degree . In the old operative lodge there was the apprentice who came to learn his trade , then the

fellow-of-craft and master , who employed men to work for him . There was also the master of the lodge , which was an office not a degree . When admitted into the lodge the apprentice seems to have received a wordand any ceremony used in iving it was simple

, g indeed ; in fact , I am not prepared to say that the entry of an apprentice mason , in the fifteenth or sixteenth centuries , say , was in any particular point different from that of an apprentice cordiner . However , being once admitted , our apprentices were now eligible to be present at all meetings , no matter what

business was transacting . Previous to the eighteenth century there was no such thing as a 'Master Mason ' s degree , ' at which none but those who had received that' degree ' were present ; for at the admission of all masters and fellows , apprentices were bound to be present by the rulesconsequentlyhad

, , any ' degree ' been worked , the apprentice would have seen it . It could not , therefore , be a secret or separate degree . In reference to this , Bro . Hughan says , 'No proof of the 3 rd degree having been worked as a degree , apart from any other degree , and confined to members only of that degreeanterior to the 18 th

, century has ever been given . Let those that say that such ever occurred before produce the necessary documentary evidence . Mere traditions and legends can be produced to prove the greatest absurdities , and the most palpable lies in creation . ' Then Bro . Lyon says , ' It has hitherto been pointed to in proof of

the antiquity of the 3 rd degree that Robert Moray , a soldier , was made a Master Mason in 1641 , iu Mary ' s Chapel . He was not made a Master Mason , but , like some other non-operatives , had an honorary connexion with that Mason ' s society . " Bro . Lyon also positively asserts that the ' Master Masons' of operative times were simply bona fide employers of

labour , and not until after 1717 , but in or before 1735 , was the ' degree ' of Master Mason ever worked in Mother Kilwinning Lodge . " I may here observe that Desaguliers visited Mary ' s Chapel Lodge in Edinburgh 1721 . He was Grand Master of England in 1719 . He was a great

mathematician , mechanic , and natural philosopher , ancl no doubt to his position and influence Freemasonry was greatly indebted at its start . In Buckle ' s ' History of Civilisation , ' Desaguliers is said to have been ' the first who popularized natural philosophy . ' All thisthereforebrings me to the conclusion I

, , started with , viz ., that the Reformation preceded Freemasonry , and that said Freemasonry is only about a century and a half old , and that there was no Master Mason ' degree , ' or anything like it , worked until after 1717 . I challenge all and sundry to bring forward the least substantial proof of the contrary . And as

for Royal Arch Masonry and the whole host of chivalric degrees , they are all based upon speculative Masonry , and sprang up after it , and are all less than a century and a half old . —I am , & c , " Glasgow , 12 th August , 1869 . " W . P . B . "

Bibles, &C., And Decapitation Of Bro. Melville (P. 129.)

BIBLES , & c ., AND DECAPITATION OF BRO . MELVILLE ( p . 129 . )

TO THE EDITOK 01- THE FI . EE 3 USO . rs' 2 TAGAZINE AND MASONIC SIIKEOE .

Dear Sir and Brother , — Our mystery-monger , adopter , and mudifier of other people ' s ideas is at

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 7
  • You're on page8
  • 9
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy