Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • May 19, 1860
  • Page 2
  • THE MORGAN MYSTERY;
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 19, 1860: Page 2

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, May 19, 1860
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article THE ROYAL ARCH. ← Page 2 of 2
    Article THE MORGAN MYSTERY; Page 1 of 2 →
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Royal Arch.

Chapters at work , and how many of them are lying dormant , if not absolutely extinct ; and the distance which , in such districts as Cornwall and Derbyshire , for instance , separates the Chapters from the Lodges .

The Morgan Mystery;

THE MORGAN MYSTERY ;

ITS CA . USE AND EFFECT . To contend with prejudice and struggle against opinions which ignorance and superstition have sanctioned , requires time , patience , and magnanimity . For a confirmation of this statement we might refer to a history of the world . Many prejudices and persecutions are got up for particular purposes—they vise as hubbies on the ocean of life and

are quickly overwhelmed in its waves ; particular circumstances give them existence , and when these causes cease to exist , they go into the same gulf of oblivion as countless exploded tenets and opinions have gone before them , and are thought of no more , or only with a smile of compassion at the weakness of human nature which permits some cunning

minds to sway tho reason aud opinions of their fellow men for their private interests , in order that they may strut their brief hour on the stage of life . No more remarkable instance of this can be produced than tho excitement which was raised by the so called abduction and murder of William Morgan .

Tho circumstances of the case were as follows . In the year 1775 or 1776 William Morgan Avas born at Culpepper , Virginia , U . S . A . Of his early life little is known . B y his partisans he has been extolled as a man of virtuous habits and principles ; on the other hand , lie has been represented as a pirate in the Gulf of Mexico , and also one of the

celebrated liver pirates of the Mississippi ; his friends state that he was a captain in the American army ; he says himself that he was a private soldier in the army and nothing more . The next place AVC hoar of him was Rochester , whence he removed to the village of Batavia , Genesee county , New York state . By trade Morgan , was an operative mason ; he is said to have been a man of quick intelligence , acute

observation , and some education , and was thus enabled to pass as a sort of oracle among the lower classes of loungers in the jireciucts of village inns . " Indeed , " says Stone , one of his partisans , " his indolence and his habits were such as very naturally to throw him into the associations of such a circle . Although not exactly a common drunkard , to be which , according to certain legal decisions in . this stateit is required

, that a man must be in a state of intoxication more than half the time , still he was continually mingling ' hot rebellious liquors with his blood . ' His nights and sometimes his days also Aveve spent at tippling houses ; while occasionall y , to the still greater neglect of his family , he joined in the drunken carousals of the vilest and most worthless of men .

His disposition was envious , malicious , and vindictive , as I am assured -by a very estimable and pious man of Genesee county , in whose veracity I have the fullest confidence , and in whoso employ Morgan was at one period engaged . " ( Stone , Letters on Masonry , xi . ) Such I have reason to believe is a fair description of tlie character of William Morgan .

While residing at Le Roy , near Rochester , ho became intimately associated with Major James Gannon , on whoso vouchment Morgan was exalted to the degree of a Royal Arch Mason , hut it is affirmed that the brethren could never ascertain in what Lodge he commenced his Masonic career . In tho year I 82 G a few Royal Arch Masons of

Batavia , whore Morgan now resided , determined to apply to the Grand Chapter of the state for a Charter to constitute a Chapter in that village . By some means or other tlie petition was presented to Morgan , which he readily signed ; but his character was now so well understood , and his habits so had , that his association was not desired among tho original promoters of -the object , consequently the fh-rit petition with Morgan ' s name attached , was destroyed , and a now oim

quietly set on foot , by which the charter was gained . Hinc illce . lachrymal . Morgan was IAOAV not a member of the Chapter , nor could he become so without the unanimous consent of the companions , which could not be obtained . Filled with rage and envy , he sought revenge . At that time there also resided at Batavia a Colonel David C . Millertlie editor of a village paper ; he was a man of

respect-, able talents , but of irreligious character , great laxity of moral principle and of intemperate habits . His conduct had alienated his best friends , and a rival neAvspaper had just been started by his old political associates , hence he Avas in great pecuniary and political depression . Miller had many years previously been admitted an Entered Apprentice at Albany ,

and this Avas all he knew of Masonry . A similarity of tastes and habits made Morgan and Miller very intimate ; tliese two then determined to publish what they called "the Secrets of Masonry , " by which they hoped to enrich and at the same time revenge themselves upon their brother Masons . The intended publication was publicly announced , hut little attention was paid to it ; the more respectable portion of the fraternity gave no heed to it ; others thought it some

catchpenny claptrap . The confederates then , for the purpose of drawing more attention to their work , which must otherwise prove ruinous to them , inserted advertisements and articles in different papers , written by themselves but as if by the Masonic party , abusing Morgan and Miller , and cautioning the public against giving any credence to the forthcoming publication . Through this pretended paper Avar some

little attention Avas drawn towards it ; this , however , was not sufficient , and in order to increase the excitement rumours Avere spread that the Freemasons would not alloAv the publication of the work , but would even resort to force to obtain the papers alleged to have been compiled . To give colour to this , the printing office of Miller Avas set fire to , but

having friends ready it Avas promptly extinguished . Morgan in his wanderings had contracted debts in various places , and his creditors had from time to time , as they could trace him , employed the law against him to recover their money ; this circumstance Miller proclaimed as persecution on the part of the Masons , whereas on tbe contrary , several times Morgan was rescued from the clutches of the law by some Masons coming forward and paying the claim brought against him .

On the morning of the 11 th September , 1826 , Morgan was arrested by a constable named Haywood , on a charge of potty larceny . Morgan made no objection to go with him , and breakfasted with the officer and his associates . He then voluntarily entered the carriage with Haywood , which was to convey him to Canandaigua . On arriving at Le Roy , Morgan was told by Haywood that if he chose he miht go

g before the magistrate who had endorsed the Avarrant , and he discharged on giving bail for his appearance to answer the charge at the next term of the general sessions of the peace for Ontario ; but he said he preferred going on to Canandaigua , where lie was taken before Justice Chapman , examined and dischargedhaving beonde fended by a

Freema-, son named Loton Lawson . He was immediately again arrested for debt at the suit of Aaron Ackley , a tavern keeper in Canandaigua , and having no money was committed to gaol . On the evening of the 12 th September , through the good offices of Lawson , who provided the money to liquidate the debtMorgan was releasedand went off arm in arm with

, , Lawson "in a friendly manner . " And now comes the mysterious part of the matter . Mrs . Hall , the wife of the gaoler , stated that having let out Morgan and Lawson , while closing the gates she heard the cry of murder , and looking out saw Morgan , Lawson , and another man struggling , while Sawyer and Cheeseboro were standing quietly by looking on .

That shortly afterwards a carriage drove by empty and immediatel y returned full of men . It was a bri ght moonlight night , so that she could swear to the carriage , ifec . ; but it does not appear that she ever swore as to the persons ill

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1860-05-19, Page 2” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 6 July 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/mmr_19051860/page/2/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE ROYAL ARCH. Article 1
THE MORGAN MYSTERY; Article 2
THE ORIGIN OF FREEMASONRY. Article 3
MASONRY IN AMERICA. Article 4
MASONRY, OPERATIVE. Article 5
THE MYSTERIES OF THE GREAT UNIVERSE OF GOD. Article 5
ARCHÆOLOGY. Article 6
MASONIC NOTES AND QUERIES. Article 6
Literature. Article 8
ERNEST II. Article 11
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 12
BLACKBALLED CANDIDATES. Article 12
VISITORS' CERTIFICATES: ALMONER OF LODGES. Article 12
ROYAL ARCH FEES. Article 12
SERVING BRETHREN. Article 13
AN IMPOSTOR. Article 13
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 14
METROPOLITAN. Article 14
PROVINCIAL. Article 16
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR. Article 17
COLONIAL. Article 18
Obituary. Article 18
THE WEEK. Article 18
PUBLIC AMUSEMENTS. Article 20
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 20
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

2 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

2 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

4 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

4 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

3 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

3 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

2 Articles
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

5 Articles
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

3 Articles
Page 2

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

The Royal Arch.

Chapters at work , and how many of them are lying dormant , if not absolutely extinct ; and the distance which , in such districts as Cornwall and Derbyshire , for instance , separates the Chapters from the Lodges .

The Morgan Mystery;

THE MORGAN MYSTERY ;

ITS CA . USE AND EFFECT . To contend with prejudice and struggle against opinions which ignorance and superstition have sanctioned , requires time , patience , and magnanimity . For a confirmation of this statement we might refer to a history of the world . Many prejudices and persecutions are got up for particular purposes—they vise as hubbies on the ocean of life and

are quickly overwhelmed in its waves ; particular circumstances give them existence , and when these causes cease to exist , they go into the same gulf of oblivion as countless exploded tenets and opinions have gone before them , and are thought of no more , or only with a smile of compassion at the weakness of human nature which permits some cunning

minds to sway tho reason aud opinions of their fellow men for their private interests , in order that they may strut their brief hour on the stage of life . No more remarkable instance of this can be produced than tho excitement which was raised by the so called abduction and murder of William Morgan .

Tho circumstances of the case were as follows . In the year 1775 or 1776 William Morgan Avas born at Culpepper , Virginia , U . S . A . Of his early life little is known . B y his partisans he has been extolled as a man of virtuous habits and principles ; on the other hand , lie has been represented as a pirate in the Gulf of Mexico , and also one of the

celebrated liver pirates of the Mississippi ; his friends state that he was a captain in the American army ; he says himself that he was a private soldier in the army and nothing more . The next place AVC hoar of him was Rochester , whence he removed to the village of Batavia , Genesee county , New York state . By trade Morgan , was an operative mason ; he is said to have been a man of quick intelligence , acute

observation , and some education , and was thus enabled to pass as a sort of oracle among the lower classes of loungers in the jireciucts of village inns . " Indeed , " says Stone , one of his partisans , " his indolence and his habits were such as very naturally to throw him into the associations of such a circle . Although not exactly a common drunkard , to be which , according to certain legal decisions in . this stateit is required

, that a man must be in a state of intoxication more than half the time , still he was continually mingling ' hot rebellious liquors with his blood . ' His nights and sometimes his days also Aveve spent at tippling houses ; while occasionall y , to the still greater neglect of his family , he joined in the drunken carousals of the vilest and most worthless of men .

His disposition was envious , malicious , and vindictive , as I am assured -by a very estimable and pious man of Genesee county , in whose veracity I have the fullest confidence , and in whoso employ Morgan was at one period engaged . " ( Stone , Letters on Masonry , xi . ) Such I have reason to believe is a fair description of tlie character of William Morgan .

While residing at Le Roy , near Rochester , ho became intimately associated with Major James Gannon , on whoso vouchment Morgan was exalted to the degree of a Royal Arch Mason , hut it is affirmed that the brethren could never ascertain in what Lodge he commenced his Masonic career . In tho year I 82 G a few Royal Arch Masons of

Batavia , whore Morgan now resided , determined to apply to the Grand Chapter of the state for a Charter to constitute a Chapter in that village . By some means or other tlie petition was presented to Morgan , which he readily signed ; but his character was now so well understood , and his habits so had , that his association was not desired among tho original promoters of -the object , consequently the fh-rit petition with Morgan ' s name attached , was destroyed , and a now oim

quietly set on foot , by which the charter was gained . Hinc illce . lachrymal . Morgan was IAOAV not a member of the Chapter , nor could he become so without the unanimous consent of the companions , which could not be obtained . Filled with rage and envy , he sought revenge . At that time there also resided at Batavia a Colonel David C . Millertlie editor of a village paper ; he was a man of

respect-, able talents , but of irreligious character , great laxity of moral principle and of intemperate habits . His conduct had alienated his best friends , and a rival neAvspaper had just been started by his old political associates , hence he Avas in great pecuniary and political depression . Miller had many years previously been admitted an Entered Apprentice at Albany ,

and this Avas all he knew of Masonry . A similarity of tastes and habits made Morgan and Miller very intimate ; tliese two then determined to publish what they called "the Secrets of Masonry , " by which they hoped to enrich and at the same time revenge themselves upon their brother Masons . The intended publication was publicly announced , hut little attention was paid to it ; the more respectable portion of the fraternity gave no heed to it ; others thought it some

catchpenny claptrap . The confederates then , for the purpose of drawing more attention to their work , which must otherwise prove ruinous to them , inserted advertisements and articles in different papers , written by themselves but as if by the Masonic party , abusing Morgan and Miller , and cautioning the public against giving any credence to the forthcoming publication . Through this pretended paper Avar some

little attention Avas drawn towards it ; this , however , was not sufficient , and in order to increase the excitement rumours Avere spread that the Freemasons would not alloAv the publication of the work , but would even resort to force to obtain the papers alleged to have been compiled . To give colour to this , the printing office of Miller Avas set fire to , but

having friends ready it Avas promptly extinguished . Morgan in his wanderings had contracted debts in various places , and his creditors had from time to time , as they could trace him , employed the law against him to recover their money ; this circumstance Miller proclaimed as persecution on the part of the Masons , whereas on tbe contrary , several times Morgan was rescued from the clutches of the law by some Masons coming forward and paying the claim brought against him .

On the morning of the 11 th September , 1826 , Morgan was arrested by a constable named Haywood , on a charge of potty larceny . Morgan made no objection to go with him , and breakfasted with the officer and his associates . He then voluntarily entered the carriage with Haywood , which was to convey him to Canandaigua . On arriving at Le Roy , Morgan was told by Haywood that if he chose he miht go

g before the magistrate who had endorsed the Avarrant , and he discharged on giving bail for his appearance to answer the charge at the next term of the general sessions of the peace for Ontario ; but he said he preferred going on to Canandaigua , where lie was taken before Justice Chapman , examined and dischargedhaving beonde fended by a

Freema-, son named Loton Lawson . He was immediately again arrested for debt at the suit of Aaron Ackley , a tavern keeper in Canandaigua , and having no money was committed to gaol . On the evening of the 12 th September , through the good offices of Lawson , who provided the money to liquidate the debtMorgan was releasedand went off arm in arm with

, , Lawson "in a friendly manner . " And now comes the mysterious part of the matter . Mrs . Hall , the wife of the gaoler , stated that having let out Morgan and Lawson , while closing the gates she heard the cry of murder , and looking out saw Morgan , Lawson , and another man struggling , while Sawyer and Cheeseboro were standing quietly by looking on .

That shortly afterwards a carriage drove by empty and immediatel y returned full of men . It was a bri ght moonlight night , so that she could swear to the carriage , ifec . ; but it does not appear that she ever swore as to the persons ill

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • You're on page2
  • 3
  • 20
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy