Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Masonic Observer
  • Sept. 20, 1858
  • Page 23
  • Correspondence.
Current:

The Masonic Observer, Sept. 20, 1858: Page 23

  • Back to The Masonic Observer, Sept. 20, 1858
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article Correspondence. Page 1 of 2 →
Page 23

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

Correspondence .

To the Editor . Sir and Brother , —I perceive in the Magazine for September 1 st an article written in solemn tones of warning and advice to the Masonic Observer . With Bottom , the Editor may say . " I grant you , my friends , if that you should fright the Dais out of their wits , they would have no more discretion but to hang us ; but I will aggravate my voice so , that I will roar you as gently as any

sucking dove ; I will roar you an 'twere any nightingale . " Midsummer Night ' s Dream . I am sure you must receive the ohidings of your contemporary with all due respect and humility . The writer of the article can point with an air of unctuous satisfaction to the columns of the Magazine for its uniform consistency , its gentle , courteous tones , its inflexible adherence to refinement of language and absence of

personality ; and if practical proof of this were necessary , -1 would quote the following felicitous paragraph from the number published in December , 1855 : — " Not get an answer from the G . Secretary ' s Office , quotha 1 Bah ! as well get the G . M . to attend upon any public Masonic occasion , except indeed , the nomination to office of some Whig protege is mooted , then indeed , he is punctual . The presence of our excellent Brother DoMe , with Ms sound practical

head , and talents for business , has been the shield of Ajax over and over again , behind which the incapalles , Lord Zetland , Brother White , and Co ., have been glad to cower . Their dulness it is which lias lost ns Canada , and for wliich the West Indies is already threatening severance—let the system go on , and the development of llasonry will shortly be reduced to Wo individuals , the placeman and the toady ; whilst the G . L . will , in all probability , be removed to Newmarket , the only place whence no plea operates to withhold our G . M . '' —Magazine , Dec , 1855 ,

Here is choice phraseology!—so elegant indeed , that I search in vain the columns of your journal for a parallel passage . I turn to the opening article in the Magazine , of the date first mentioned , and there I find the writer , whilst bewailing the faults and warning the Masonic Observer , betrays " an umble , " Heep-like penitential tone , quite edifying to minds independent . I admire consistency and I cannot tolerate expediency and miserable compromises ;

a bold and truthful policy will ever command the sympathy of the honest and fearless . The Magazine has achieved a great , a sublime consistency—vindicated a great principle—it has , to use a not very elegant expression of Lord Castlereagh ' s , "turned its back upon itself , " and should henceforth inscribe on its title-page , as its legitimate motto , its own epithet , "The Placeman and The Toady . "—I am , Sir and Brother , yours truly , PLUM .

To tfte Editor . Sir and Brother , —The M . W . G . M ., in open G . L ., made an attack on the Masonic Observer at the last Quarterly Communication . His lordship says that political feeling has , in no respect , guided him in his choice of G . Officers , and appeals to his appointments in confirmation of the fact . This was unfortunate , because the enquiry has

very often been enforced upon one , why certain noblemen , and others , were appointed to high positions , notoriously unfitted by their habits and knowledge of the Craft , to fill them . As an illustration of what I mean , take the appointment of Bro . the Earl of Durham to the G . S . W . ' s chair . His lordship at the time he was so promoted was not only unfitted by reason of his inexperience and the slender services he had rendered to the Craft , but he was not legally qualified , according to the Book of Constitutions , to fill the post ; and yet

the G . M . selected and placed him over the heads of men distinguished by their ability , zeal , unwearied application , and signal services to the Craft . And wherefore ? By what principle is the G . M . guided in his appointments ? If the exalted position of a G . O . of England be a reward for distinguished services to the Order , as in theory it is , where , when , and how , had the noble Bro . performed these services ? This is by no means a solitary instance of the nepotism and striking

unfairness which prevails in the bestowal of the honours of G . L I am not prepared to say that the M . W . G . M . is biassed by political feeling , but I should be better satisfied that such is not the case , by a more practical manifestation of his impartiality than his lordship ' s "indignant denial . " Sir , the feeling in the country ( and it is not confined to the country ) by no means acquits Lord Zetland of the charge alleged against him , nor will the Brethren generally

acquiesce in the policy of his lordship and the Dais , until fresh vigour , energy , and disinterestedness be more conspicuous in its development . It occurred to me and many others , that this speech of the G . M . was a clap-trap , a mere vapouring in order to divert the minds of Brethren from those important subjects which many Brethren bring forward and urge with so much ability , and such inconvenient pertinacity . —I am , Sir and Brother , Yours fraternally , ' BLUE APRON .

To the Editor . Dear Sir and Brother , —What are our friend Warren and the Magazine about ? Have they jumped JIM CROW ? Bath ; September , 1858 .

To the Editor .

Sir and Brother , —I was irresistibly reminded in G . L . of the wellknown instruction whispered into the ear of a counsel whose canse was breaking down , — "Abuse the plaintiff ' s attorney . " You certainly received enough of that article : but still facts are facts ; and the fact remains , which since the G . M ' s . denial of political motives , is perfectly inexplicable , that the last and present D , G . M .,

the last and present G . Wardens , are all Whigs . Since it is the case that noble Brethren are not excluded on account of their politics the only alternative is this , that they are excluded because of the independence of their course in G . L ., which is as bad a reason as the other , and entitles the excluded to the sympathy and support of every independent Mason . It has been alleged by the . clique , that there is in G . L . a faction

determined on opposition to the Executive for opposition ' s sake ; and the following funny reason is given for the statement : that the late Executive only , ie . poor old White , were responsible for Canadian mismanagement , and that things are now so well conducted by the gallant Clarke and his shadow , that there is no room for anything to he desired . But unfortunately the G . M . was proved by the investigations of the Board of General Purposes , to have had the Canadian

memorial in his own possession for months , which indeed his lordshi p avowed and justified : and next , the last act of our pattern Executive , has been to write two letters to Bro . Harington , so vulgar in their tone , and slang in their expression ( to say nothing of their wretched grammar ) , as to he taken by him as a personal insult , and involve our whole relations with Canada to a worse extent than ever , which was probably their object . Doubtless our worthies think to escape in the dust and confusion of the scrimmage that is likely to ensue ; but the English Craft will be strangely forgetful of their responsibility in the

“The Masonic Observer: 1858-09-20, Page 23” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 12 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mob/issues/mob_20091858/page/23/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 1
Untitled Article 2
Untitled Article 3
Untitled Article 4
Untitled Article 5
Untitled Article 6
Untitled Article 7
GRAND LODGE. Article 7
The Colonies. Article 10
Untitled Article 11
Untitled Article 11
Untitled Article 14
UNION IN NEW YORK. Article 14
NEW BRUNSWICK. Article 14
NEW ZEALAND. Article 15
AUSTRALIA.-VICTORIA. Article 15
Mark Masonry. Article 16
Masonic Charities. Article 17
The Provinces. Article 19
Untitled Article 22
Correspondence. Article 23
Untitled Article 24
Untitled Article 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Ad 24
Untitled Article 24
Untitled Article 24
Page 1

Page 1

2 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

2 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

3 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

2 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

4 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

3 Articles
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

2 Articles
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

2 Articles
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

2 Articles
Page 23

Page 23

1 Article
Page 24

Page 24

9 Articles
Page 23

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Correspondence.

Correspondence .

To the Editor . Sir and Brother , —I perceive in the Magazine for September 1 st an article written in solemn tones of warning and advice to the Masonic Observer . With Bottom , the Editor may say . " I grant you , my friends , if that you should fright the Dais out of their wits , they would have no more discretion but to hang us ; but I will aggravate my voice so , that I will roar you as gently as any

sucking dove ; I will roar you an 'twere any nightingale . " Midsummer Night ' s Dream . I am sure you must receive the ohidings of your contemporary with all due respect and humility . The writer of the article can point with an air of unctuous satisfaction to the columns of the Magazine for its uniform consistency , its gentle , courteous tones , its inflexible adherence to refinement of language and absence of

personality ; and if practical proof of this were necessary , -1 would quote the following felicitous paragraph from the number published in December , 1855 : — " Not get an answer from the G . Secretary ' s Office , quotha 1 Bah ! as well get the G . M . to attend upon any public Masonic occasion , except indeed , the nomination to office of some Whig protege is mooted , then indeed , he is punctual . The presence of our excellent Brother DoMe , with Ms sound practical

head , and talents for business , has been the shield of Ajax over and over again , behind which the incapalles , Lord Zetland , Brother White , and Co ., have been glad to cower . Their dulness it is which lias lost ns Canada , and for wliich the West Indies is already threatening severance—let the system go on , and the development of llasonry will shortly be reduced to Wo individuals , the placeman and the toady ; whilst the G . L . will , in all probability , be removed to Newmarket , the only place whence no plea operates to withhold our G . M . '' —Magazine , Dec , 1855 ,

Here is choice phraseology!—so elegant indeed , that I search in vain the columns of your journal for a parallel passage . I turn to the opening article in the Magazine , of the date first mentioned , and there I find the writer , whilst bewailing the faults and warning the Masonic Observer , betrays " an umble , " Heep-like penitential tone , quite edifying to minds independent . I admire consistency and I cannot tolerate expediency and miserable compromises ;

a bold and truthful policy will ever command the sympathy of the honest and fearless . The Magazine has achieved a great , a sublime consistency—vindicated a great principle—it has , to use a not very elegant expression of Lord Castlereagh ' s , "turned its back upon itself , " and should henceforth inscribe on its title-page , as its legitimate motto , its own epithet , "The Placeman and The Toady . "—I am , Sir and Brother , yours truly , PLUM .

To tfte Editor . Sir and Brother , —The M . W . G . M ., in open G . L ., made an attack on the Masonic Observer at the last Quarterly Communication . His lordship says that political feeling has , in no respect , guided him in his choice of G . Officers , and appeals to his appointments in confirmation of the fact . This was unfortunate , because the enquiry has

very often been enforced upon one , why certain noblemen , and others , were appointed to high positions , notoriously unfitted by their habits and knowledge of the Craft , to fill them . As an illustration of what I mean , take the appointment of Bro . the Earl of Durham to the G . S . W . ' s chair . His lordship at the time he was so promoted was not only unfitted by reason of his inexperience and the slender services he had rendered to the Craft , but he was not legally qualified , according to the Book of Constitutions , to fill the post ; and yet

the G . M . selected and placed him over the heads of men distinguished by their ability , zeal , unwearied application , and signal services to the Craft . And wherefore ? By what principle is the G . M . guided in his appointments ? If the exalted position of a G . O . of England be a reward for distinguished services to the Order , as in theory it is , where , when , and how , had the noble Bro . performed these services ? This is by no means a solitary instance of the nepotism and striking

unfairness which prevails in the bestowal of the honours of G . L I am not prepared to say that the M . W . G . M . is biassed by political feeling , but I should be better satisfied that such is not the case , by a more practical manifestation of his impartiality than his lordship ' s "indignant denial . " Sir , the feeling in the country ( and it is not confined to the country ) by no means acquits Lord Zetland of the charge alleged against him , nor will the Brethren generally

acquiesce in the policy of his lordship and the Dais , until fresh vigour , energy , and disinterestedness be more conspicuous in its development . It occurred to me and many others , that this speech of the G . M . was a clap-trap , a mere vapouring in order to divert the minds of Brethren from those important subjects which many Brethren bring forward and urge with so much ability , and such inconvenient pertinacity . —I am , Sir and Brother , Yours fraternally , ' BLUE APRON .

To the Editor . Dear Sir and Brother , —What are our friend Warren and the Magazine about ? Have they jumped JIM CROW ? Bath ; September , 1858 .

To the Editor .

Sir and Brother , —I was irresistibly reminded in G . L . of the wellknown instruction whispered into the ear of a counsel whose canse was breaking down , — "Abuse the plaintiff ' s attorney . " You certainly received enough of that article : but still facts are facts ; and the fact remains , which since the G . M ' s . denial of political motives , is perfectly inexplicable , that the last and present D , G . M .,

the last and present G . Wardens , are all Whigs . Since it is the case that noble Brethren are not excluded on account of their politics the only alternative is this , that they are excluded because of the independence of their course in G . L ., which is as bad a reason as the other , and entitles the excluded to the sympathy and support of every independent Mason . It has been alleged by the . clique , that there is in G . L . a faction

determined on opposition to the Executive for opposition ' s sake ; and the following funny reason is given for the statement : that the late Executive only , ie . poor old White , were responsible for Canadian mismanagement , and that things are now so well conducted by the gallant Clarke and his shadow , that there is no room for anything to he desired . But unfortunately the G . M . was proved by the investigations of the Board of General Purposes , to have had the Canadian

memorial in his own possession for months , which indeed his lordshi p avowed and justified : and next , the last act of our pattern Executive , has been to write two letters to Bro . Harington , so vulgar in their tone , and slang in their expression ( to say nothing of their wretched grammar ) , as to he taken by him as a personal insult , and involve our whole relations with Canada to a worse extent than ever , which was probably their object . Doubtless our worthies think to escape in the dust and confusion of the scrimmage that is likely to ensue ; but the English Craft will be strangely forgetful of their responsibility in the

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 22
  • You're on page23
  • 24
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy