Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • March 25, 1865
  • Page 7
  • MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES.
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, March 25, 1865: Page 7

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, March 25, 1865
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE SEPULCHRE Of CHRIST. ← Page 3 of 3
    Article MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Page 1 of 4 →
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Sepulchre Of Christ.

history and the topography are agreed . Returning to the south-west angle , and measuring 600 ft . north , we come to a second bridge or causeway . Up to that point the great " bevilled " masonry of Herod extends , but there it ceases . On this side , again , the history and topography are at one , and

thus two sides of the quadrangle are obtained . The other two , lying within the sacred inclosure , have not yet been investigated . The position of the great rock-cut reservoir in front of the Aksah , thewatercourses , as far as they have been examined , all accord with the indications of Josephus and the

Talmud . Everything tends to show that the Temple of Herod was , as Josephus tells us , 600 ft . square , and was situated in the south-western angle of the present Harem area . The rock , therefore , which now stands under the Dome of the Roch was certainly outside the area of the Temple , cot a

distance of 150 feet from its northern wall . A few words were devoted to showing that the supposition that the altar in the Temple was placed upon a rock is unsupported by any evidence or implication of the Bible , Josephus , or the Talmud , and is , in fact , a mere Mohammedan tradition . The remainder of the lecture was devoted to an

examination of the post-Christian evidence . The lecturer said that he had Sir H . Rawlinson ' s Arabic library examined by a competent Arabic scholar , who had extracted and translated all passages bearing on Jerusalem , the result being that , down to the time of Abd-el-Malik , and later , the limits of the Temple were well known to the Mohammedans , and that they neither built nor pretended to have built the structure now called the

ec Mosque of Omar . " "If , then , " concluded Mr . Eergusson , "the Dome of the Rock was not built by the Saracens , ifc must have been built by the Christians : there is no third party in the field who could have clone it . In that case , I would ask , ' What church did

Constantine or any other Christian priest or monarch build in Jerusalem over a great rock ¦ with one cave in it but the Church of the Holy Sepulchre ? ' Till this question is answered—and no attempt has yet been made to reply to it , or to supply its place with any-reasonable suggestion—¦

the arguments of my opponents halt . As I began let me conclude . I first took up the question on ai'chifcecfcural grounds ; I then examined it historically ; and lastly , I investigated it on the topographical ground I have this evening laid before you . Whichever path I attempted to pursueI

, always came back to the same point . I do not mean to say that the question is without difficulties , or the road without its ruts ancl roughnesses ; but I do assert that , so far as I can judge , an immense preponderance of evidence , from whatever point it is viewedis in favour of the conclusion that the

, building at Jerusalem known as the Dome of the Rock is the identical church which Constantine built over what he believed to be the Sepulchre of Christ . "

Masonic Notes And Queries.

MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES .

BIBLIOGRAPHIC AI ; QTTEEIES . Some writers have favoured us with the titles of the following works . The dates of publication are of vast importance , and , in order that there may be no mistake about them , instead of inserting them in figures I have done so in words : —

1 . A Short Analysis of the Unchanged Rites and Ceremonies of the Free-Masons . London , 8 yo . Printed for Steph . Billy . SIXTEEN-HTINDEED AND SEVENTY-SIX .

2 . Observations and Inquiries relating to the Brotherhood , of the Free-Masons , hy Simeon Townshend . 8 vo ., London . SEYENTEEN- HUNDBED AND TWELVE . 3 . The Constitutions of'the Fraternity of Free-ancl-Aeeeptei-llasonry . Wo sizeno lace of publication

, p mentioned , hut dates given thus : —SIXTEEN-HUNDBED AND EIGHTY-NINE ; SLXTEEN-HTJNDEED AND NINETY ; SEVENTEEN-HOTDEED AND ONE ; S EVENTEEN-HUNDEED AND TWENTY-THBEE ; SEVENTEEN-HUNDBED

