Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemason
  • Feb. 9, 1878
  • Page 10
  • ALL SERENE.
Current:

The Freemason, Feb. 9, 1878: Page 10

  • Back to The Freemason, Feb. 9, 1878
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article TO OUR READERS. Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article Answers to Correspondents. Page 1 of 1
    Article ALL SERENE. Page 1 of 1
    Article Untitled Page 1 of 1
    Article BRO. HUBERT AND FRENCH FREEMASONRY. Page 1 of 1
    Article ALL SERENE. Page 1 of 1
    Article ALL SERENE. Page 1 of 1
    Article GRANTS TO OUR CHARITIES Page 1 of 1
    Article THE PRESENT POSITION OF THE FRENCH GRAND ORIENT. Page 1 of 1
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

To Our Readers.

TO OUR READERS .

The FREEMASON is a Weekly Newspaper , price ad . It is published every Friday morning , and contains the most important , interesting , and useful information relating to Freemasonry in every degree . Subscription , including postage : United America , India , India , China , & rc

Kingdom , the Continent , & c . Via Brindrsr . Twelve Months ios . 6 d . t 2 s . od . 17 s . 4 d . Six „ 3 s . 3 d . 6 s . 6 d . 8 s . 8 d . Three „ 2 s . 8 d . 3 s . 3 d . 4 s . 6 d . Subscriptions may be paid for in stamps , but Post Office Orders or Cheques arc preferred , the former payable to

GEORGE KENNING , CHIEF OFFICE , LONDON , the latter crossed London and Joint Stock Bank . Advertisements and other business communications should be addressed to the Publisher . Communications on literary subjects and books for review are to be forwarded to the Editor . Anonymous correspondence will be wholly disregarded , and the return of rejected MSS . cannot be guaranteed . Further information will be supplied o ^ application to the Publisher , 198 , Fleet-street , London .

Ar01001

NOTICE . To prevent delay or miscarriage , it is particularly requested that ALL communications for the FREEMASON , may be addressed to the Office , 19 8 , Fleet-street , London .

Ar01002

IMPORTANT NOTICE . COLONIAL and FOREIGN SUBSCRIBERS are informed that acknowledgments of remittances received are published in the first number of every month .

It is very necessary for our readers to advise us of all money orders they remit , more especially those from the United States of America and India ; otherwise we cannot tell where to credit them .

ADVERTISEMENTS to ensure insertion in current week ' s rssue should reach the Office , 198 , Fleet-street , by 12 o ' clock on "Wednesdays .

Ar01003

TO ADVERTISERS . The FPEEMASON has a large circulation in all parts of the Globe , its advantages as an advertising medium can herefore scarcely be overrated .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

Bro . Chirnside s letter in our next . BOOKS Sec , RECEIVED . "European Mail , " "Hull Packet , " "Medical Examiner , " "Broad Arrow , " "Catalogue of Books in the Library ofthe Supreme Council 33 , " ' -The Westminster Papers , " " La Voz de Hiram , " "East Anglian Hand book . " " La Chaine

d'Union , " "Risorgimento , " "The Freemasons Repository , " " Masonic Jewel , " " Keystone , " "Great Industries of Great Britian , " " Sunday Times , " " Proceedings of thc Grand Lodge of Scotland , " " Dcbrett ' s House of Commons , and the Judicial Bench , 18 7 8 , " "The Freemason ' s Kalendar and Directory for the Province of North Wales and Shropshire , 1878 . "

All Serene.

ALL SERENE .

[ The charge is 2 s . 6 d . for announcements , not exceeding four lines , under this heading . } BIRTHS . MAIIHIOTT . —On the ist inst ., at Foulden-road , Stoke Newington , thc wife of E . D . Marriott , of a son . Wooi ) . —On the 29 th ult ., at Banff , thc wife of G . Wood , Esq ., of a daughter .

MARRIAGE . BOYD—BROWN . —On the 31 st ult ., at Edinburgh , Robert Mitchell , son of S . Boyd " , Esq ., late of Sydney , N . S . W ., to Eliza Agnes , daughter of the late W . C . Brown , Esq .

DEATHS . CRITIKSIIANK . —On the ist inst ., at 7 . 20 p . m ., at his residence , 263 , Hampstcad-road , N . W ., George Cruikshank , artist , in thc 86 th year of his age , beloved and respected by all who knew him . Friends will please kindly accept this intimation . KELI . Y . —On the 25 th ult ., the Rev . George Fiuroy Kelly ,

M . A ., LL . D ., of Pembroke Dock , South Wales , aged KYNASTON . —On the 31 st ult ., at Ventnor , \\ . Kynaston , of Gresham-street and Russcll-squarc . agcd 51 . LEWIS . —On the 4 th inst ., at 118 , Houndsditch , E . G .,

Abraham Lewis , aged 3 8 years , deeply lamented by his family and numerous friends . American and Continental papers please copy . SnCRY . —On the 27 th ult ., Wm . Shury , of Mylaiid , Colchester , after two years' intense suffering . His whole soul was in Freemasonry up to his last moment .

Ar01011

TheFreemason, SATURDAY , FEBRUARY 9 , 1878 .

Bro. Hubert And French Freemasonry.

BRO . HUBERT AND FRENCH FREEMASONRY .

Bro . Hubert , who is well known as the Editor of the Chaine d'Union , an independent and important French Masonic serial , and which is a credit to French Freemasonry , has , by refusing the unanimous election to the chair of the lodge he has served

so well for years , openly protested against the revolution recently effected by the French Grand Orient . For his refusal is based simply on his unwillingness to follow the majority of the French Grand Orient into the " Caudine Forks" of revolution , and his fears as to the future . This is

a very important step in itself , and one which may have important consequences for French Freemasonry . This announcement serves as a very striking commentary on the somewhat rash declaration of our esteemed Bro . Thevenot , which appeared in our columns the previous week .

Knowing how great a discontent exists in French Freemasonry at the recent most unwise and uncalled for change , though we always prefer to let people speak for themselves , we were perfectly convinced that thc letter of Bro . Thcvenot must have but one result in France . Bro . Hubert voted

against the change , and , like an honest man and true Mason as lie is , finding he cannot any longer conscientiously go with the Grand Orient of France in its downward course , and in the discredit which is coming on French Freemasonry , he very wisely , in our opinion , openly

and manfully says so , and declines the high honour offered to him by . ' lis brethren . If anything can open the eyes of the ruling party in the French Grand Orient to the gulf which is opening out before French Freemasonry this fact ought to do so , but we fear that at this moment ,

elate in the victory they have gained over the "indiiTerentism'' of too many in French Freemasonry , nothing will induce them to pause in their ill-omened career , much less to think where they are , and where they are going to . Bro . Marchal , of the Lodge St . Jean de Jerusalem , Nancy , has

also resigned the chair of the lodge , and the lodge itself only remains in obedience to the Grand Orient on the condition that the ritual of French Freemasonry is not to be interfered with . Everyone will , therefore , feel the greatest anxiety for tho future position of French Freemasonry .

We say all this with much regret , but we feet it to be our duty to say as much and to hold out the hand of brotherhood to the good Bros . Hubert , Marchal , Lechaut , Behr , and the 76 who so gallantly upheld the " good old cause " in the French Grand Orient .

All Serene.

ALL SERENE .

How very remarkable is the present position of English Freemasonry . Those of us who commenced Masonic life in England , say thirty years ago , must be struck with the onward progress , the rapid advance , of our Masonic phalanx . We can recall , many of us , less prosperous days . We can remember slovenly work ,

neglected aesthetics , the prevailing association of a " House of Call , " the difficulty of finding sometimes a " quorum" to carry on the needful necessary work even of that famous old lodge . Now all is happily changed , and for the better . We may have other evils coming upon us , but we cannot comnlain either of the work or attendance

of our brethren . Masonic ceremonial and Masonic ornamentation have latterly received befitting attention , and though much room still exists for further desirable changes in the latter respect , yet we do not despair of seeing ourselves a happy further amelioration of lodge life and

work in many particulars . As it is , week by week the Craft is pushing on , new lodges are formed and forming , and brethren exhibit a vitality , an interest , and a zeal in things Masonic , which makes some of us old-boys Masons

almost say with a sigh , " Ah , mihi prarteritos si referet Jupiter annos . " " Would I were young again to take my part in the good work of my lodge , and to meet pleasant faces , and sympathize with warm hearts as in happy days ofjold . "

All Serene.

But thus it cannot be ; old age is upon some of us , with benumbing powers , and weakened frames , and all we can do is to wish our old Craft " God Speed , " to offer our "hearty good wishes" to the lodge , and to leave the prestige and the personality of

Freemasonry to the "young uns . " May they care as much for the Brotherhood as we really did in our " little day . " Two " points " seem to demand our attention . One is still more attention to the aesthetic adornment and the "locale " of our lodges , the other

is , more economy in our " commissariat" arrangments , and rather larger offerings on the part of lodges to Masonic Charity . We know the difficulties attendant on both these points , and which are neither trifling or unreal , but we think it well to call the attention of our good

brethren to them , as it seems to be a groat pity to have any " spots " in our "feasts of charity , " as it would greatly strengthen lodge life and Masonic prestige , if our balance-sheets couldamply demonstrate more than they often do , that our professions and practice were properly squared ?

Grants To Our Charities

GRANTS TO OUR CHARITIES

All companions will rejoice to note that our esteemed and zealous Bro . Col . Creaton , always gallantly to " the fore " in every good work of Frcemasonrv , has given notice on behalf of the Committee of General Purposes of Grand Chapter of a vote of £ 2000 to our

three great Metropolitan' Chanties . We hig hly commend the idea and the notice , and think that ail will concur in the expediency of such a resolution . We trust that it will be carried unanimousl y , as we feel sure that no

better use can be made of the money , which is not clearly wanted for any ordinary purposes of the Grand Chapter . Since we wiote this the Grand Chapter has , with happy unanimity , voted thus very wise and desirable grant .

The Present Position Of The French Grand Orient.

THE PRESENT POSITION OF THE FRENCH GRAND ORIENT .

Dear Bro . Kenning , — As I have twice pointed out in the Freemason , the present alarming position of Preerr asonry is as alarming as well it can be . Bro . Thevenot ' s assurance , recently published in your columns , that no French brother is dissatisfied with the decision ol the Grand Orient is entirelv

overthrown by the march of events . Alreaay Bro . Hubert refuses to be re-elected W . M . of one of the leading lodges in Paris , Bro . Marchal leaves the chair at Nancy , and your readers perused Bro . Lechaut ' s letter in your last number . And how , then , about the future' What is the minority

conscientious , intelligent and important , to do ? Curiously enough , the French Grand Orient has furnished the weapons itself for a dissenting minority . Tn its recognition of the coloured Grand Lodge , for instance , itjaid down this axiom , that a lawful charter is a

sufficent qualification . I have always said that such a view is erroneous , as proceeding on two false assumptions—first , that a charter can give any more rights than it professes to grant j and , secondly , that a dormant charter , once dormant , cannot be . revived except by the action

of the original grantor . The grantee cannot revive it except with the approval of the grantor . But the Grand Orient of France has decided differently , and the dissident French Masons can appeal to it as their ground of action . Thus , on this assertion of Masonic law , thev can

revive any charter of a lodge granted by the old Grand Lodge of France , or the Grand Orient itself , before the Union , and it may be a very serious question whether by this grave innovation the concordat of the old Grand Lodge of France and the Grand Orient is not

dissolved . I am simply arguing as a French Freemason now on the " dicta " of the Grand Orient itself—and I leave out of the case "pour le moment , " the heavy blow inflicted by the recent decision of the French Grand Orient on French

Freemasonry , and the legal position ofthe French Grand Orient itself . Under the circumstances of the case , in my humble opinion French Freemasons will have a right to revive dormant charters and to reconstitute the Grand Lodge of France on these two grounds , first , that the French Grand

“The Freemason: 1878-02-09, Page 10” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 10 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fvl/issues/fvl_09021878/page/10/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
CONTENTS. Article 1
REPORTS OF MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 1
Royal Arch. Article 4
Mark Masonry. Article 4
Knights Templar. Article 4
Ancient and Accepted Rite. Article 4
SUPREME GRAND CHAPTER. Article 5
GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND. Article 5
Public Amusements. Article 5
THE ROYAL VISIT TO DORSET. Article 6
Masonic and General Tidings. Article 6
THE GIRLS' SCHOOL. Article 7
Original Correspondents. Article 7
THE INSTALLATION ENGRAVING. Article 7
PINE'S LIST OF LODGES A.D. 1729. Article 7
CONSECRATION OF ST. JOHN'S MARK LODGE No 214. Article 8
A NICE QUESTION. Article 8
THE GRAND ORIENT OF FRANCE. Article 8
PRESENTATION TO A LIVERPOOL BROTHER. Article 8
THE "CLEOPATRA NEEDLE IN LONDON. Article 9
Reviews. Article 9
NOTES ON ART, &c. Article 9
TO OUR READERS. Article 10
Untitled Article 10
Untitled Article 10
Untitled Article 10
Answers to Correspondents. Article 10
ALL SERENE. Article 10
Untitled Article 10
BRO. HUBERT AND FRENCH FREEMASONRY. Article 10
ALL SERENE. Article 10
GRANTS TO OUR CHARITIES Article 10
THE PRESENT POSITION OF THE FRENCH GRAND ORIENT. Article 10
FREEMASONRY IN NEW ZEALAND. (Continued from Page 68). Article 11
MASONIC BALL AT HALIFAX. Article 12
ROYAL MASONIC INSTITUTION FOR BOYS. Article 12
Multum in Parbo, or Masonic Notes and Queries. Article 12
METROPOLITAN MASONIC MEETINGS. Article 12
MASONIC MEETINGS IN WEST LANCASHIRE AND CHESHIRE. Article 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 13
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Untitled Ad 14
Page 1

Page 1

4 Articles
Page 2

Page 2

3 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

3 Articles
Page 4

Page 4

7 Articles
Page 5

Page 5

5 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

3 Articles
Page 7

Page 7

7 Articles
Page 8

Page 8

7 Articles
Page 9

Page 9

5 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

12 Articles
Page 11

Page 11

3 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

6 Articles
Page 13

Page 13

8 Articles
Page 14

Page 14

19 Articles
Page 10

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

To Our Readers.

TO OUR READERS .

The FREEMASON is a Weekly Newspaper , price ad . It is published every Friday morning , and contains the most important , interesting , and useful information relating to Freemasonry in every degree . Subscription , including postage : United America , India , India , China , & rc

Kingdom , the Continent , & c . Via Brindrsr . Twelve Months ios . 6 d . t 2 s . od . 17 s . 4 d . Six „ 3 s . 3 d . 6 s . 6 d . 8 s . 8 d . Three „ 2 s . 8 d . 3 s . 3 d . 4 s . 6 d . Subscriptions may be paid for in stamps , but Post Office Orders or Cheques arc preferred , the former payable to

GEORGE KENNING , CHIEF OFFICE , LONDON , the latter crossed London and Joint Stock Bank . Advertisements and other business communications should be addressed to the Publisher . Communications on literary subjects and books for review are to be forwarded to the Editor . Anonymous correspondence will be wholly disregarded , and the return of rejected MSS . cannot be guaranteed . Further information will be supplied o ^ application to the Publisher , 198 , Fleet-street , London .

Ar01001

NOTICE . To prevent delay or miscarriage , it is particularly requested that ALL communications for the FREEMASON , may be addressed to the Office , 19 8 , Fleet-street , London .

Ar01002

IMPORTANT NOTICE . COLONIAL and FOREIGN SUBSCRIBERS are informed that acknowledgments of remittances received are published in the first number of every month .

It is very necessary for our readers to advise us of all money orders they remit , more especially those from the United States of America and India ; otherwise we cannot tell where to credit them .

ADVERTISEMENTS to ensure insertion in current week ' s rssue should reach the Office , 198 , Fleet-street , by 12 o ' clock on "Wednesdays .

Ar01003

TO ADVERTISERS . The FPEEMASON has a large circulation in all parts of the Globe , its advantages as an advertising medium can herefore scarcely be overrated .

Answers To Correspondents.

Answers to Correspondents .

Bro . Chirnside s letter in our next . BOOKS Sec , RECEIVED . "European Mail , " "Hull Packet , " "Medical Examiner , " "Broad Arrow , " "Catalogue of Books in the Library ofthe Supreme Council 33 , " ' -The Westminster Papers , " " La Voz de Hiram , " "East Anglian Hand book . " " La Chaine

d'Union , " "Risorgimento , " "The Freemasons Repository , " " Masonic Jewel , " " Keystone , " "Great Industries of Great Britian , " " Sunday Times , " " Proceedings of thc Grand Lodge of Scotland , " " Dcbrett ' s House of Commons , and the Judicial Bench , 18 7 8 , " "The Freemason ' s Kalendar and Directory for the Province of North Wales and Shropshire , 1878 . "

All Serene.

ALL SERENE .

[ The charge is 2 s . 6 d . for announcements , not exceeding four lines , under this heading . } BIRTHS . MAIIHIOTT . —On the ist inst ., at Foulden-road , Stoke Newington , thc wife of E . D . Marriott , of a son . Wooi ) . —On the 29 th ult ., at Banff , thc wife of G . Wood , Esq ., of a daughter .

MARRIAGE . BOYD—BROWN . —On the 31 st ult ., at Edinburgh , Robert Mitchell , son of S . Boyd " , Esq ., late of Sydney , N . S . W ., to Eliza Agnes , daughter of the late W . C . Brown , Esq .

DEATHS . CRITIKSIIANK . —On the ist inst ., at 7 . 20 p . m ., at his residence , 263 , Hampstcad-road , N . W ., George Cruikshank , artist , in thc 86 th year of his age , beloved and respected by all who knew him . Friends will please kindly accept this intimation . KELI . Y . —On the 25 th ult ., the Rev . George Fiuroy Kelly ,

M . A ., LL . D ., of Pembroke Dock , South Wales , aged KYNASTON . —On the 31 st ult ., at Ventnor , \\ . Kynaston , of Gresham-street and Russcll-squarc . agcd 51 . LEWIS . —On the 4 th inst ., at 118 , Houndsditch , E . G .,

Abraham Lewis , aged 3 8 years , deeply lamented by his family and numerous friends . American and Continental papers please copy . SnCRY . —On the 27 th ult ., Wm . Shury , of Mylaiid , Colchester , after two years' intense suffering . His whole soul was in Freemasonry up to his last moment .

Ar01011

TheFreemason, SATURDAY , FEBRUARY 9 , 1878 .

Bro. Hubert And French Freemasonry.

BRO . HUBERT AND FRENCH FREEMASONRY .

Bro . Hubert , who is well known as the Editor of the Chaine d'Union , an independent and important French Masonic serial , and which is a credit to French Freemasonry , has , by refusing the unanimous election to the chair of the lodge he has served

so well for years , openly protested against the revolution recently effected by the French Grand Orient . For his refusal is based simply on his unwillingness to follow the majority of the French Grand Orient into the " Caudine Forks" of revolution , and his fears as to the future . This is

a very important step in itself , and one which may have important consequences for French Freemasonry . This announcement serves as a very striking commentary on the somewhat rash declaration of our esteemed Bro . Thevenot , which appeared in our columns the previous week .

Knowing how great a discontent exists in French Freemasonry at the recent most unwise and uncalled for change , though we always prefer to let people speak for themselves , we were perfectly convinced that thc letter of Bro . Thcvenot must have but one result in France . Bro . Hubert voted

against the change , and , like an honest man and true Mason as lie is , finding he cannot any longer conscientiously go with the Grand Orient of France in its downward course , and in the discredit which is coming on French Freemasonry , he very wisely , in our opinion , openly

and manfully says so , and declines the high honour offered to him by . ' lis brethren . If anything can open the eyes of the ruling party in the French Grand Orient to the gulf which is opening out before French Freemasonry this fact ought to do so , but we fear that at this moment ,

elate in the victory they have gained over the "indiiTerentism'' of too many in French Freemasonry , nothing will induce them to pause in their ill-omened career , much less to think where they are , and where they are going to . Bro . Marchal , of the Lodge St . Jean de Jerusalem , Nancy , has

also resigned the chair of the lodge , and the lodge itself only remains in obedience to the Grand Orient on the condition that the ritual of French Freemasonry is not to be interfered with . Everyone will , therefore , feel the greatest anxiety for tho future position of French Freemasonry .

We say all this with much regret , but we feet it to be our duty to say as much and to hold out the hand of brotherhood to the good Bros . Hubert , Marchal , Lechaut , Behr , and the 76 who so gallantly upheld the " good old cause " in the French Grand Orient .

All Serene.

ALL SERENE .

How very remarkable is the present position of English Freemasonry . Those of us who commenced Masonic life in England , say thirty years ago , must be struck with the onward progress , the rapid advance , of our Masonic phalanx . We can recall , many of us , less prosperous days . We can remember slovenly work ,

neglected aesthetics , the prevailing association of a " House of Call , " the difficulty of finding sometimes a " quorum" to carry on the needful necessary work even of that famous old lodge . Now all is happily changed , and for the better . We may have other evils coming upon us , but we cannot comnlain either of the work or attendance

of our brethren . Masonic ceremonial and Masonic ornamentation have latterly received befitting attention , and though much room still exists for further desirable changes in the latter respect , yet we do not despair of seeing ourselves a happy further amelioration of lodge life and

work in many particulars . As it is , week by week the Craft is pushing on , new lodges are formed and forming , and brethren exhibit a vitality , an interest , and a zeal in things Masonic , which makes some of us old-boys Masons

almost say with a sigh , " Ah , mihi prarteritos si referet Jupiter annos . " " Would I were young again to take my part in the good work of my lodge , and to meet pleasant faces , and sympathize with warm hearts as in happy days ofjold . "

All Serene.

But thus it cannot be ; old age is upon some of us , with benumbing powers , and weakened frames , and all we can do is to wish our old Craft " God Speed , " to offer our "hearty good wishes" to the lodge , and to leave the prestige and the personality of

Freemasonry to the "young uns . " May they care as much for the Brotherhood as we really did in our " little day . " Two " points " seem to demand our attention . One is still more attention to the aesthetic adornment and the "locale " of our lodges , the other

is , more economy in our " commissariat" arrangments , and rather larger offerings on the part of lodges to Masonic Charity . We know the difficulties attendant on both these points , and which are neither trifling or unreal , but we think it well to call the attention of our good

brethren to them , as it seems to be a groat pity to have any " spots " in our "feasts of charity , " as it would greatly strengthen lodge life and Masonic prestige , if our balance-sheets couldamply demonstrate more than they often do , that our professions and practice were properly squared ?

Grants To Our Charities

GRANTS TO OUR CHARITIES

All companions will rejoice to note that our esteemed and zealous Bro . Col . Creaton , always gallantly to " the fore " in every good work of Frcemasonrv , has given notice on behalf of the Committee of General Purposes of Grand Chapter of a vote of £ 2000 to our

three great Metropolitan' Chanties . We hig hly commend the idea and the notice , and think that ail will concur in the expediency of such a resolution . We trust that it will be carried unanimousl y , as we feel sure that no

better use can be made of the money , which is not clearly wanted for any ordinary purposes of the Grand Chapter . Since we wiote this the Grand Chapter has , with happy unanimity , voted thus very wise and desirable grant .

The Present Position Of The French Grand Orient.

THE PRESENT POSITION OF THE FRENCH GRAND ORIENT .

Dear Bro . Kenning , — As I have twice pointed out in the Freemason , the present alarming position of Preerr asonry is as alarming as well it can be . Bro . Thevenot ' s assurance , recently published in your columns , that no French brother is dissatisfied with the decision ol the Grand Orient is entirelv

overthrown by the march of events . Alreaay Bro . Hubert refuses to be re-elected W . M . of one of the leading lodges in Paris , Bro . Marchal leaves the chair at Nancy , and your readers perused Bro . Lechaut ' s letter in your last number . And how , then , about the future' What is the minority

conscientious , intelligent and important , to do ? Curiously enough , the French Grand Orient has furnished the weapons itself for a dissenting minority . Tn its recognition of the coloured Grand Lodge , for instance , itjaid down this axiom , that a lawful charter is a

sufficent qualification . I have always said that such a view is erroneous , as proceeding on two false assumptions—first , that a charter can give any more rights than it professes to grant j and , secondly , that a dormant charter , once dormant , cannot be . revived except by the action

of the original grantor . The grantee cannot revive it except with the approval of the grantor . But the Grand Orient of France has decided differently , and the dissident French Masons can appeal to it as their ground of action . Thus , on this assertion of Masonic law , thev can

revive any charter of a lodge granted by the old Grand Lodge of France , or the Grand Orient itself , before the Union , and it may be a very serious question whether by this grave innovation the concordat of the old Grand Lodge of France and the Grand Orient is not

dissolved . I am simply arguing as a French Freemason now on the " dicta " of the Grand Orient itself—and I leave out of the case "pour le moment , " the heavy blow inflicted by the recent decision of the French Grand Orient on French

Freemasonry , and the legal position ofthe French Grand Orient itself . Under the circumstances of the case , in my humble opinion French Freemasons will have a right to revive dormant charters and to reconstitute the Grand Lodge of France on these two grounds , first , that the French Grand

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 9
  • You're on page10
  • 11
  • 14
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy