Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Oct. 25, 1862
  • Page 11
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 25, 1862: Page 11

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 25, 1862
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE QUESTION OF CERTIFICATES. ← Page 2 of 2
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Question Of Certificates.

such a way that I could be present in time for the meeting . So after visiting the Exhibition , and taking there a hasty dinner , I proceeded to my hotel , and from thence to Great Queen-street again , where I came at the appointed hour , not a little tired by all the AA * alking I had done that day . I looked rather silly Avhen on my arrival at the hall I heard that , to join the brethren , I had

to mount all the staircases , the lodge being held in the roof . Well , thought I to myself , if in my country lodges are held on the first floor , every country has its own manners ; and , perhaps , in the Emulation Lodge astronomical lectures are given ; or it may be that its members meet so high , in order that they should be nearer to "heaven . So I took courage , Avalked up , and arrived at

the top of the staircase without accident , but rather out of breath . In the ante-room I found a brother , to Avhom I expressed my Avish to witness the proceedings . I handed him my card , which he returned to me , asking me at the same time if I could show my certificate . My answer was that I could not ; and , in ' act , I never , when visiting Belgium , France , or Germany , took any with me , my name being sufficiently known in these countries as that of a man who is accustomed to grant diplomas ,

and not to be asked to produce any himself . I showed , however , the apron and badge , being those of a P . G . S . W . and Grand Officer of the Grand Orient of the Netherlands . I mentioned your name and ray quality as your correspondent ; I declared myself ready to answer any questions that should be put to me about every degree of Masonry practised in England , from that of Apprentice

up to those of S . P . R . S ., Knight Templar or Knight of the Royal Order . Nothing would do ; ancl even my request that I should see the Master and Wardens of the lodge Avas not granted , to whom I could have shown such proofs of my nob being- an impostor as would hare convinced all reasonable men . I was told that even if my assertions were believed , the law ( I did not exactly

understand if it was tbe law by Avhich all English Masons are ruled , or one of the bye-laws of the lodge itself ) forbade them to admit anybody who could not shoAV his certificate , and so I was obliged to retire , and to look elsewhere how to spend the evening . My hope to enjoy a friendly and instructive meeting with English brethren so far , was frustrated ; but this was not totally the casetwo brethren from Manchester were in the same predicament as myself .

" Solamen miseris socios habuisse malormn . " So AVO left together , ancl , being in due number , Ave held a meeting ou a smaller scale . If our labours 'were not very important , and our refreshments of the simplest kind , the spirit of Masonry was with us , ancl it Avas not Avithout' having reaped some fruit from our mutual conversation that wo separated that night .

My story is told ; and if , 1 have thought it necessary to tell it , it is not to complain about the proceedings used against me , but simply to call the attention of ray brethren in England to the following question , which -arises from it . Is there any laiv or regulation , by which the want of a certificate bars the entrance of a lodto a visitorwho

ge , by pass-Avord , grip , and token , can prove himself a Mason , in conformity with the fundamental law of oiu- holy Order ? I think tho only reply can be in the negative . When a candidate is admitted , the Master of the lodge not only imparts to him the mysterious signs by which Ave know each other , but he also tells him that by these he will be recognised as a Mason the v . 'hole

world round , and be admitted where brethren meet : even more , he plainly proclaims him ( at least such is the case in the lodges on the continent where I have visited ) to be a brother Mason , and declares that every Mason on the whole surface of the world will be bound in future , to respect him as such ; but he does not toll him a word about a certificate . If a certificate is the required sine qua , non , I wonder why it still seems necessary to communicate to the

neophyte any pass-word or sign . The tokens to which Ave Avere learned to attach great importance are in future to be considered as useless forms , belonging to an obsolete state of things . The Emulation Lodge held a lodge of Instruction . Perhaps they Avent through the Masonic catechism ancl charges . I wonder if they found in these a " single word

about certificates . I question if Apnelius in his time , when Avishing to join a meeting of the initiated in the sacred mysteries , was ever sent back for Avant of a certificate . Of course I speak of the time Avhen he ivas restored to human shape , and no longer a golden ass ; although , heaven knows ! in onr clays golden asses have free entrance

every Avhere , even without a diploma . The chronicles of Masonry record several instances of prisoners' released , of soldiers saved from death , of shipwrecked travellers relieved , only by making themselves known as Masons . I wonder whether they did so by showing their certificates . I will grant that the modern iuA'ention of

certificates is , in some cases , of use to the bearer . When , for instance , a candidate , being on the point of starting for a foreign climate , has , therefore , been initiated , passed , and raised on the same clay , or in a very small compass of time , it is ten to one that his memory will but confusedly retain the different secrets imparted to him ; ancl in such case he would cut but a silly figure at the gate of a foreign lodge ; were ho not in possession of a

diploma . But for Masons of long standing , ' and Avho have iDersevered in their working , they have better proofs to show that they belong to the Order than any certificate . Nay , there is more ; a certificate is not always a proof that tbe bearer is a true Mason ; the certificate itself can be hut a worthless piece of parehment . There are spurious lodges everywhere . Wc have one

in our country . The candidates initiated in that unlawful body are not to be considered as Masons , not only on account of the irregularity of their admission , but also because nobody can tell if the real doctrine and the real secrets of our Order have been communicated to them . Well , that same unlawful body grants diplomas to its members . Suppose one of these members had presented

himself , certificate in hand , at the door of the Emulation Lodge on that same Friday night when I claimed admittance . Most likely the lodge , not being aware of tho fact I have stated , AVOUIC ! not have objected to the document produced by him ; and he , the false brother , would have been admitted , while I , the true Mason of forty years ' standing , would have been rejected .

As I said before , I leave the matter to the serious consideration of my English brethren , especially of such as are in authority . We live in days when passports everyAvhere have been , or soon will be , abolished . When even Governments haA'e learnt by experience that passports were a nuisance to travellers without answering to the purpose for which they were established , will the obsolete rule , " No admittance Avithout a passport" bo retained bv Masons aolne ? I am , clear Sir ancl Brother .

YOUR AMSTERDAM CORRESPONDENT . P . S . —A severe illness of a near relation of mine , and my absence for some time from home , caused my letter to remain in my desk unfinished till now . The matter ivas , happily , not one of urgency . [ We feel convinced there must haA * e been some error on the ] 3 art of the Tyler , who is new in his office . We

ourselves paid our first visit to the lodge , being then unknown , Avithout a certificate , and gained admission after being examined by Bro . John Hervey , P . G . D ., our certificate having been destroyed by fire in 184 * 2 , two years after our initiation . Foreign brethren without certificates have to our knowledge been admitted to Grand Lodge on giving other proofs of their being Masons , Bro . S . B . Wilson , P . G . D ., the talented Preceptor of the Emulation Lodge of Instruction , being generally selected to examine them . ]

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1862-10-25, Page 11” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 14 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_25101862/page/11/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
MY STARS AND GARTERS. Article 1
OUR MASONIC CONTEMPORARIES. Article 1
BRITISH ACHITECTS.—NEW MATERIALS FOR THEIR LIVES. Article 3
THE QUEEN'S CROSS, NORTHAMPTON* Article 5
PARIS OF TO-DAY. Article 8
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 9
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 10
THE QUESTION OF CERTIFICATES. Article 10
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 12
METROPOLITAN. Article 12
PROVINCIAL. Article 13
AUSTRALIA. Article 14
ROYAL ARCH. Article 16
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE. Article 16
MARK MASONRY. Article 17
Poetry. Article 18
Obituary. Article 18
THE WEEK. Article 18
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

2 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

3 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

3 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

2 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

3 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

3 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

3 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

3 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 11

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Question Of Certificates.

such a way that I could be present in time for the meeting . So after visiting the Exhibition , and taking there a hasty dinner , I proceeded to my hotel , and from thence to Great Queen-street again , where I came at the appointed hour , not a little tired by all the AA * alking I had done that day . I looked rather silly Avhen on my arrival at the hall I heard that , to join the brethren , I had

to mount all the staircases , the lodge being held in the roof . Well , thought I to myself , if in my country lodges are held on the first floor , every country has its own manners ; and , perhaps , in the Emulation Lodge astronomical lectures are given ; or it may be that its members meet so high , in order that they should be nearer to "heaven . So I took courage , Avalked up , and arrived at

the top of the staircase without accident , but rather out of breath . In the ante-room I found a brother , to Avhom I expressed my Avish to witness the proceedings . I handed him my card , which he returned to me , asking me at the same time if I could show my certificate . My answer was that I could not ; and , in ' act , I never , when visiting Belgium , France , or Germany , took any with me , my name being sufficiently known in these countries as that of a man who is accustomed to grant diplomas ,

and not to be asked to produce any himself . I showed , however , the apron and badge , being those of a P . G . S . W . and Grand Officer of the Grand Orient of the Netherlands . I mentioned your name and ray quality as your correspondent ; I declared myself ready to answer any questions that should be put to me about every degree of Masonry practised in England , from that of Apprentice

up to those of S . P . R . S ., Knight Templar or Knight of the Royal Order . Nothing would do ; ancl even my request that I should see the Master and Wardens of the lodge Avas not granted , to whom I could have shown such proofs of my nob being- an impostor as would hare convinced all reasonable men . I was told that even if my assertions were believed , the law ( I did not exactly

understand if it was tbe law by Avhich all English Masons are ruled , or one of the bye-laws of the lodge itself ) forbade them to admit anybody who could not shoAV his certificate , and so I was obliged to retire , and to look elsewhere how to spend the evening . My hope to enjoy a friendly and instructive meeting with English brethren so far , was frustrated ; but this was not totally the casetwo brethren from Manchester were in the same predicament as myself .

" Solamen miseris socios habuisse malormn . " So AVO left together , ancl , being in due number , Ave held a meeting ou a smaller scale . If our labours 'were not very important , and our refreshments of the simplest kind , the spirit of Masonry was with us , ancl it Avas not Avithout' having reaped some fruit from our mutual conversation that wo separated that night .

My story is told ; and if , 1 have thought it necessary to tell it , it is not to complain about the proceedings used against me , but simply to call the attention of ray brethren in England to the following question , which -arises from it . Is there any laiv or regulation , by which the want of a certificate bars the entrance of a lodto a visitorwho

ge , by pass-Avord , grip , and token , can prove himself a Mason , in conformity with the fundamental law of oiu- holy Order ? I think tho only reply can be in the negative . When a candidate is admitted , the Master of the lodge not only imparts to him the mysterious signs by which Ave know each other , but he also tells him that by these he will be recognised as a Mason the v . 'hole

world round , and be admitted where brethren meet : even more , he plainly proclaims him ( at least such is the case in the lodges on the continent where I have visited ) to be a brother Mason , and declares that every Mason on the whole surface of the world will be bound in future , to respect him as such ; but he does not toll him a word about a certificate . If a certificate is the required sine qua , non , I wonder why it still seems necessary to communicate to the

neophyte any pass-word or sign . The tokens to which Ave Avere learned to attach great importance are in future to be considered as useless forms , belonging to an obsolete state of things . The Emulation Lodge held a lodge of Instruction . Perhaps they Avent through the Masonic catechism ancl charges . I wonder if they found in these a " single word

about certificates . I question if Apnelius in his time , when Avishing to join a meeting of the initiated in the sacred mysteries , was ever sent back for Avant of a certificate . Of course I speak of the time Avhen he ivas restored to human shape , and no longer a golden ass ; although , heaven knows ! in onr clays golden asses have free entrance

every Avhere , even without a diploma . The chronicles of Masonry record several instances of prisoners' released , of soldiers saved from death , of shipwrecked travellers relieved , only by making themselves known as Masons . I wonder whether they did so by showing their certificates . I will grant that the modern iuA'ention of

certificates is , in some cases , of use to the bearer . When , for instance , a candidate , being on the point of starting for a foreign climate , has , therefore , been initiated , passed , and raised on the same clay , or in a very small compass of time , it is ten to one that his memory will but confusedly retain the different secrets imparted to him ; ancl in such case he would cut but a silly figure at the gate of a foreign lodge ; were ho not in possession of a

diploma . But for Masons of long standing , ' and Avho have iDersevered in their working , they have better proofs to show that they belong to the Order than any certificate . Nay , there is more ; a certificate is not always a proof that tbe bearer is a true Mason ; the certificate itself can be hut a worthless piece of parehment . There are spurious lodges everywhere . Wc have one

in our country . The candidates initiated in that unlawful body are not to be considered as Masons , not only on account of the irregularity of their admission , but also because nobody can tell if the real doctrine and the real secrets of our Order have been communicated to them . Well , that same unlawful body grants diplomas to its members . Suppose one of these members had presented

himself , certificate in hand , at the door of the Emulation Lodge on that same Friday night when I claimed admittance . Most likely the lodge , not being aware of tho fact I have stated , AVOUIC ! not have objected to the document produced by him ; and he , the false brother , would have been admitted , while I , the true Mason of forty years ' standing , would have been rejected .

As I said before , I leave the matter to the serious consideration of my English brethren , especially of such as are in authority . We live in days when passports everyAvhere have been , or soon will be , abolished . When even Governments haA'e learnt by experience that passports were a nuisance to travellers without answering to the purpose for which they were established , will the obsolete rule , " No admittance Avithout a passport" bo retained bv Masons aolne ? I am , clear Sir ancl Brother .

YOUR AMSTERDAM CORRESPONDENT . P . S . —A severe illness of a near relation of mine , and my absence for some time from home , caused my letter to remain in my desk unfinished till now . The matter ivas , happily , not one of urgency . [ We feel convinced there must haA * e been some error on the ] 3 art of the Tyler , who is new in his office . We

ourselves paid our first visit to the lodge , being then unknown , Avithout a certificate , and gained admission after being examined by Bro . John Hervey , P . G . D ., our certificate having been destroyed by fire in 184 * 2 , two years after our initiation . Foreign brethren without certificates have to our knowledge been admitted to Grand Lodge on giving other proofs of their being Masons , Bro . S . B . Wilson , P . G . D ., the talented Preceptor of the Emulation Lodge of Instruction , being generally selected to examine them . ]

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 10
  • You're on page11
  • 12
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy