Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Quarterly Review
  • Dec. 31, 1849
  • Page 47
  • TO THE EDITOR.
Current:

The Freemasons' Quarterly Review, Dec. 31, 1849: Page 47

  • Back to The Freemasons' Quarterly Review, Dec. 31, 1849
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article TO THE EDITOR. ← Page 3 of 3
Page 47

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

To The Editor.

the hands of a few . Rule 19 is— "That one-half only of the sum to be granted in annuities shall be assigned to widows of brethren from lodges in the London district . " One-third would be a much more just and equitable proportion . The provinces already think that the Board of Benevolence distribute too large a portion of their funds in the London district . The rate of subscriptions as compared with the privileges attachedis much too low . The scale adopted in the Girls' charity is

, far preferable . Rule 32 is absurdly liberal . It was amusing to hear some of the brethren , high , aye , very high in rank , who had done their best to stifle the infant institution in its birth , now promise to rear the bantling with the utmost care . Kind creatures 1 they find that Charity has prevailed , and think to gain credit for swimming with the stream . Fudge 1 we will watch their movements . The concluding debate was one of overwhelming interest : one

difficult to touch upon , but still of too vital an importance to be entirely passed over . Bro . Scarborough , in moving for a " Committee to investigate whether any and what alterations can be made in the ceremonies of the three degrees , " although he did not let out much of his plan , told quite enough to mahe it evident that his views are most dangerous and destructive . The Grand Registrar opposed the measure in terms most just and forcible . Truly did he say , that if Bro . Scarborough ' s views

were carried , we should no longer be members of that body of Masons , known throughout the whole world by the same marks , bound together by the same ties . We should be repudiated , go where we would , as nothing better than the other spurious offsets of Freemasonry . We should destroy the -universality which had been adopted in all ages and in all countries . Although Bro . Scarborough ' s motion was negatived by an overwhelming majority , there being only some half dozen hands

held up for it ; yet let us keep a watchful eye upon him , for he threatens to take the field again . Here I would gladly lay down my pen ; but the conduct of the M . W . G . M . during this important debate was of a most extraordinary nature . Many and strong were the expressions of censure to be heard in various parts of the hall , as soon as G . Lodge was closed . In expressing his own willingness to grant the Committee , the G . M . made a most

unwarrantable use of a deceased Grand Master ' s name . Towards the close of the evening , he made a Quixotic attack upon the " Freemasons ' Quarterly Review , " as a highly improper publication , which had already been denounced by Grand Lodge . Most chivalrous Grand Master ! if your predecessor , with all the prestige of royalty to aid him , could not suppress the " Review " in its early days , think not that your aweinspiring dignity and overwhelming eloquence can achieve the task . No ! the Craft know too well the value of the information it contains , and

dare you to the enterprise . And to conclude , the brethren were called on to pledge themselves not to disclose any of the proceedings of the evening . Of course numbers made the sign ; but I observed many who did not . The call was an insult to Grand Lodge . No brother would improperly disclose what ought to be kept secret ; but much takes place in that building , the knowledge of which , without the walls , is not only harmless , but beneficial . In fact , the call was nothing more nor less than an indirect attempt to stop the " Freemasons' Quarterly Review . " I am , yours fraternally , PHILO-MASONIOUS .

“The Freemasons' Quarterly Review: 1849-12-31, Page 47” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 29 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/fqr/issues/fqr_31121849/page/47/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
THE FREEMASONS' QUARTERLY REVIEW, AND GENERAL ASSURANCE ADVOCATE. Article 1
TO THE CRAFT. Article 2
THE GRAND LODGE AND THE GRAND MASTER. Article 2
MASONIC CHARGE, Article 5
ON FREEMASONRY. THE FIRST POINT IK THE P... Article 9
EDITORIAL PRÆCOGNITION. Article 9
THE FIRST POINT IN THE PYTHAGOREAN TRIANGLE EXPLAINED. Article 14
FREEMASONRY AND THE SPANISH INQUISITION. Article 20
MASONRY IN SCOTLAND.—No. 2. Article 24
ARE NOT AUTHORS GENERALLY FREEMASONS ? Article 29
ANECDOTAL. Article 32
THE PORTRAIT GALLERY.—No. 4. Article 33
BROTHER GEORGE PETER DE RHE PHILIPE, P. G. S. B Article 35
BROTHER PETER THOMSON, P. G. D. Article 36
BROTHER STEPHEN BARTON WILSON, P. M. Article 39
THE R. W. BROTHER H. R. LEWIS, P. G. M., SUMATRA. Article 40
THE MONK AND THE RABBI. Article 42
RIZPAH, THE DAUGHTER OF AIAH, OR WOMAN'S DEVOTEDNESS. Article 43
TO ITHURIEL. Article 44
TO THE EDITOR. Article 45
TO THE EDITOR. Article 48
TO THE EDITOR. Article 49
TO THE EDITOR. Article 49
TO THE EDITOR. Article 50
POETRY. Article 51
ON A TEAR. Article 51
TO THE MEMORY OF BRO. JOHN WILSON, THE VOCALIST. . Article 52
SCRIBBLING PAPERS, Article 53
CHIT CHAT. Article 54
Obituary. Article 57
MASONIC INTELLIGENCE. Article 61
THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND Article 62
SUPREME GRAND COUNCIL 33°. Article 63
THE CHARITIES. Article 63
THE REPORTER. Article 64
PROVINCIAL. Article 71
SCOTLAND. Article 87
IRELAND. Article 93
FOREIGN. Article 94
AMERICA.—UNITED STATES. Article 96
INDIA. Article 96
THE GENERAL ASSURANCE ADVOCATE. Article 103
MEDICAL REFEREES. Article 109
INSTITUTE OF ACTUARIES. Article 109
LITERARY NOTICES. Article 111
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 113
VALEDICTORY SONNET. Article 114
INDEX. Article 115
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

2 Articles
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

2 Articles
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

2 Articles
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

1 Article
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

2 Articles
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

1 Article
Page 23

Page 23

1 Article
Page 24

Page 24

2 Articles
Page 25

Page 25

1 Article
Page 26

Page 26

1 Article
Page 27

Page 27

1 Article
Page 28

Page 28

1 Article
Page 29

Page 29

2 Articles
Page 30

Page 30

1 Article
Page 31

Page 31

1 Article
Page 32

Page 32

2 Articles
Page 33

Page 33

1 Article
Page 34

Page 34

1 Article
Page 35

Page 35

1 Article
Page 36

Page 36

2 Articles
Page 37

Page 37

1 Article
Page 38

Page 38

1 Article
Page 39

Page 39

1 Article
Page 40

Page 40

2 Articles
Page 41

Page 41

1 Article
Page 42

Page 42

2 Articles
Page 43

Page 43

2 Articles
Page 44

Page 44

2 Articles
Page 45

Page 45

2 Articles
Page 46

Page 46

1 Article
Page 47

Page 47

1 Article
Page 48

Page 48

1 Article
Page 49

Page 49

2 Articles
Page 50

Page 50

1 Article
Page 51

Page 51

2 Articles
Page 52

Page 52

1 Article
Page 53

Page 53

1 Article
Page 54

Page 54

1 Article
Page 55

Page 55

1 Article
Page 56

Page 56

1 Article
Page 57

Page 57

2 Articles
Page 58

Page 58

1 Article
Page 59

Page 59

1 Article
Page 60

Page 60

1 Article
Page 61

Page 61

2 Articles
Page 62

Page 62

2 Articles
Page 63

Page 63

2 Articles
Page 64

Page 64

2 Articles
Page 65

Page 65

1 Article
Page 66

Page 66

1 Article
Page 67

Page 67

1 Article
Page 68

Page 68

1 Article
Page 69

Page 69

1 Article
Page 70

Page 70

1 Article
Page 71

Page 71

1 Article
Page 72

Page 72

1 Article
Page 73

Page 73

1 Article
Page 74

Page 74

1 Article
Page 75

Page 75

1 Article
Page 76

Page 76

1 Article
Page 77

Page 77

1 Article
Page 78

Page 78

1 Article
Page 79

Page 79

1 Article
Page 80

Page 80

1 Article
Page 81

Page 81

1 Article
Page 82

Page 82

1 Article
Page 83

Page 83

1 Article
Page 84

Page 84

1 Article
Page 85

Page 85

1 Article
Page 86

Page 86

1 Article
Page 87

Page 87

1 Article
Page 88

Page 88

1 Article
Page 89

Page 89

1 Article
Page 90

Page 90

1 Article
Page 91

Page 91

1 Article
Page 92

Page 92

1 Article
Page 93

Page 93

2 Articles
Page 94

Page 94

2 Articles
Page 95

Page 95

1 Article
Page 96

Page 96

2 Articles
Page 97

Page 97

1 Article
Page 98

Page 98

1 Article
Page 99

Page 99

1 Article
Page 100

Page 100

1 Article
Page 101

Page 101

1 Article
Page 102

Page 102

1 Article
Page 103

Page 103

1 Article
Page 104

Page 104

1 Article
Page 105

Page 105

1 Article
Page 106

Page 106

1 Article
Page 107

Page 107

1 Article
Page 108

Page 108

1 Article
Page 109

Page 109

3 Articles
Page 110

Page 110

1 Article
Page 111

Page 111

1 Article
Page 112

Page 112

1 Article
Page 113

Page 113

1 Article
Page 114

Page 114

1 Article
Page 115

Page 115

1 Article
Page 116

Page 116

1 Article
Page 47

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

To The Editor.

the hands of a few . Rule 19 is— "That one-half only of the sum to be granted in annuities shall be assigned to widows of brethren from lodges in the London district . " One-third would be a much more just and equitable proportion . The provinces already think that the Board of Benevolence distribute too large a portion of their funds in the London district . The rate of subscriptions as compared with the privileges attachedis much too low . The scale adopted in the Girls' charity is

, far preferable . Rule 32 is absurdly liberal . It was amusing to hear some of the brethren , high , aye , very high in rank , who had done their best to stifle the infant institution in its birth , now promise to rear the bantling with the utmost care . Kind creatures 1 they find that Charity has prevailed , and think to gain credit for swimming with the stream . Fudge 1 we will watch their movements . The concluding debate was one of overwhelming interest : one

difficult to touch upon , but still of too vital an importance to be entirely passed over . Bro . Scarborough , in moving for a " Committee to investigate whether any and what alterations can be made in the ceremonies of the three degrees , " although he did not let out much of his plan , told quite enough to mahe it evident that his views are most dangerous and destructive . The Grand Registrar opposed the measure in terms most just and forcible . Truly did he say , that if Bro . Scarborough ' s views

were carried , we should no longer be members of that body of Masons , known throughout the whole world by the same marks , bound together by the same ties . We should be repudiated , go where we would , as nothing better than the other spurious offsets of Freemasonry . We should destroy the -universality which had been adopted in all ages and in all countries . Although Bro . Scarborough ' s motion was negatived by an overwhelming majority , there being only some half dozen hands

held up for it ; yet let us keep a watchful eye upon him , for he threatens to take the field again . Here I would gladly lay down my pen ; but the conduct of the M . W . G . M . during this important debate was of a most extraordinary nature . Many and strong were the expressions of censure to be heard in various parts of the hall , as soon as G . Lodge was closed . In expressing his own willingness to grant the Committee , the G . M . made a most

unwarrantable use of a deceased Grand Master ' s name . Towards the close of the evening , he made a Quixotic attack upon the " Freemasons ' Quarterly Review , " as a highly improper publication , which had already been denounced by Grand Lodge . Most chivalrous Grand Master ! if your predecessor , with all the prestige of royalty to aid him , could not suppress the " Review " in its early days , think not that your aweinspiring dignity and overwhelming eloquence can achieve the task . No ! the Craft know too well the value of the information it contains , and

dare you to the enterprise . And to conclude , the brethren were called on to pledge themselves not to disclose any of the proceedings of the evening . Of course numbers made the sign ; but I observed many who did not . The call was an insult to Grand Lodge . No brother would improperly disclose what ought to be kept secret ; but much takes place in that building , the knowledge of which , without the walls , is not only harmless , but beneficial . In fact , the call was nothing more nor less than an indirect attempt to stop the " Freemasons' Quarterly Review . " I am , yours fraternally , PHILO-MASONIOUS .

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 46
  • You're on page47
  • 48
  • 116
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy