Skip to main content
Museum of Freemasonry

Masonic Periodicals Online

  • Explore
  • Advanced Search
  • Home
  • Explore
  • The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine
  • Oct. 1, 1858
  • Page 29
Current:

The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 1, 1858: Page 29

  • Back to The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine, Oct. 1, 1858
  • Print image
  • Articles/Ads
    Article OOMESPOTOENCE. ← Page 5 of 6 →
Page 29

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Oomespotoence.

of misstatements made by him , must be an entire stranger among us ; and certainly common courtesy ought to have dictated to him that he should thoroughly become acquainted with the truth of what he asserted , before publishing it forth to the world . Besides , in my opinion he violates his O . B .

in publishing to the world the private business of the Carleton Chapter , without- ' permission . He states that in the city of St . John " there is also a spurious Mark Lodge ; many members , when they are initiated , and find out that it is surreptitious , refuse to again enter its portals . The Master is William W . Smith . " An answer to this falsehood I will quote fromthe May Freemason ' s Monthly i ^? b ?^^^ r , published in St . Johns .

" CARLETON MARK LODGE . " Our attention was lately arrested by the appearance of a paragraph in the proceedings of the last quarterly meeting of the Supreme Grand Chapter of Scotland , published in the March number of the London Freemasons' Magazine , which we copy in this issue of the Monitor . After reading the paragraph alluded to , we immediately rnade inquiries relative to the subject , and it was not without some degree of satisfaction that we became acquainted with the whole circumstances .

'" Now , the facts are simply these , and our information is obtained from the most undoubted authority . On the 18 th of January , 1847 , a communication was forwarded by the Carleton Royal Arch Chapter to the Mark Lodge working under its authority , stating that doubts had arisen relative to the existing government or workings of that Lodge , and at the same time requested and desired that body to suspend all operations until further information and instructions were received

from the Supreme Grand Chapter of Scotland touching the matters in question . This request the members ef Carleton Mark Lodge promptly and implicitly complied with . On the 29 th of January , 1847 , the First Principal of Carleton Chapter addressed a communication to the then First Proxy Principal , in Edinburgh ( Comp . A . Douglas ) , relating to the subject , to which no definite answer had been received up to the 22 d of March , 1848 . The reasons assigned for the non-reception of information was , that Comp . A . Douglas did , shortly after the communication

had been sent to him , retire from farther connection with the Supreme Grand Chapter . On learning this , the Carleton Chapter did , on the 23 d September , 1847 , appoint another Proxy First Principal , and duly forwarded him his commission , bat even from him no information had been received relative to the Mark Lodge . The members of Carleton Chapter deeming it expedient that Carleton Mark Lodge should be permitted to go on with its work , did , in the absence of more definite nformation , determine that the resolution passed on the 13 th January , 1847 ,

requesting the Mark Lodge to suspend operations until further information was received , be set aside for the present ; and the Right Worshipful Master , Wardens and members , were then authorized to renew their operations until further information be received by and communicated to them through the Chapter . A provision was also made , which stated that none but R . A . Masons , being members of the Carleton Chapter , should be appointed to the chairs of the Eight Worshipful Master and Wardens .

" The foregoing is a brief outline of the manner m which the authority for working the Carleton Mark Lodge was granted . Regarding the legality of this authority , we feel assured that none can presume to question it . Although the Mark Lodge is in a measure separate , it is nevertheless connected with the Carleton Royal Arch , Chapter , more particularly as its power to work emanated from that f

body , and one of the stipulations being ' that none but Royal Arch Masons , being members of the Chapter , shall be appointed to the chairs of the Right Worshipful Master and Wardens . ' Under the authority of Ireland , we believe it is customary for the three Principals of the Chapter to occupy the three principal chairs in the Mark Lodge . ( i

We can discover no reason why the legality of the Carleton Mark Lodge should be questioned ; but we suppose it is perfectly correct that the Grand Chapter should request information relative to its working , particularly as a thorough understanding was not arrived at on a former occasion . Tbere is every reason to

“The Freemasons' Monthly Magazine: 1858-10-01, Page 29” Masonic Periodicals Online, Library and Museum of Freemasonry, 9 May 2025, django:8000/periodicals/mmr/issues/frm_01101858/page/29/.
  • List
  • Grid
Title Category Page
PROVINCIAL GRAND LODGES. Article 1
ANGLO-SAXON HISTORY ILLUSTRATED BY TOPOGRAPHICAL NOMENCLATURE. Article 6
OUR ARCHITECTURAL CHAPTER. Article 11
WHAT IS FREEMASONRY? Article 16
TIDINGS FROM THE CRAFT IN THE UNITED STATES Article 21
FREEMASONRY IN ENGLAND AND IN INDIA. Article 23
HAPPY TO MEET. Article 24
CORRESPONDENCE Article 25
THE MASONIC MIRROR Article 31
PROVINCIAL Article 33
MARK MASONRY Article 37
ROYAL ARCH Article 40
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR Article 41
SCOTLAND Article 41
AMERICA Article 43
THE WEEK Article 43
Obituary Article 47
NQTICES, Article 48
PROVINCIAL GRAND OFFICERS. Article 49
OUR ARCHITECTURAL CHAPTER Article 52
Selections Article 53
ANGLO-SAXON HISTORY ILLUSTRATED BY TOPOGRAPHICAL NOMENCLATURE. Article 54
FREEMASONRY VINDICATED. Article 58
REMARKS ON THE HISTORICAL SCRIPTURES. Article 64
REVIEWS OF NEW MUSIC, Article 66
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 67
THE MASONIC MIRROR Article 75
METROPOLITAN. Article 75
PROVINCIAL. Article 81
MARK MASONRY Article 88
ROYAL ARCH Article 89
IRELAND Article 89
SCOTLAND Article 90
CANADA Article 90
THE WEEK. Article 91
Obituary. Article 95
NOTICES. Article 96
THE "FREEMASONS' MAGAZINE" AND THE GRAND LODGE CLUB. Article 97
MASONIC CONSECRATION OF A CEMETERY IN KENTUCKY. Article 99
ANGLO-SAXON HISTORY ILLUSTRATED BY TOPOGRAPHICAL NOMENCLATURE. Article 109
CORRESPONDENCE. Article 114
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 121
METROPOLITAN. Article 124
PROVINCIAL Article 129
ROYAL ARCH. Article 137
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED RITE Article 137
SC0TLAND Article 139
THE WEEK Article 140
THE PROVINCIAL GRAND MASTER OF TASMANIA. Article 145
OUR ARCHITECTURAL CHAPTER Article 149
TIDINGS FROM THE CRAFT IN THE UNITED STATES Article 152
FREEMASONRY AND ARCHITECTUEE. Article 154
ANGRY WORDS. Article 158
CORRESPONDENCE Article 159
THE GRAND MASTER AND THE "MASONIC OBSERVER." Article 163
THE MASONIC MIRROR. Article 171
METROPOLITAN. Article 171
PROVINCIAL Article 174
MARK MASONRY Article 181
ROYAL ARCH Article 184
KNIGHTS TEMPLAR Article 185
SC0TLAND Article 185
COLONIAL Article 186
INDIA Article 186
THE WEEK. Article 189
TO CORRESPONDENTS. Article 192
Page 1

Page 1

1 Article
Page 2

Page 2

1 Article
Page 3

Page 3

1 Article
Page 4

Page 4

1 Article
Page 5

Page 5

1 Article
Page 6

Page 6

1 Article
Page 7

Page 7

1 Article
Page 8

Page 8

1 Article
Page 9

Page 9

1 Article
Page 10

Page 10

1 Article
Page 11

Page 11

2 Articles
Page 12

Page 12

1 Article
Page 13

Page 13

1 Article
Page 14

Page 14

1 Article
Page 15

Page 15

1 Article
Page 16

Page 16

1 Article
Page 17

Page 17

1 Article
Page 18

Page 18

1 Article
Page 19

Page 19

1 Article
Page 20

Page 20

1 Article
Page 21

Page 21

1 Article
Page 22

Page 22

1 Article
Page 23

Page 23

2 Articles
Page 24

Page 24

2 Articles
Page 25

Page 25

1 Article
Page 26

Page 26

1 Article
Page 27

Page 27

1 Article
Page 28

Page 28

1 Article
Page 29

Page 29

1 Article
Page 30

Page 30

1 Article
Page 31

Page 31

1 Article
Page 32

Page 32

1 Article
Page 33

Page 33

2 Articles
Page 34

Page 34

1 Article
Page 35

Page 35

1 Article
Page 36

Page 36

1 Article
Page 37

Page 37

2 Articles
Page 38

Page 38

1 Article
Page 39

Page 39

1 Article
Page 40

Page 40

2 Articles
Page 41

Page 41

2 Articles
Page 42

Page 42

1 Article
Page 43

Page 43

3 Articles
Page 44

Page 44

1 Article
Page 45

Page 45

1 Article
Page 46

Page 46

1 Article
Page 47

Page 47

2 Articles
Page 48

Page 48

1 Article
Page 49

Page 49

1 Article
Page 50

Page 50

1 Article
Page 51

Page 51

1 Article
Page 52

Page 52

2 Articles
Page 53

Page 53

2 Articles
Page 54

Page 54

1 Article
Page 55

Page 55

1 Article
Page 56

Page 56

1 Article
Page 57

Page 57

1 Article
Page 58

Page 58

2 Articles
Page 59

Page 59

1 Article
Page 60

Page 60

1 Article
Page 61

Page 61

1 Article
Page 62

Page 62

1 Article
Page 63

Page 63

1 Article
Page 64

Page 64

2 Articles
Page 65

Page 65

1 Article
Page 66

Page 66

1 Article
Page 67

Page 67

1 Article
Page 68

Page 68

1 Article
Page 69

Page 69

1 Article
Page 70

Page 70

1 Article
Page 71

Page 71

1 Article
Page 72

Page 72

1 Article
Page 73

Page 73

1 Article
Page 74

Page 74

1 Article
Page 75

Page 75

2 Articles
Page 76

Page 76

1 Article
Page 77

Page 77

1 Article
Page 78

Page 78

1 Article
Page 79

Page 79

1 Article
Page 80

Page 80

1 Article
Page 81

Page 81

1 Article
Page 82

Page 82

1 Article
Page 83

Page 83

1 Article
Page 84

Page 84

1 Article
Page 85

Page 85

1 Article
Page 86

Page 86

1 Article
Page 87

Page 87

1 Article
Page 88

Page 88

2 Articles
Page 89

Page 89

3 Articles
Page 90

Page 90

3 Articles
Page 91

Page 91

1 Article
Page 92

Page 92

1 Article
Page 93

Page 93

1 Article
Page 94

Page 94

1 Article
Page 95

Page 95

2 Articles
Page 96

Page 96

1 Article
Page 97

Page 97

1 Article
Page 98

Page 98

1 Article
Page 99

Page 99

1 Article
Page 100

Page 100

1 Article
Page 101

Page 101

1 Article
Page 102

Page 102

1 Article
Page 103

Page 103

1 Article
Page 104

Page 104

1 Article
Page 105

Page 105

1 Article
Page 106

Page 106

1 Article
Page 107

Page 107

1 Article
Page 108

Page 108

1 Article
Page 109

Page 109

2 Articles
Page 110

Page 110

1 Article
Page 111

Page 111

1 Article
Page 112

Page 112

1 Article
Page 113

Page 113

1 Article
Page 114

Page 114

1 Article
Page 115

Page 115

1 Article
Page 116

Page 116

1 Article
Page 117

Page 117

1 Article
Page 118

Page 118

1 Article
Page 119

Page 119

1 Article
Page 120

Page 120

1 Article
Page 121

Page 121

1 Article
Page 122

Page 122

1 Article
Page 123

Page 123

1 Article
Page 124

Page 124

2 Articles
Page 125

Page 125

1 Article
Page 126

Page 126

1 Article
Page 127

Page 127

1 Article
Page 128

Page 128

1 Article
Page 129

Page 129

2 Articles
Page 130

Page 130

1 Article
Page 131

Page 131

1 Article
Page 132

Page 132

1 Article
Page 133

Page 133

1 Article
Page 134

Page 134

1 Article
Page 135

Page 135

1 Article
Page 136

Page 136

1 Article
Page 137

Page 137

2 Articles
Page 138

Page 138

1 Article
Page 139

Page 139

2 Articles
Page 140

Page 140

2 Articles
Page 141

Page 141

1 Article
Page 142

Page 142

1 Article
Page 143

Page 143

1 Article
Page 144

Page 144

1 Article
Page 145

Page 145

1 Article
Page 146

Page 146

1 Article
Page 147

Page 147

1 Article
Page 148

Page 148

1 Article
Page 149

Page 149

1 Article
Page 150

Page 150

1 Article
Page 151

Page 151

1 Article
Page 152

Page 152

2 Articles
Page 153

Page 153

1 Article
Page 154

Page 154

2 Articles
Page 155

Page 155

1 Article
Page 156

Page 156

1 Article
Page 157

Page 157

1 Article
Page 158

Page 158

2 Articles
Page 159

Page 159

1 Article
Page 160

Page 160

1 Article
Page 161

Page 161

1 Article
Page 162

Page 162

1 Article
Page 163

Page 163

1 Article
Page 164

Page 164

1 Article
Page 165

Page 165

1 Article
Page 166

Page 166

1 Article
Page 167

Page 167

1 Article
Page 168

Page 168

1 Article
Page 169

Page 169

1 Article
Page 170

Page 170

1 Article
Page 171

Page 171

2 Articles
Page 172

Page 172

1 Article
Page 173

Page 173

1 Article
Page 174

Page 174

2 Articles
Page 175

Page 175

1 Article
Page 176

Page 176

1 Article
Page 177

Page 177

1 Article
Page 178

Page 178

1 Article
Page 179

Page 179

1 Article
Page 180

Page 180

1 Article
Page 181

Page 181

2 Articles
Page 182

Page 182

1 Article
Page 183

Page 183

1 Article
Page 184

Page 184

2 Articles
Page 185

Page 185

3 Articles
Page 186

Page 186

3 Articles
Page 187

Page 187

1 Article
Page 188

Page 188

1 Article
Page 189

Page 189

1 Article
Page 190

Page 190

1 Article
Page 191

Page 191

1 Article
Page 192

Page 192

2 Articles
Page 29

Note: This text has been automatically extracted via Optical Character Recognition (OCR) software.

Oomespotoence.

of misstatements made by him , must be an entire stranger among us ; and certainly common courtesy ought to have dictated to him that he should thoroughly become acquainted with the truth of what he asserted , before publishing it forth to the world . Besides , in my opinion he violates his O . B .

in publishing to the world the private business of the Carleton Chapter , without- ' permission . He states that in the city of St . John " there is also a spurious Mark Lodge ; many members , when they are initiated , and find out that it is surreptitious , refuse to again enter its portals . The Master is William W . Smith . " An answer to this falsehood I will quote fromthe May Freemason ' s Monthly i ^? b ?^^^ r , published in St . Johns .

" CARLETON MARK LODGE . " Our attention was lately arrested by the appearance of a paragraph in the proceedings of the last quarterly meeting of the Supreme Grand Chapter of Scotland , published in the March number of the London Freemasons' Magazine , which we copy in this issue of the Monitor . After reading the paragraph alluded to , we immediately rnade inquiries relative to the subject , and it was not without some degree of satisfaction that we became acquainted with the whole circumstances .

'" Now , the facts are simply these , and our information is obtained from the most undoubted authority . On the 18 th of January , 1847 , a communication was forwarded by the Carleton Royal Arch Chapter to the Mark Lodge working under its authority , stating that doubts had arisen relative to the existing government or workings of that Lodge , and at the same time requested and desired that body to suspend all operations until further information and instructions were received

from the Supreme Grand Chapter of Scotland touching the matters in question . This request the members ef Carleton Mark Lodge promptly and implicitly complied with . On the 29 th of January , 1847 , the First Principal of Carleton Chapter addressed a communication to the then First Proxy Principal , in Edinburgh ( Comp . A . Douglas ) , relating to the subject , to which no definite answer had been received up to the 22 d of March , 1848 . The reasons assigned for the non-reception of information was , that Comp . A . Douglas did , shortly after the communication

had been sent to him , retire from farther connection with the Supreme Grand Chapter . On learning this , the Carleton Chapter did , on the 23 d September , 1847 , appoint another Proxy First Principal , and duly forwarded him his commission , bat even from him no information had been received relative to the Mark Lodge . The members of Carleton Chapter deeming it expedient that Carleton Mark Lodge should be permitted to go on with its work , did , in the absence of more definite nformation , determine that the resolution passed on the 13 th January , 1847 ,

requesting the Mark Lodge to suspend operations until further information was received , be set aside for the present ; and the Right Worshipful Master , Wardens and members , were then authorized to renew their operations until further information be received by and communicated to them through the Chapter . A provision was also made , which stated that none but R . A . Masons , being members of the Carleton Chapter , should be appointed to the chairs of the Eight Worshipful Master and Wardens .

" The foregoing is a brief outline of the manner m which the authority for working the Carleton Mark Lodge was granted . Regarding the legality of this authority , we feel assured that none can presume to question it . Although the Mark Lodge is in a measure separate , it is nevertheless connected with the Carleton Royal Arch , Chapter , more particularly as its power to work emanated from that f

body , and one of the stipulations being ' that none but Royal Arch Masons , being members of the Chapter , shall be appointed to the chairs of the Right Worshipful Master and Wardens . ' Under the authority of Ireland , we believe it is customary for the three Principals of the Chapter to occupy the three principal chairs in the Mark Lodge . ( i

We can discover no reason why the legality of the Carleton Mark Lodge should be questioned ; but we suppose it is perfectly correct that the Grand Chapter should request information relative to its working , particularly as a thorough understanding was not arrived at on a former occasion . Tbere is every reason to

  • Prev page
  • 1
  • 28
  • You're on page29
  • 30
  • 192
  • Next page
  • Accredited Museum Designated Outstanding Collection
  • LIBRARY AND MUSEUM CHARITABLE TRUST OF THE UNITED GRAND LODGE OF ENGLAND REGISTERED CHARITY NUMBER 1058497 / ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 2025

  • Accessibility statement

  • Designed, developed, and maintained by King's Digital Lab

We use cookies to track usage and preferences.

Privacy & cookie policy