AND TWENTY-FIVE . "Watt , Lowndes , Bagford , the Bodleian , and British Museum Catalogues have been carefully searched , hut not a vestige of any one of these titles can be found . Nicholls ' s , Grainger , and the various dictionaries of . authors and printers hlexaminedbut

have been most thorougy , no traces have heen found of a Simeon Townshend or a Stephen Dilly . Thory , in his introduction to his Acta Latomorum expresses his doubt of the existence of such books . "We already know that , in the instance of the " Certayne Questions" and theso-called

, John Locke's , letter on them , said to be copied from the Bodleian , and printed ad nauseum in every history of Masonry , that some brother did forge a document which deceived Preston , but that there never has been —so the librarians say—any such letter or MS . in the Bodleian library . I grant it is much easier to

impose on persons , not used to old documents , by the fabrication of a manuscript , but what I am treating of are printed books—books that are said to be printed before the formation—or reconstruction—or any othep of

term the reader may choose—the Grand Lodge in 1717 . Nor must the present , or Anderson's , Book of Constitutions , be confounded with that quoted above—although both are dated in the year 1723 , when an edition of Desagulier ' s or Andersonthey both claimed ifc , and signed the preface—waa

printed , and is lying before me at this moment , and entitled , The Constitutions of the Freemasons . Containing the History , Charges , Regulations , Sfe ., of that most Ancient and Bight Wbrsldpful Fraternity . For the Use of the Lodges . So the identity of year of publicationalthough remarkablecannot be said to

, , refer to one and the same book . My query shall be a terse one . Has any brother ever seen , and if so where , a copy of the printed books I have numbered 1 , 2 , 3 ? Because it does not seem credible to me that every sheet of them should vanish and leave no trace behind . We swallow quite enough

nonsense in the lectures , but historical truth and accuracy demand a more correct version of the existence of those books which have , hitherto , escaped the inquiries of—MATTHEW COOKE .

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1865-03-25, Page 7” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 22 June 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_25031865/page/7/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CLASSICAL THEOLOGY.—LXXX. Article 1
GENERAL CHARGES. Article 2
THE GREEK LODGE ARETE AT CONSTANTINOPLE. Article 4
THE SEPULCHRE Of CHRIST. Article 5
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 7
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 10
Untitled Article 11
MASONIC MEMS. Article 11
THE BOYS' SCHOOL. Article 11
PROVINCIAL. Article 11
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 13
AMERICA. Article 13
NEW ZEALAND. Article 13
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. DRURY LANE THEATRE, Article 16
LITERARY EXTRACTS. Article 16
THE WEEK. Article 17
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

3 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

2 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

5 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

5 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

4 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 7

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Sepulchre Of Christ.

history and the topography are agreed . Returning to the south-west angle , and measuring 600 ft . north , we come to a second bridge or causeway . Up to that point the great " bevilled " masonry of Herod extends , but there it ceases . On this side , again , the history and topography are at one , and

thus two sides of the quadrangle are obtained . The other two , lying within the sacred inclosure , have not yet been investigated . The position of the great rock-cut reservoir in front of the Aksah , thewatercourses , as far as they have been examined , all accord with the indications of Josephus and the

Talmud . Everything tends to show that the Temple of Herod was , as Josephus tells us , 600 ft . square , and was situated in the south-western angle of the present Harem area . The rock , therefore , which now stands under the Dome of the Roch was certainly outside the area of the Temple , cot a

distance of 150 feet from its northern wall . A few words were devoted to showing that the supposition that the altar in the Temple was placed upon a rock is unsupported by any evidence or implication of the Bible , Josephus , or the Talmud , and is , in fact , a mere Mohammedan tradition . The remainder of the lecture was devoted to an

examination of the post-Christian evidence . The lecturer said that he had Sir H . Rawlinson ' s Arabic library examined by a competent Arabic scholar , who had extracted and translated all passages bearing on Jerusalem , the result being that , down to the time of Abd-el-Malik , and later , the limits of the Temple were well known to the Mohammedans , and that they neither built nor pretended to have built the structure now called the

ec Mosque of Omar . " "If , then , " concluded Mr . Eergusson , "the Dome of the Rock was not built by the Saracens , ifc must have been built by the Christians : there is no third party in the field who could have clone it . In that case , I would ask , ' What church did

Constantine or any other Christian priest or monarch build in Jerusalem over a great rock ¦ with one cave in it but the Church of the Holy Sepulchre ? ' Till this question is answered—and no attempt has yet been made to reply to it , or to supply its place with any-reasonable suggestion—¦

the arguments of my opponents halt . As I began let me conclude . I first took up the question on ai'chifcecfcural grounds ; I then examined it historically ; and lastly , I investigated it on the topographical ground I have this evening laid before you . Whichever path I attempted to pursueI

, always came back to the same point . I do not mean to say that the question is without difficulties , or the road without its ruts ancl roughnesses ; but I do assert that , so far as I can judge , an immense preponderance of evidence , from whatever point it is viewedis in favour of the conclusion that the

, building at Jerusalem known as the Dome of the Rock is the identical church which Constantine built over what he believed to be the Sepulchre of Christ . "

Masonic Notes And Queries.

MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES .

BIBLIOGRAPHIC AI ; QTTEEIES . Some writers have favoured us with the titles of the following works . The dates of publication are of vast importance , and , in order that there may be no mistake about them , instead of inserting them in figures I have done so in words : —

1 . A Short Analysis of the Unchanged Rites and Ceremonies of the Free-Masons . London , 8 yo . Printed for Steph . Billy . SIXTEEN-HTINDEED AND SEVENTY-SIX .

2 . Observations and Inquiries relating to the Brotherhood , of the Free-Masons , hy Simeon Townshend . 8 vo ., London . SEYENTEEN- HUNDBED AND TWELVE . 3 . The Constitutions of'the Fraternity of Free-ancl-Aeeeptei-llasonry . Wo sizeno lace of publication

, p mentioned , hut dates given thus : —SIXTEEN-HUNDBED AND EIGHTY-NINE ; SLXTEEN-HTJNDEED AND NINETY ; SEVENTEEN-HOTDEED AND ONE ; S EVENTEEN-HUNDEED AND TWENTY-THBEE ; SEVENTEEN-HUNDBED

AND TWENTY-FIVE . "Watt , Lowndes , Bagford , the Bodleian , and British Museum Catalogues have been carefully searched , hut not a vestige of any one of these titles can be found . Nicholls ' s , Grainger , and the various dictionaries of . authors and printers hlexaminedbut

have been most thorougy , no traces have heen found of a Simeon Townshend or a Stephen Dilly . Thory , in his introduction to his Acta Latomorum expresses his doubt of the existence of such books . "We already know that , in the instance of the " Certayne Questions" and theso-called

, John Locke's , letter on them , said to be copied from the Bodleian , and printed ad nauseum in every history of Masonry , that some brother did forge a document which deceived Preston , but that there never has been —so the librarians say—any such letter or MS . in the Bodleian library . I grant it is much easier to

impose on persons , not used to old documents , by the fabrication of a manuscript , but what I am treating of are printed books—books that are said to be printed before the formation—or reconstruction—or any othep of

term the reader may choose—the Grand Lodge in 1717 . Nor must the present , or Anderson's , Book of Constitutions , be confounded with that quoted above—although both are dated in the year 1723 , when an edition of Desagulier ' s or Andersonthey both claimed ifc , and signed the preface—waa

printed , and is lying before me at this moment , and entitled , The Constitutions of the Freemasons . Containing the History , Charges , Regulations , Sfe ., of that most Ancient and Bight Wbrsldpful Fraternity . For the Use of the Lodges . So the identity of year of publicationalthough remarkablecannot be said to

, , refer to one and the same book . My query shall be a terse one . Has any brother ever seen , and if so where , a copy of the printed books I have numbered 1 , 2 , 3 ? Because it does not seem credible to me that every sheet of them should vanish and leave no trace behind . We swallow quite enough

nonsense in the lectures , but historical truth and accuracy demand a more correct version of the existence of those books which have , hitherto , escaped the inquiries of—MATTHEW COOKE .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 6
  • You're on page7
  • 8
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy