Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • July 24, 1869
  • Page 11
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, July 24, 1869: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, July 24, 1869
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article MARK MASONRY AND THE GRAND MARK LODGE OFFICIALS. Page 1 of 1
    Article BRO. MELVILLE'S DISCOVERIES. Page 1 of 1
    Article BRO. MELVILLE'S DISCOVERIES. Page 1 of 1
    Article POSITION AS A CRAFTSMAN. Page 1 of 1
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Mark Masonry And The Grand Mark Lodge Officials.

MARK MASONRY AND THE GRAND MARK LODGE OFFICIALS .

TO THE 33 DITOB OE THE EBEEMASOJJS' MAGAZINE AND MASOIfIC MIBBOB . Dear Sir and Brother , —Under the above heading a correspondent in your last number , signing himself " "W . M ., " thinks proper to state , " as a fact , " that no one need expect an answer to any communication addressed to this office . Nowassertion is not proof .

, I repeat the statement contained in a former letter to your paper on this subject , that there is not one letter unanswered in this office . I receive complaints occasionally of neglect , but never fail to vindicate myself , and have only recently proved , by official testimony from the Post Office , that two letters with

remittances—for the non-acknowledgement of which I had been censured—never reached me . Such is the case , doubtless , with regard to the letters alluded to by " W . W . " For my own errors I am content to be responsible , but I cannot allow myself to be held accountable for postal laches , of which not only I , but

many others , have but too much reason to complain . Further , I demur to the fairness of anyone holding up another to public reprobation without inquiry or affording opportunity for explanation . Yours fraternally , FREDERICK BINCKES , G . SEC . Office , 2 , Eed Lion-square , W . C . 19 th July , 1869 .

Bro. Melville's Discoveries.

BRO . MELVILLE'S DISCOVERIES .

TO TUB EDITOR OF THE EBEEMAS 02 TS' MAGAZINE AJfD MASOKIC MIBBOB . Dear Sir and Brother , —As Bro . Buchan , in reply to my last letter , has lost sight of the spirit of it , and quarrels with it in a personal way , I would explain to him that my wish was not to annoy him , or any other brother who had condemned these so-called discoveries , without searching into them or accepting

the offered key for understanding them , but to point out how the Craft might probably lose some li g ht or knowledge if such policy was persevered in . It is probable Bro . Melville looks upon his discoveries as greater than we may all find them to be when examined , yet this does not warrant anyone of us in treating with rudeness and insult the apparent earnestness of a brother who seems to have devoted

years of his life with the object alone of benefiting his brethren . I must confess I cannot see the application of Bro . Buchan ' s remarks about a lunatic asylum and Julius Caesar , and the figure of a coalcellar and farthing candle is equally elegant and clear . I will not further allude to the words " nasty look of imposture and money-getting" than to say they

, do not look well in print . Bro . Buchan alludes to my deficiency in geography . I have many and great deficiencies , but I have a practical knowledge of the distance between Glasgow and London , and must still call it " a few miles ;" had the travelling required for the journey been at the

time of the old stage coaches , or had the destination been Australia , Bro . B . ' s remark might have have had some little weight . I fear Bro . Buchan ' s cable tow is a short one when the " saxpences " are required , though he very modestly tells us that the money he has spent in postage-stamps alone on Masonic matters during the last twelve months is more than many Masons have expended on Masonic literature during their whole lives . Of course Bro . B . knows .

Bro. Melville's Discoveries.

What I wish is , that any truth or information there may be in these discoveries may be secured for the benefit of the Craft ; or , if the whole is found to be but the result of an over-enthusiastic temperament , let this also be shown clearly and temperately , and the matter will of itself pass into oblivion , without being trampled down with hard words . This is a work

which may be done without any personality or undignified language , and Bro . Buchan can , if he will , render good service in the cause . Yours fraternally , EXCELSIOR . [ The correspondence respecting Bro . Melville and his discoveries must now cease . It has far exceeded the length usually allotted in the Freemasons' Magazine to

any particular subject , however interesting ; and , as we see no useful purpose will be served by further protracting it , we cannot insert any more letters on the subject—En . F . M . ]

Position As A Craftsman.

POSITION AS A CRAFTSMAN .

TO THE EDITOB OE THE EBEEMASOXS' MAGAZINE A 2 fD MASONIC MIBBOB . Dear Sir and Brother , —At page 19 of the Magazine we read of the " honourable position as a Craftsman " of the R . W . M . of No . 3 bis . May I ask , what does that mean ? Because , while we know that he was " elected to fill the chair" weas yethave

, , , heard nothing of his having since then discharged the duties of a master . The mere election to office—as is well known—does not necessarily infer performance of its duties ; therefore , does the R . W . M . of No . 3 bis "fill the chair " by merely sitting in it while another brother does

his work ; or , does he work his lodge himself?—thereby proving that he is a true workman that needeth not to be ashamed of his work . A Master who is ashamed to work his lodge himself , or who considers it beneath him to do so , throws a slur upon

the Craft , and he should , therefore , be ashamed to occupy the position ; besides , he is sometimes apt to receive the anything but honourable , although significant title of " duffer ; " which title I have heard applied to brethren who enjoyed the pomposity of " filling the chair" without seeming to have any ability to do anything when in it . ( In such a case

" pomposity of filling the chair" is a proper expression , and gives the true idea ; but to the real Master we say he has the honour of filling the chair . " In a lodge , as we understand , composed in a great measure of tradesmen connected with building , an architect is only too liable to be elected for other

reasons than Masonic ones ; however , any lodge that makes such high claims to antiquity and position as No . 3 bis , ought to set a wholesome example in its working ; therefore , we shall be very happy to hear that its chief officer holds a good " position as a Craftsman ' ' in that respect . Yours fraternally , ENQTJTBEE .

IMPOETAKT GEOIOG-ICAL DISCOVEBT . —Tiie prizes tbat were offered by Mr . Barkas , of Newcastle , to pit lads , in Durham aud Northumberland , to induce them to search for fossil remains , have been attended by the most unexpected results . Not only have the laels picked up from the refuse shale heads large numbers of fish remains , and some remains of large reptiles , but what is really extraordinary , and will astonish palaeontologists , one of the laels has found the lower jaw of a true mammal . The effect of this discovery will be to reduce the comparative ages of all hitherto known mammalia , and carry back the mammalian life of the world for millions of years .

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1869-07-24, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 19 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_24071869/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
THE GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND AND THE GRAND MASONIC BODY OF FRANCE. Article 1
THE KEYS IDENTIFIED. Article 2
FREEMASONRY OVER THE BORDER. Article 4
BURGH RECORDS.—No. 4. Article 7
MASONIC NOTES AND QERIES. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 9
MARK MASONRY AND THE GRAND MARK LODGE OFFICIALS. Article 11
BRO. MELVILLE'S DISCOVERIES. Article 11
POSITION AS A CRAFTSMAN. Article 11
Untitled Article 12
LODGE OF BENEVOLENCE. Article 12
ROYAL MASONIC BENEVOLENT INSTITUTION. Article 12
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS, WOOD GREEN. Article 12
METROPOLITAN. Article 17
PROVINCIAL. Article 18
IRELAND. Article 18
ROYAL ARCH. Article 19
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 19
Obituary. Article 19
LIST OF LODGE, &c., MEETINGS FOR WEEK ENDING 31ST JULY, 1869. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

3 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

4 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

5 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

4 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

4 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

4 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Mark Masonry And The Grand Mark Lodge Officials.

MARK MASONRY AND THE GRAND MARK LODGE OFFICIALS .

TO THE 33 DITOB OE THE EBEEMASOJJS' MAGAZINE AND MASOIfIC MIBBOB . Dear Sir and Brother , —Under the above heading a correspondent in your last number , signing himself " "W . M ., " thinks proper to state , " as a fact , " that no one need expect an answer to any communication addressed to this office . Nowassertion is not proof .

, I repeat the statement contained in a former letter to your paper on this subject , that there is not one letter unanswered in this office . I receive complaints occasionally of neglect , but never fail to vindicate myself , and have only recently proved , by official testimony from the Post Office , that two letters with

remittances—for the non-acknowledgement of which I had been censured—never reached me . Such is the case , doubtless , with regard to the letters alluded to by " W . W . " For my own errors I am content to be responsible , but I cannot allow myself to be held accountable for postal laches , of which not only I , but

many others , have but too much reason to complain . Further , I demur to the fairness of anyone holding up another to public reprobation without inquiry or affording opportunity for explanation . Yours fraternally , FREDERICK BINCKES , G . SEC . Office , 2 , Eed Lion-square , W . C . 19 th July , 1869 .

Bro. Melville's Discoveries.

BRO . MELVILLE'S DISCOVERIES .

TO TUB EDITOR OF THE EBEEMAS 02 TS' MAGAZINE AJfD MASOKIC MIBBOB . Dear Sir and Brother , —As Bro . Buchan , in reply to my last letter , has lost sight of the spirit of it , and quarrels with it in a personal way , I would explain to him that my wish was not to annoy him , or any other brother who had condemned these so-called discoveries , without searching into them or accepting

the offered key for understanding them , but to point out how the Craft might probably lose some li g ht or knowledge if such policy was persevered in . It is probable Bro . Melville looks upon his discoveries as greater than we may all find them to be when examined , yet this does not warrant anyone of us in treating with rudeness and insult the apparent earnestness of a brother who seems to have devoted

years of his life with the object alone of benefiting his brethren . I must confess I cannot see the application of Bro . Buchan ' s remarks about a lunatic asylum and Julius Caesar , and the figure of a coalcellar and farthing candle is equally elegant and clear . I will not further allude to the words " nasty look of imposture and money-getting" than to say they

, do not look well in print . Bro . Buchan alludes to my deficiency in geography . I have many and great deficiencies , but I have a practical knowledge of the distance between Glasgow and London , and must still call it " a few miles ;" had the travelling required for the journey been at the

time of the old stage coaches , or had the destination been Australia , Bro . B . ' s remark might have have had some little weight . I fear Bro . Buchan ' s cable tow is a short one when the " saxpences " are required , though he very modestly tells us that the money he has spent in postage-stamps alone on Masonic matters during the last twelve months is more than many Masons have expended on Masonic literature during their whole lives . Of course Bro . B . knows .

Bro. Melville's Discoveries.

What I wish is , that any truth or information there may be in these discoveries may be secured for the benefit of the Craft ; or , if the whole is found to be but the result of an over-enthusiastic temperament , let this also be shown clearly and temperately , and the matter will of itself pass into oblivion , without being trampled down with hard words . This is a work

which may be done without any personality or undignified language , and Bro . Buchan can , if he will , render good service in the cause . Yours fraternally , EXCELSIOR . [ The correspondence respecting Bro . Melville and his discoveries must now cease . It has far exceeded the length usually allotted in the Freemasons' Magazine to

any particular subject , however interesting ; and , as we see no useful purpose will be served by further protracting it , we cannot insert any more letters on the subject—En . F . M . ]

Position As A Craftsman.

POSITION AS A CRAFTSMAN .

TO THE EDITOB OE THE EBEEMASOXS' MAGAZINE A 2 fD MASONIC MIBBOB . Dear Sir and Brother , —At page 19 of the Magazine we read of the " honourable position as a Craftsman " of the R . W . M . of No . 3 bis . May I ask , what does that mean ? Because , while we know that he was " elected to fill the chair" weas yethave

, , , heard nothing of his having since then discharged the duties of a master . The mere election to office—as is well known—does not necessarily infer performance of its duties ; therefore , does the R . W . M . of No . 3 bis "fill the chair " by merely sitting in it while another brother does

his work ; or , does he work his lodge himself?—thereby proving that he is a true workman that needeth not to be ashamed of his work . A Master who is ashamed to work his lodge himself , or who considers it beneath him to do so , throws a slur upon

the Craft , and he should , therefore , be ashamed to occupy the position ; besides , he is sometimes apt to receive the anything but honourable , although significant title of " duffer ; " which title I have heard applied to brethren who enjoyed the pomposity of " filling the chair" without seeming to have any ability to do anything when in it . ( In such a case

" pomposity of filling the chair" is a proper expression , and gives the true idea ; but to the real Master we say he has the honour of filling the chair . " In a lodge , as we understand , composed in a great measure of tradesmen connected with building , an architect is only too liable to be elected for other

reasons than Masonic ones ; however , any lodge that makes such high claims to antiquity and position as No . 3 bis , ought to set a wholesome example in its working ; therefore , we shall be very happy to hear that its chief officer holds a good " position as a Craftsman ' ' in that respect . Yours fraternally , ENQTJTBEE .

IMPOETAKT GEOIOG-ICAL DISCOVEBT . —Tiie prizes tbat were offered by Mr . Barkas , of Newcastle , to pit lads , in Durham aud Northumberland , to induce them to search for fossil remains , have been attended by the most unexpected results . Not only have the laels picked up from the refuse shale heads large numbers of fish remains , and some remains of large reptiles , but what is really extraordinary , and will astonish palaeontologists , one of the laels has found the lower jaw of a true mammal . The effect of this discovery will be to reduce the comparative ages of all hitherto known mammalia , and carry back the mammalian life of the world for millions of years .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy